Sarah, who's either left behind in a trailer or trapped beneath rubble in Season Two: Episode 4 and is Devoured by the Horde of Walkers. In the latter situation, there is nothing the player can do to save her, even if Clem tells Jane to save her.
Some fans hated Luke after what he did in Amid The Ruins, but absolutely no one was happy when he drowned in the river after Clementine and Bonnie failed to save him.
Kenny's behaviour is extremely contentious among the fanbase. Is he a wounded man who is struggling to control his emotions as he is surrounded by people he is unable to trust, and his relationship with Clementine is the only way to move on from the death of his family and new girlfriend, and his desperation to get to Wellington in the finale is only because he wants he believe is best for Clementine and baby A.J.? Or, is he needlessly hot-headed and antagonistic towards the more rational team members to the point where he pushes them away because of his increasingly unstable and violent behaviour, acts rather possessive towards Clementine and baby A.J. and sees anyone who tries to bond with them as a threat, relies far too much on pure dumb luck on planning to take his group to a rumoured safe-haven in the middle of a blizzard with a baby in tow, low supplies, and with no sense of direction, and could have very well gotten everyone killed in a worst-case scenario? There's also how some believe that Kenny's incessant belligerence, irrationality, and controlling nature, is what played a major part in the eventual downfall of the group in the Season Two finale, along with driving Bonnie, Mike and Arvo to betray the team out of fear of Kenny.
Christa's behavior towards Clementine after Omid's death. Does she resent Clementine for letting Michelle get a hold of her gun, which led to her shooting Omid? Or is she simply broken by it all? These two interpretations aren't necessarily exclusive. The fact that she tries to protect Clementine by lying to the bandits about being alone at gunpoint lends credence to the latter.
Sarah. Does she have a mental disorder of some kind that causes her to act the way she does or is it simply a result of extremely overprotective parenting? Again, it could be a combination of the two.
Arvo. Was he dangerous and morally loose all along? Or did Kenny's constant abuse break him? A number of his actions: ambushing the group with the intent to rob them, leading them over an icy lake and then running for it, and constantly giving Clementine dirty looks, are viewed completely differently depending on whether the player chose to rob him or not.
Jane and Kenny in the Season Two Finale. Both are on shaky moral ground throughout the episode, but their actions in the climax have practically split the fandom apart to the point that the character pages on this very wiki had a minor edit war over which was the Big Bad, or if either of them were.
While it was a boss fight in a storyline sense rather than a gameplay sense, the battle with the Russians and the end of Episode 4 and beginning of Episode 5 was extremely anti-climatic. True, you did outnumber them, but considering how intimidating they looked, plus the implied mafia past and the long wait between episodes made it very anti-climactic when the only people who died were minor characters on their side and not a single person on yours.
Norma from the finale of Michonne was this for a few players since it's another Telltale boss fight with easy quick-time events.
The finale to the Michonne miniseries has been well-regarded by a few fans, mostly because it successfully shakes off some of the Darkness-Induced Audience Apathy that have plagued the series since Season Two by offering a somewhat potentially positive ending (at least depending on your choices).
Sarah is a big one too. Seen as either an AdorkableWoobie and a sweet, lovable companion of Clementine or an annoying liability due to her immaturity and anxiety issues.
Carver's characterization in Episode 3, some players either find his ruthless and tyrannical nature in tone with the bleak and desperate setting of the chapter, while others find his might-make-right attitude over the top, cliché, obnoxious, and inconsistent with his Affably Evil demeanour in Episode 2.
Arvo gets this a bit as well. Players are split between him being perceived a conniving and irredeemable scumbag who is responsible for the shoot-out in episode 4, tries to lead the group across a potential death trap that costs Luke's life, willingly shoots Clementine out of spite when he tries to make his escape, and worst of all never pays for his crimes. Others feel that his treatment at the hands of Kenny is unjust due to the lack of concrete evidence that Arvo had planned out or supported his group's idea of ambushing Clementine and her group over a theft that Jane had definitely committed against him (she takes his gun and doesn't return it after she tries to rob him from earlier). The outcome of the frozen river was also seen as out of Arvo's control due to the whole group making their own decision to cross the river in order to reach Arvo's hideout for supplies, since Arvo was being held hostage by the group and was in no position to order anyone. And finally, Arvo's decision to shoot Clementine is either seen as a response of Kenny's abuse and paranoia towards a defenseless kid, or a flimsy attempt to justify Kenny's needlessly cruel actions towards Arvo.
