- It's the Same, So It Sucks: One of the biggest sticking points that readers had with the story (especially the deviantart user acepredator) was that while cases of Science Marches On were acknowledged for the most part, the Grandfather Clause was applied to other plot points. For example, the Cryptocleidus can still come onto land despite this being a physical impossibility for plesiosaurs, and Gastornis is still portrayed as a predator (albeit being an omnivore in this story). The former point resulted in an absolutely vicious arguement between WWCB and acepredator in the comments for the first chapter of his rewrite of A Cruel Sea.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Ymmv/WWCB
Go To
