Follow TV Tropes

Following

YMMV / The Book of Mormon

Go To

The religious text contains examples of:

  • Fair for Its Day: Max Perry Mueller argues in Race and the Making of the Mormon People that the Book of Mormon actually challenged some aspects of the 19th-century racial worldview by preaching against racial schisms and that everyone could be saved regardless of their race (2 Nephi 26:33). However, other passages haven't aged so well, like the Lamanites receiving a "skin of blackness" as a sign of their curse, and they become "white" through conversion.
  • Advertisement:
  • Hilarious in Hindsight: The Lamanites utterly fail to take the city of Noah, and the narrative describes how some of the Nephites were only wounded due to arrows striking their unarmored legs. No doubt more than one of them took an arrow in the knee.
  • Tearjerker: The final chapter, when Moroni is the Last of His Kind. All the time he is writing, he is completely alone, his father has been killed, and he's doing all he can do to finish his work while on the run. He knows full well that God will quit protecting him after he finishes, and he wants it to be this way, as he has nothing else to live for. The last verse is him saying goodbye to the reader and hoping to see them in the afterlife.


Advertisement:

The stage musical contains examples of:

  • Adorkable: Elder Kevin Price. There's something rather endearing about his utter adoration of Orlando and how devoutly he believes in the Book of Mormon.
  • Awesome Music:
    • "Man Up" (which closes Act I), Elder Cunningham getting his first real bit of character development by choosing to stay in Uganda and help people. Besides being empowering, the excessive yarling and heart that Cunningham puts into it makes the song awesome and funny at the same time.
    • "I Believe" (Elder Price's mid-Act-II power ballad). It's something like The Eleven O'Clock Number, as the climax begins to happen shortly after it. But it manages to cross into audacious with how Price reaffirms his faith, only to have all of that undone by General Butt-Fucking-Naked.
    • "Tomorrow is a Latter Day", which closes the show, contains call backs to "Hello" and "Hasa Diga Eebowai", in addition to being a huge ending number.
    • Advertisement:
    • "Spooky Mormon Hell Dream," an Opinion-Changing Dream for Price and the closest the musical gets to a Villain Song. There's even a sick guitar solo in the middle of the song worthy of a heavy metal band, played by The Devil.
  • Crosses the Line Twice: When "Hasa Diga Eebowai" isn't being terrifying, it does this by showing how bad things really are in Africa for the Ugandans.
  • Ensemble Dark Horse: No matter how minor, if a character in this show has a name (even one that only appears in the script), they have a fan following. Elder Thomas, Elder Church, and Kimbay seem to be especially popular.
    • The biggest example would be Elder McKinley for his Camp Gay antics and Ho Yay with Elder Price.
    • Mafala is also popular for singing “Hasa Diga Ebowai”.
  • Esoteric Happy Ending: Sure, the Elders and the Ugandans are happy with their new bastardized version of Mormonism, and they've even defeated General Butt-Fucking Naked, but nothing has really happened to fix the numerous other problems facing the Ugandans, such as AIDS, starvation, and maggots in their scrotums. Although the creators probably intended for people to pick up on this.
  • Fandom-Specific Plot: So much of the fan fiction pairing Elder Price and Elder McKinley together follows the same general formula (one of them not being able to sleep and going to a communal space in the middle of the night, finding the other already there, sharing an emotional conversation, confessing feelings for one another, and falling asleep together) that it’s become a running joke among fans. To some, the formula is prolific enough to be seen as all but canon, and as such, is expected in stories about the pairing - it would be easier to list all of the fics that don’t incorporate it in some way.
  • Fanon:
    • While Elder McKinley's first name is never stated In-Universe, he's almost universally referred to as 'Connor' by the fandom. Elders Church and Thomas are generally referred to as 'James' and 'Chris', respectively.
    • While his adoration of Disney is well established in canon, for absolutely no discernible reason it is widely agreed that Elder Price’s specific favourite Disney movie is The Little Mermaid.
  • Fridge Brilliance:
    • You'll notice that there's no cursing for the first twenty minutes or so of the play until they finally arrive in Africa during "Hasa Diga Eebowai." That's to lull the viewer into forgetting that they're watching a show written by the creators of South Park, and then club you over the head with as much cursing as humanly possible.
    • Hatimbi mentions during the song that "80% of us have AIDS; Hasa Diga Eebowai!" He later rattles off a list of people he knows that have AIDS, including the butcher, the teacher, the doctor, and himself, except for his daughter who has "a wonderful disposition." If you're keeping track, that's four out of five people, or 80%.
    • The whole "maggots in my scrotum" bit has some rather obscure Fridge Brilliance: that kind of infestation is known as warbles, as is a type of singing.
    • "Joseph Smith: American Moses" Crosses the Line Twice in every act of the play, but almost every message is something directly applicable to the Ugandans: stopping rape, preventing genital mutilation, and promoting clean water. The only thing that stands out is their literal interpretation of Go Forth and Multiply, which is probably the most grotesque part of the play. Except we never see Elder Cunningham talk about that aspect of the scripture (and his own anxiety in "Baptize Me" makes it seem unlikely he'd give a sermon on orgies with Jesus). The person who does talk about that part of scripture? Elder Price, in "All-American Prophet," as a lead-in to talking about himself. It seems like Arnold isn't the only one to blame for that racy number.
  • Fridge Horror: Elder McKinley's situation, when you remember the Ugandan government's general attitude towards homosexuality.