Nate is this as well and has a special mention of splitting the Base in thirds. Either people hate him because of his creepy, perverted, Jerkass behaviour and the fact that he killed the elderly couple at the end of Russell's story and possibly killed Eddie. Others are drawn to him, finding him funny and like him because of his flaws or despite them. The last group are torn between the first two, liking Nate up until the aforementioned killings. However, these people can't seem to decide whether or not they want to continue liking him or start hating him, usually opting for a middleground.
Visiting the museum with Mike and Bonnie to find supplies for Rebecca and her baby in episode 4 of season 2 counts as well. Aside from a single walker trapped in a room there are no hazards or enemies for Clementine to fight and the player doesn't have to make any hard choices. The atmosphere is also more lighthearted with some funny comments made by Mike and Bonnie as they look for the stuff they need. The group doesn't even suffer any setbacks and returns with some water and a coat that they can use as a blanket for the baby. Given the events that take place before and after this part most players were probably very thankful for it.
Sitting around the campfire in episode 5 of season 2 is definitely this. The party stops to spend the night, and the player is given a quite long sequence that involves nothing more than the entire group sitting around the fire, drinking, laughing, and generally getting along, with quite a bit of humor and some possible heartwarming moments. This comes right after a lot of hardship, and is more or less the last time the entire group ever gets along with each other again.
Those who are on Luke's side in Season 2 and those who are on Kenny's. Some find Luke to be naive and too idealistic, others find him to be genuinely nice and a likeable character. Some dislike Kenny for being too brash and selfish (his actions in Season 1 don't help at all), some think he's awesome and trustworthy. The base has become ever MORE broken after "Amid the Ruins", during which some Team Luke members went to Team Kenny after him sleeping with Jane and, thus, accidentally killing Sarah. In the same way, Team Kenny members have gone Team Luke after Kenny's unfair outburst at Clementine and his odd liking for Rebecca's baby. A rumor going around says that you'll have to choose between Kenny or Luke in Episode 5, which pretty much makes the broken base necessary. Although in Episode 5, it turns out you don't. You do have to choose between Kenny and someone else, but that someone else is Jane, not Luke, who dies partway through the episode.
The Season 2 finale tore the fanbase asunder during the climax. As listed above, many players still like Kenny, and agree with him that Jane (if the player let him kill her) could've prevented the fight if she merely told him the baby was alive. And then there are people who support Jane, and knew that sooner or later, Kenny would've snapped and that he needed to be put down before he seriously hurt anyone else. But like "Amid the Ruins" some fans immediately switched sides during and/or after the fight; those on Team Kenny switched over to Team Jane upon realizing how savage, petty, and insane he became, and those on Team Jane switched over to Team Kenny upon realizing that Jane was intentionally trying to make Kenny snap all just to prove a point. And then there are those who don't support either team, stating that Kenny and Jane crossed the Moral Event Horizon and couldn't be forgiven for what they've done to each other.
Though it did eventually die down, the Clementine/Luke ship caused quite a riot in the fanbase. explanation The reason the ship appeared to begin with was because, if one were to up Clementine's age to at least her late teens, then the interactions with her an Luke would be ambiguous Ship Tease There seems to be four parties regarding the matter: the very small base that ship them as they are (with Clementine still at eleven), the second base that ships them only if Clementine is depicted as older, the third base that doesn't ship them at all just because, and the fourth base that doesn't ship them because they find it to be Squick. Many wars pop up between the bases, mostly pointed at the first base.
Carlos' decision to shield Sarah from the way things really are tends to get divided opinions from every player. Some are willing to accept that, as Sarah's father, this is how he's choosing to raise her and it isn't Clem's place to object to it. Considering how Sarah later behaves after Carlos' death, freaked out to the point of near catatonia, the same players also consider Carlos' choice to be the right one. On the flip side, other players greatly disagree with Carlos, feeling that on top of not being able to shield Sarah forever, keeping her in the dark only made things worse for her. Again these players still feel this way after Carlos' death—that Sarah would not have been so damaged by her father's death or helpless against walkers if Carlos had properly prepared her beforehand.
