- Draco in Leather Pants: SUBVERTED! Slender Man, Jeff, Masky and Hoodie may be the "good guys", but it's made very clear in the story that they are not traditionally good people; Slendy is the one giving orders, Jeff is still as homicidal as ever, Masky has a murderous Split Personality and Hoodie...um...hasn't appeared much.
- Following Marble Hornets canon, Masky is probably the split personality.
- Moral Event Horizon: Provided he hadn't crossed it already, Zalgo seems to have crossed this when he manipulated Scarecrow.
- Nightmare Fuel: It's a Creepypasta webcomic. This is a requirement.
- Tear Jerker: Scarecrow and Masky's backstories certainly qualify.
- The Woobie: Masky and Scarecrow.
YMMV / The Seer