  • "Funny Aneurysm" Moment: Elder Price's dream of going to Orlando has become this, following the deadliest mass shooting in US history taking place in the city in June 2016. Worse yet is the fact that said shooting took place in a gay nightclub. Andrew Rannells, the original Elder Price, is gay, and Price himself could be considered Ambiguously Gay.
  • Genius Bonus: Cunningham being heavily into science fiction (Star Wars, Star Trek, etc.) and fantasy (Lord of the Rings) may seem like stock Hollywood Nerd traits at first, but it is also a subtle reference to the disproportionate influence Mormon writers had on those genres.
  • Harsher in Hindsight: Elder Price's Dark Reprise of the "Orlando" refrain can hit a little too close to home for some after the June 2016 mass shooting. See above.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight:
    • At one point, Elder Cunningham calls Nabulungi "Nala"; in a later Los Angeles show, Nabulungi's actress played Nala and General Butt-Fucking Naked played Mufasa.
    • In "Turn It Off," Elder Price says that he's not having gay thoughts. Andrew Rannells (the original Elder Price) later came out as gay and played a gay character on Big Mouth.
    • The shoutout to Les Misérables becomes hilarious at the news of Nikki M. James (Nabulungi) going on to play Eponine in that very show on Broadway.
    • Elder Young hopes to meet gnomes and trolls in Norway. Maybe if he followed Josh Gad into another Robert Lopez musical, which took some inspiration from Norwegian culture...
    • If you have a very dark sense of humour, all the AIDS jokes are this when you remember what one of Andrew Rannells’s next big stage roles was.
  • Ho Yay:
    • Depending on the production, Elder McKinley and Elder Price. It helps that McKinley is canonically gay and Price has no love interest in-story (plus Price's original actor, former 4Kids voice actor Andrew Rannells, is gay).
    • In some later productions, after returning from the village covered in the blood of a recently executed Ugandan, Elder Price grabs Elder McKinley by the arms and/or face in excitement. Elder McKinley almost tries to kiss him.
    • Some versions have them make out during "Spooky Mormon Hell Dream".
    • Elders Price and Cunningham have quite a bit of this as well.
  • It's Been Done: To take a page from South Park... Simpsons did it!
  • Jerkass Woobie: Elder Price during his Crisis of Faith. He's still a self-centered jerk, but it's hard not to feel bad for him when everything keeps going wrong for him.
  • Mexicans Love Speedy Gonzales: Despite the musical's extremely irreverent portrayal of Mormonism, lots of real Mormons are fans of this musical. The LDS church even referenced it for an advertising campaign.
    • It also helps that the musical never portrays Mormons or even Mormonism itself as bad. The whole point of the musical is that religion can be used to bring people together, and that's what the Mormons ultimately do.
    • During the touring production, not only has the LDS church bought multiple ads in the Playbill, but they station missionaries at the entrance to hand out cards. Members of the church knew that protesting wasn't going to work, so why not use it to their advantage?
      Playbill ad: Our version is sliiiightly different.
    • Matt Stone and Trey Parker have suggested that part of the reason Mormons like it is that it never uses the old joke about Mormons being polygamists.
  • Nausea Fuel/Squick: The running gag about the doctor having maggots in his scrotum, as well as a later point where Elder Price gets his copy of the title book shoved up his butt by General Butt-Fucking Naked.
  • Nightmare Retardant: "Spooky Mormon Hell Dream" is deliberately anything but spooky, which is part of the reason why the number is so hysterical.
  • Portmanteau Couple Name: McPriceley (Price/McKinley), Arnaba (Cunningham/Nabulungi), and Pricingham (Price/Cunningham). Also 'Churchtarts' and 'Schravis', as detailed below.
  • Ships That Pass in the Night: 'Churchtarts', the pairing of Elder Church and Elder 'Poptarts' Thomas, who each have a verse in "Turn It Off". They have about ten lines between them, and never speak to each other.
    • Even more random is 'Schravis' - Elders Schrader and Davis. The former isn't even named outside of the script.
  • Suspiciously Similar Song: "Hasa Diga Eebowai" sounds like a combination of "I Can't Just Wait To Be King" and "Hakuna Matata". "Hankuna Matata" is even referenced in the song, so it could be one big Shout-Out to The Lion King (1994).
  • Signature Song: Depending on who you ask, it’s either “Hello”, “Hasa Diga Ebowai”, or “I Believe”.
  • Unfortunate Implications: This article brings up a few, albeit by missing the point of the show. Also, the LDS Church's unkind opinion on homosexuality renders McKinley's situation rather uncomfortable, especially when the dialogue at times seems to support the "moral validity" of his repression. It also doesn't help that the message of the musical is that Mormonism does teach good moral lessons, implying (obviously accidentally, considering Stone's and Parker's well-established acceptance of gay people) that homophobia is one of those "good moral lessons," or is otherwise just one of the silly, unimportant side-effects of the Mormon teachings like the other ridiculous factual teachings made fun of throughout the show.
    • However, McKinley's line "We love to dance and shout/And let all our feelings out" in the finale does hint that he's getting closer to finding/accepting himself in spite of this.
    • This 2019 re-review of the Broadway production (alongside a similar reassessment of Hamilton) points out that the original critical discussions around the show fell under this by prioritizing how Mormons might feel over its portrayal of their religion over how Africans might feel about its portrayal of Uganda and its people — which is significantly less sympathetic and affectionate in the latter case, to the point of being outright racist.
  • The Woobie:
    • Elder Cunningham. He may be kind of a self-centered Wide-Eyed Idealist, but it's hard not to feel bad for him when he keeps failing to do what he earnestly set out to do.
    • A good majority of the Mormon missionaries seem to be woobies, actually, if "Turn It Off" is anything to go by.
    • With the horrors the Ugandans go through, their lack of faith is unsurprising.

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report