Complete Monster: William Carver is a cruel despot who runs his settlement like a prison camp. When a group of survivors escape from him, including Rebecca, the woman he raped and impregnated, Carver relentlessly pursue them and upon finding them he would break Carlos fingers to lure Rebecca. Carver would then proceed to kill his hostages one-by-one, starting off with Walter, then potentially Alvin, and threatens to kill either Sarita or Clementine; if Alvin survives, Carver will torture him to death. He also murders one of his own men, and beats Kenny so savagely that his eye is permanently damaged. When Rebecca tries to escape with her group again, Carver attempts to kill her and the unborn child. Though claiming to have everyone's best interests, Carver just wants complete control believing that the strong should rule and the weak should be dominated or culled.
Crosses the Line Twice: Vitali from the Russian Group in Episode 4 is quite obviously a violent, unstable, and bloodthirsty monster of a man, and it's hard to find anything even mildly amusing about him. However, if you know Russian or look up the translation for his lines, you'll discover that he is so Ax-Crazy that it almost crosses into Cloud Cuckoolander, and makes his lines almost hilarious in how insane they are.
(Translated) "I can kill any three of them with my bare hands, we don't even need the weapons! That's right, I mean you, eyepatch man, you're weak and I could tear out your throat with my teeth, who needs to use bullets for the likes of you? I'll kill you all and eat your entrails for breakfast!"
Nate from 400 Days is a pretty bad guy, but some of the ways he torments Russell are darkly hilarious.
The episode 4 of season 2 "Amid The Ruins" becomes an egregious example of the entire series, as the shocking and abrupt deaths of Sarita (who is immediately Stuffed into the Fridge regardless of the player's choice with cutting her arm off or not after she is bitten) Nick (who dies and reanimates off-screen anti-climatically) Sarah (who cannot be saved from the walkers no matter what choice the player makes), and Rebecca (who dies and reanimates while holding her newborn baby in the finale). Then all of this is topped off by a crossfire between the Russian bandits and what's left of the group, leaving little hope for any more survivors, thus marking the end of the episode.
Designated Hero: Sam (and possibly Michonne herself, depending on the player's actions) from the Michonne mini-series can be considered this. Sam is introduced to Michonne's group by signalling for help after her supplies raid from the Monroe community, causing Norma and Randal to capture Sam and her brother Greg down, and also inadvertently causes Michonne's group to be captured as well. Come the next episode, Sam and Michonne break out of captive and escapes, while causing the entirety of Monroe to catch on fire and thus destroy the community and kill several inhabitants off-screen who have likely never met Sam and Michonne before. This causes the remaining survivors to hunt down Sam and Michonne for revenge, only for the rest to be killed as well in the finale, including Norma, who was still willing to try a diplomatic approach in spite of what she had lost, until her brother is killed. The entire series of events happens because Sam steals from the people of Monroe not once, but twice, and incurs the wrath of the Monroe community for her theft, as well as getting Michonne's group captured in the ensuing struggle between her and people from Monroe. To the dismay of several players, Sam is never called out on how she is arguably(if unintentionally) responsible for every death in the mini-series, including one or two of Michonne's own people.
Designated Villain: Norma from the mini-series can be perceived as this. Unlike her violent and brutish brother Randall, Norma is portrayed as a 'tough, but fair' leader and diplomat of Monroe. She is introduced during Michonne and Sam's capture, and while making the poor assumption that Michonne was a part of Sam's group who had raided her supplies, Norma is shown to be reasonably polite towards Michonne without resorting to needless violence. After Michonne and Sam escapes, she contacts them upon finding out that they had held Randal hostage, and tries to negotiate with them to bring him back safely. During the finale, Norma goes out of her way to be diplomatic and reasonable in spite of having lost both her people and community in one day because of Michonne and Sam's escape, right up to the point she easily releases a captive and unharmed Pete (if he stayed behind in Episode 2) back to Michonne, and allows them to kill one of her men for impulsively killing Berto during the trade. Unfortunately the trade goes awry and causes Randal to die, quickly sending Norma in a fit of rage and orders her remaining men to kill everyone. Eventually, Norma dies in a horrific fashion that most feels undeserving for someone who had suffered at the hands of the heroes who had destroyed her community and killed all of her people over the supplies that Sam had willingly stole from her twice.
