- Alternative Character Interpretation:
- The Killer appears to be merely a bloodthirsty For the Evulz madman, but one theory by the director is that he's actually doing this for revenge.Casper Kelly: My direction to him was very specific for each shot, but in my head he is a man who tried to be a sitcom dad with his attempt at a Cosby sweater and such but just will never allowed to be a part of this world he has to dwell in. So hes gotten a little bitter and vengeful about being left out.
- Another growing theory is that he's just one of many of the Always Chaotic Evil forces of B.R.o.t.H.
- "Intronitis" being a disease that professional doctors are horrified by calls into question if it's a good thing that Smarf reset the show.
- It also creates a possibly that The Killer is ultimately doing a good thing by attempting to destroy the show.
- Also, the fact His credits glitch out suggests The killer is at worst a carrier of the infection, but possibly even could be immune to Intronitis.
- The show is actually about a group of people who are all rampant sufferers of Intronitis who were put onto the show purely to give them something to do with their lives. If you look at some of the younger cast members, they are slumped, seemingly bored out of their minds. Imagine if you were stuck in a sitcom purely since a name floats into view a short distance in front of you. No wonder the doctor wants to commit suicide!
- The Killer appears to be merely a bloodthirsty For the Evulz madman, but one theory by the director is that he's actually doing this for revenge.
- Applicability: Dozens of theories have been made about the short's applicability to real television, such as it being a critique of cookie-cutter entertainment, forced retools, multiple writers/showrunners working on and overcomplicating long-running sitcoms, the dark undertones behind cheery family-friendly shows, or even an attempt to overthrow television as a whole. Word of God is that there's probably a message in the short somewhere, but the main reason why they made it was just to screw with people's minds at four in the morning.
- Award Snub: The short was wildly popular on the Internet and received high praise for its twisting of TV cliches, but didn't even get nominated for the 2015 Primetime Emmy for Outstanding Short Form Comedy or Drama Series.
- Awesome Music: Some of the variations on the main theme get absolutely amazing, like the crime drama variation and the G.I. Joe parody one.
- Big-Lipped Alligator Moment: Grandma turning into an owl. A bunch of the other surreal gags have setup or payoff but this bit comes right out of nowhere — for everybody except people who saw Manimal when it was on the air.
- Creepy Awesome: The Killer, who feels like Jack Torrance made his way into a family show.
- Ear Worm: The theme, even (or perhaps especially) after becoming an Overly Long Gag. Lampshaded in-universe by "intronitis" being a contagious disease, complete with theme music.
- Ending Fatigue: A common complaint about the short is that it just keeps going and seems to end multiple times before starting back up again. Not many people realize that's it's All Part of the Joke.
- Ensemble Dark Horse: Quite a few given the Loads and Loads of Characters nature of the short.
- Everyone Is Jesus in Purgatory: And how. The amount of slightly ponderous chin-scratching clickbaity articles about what this short is really about (and the various abstract theories they're coming up with) is getting more insane than the short itself.
- He's Just Hiding!: Thanks to a zombie cosplay by the real Katie Adkins, a popular bit of fanon is that, if a sequel happens, her character will return as a zombie.
- Hilarious in Hindsight: 31 seconds in there is a brief shot of Savannah getting her face painted with a paint roller. As pointed out on the Reddit AMA, a month earlier there had been a query on Facebook, Reddit, and Metafilter about finding a show opening with such a shot, which was so hard to find that even librarians from the Library of Congress were stumped.
- Older Than They Think:
- This 2004 Mad TV sketch has a similar premise and punchline. This 2012 Upright Citizens' Brigade video also has some of the same ideas.
- There actually was a sitcom called Too Many Cooks about a large family (10 kids) named Cook — a 1950 radio series that aired on CBS but was canceled after eight episodes.
- Rewatch Bonus: The Killer and his later actions in the video add significance to some of his appearances before then, particularly looking through a cupboard at spices. Some of the places he appears and expressions he makes also make more sense if you know what Casper Kelly's interpretation behind him is.
- The Scrappy: Smarf appears to be an invoking of this trope, with his ugly design and puppet contrast to the live-action actors. Rescued from the Scrappy Heap when he uses his Eye Beams to explode the Killer. Also when he presses the reset button in his (would be) last moments. He is, in fact, the closest thing this short has to a hero.
- Tastes Like Diabetes: Much of the opening's super-saccharine nature, especially the shots of the little kids and Smarf shooting rainbows out of his hands. Then the Killer comes to change all that.
- What Do You Mean, It Wasn't Made on Drugs?: The entire thing.
YMMV / Too Many Cooks