Pete became a fan favorite in Season 2 Episode 1 for being a strong and stern leader type, as well as being the only member of the Cabin group who was consistently intelligent and welcoming of Clementine. Many believe that if Pete had lived past "All That Remains"/"A House Divided", the plot wouldn't have turned so dark.
Walter was a beloved character in "A House Divided", because his level of kindness was a breath of fresh air after dealing with a group that locked Clementine in a shed.
Walter's boyfriend Matthew is in the same boat, resulting in jokes about how much he loves peanut butter.
Carver is already being favorably compared to the comics' Governor and Negan...at least in Episode 2. His characterization shift in Episode 3 has been rather polarizing among fans.
As of "Amid the Ruins", Mike and Bonnie have become this for being the most level headed people in the group and for having the only lighthearted moments in the whole episode. However them trying to leave the group in episode 5, taking all the food in the process, has made some fans change their opinions of them.
Eddie from the 400 Days DLC, because his banter with Wyatt was so hilarious.
After Omid and Christa show up in Season 1, it's subtly insinuated several different ways that she has just recently learned she's pregnant, before being outright stated in Episode 5. When Season 2 picks up months later, she's obviously in the late stages of the pregnancy. Then comes the sixteen month time skip, with no baby in evidence. So there are three options, each worse than the last:
Christa had the baby and she either left it behind for someone else to raise or was kidnapped.
She had the baby and it later died, forcing them to then prevent it reanimating.
She had a late-term miscarriage, which is perhaps the worst of the three. Because that late in the pregnancy, she would have had to go through labor and full delivery if the fetus died. And since we have no idea if reanimation can occur that young, Christa would have to undergone delivery, unsure if her child could have potentially come back to life and start to kill her from the inside?
Whoever the player decides to let die in episode 5 of season 2 comes back as a walker as neither suffered brain damage (with Kenny being shot in the chest and Jane getting stabbed by a knife) in their respective deaths, which are are followed by Clementine and the survivor immediately leaving with Baby A.J. to find shelter. Not only are they probably still out there, but Telltale may even decide to bring them back in season 3 for a special encounter...
Even worse, Season 3 reveals that Jane was pregnant.
Clementine threatening to reveal that Rebecca's baby may not be Alvin's. At the time it's a satisfying Take That! after Rebecca consistently treated Clem badly and suggested she be left to die. However, it's harder to do on subsequent playthroughs, when you realise the baby may be a result of Carver raping Rebecca.
In the season 2 finale trailer, Sandra's line of "That's no way to say goodbye to your mother!" is this. Given, she does give a formal goodbye to her parents a moment later but it's not much better. "See you soon."
Trying to get all the main characters in "400 Days" to leave with Tavia ends up making the bad endings being better choices as we find out they ended up working for Carver, the Big Bad of season 2.
Ho Yay: Luke and Nick have a few moments like this. Kenny actually comments on this when trying to get a rise out of them.
Mixing with No Yay, quite of few things that Russell can say ends up with Nate responding in some sort of flirty manner, intentional or not. If all of these possible responses are chosen in one gameplay and you choose to befriend him, Russell's storyline can feel like a quasi-slash fic, much to the pleasure or horror of the player.
From the beginning to end, Nate can possibly come across as being very "friendly". If Russell doesn't hide from Nate and tells him that he needs a ride, Nate will respond by asking if he'll work for it because he has "needs", though he'll soon say that he was joking. When in the car if Russell asks Nate if they can just drive instead of talk, Nate responds with confusion over the plural usage and asks if Russell wants to sit on his lap. He apologizes soon after for freaking him out. At the gas station when they're both getting shot at, if Russell responds with fear, Nate will ask Russell to look at him. If Russell refuses, Nate will cup his chin, not so roughly make Russell look at him, and motivate him to continue on. With all of these moments from Nate and the more friendly actions on Russell's part; accepting the drink, apologizing for being scared, thanking/acknowledging that Nate saves his life when he falls, and staying with him at the end can make this part of the game really enjoyable or disturbing.
Idiot Plot: A touch of this for Season 2 Episode 1. The premise of the cabin group mistaking Clem's wound for a walker bite relies upon a trained doctor who can't tell the difference between bite marks left by a dog and bite marks left by a (deceased) human. The doctor in question then decides the best way to be certain whether she was bitten by a walker is to leave her possibly infected wound completely untreated and lock her in a cold shed until the morning, very likely killing her regardless. He is apparently oblivious as to the Catch 22 nature of his solution. After Clem's desperate attempts to patch up her own wound, the doctor proclaims later that night that he can tell by her lack of fever that she wasn't bitten by a walker, implying the entire wait until morning was completely pointless.
It's Short, So It Sucks!: The main problem people have with the Michonne miniseries is that although the episodes aren't bad, they're just too short to make an impact.
Jane. Which is now more applied in episode 5, in which she abandons Alvin Junior and pretends that he's dead just so Clementine will come with her.
Arvo. Sure, he may have been involved with the shootout at Episode 4 and nearly got everyone killed, but watching the man cry over his sister's corpse, and later crossing the Despair Event Horizon, is enough to make anyone feel sorry for the man.
Moral Event Horizon: Bill Carver, the Big Bad of Season 2, Episodes 2 and 3, establishes himself as the scum of the earth in his very first episode, between torturing Carlos in front of his daughter, killing Walter to prove a point, and threatening to shoot Clementine in order to force Kenny's surrender.
Troy in general is a relentless Jerkass in Season 2 Episode 3, but after he smashes an 11 year old girl in the face with the butt of his AK-47 few people were sympathetic when he was shot in the groin and devoured alive and screaming shortly thereafter.
Jane recklessly endangers Alvin Jr. by leaving him in a car, surrounded by walkers, solely to provoke a fight with Kenny. Depending on the player's actions, this may also be her undoing.
Nate in 400 days. At first he seems somewhat crazy but mostly amicable towards Russell. Even his actions in Wyatt's story are justified. However, Russell, and the player see Nate kill an elderly couple and take their stuff with a smile on his face.
In Season 2, Episode 2, Walter's Patrick Stewart Speech about how there's still hope for humanity feels a tad too scripted. Possibly justified by him being a teacher, and used to talking this way.
In Episode 3 of season 2, if Alvin was shot in 2, Carver will take Clem aside for a personal interview in his office, where he'll threaten her to cooperate if she doesn't want to "end up in that chair"... which the camera shows to be a perfectly ordinary, empty chair (albeit one with handcuffs). This threat carries more weight if Alvin survived the ski lodge encounter, in which case his bloodied, passed-out body will be occupying the chair.
Some players can't seem to take Reggie's voice acting seriously, leading to most feeling apathetic or unintentionally cheering for Carver when he murders him.
The scene where Rebecca gives birth to her son feels more awkward than heartwarming for players who rescued Sarah from the trailer as it completely glosses over the fact that the same fifteen year old girl was brutally killed by walkers a few meters away from them not more than a few seconds ago, and everyone acts as if it never happened.
Some find Nick's death in Episode 4 to be this as well. It was highly foreshadowed by his little influence in Episode 3, and it's done in a very lazy fashion. It does not help at all that everyone is sad about it for five seconds, at the most.
Season 2 hits you right off the bat. If Omid's Sudden Sequel Death Syndrome didn't get you, how about meeting a cute little dog, searching for food together, playing fetch...and then getting viciously attacked by it and subsequently having the option to let it suffer a particularly slow and agonizing death?
For those who liked her seeing that convincing Sarah to leave the trailer does nothing as she gets a brutal death later in episode 4.
Episode 5 of Season 2 is filled to the brim with these.
If Clementine stayed and watched Kenny murder Carver, and then tells him to stop beating Arvo in Episode 5, he'll growl at her "What, lose your taste for this sorta thing?" Ouch...
Clementine being shot and having a flashback with Lee.
Luke's unavoidable death, which happens shortly after his birthday and a much-needed calm, heartwarming moment in the episode. Even after he falls into the lake, the game gives you the option to try and save him by bashing the butt of your gun against the ice to free him, which proves to be futile. None of this is helped by Bonnie's potential death either.
Mike, Arvo, and (possibly) Bonnie trying to steal the truck and leave the group. Sure, they had a good reason, but seeing the one person (or two people) you could trust suddenly betray you out of fear of one man, and having no way to convince them to stay is horrible.
Rescued from the Scrappy Heap: For some fans, Rebecca in Episode 2. Not only is she much nicer to Clementine, and less abrasive to everyone, but she even admits and apologizes for being a bitch to both Clementine and Alvin.
Despite coming off as the new Ben, Nick has grown on many players during the second episode.
According to a statistic, the 85% of players chose to convince Walter to forgive Nick, thus saving his life.
Luke lost a few fans in Episode 4, however, his death has lead many to comment on how sad it made them, and when a soundfile was found which suggested you could save Luke, some people got pretty angry.
Rooting for the Empire: As it turns out, a lot of people like Carver because he's more interesting than our bland, not-really-fleshed-out "heroes" of the cabin group. Even if the protagonists did have some personality (which was kind of rare when you think about it) they were still badly written.
Nick seems to be the Season 2 equivalent of Ben. In Episode 2 especially. In fact, if you saved Nick instead of Pete back in episode 1, then in the Nick-scenario "beginning segment", one of the dialogue choices even has Clementine compare Nick to someone she once knew, and "he was always screwing up, too". Presumably she is referring to Ben.
Carlos gets a lot of derision for not being The Smart Guy he is set up to be. He is unable to differentiate between a dog and walker bite and is unaware of the stupidity of his proposed remedy (or alternatively is, and is willing to doom Clementine from the get-go), asks Clementine how big "a small house" is, views an 11 year old as the best candidate to turn off a windmill, thinks sheltering Sarah is good parenting...
Arvo lost supporters and attracted a new level of hate by shooting Clementine, in what may have been a spiteful attempted murder.
In Episode 1, Clementine is forced to stitch up her own wound. The game forces you to go through every agonizing step of this process.
In Episode 3, Kenny smashes in Carver's face with a crowbar. Repeatedly. With long close-ups of the bloody, ruined mess that used to be said face.
In Episode 4, killing the zombified Nick is much less than clean. Basically, while attempting to take him out with a hatchet, Clem ends up lopping off side of his head before finally getting through to it.
Strangled by the Red String: A father-daughter variant can occur to those who don't see Clementine's and Kenny's bond all that convincing in Season 2, mainly due to how very little the two interacts in Season 1, with Kenny even going as far as to willingly not participate in rescuing Clementine upon being kidnapped by The Stranger in "Around Every Corner" if the player does not build a strong enough bond as Lee beforehand. By the time Season 2 arrives, Kenny reunites with Clementine and suddenly takes it upon themselves to become Clementine's new friend and guardian, and even if the player as Clementine tries to distance themselves from Kenny, the narrative seems determined to treat them as beloved friends to the end even if the player shoots Kenny to stop him from killing Jane in the finale. It does not help that Kenny's behaviour listed in the aforementioned Glurge section makes them come across as more obsessive towards Clementine and baby AJ to the point of appearing very possessive.
After Omid's death, Christa becomes more cold and resentful towards Clem since she's the one who got him killed indirectly with her gun and when Christa is apprehended by scavengers, fans can have Clem choose to abandon her to save not only her own ass but to retaliate against Christa for her bitchy attitude according to them.
Threatening/Blackmailing Rebecca in the first episode of Season 2 felt like this to many players.
At one point in Season 2: Episode 4, you have the option to leave Sarah to die inside of a trailer. Even if you don't, Clementine will be forced to slap her just so you'll be able to rescue her.
There's also Nick's ignominious offscreen death, which no one seems to care about afterwards.
They Wasted a Perfectly Good Character: Christa and Clem are separated early in the first episode by bandits, and remains missing throughout the rest of the season. Players were expecting this to be resolved later, but come the fourth and final season, Christa's fate is left unknown. Clementine hardly ever mentions her afterwards, despite Christa being her sole companion for quite a while.
Uncanny Valley: In the finale, Gill looks...odd compared to the game's graphics. As many fans have noticed, this is probably because he and his family are simply reusing models from earlier characters with very little changes. While Gill is basically Duck painted black, his mother Patricia is Molly with a different hair color and his father is a Frankenstein's monster kind of deal, reusing Carlos' hair, Mark's face and glasses and even his outfit being a slightly altered version of Nick's. It's clear the family was an afterthought by the developers, and very little effort was put into them (or at least they had little time to work on them).
Unintentionally Sympathetic: Sarah can be considered one by the fandom who don't consider her as The Scrappy, especially when considering how the narrative in Episode 4 of Season 2 seems to want to persuade the audience to abandon a shell-shocked young girl to a horrible fate after the death of her father, for the crime of being considered as The Load or an outright liability, the majority of players chose to save her than leave her to die. This is especially notable when her actions is nowhere near as catastrophic or liable as Ben was in Season 1, who could arguably be responsible for nearly every death and disaster that occurred in his group from Season 1 after Episode 3, and yet was portrayed in a far more sympathetic light than Sarah. The creator's disdain towards Sarah may also inspire more sympathy for her due to some feeling that the negative reception towards her detractors tends to come across as both irrational and undeserving.
Norma, the Big Bad of the Michonne miniseries, has been viewed as a genuinely sympathetic Anti-Villain as opposed to the monstrous villain Telltale wanted us to believe.
Unintentionally Unsympathetic: Both Kenny and Jane can come across as this to some in Season 2, especially in the finale where the fight to the death between the two had split the fandom on who was the one crossed the line during the finale. Considering how contentious both characters are with the fandom for varying reasons, some opted to abandon the two and walk away with baby A.J. due to how unlikable they were.
Arvo is this as well. One could make a reasonable insight that Kenny's abuse broke the kid in very bad ways...unless you took the opposite option when you first met him and reveal that he was going to attack you either way. Arvo gets beat up by Kenny for sure, but when you realize what he does and what he later does, you lose sympathy for the kid fast.
Vindicated by History: While it isn`t the strongest example of the trope, Season two was better looked upon by gamers when compared to A New Frontier, the follow up season that did worse in critical and audience reception.
Clementine/The Player is forced to succumb to this in the prologue of the first episode of Season 2 when she sets her gun down and goes to retrieve her water bottle. Despite many people knowing Clementine should take her gun with her, it is not an option, and so they are forced into this. The mistake costs Omid his life. However, this example is more forgivable than most, as nobody could've predicted in advance that instead of a Walker who wouldn't use Clementine's gun, a random human bandit would wander into the bathroom in the few seconds it takes to pick up the water bottle.
Speaking of this example, what in the world was Omid or Christa doing to have allowed the teenaged bandit to enter the bathroom that their 9 year old surrogate daughter was solely occupying? From their talk of "the night in Vegas" and the coy look Christa gives Omid and his rather nervous proposition for Clem to get cleaned up in the bathroom alone immediately afterwards, it's heavily implied the two were having sex. Luke and Jane get flak from the fanbase for this decision when they should have been on lookout but at least the people they were meant to be looking out for when in a group with 4 capable members. Clementine was not nearly as capable or confident as she would be 2 years later and they just leave her unsupervised. What happened should come as a surprise to no one.
When Nick impulsively shoots Matthew on the bridge. While he says he couldn't hear them, Luke and Clementine were only frantic after Nick began approaching with the gun. Furthermore, Matthew had been calmly speaking with Clementine and Luke, even putting his gun down to show that he wasn't hostile.
Happens again in Episode 2, when Clementine climbs the tower and spots people with flashlights following her group (eventually revealed to be Carver's group). The option to push her group to leave before the intruders catch up is abandoned seconds later due to Clementine's shock in meeting Kenny who was though to have died since the last time they met. Apparently her shock in meeting an old friend made her less inclined to tell her group to leave before the intruders arrive, and this mistake leads to the death of one of Kenny's new friend, potentially one or two of Clementine's group, and Luke going missing. To be fair, Clementine does tell at least Rebecca and Alvin about seeing the flashlights, which prompts Carlos to say they're leaving at dawn. It's just that "dawn" turned out to be too late, since Carver's group shows up in the middle of the night.
Yes, Luke. Yes, have sex with Jane right now. Right when you're supposed to be looking for walkers. What could go wrong?
Great job, Jane. Way to go on tricking Kenny into thinking AJ was dead so that he'd attempt to kill you in a rage, all so Clementine could see how far he'd fallen. What's that? His reaction was worse than you were expecting, and you still chose not to reveal the truth when that could have saved your life (or Kenny's, depending on the player's choice)? Well, that's just great.
If you let Jane die, after you find Kenny he lampshades that she could've stopped at any time and Kenny says that she just wanted a fight. It was still pretty stupid.
Bonnie. Yes, Bonnie. Luke had fallen through the ice and is struggling to get to his feet and Bonnie decides the best thing to do is to approach Luke and add more weight to the already thin ice, all the while Luke is telling her to back off. Predictably, the ice breaks and both of them go under. Having been told a sensible idea to cover for Luke while he pulls himself out of the water, she instead indirectly kills him and endangers potentially her life and Clementine's. And to pour salt on the wound, after you make it to the cabin she has the audacity to blame you for it.
Dee in 400 Days, big time. She, Leland and Bonnie are fleeing from a group of armed assailants trying to kill them, who are seeking them out with flashlights, and as they flee, they get separated. Dee then seems to think it's a brilliant idea to use the flashlight from the bag she took from said people and walk around, a flashlight that neither Bonnie nor Leland knew she had, which ends up with Bonnie killing her by mistake. And it can be argued that even if Bonnie hadn't killed her, the people after them would have, being able to spot the light from Dee's stolen flashlight. Of course, if you don't swing, it turns out she kills Bonnie.
John from the Michonne DLC. Disturbed over seeing a walker's severed arm, he opens the gate to his house so he can toss it out, instead of simply tossing it over the gate. Then he chooses to continue chatting with Michonne with the gate left ajar despite knowing Randall and his thugs were chasing her earlier. Moments later, he gets shot in the head, and Randall and his thugs infiltrate the premises.
Nick. It's been established that even before the apocalypse he had issues with parental abandonment and self-worth, but then his uncle Pete is bitten by a walker, and after realizing he's lost his last family member, he confides in you that before you joined the group, he had to kill his own mother.
Sarah. At first she just seems like a Creepy Child who's a little bit too oblivious to whats happening with the world but eventually the game starts to seriously screw her up. In the space of only a few days, she is forced to leave her home, get tracked down by the man she and the group tried to escape from, witnesses the death of Walter and (potentially) Alvin and also sees her fathers fingers brutally broken. Then they're brought back to Carver's settlement where her father is instructed to hit her and she also witnesses Carver shove Reggie off the roof (which she is an indirect cause of). Finally to top it off, she sees her father get shot when they try to escape and then attacked by walkers. The fact that she appears to have some sort of as yet unidentified developmental disorder also makes it much harsher and crueler when bad things happen to her and her father, and this aspect of her character can potentially make players feel inclined to be sympathetic towards her and motivate them to try and be protective of her in these incredibly terrible situations she quite clearly doesn't fully understand.
Although initial interactions with her made it seem like she would be The Scrappy, Rebecca turns out to be this as Season 2 goes on. It's revealed that the child she is having is potentially a Child by Rape via Carver. Then, she's forced to lose her husband, either by seeing her rapist shoot him dead in a hostage stand-off or by losing him to a Heroic Sacrifice. She then spends a good amount of time wondering whether or not she'll be alone in the world, all while doing her best to avoid becoming The Load for the group. When she finally goes into labor, it initially looks like her child is a stillbirth, though this is thankfully averted immediately afterward. However, she doesn't even get the chance to enjoy this much, as she dies from exhaustion in the cold just a few days later, reanimating into a Walker while holding the newborn in her hands.
Luke also gets a bit of this, having been forced to see EVERYONE from his original cabin group die horribly before he himself freezes and/or drowns in a lake, trapped under ice.
Sam goes through a lot in the few days Michonne knows her. First she and her brother are caught by Norma's group and interrogated at gunpoint. Then she watches as her brother is accidentally shot and killed in front of her, after which she has to hold him down as he reanimates so Michonne can either bash his face in or drive a screwdriver through his eye. After managing to escape Monroe, she gets shot in the shoulder and almost bleeds to death. Her life is only saved when Michonne performs an excruciating impromptu surgery on her, involving pulling out the bullet while she is still conscious and cauterising the wound with a red hot fireplace stoker. Then she finds out her father has just been murdered by Randall, orphaning her and her brothers. Finally, her beloved family home is burnt to the ground, and she can even die while trying to escape it! The poor girl can't catch a break.
Sam's younger brothers also count, having already lost their mother to suicide, and then losing their brother, father and (potentially) sister all in the same day.