Follow TV Tropes

Following

YMMV / The BFG

Go To

All versions:

The 1989 animated feature:

  • Awesome Art: Stunningly detailed backgrounds, with an apt mix of expression and naturalism in the character designs, weave a sense of pure wonder. And get a load of the scenery - Sophie's moonlit village, the baked wastes of Giant Country, the vast, vaporous starscape of Dream Country...
  • Awesome Music: The movie has what is arguably one of the most beautiful scores to be heard in an animated film, courtesy of composers Keith Hopwood and Malcolm Rowe. Notable examples are when the BFG makes the nightmare for the queen and when the BFG leads the RAF to Giant Country. Pretty funny, considering that Keith Hopwood was one of the members of Herman's Hermits. Despite considerable demand, however, the soundtrack was not officially released until 2016.
  • Big-Lipped Alligator Moment: As the soldiers fly into Giant Country, they pass a random family of dinosaurs. There are no dinosaurs in the original book and their appearance is never addressed.
  • Complete Monster: The Fleshlumpeater, leader of the giants, is a savage brute who loves to devour children. Stealing into the human world every night to eat them, the Fleshlumpeater has been responsible for countless deaths. Later glimpsed by Sophie and the Big Friendly Giant preparing to devour a little boy, Fleshlumpeater leads his giants to attack schools full of children, leaving bones strewn all about, and violates the taboo of giant not killing giant to attempt to murder the BFG at the end.
  • Heartwarming Moments: The ending, where Sophie decides to stay with the BFG, even though, as he himself states, he has no palace or other comforts to offer her.
  • Unintentional Uncanny Valley: Due to being rotoscoped (and thus having a more realistic design), the queen, the Paras and the Royal Guards look very unnatural in the otherwise cartoony setting of the story.
  • What Do You Mean, It's for Kids?: Despite it getting a "suitable for general audiences" rating, younger children will no doubt find scenes of the monstrous children-eating giants terrifying.

The 2016 live-action film:

  • Audience-Coloring Adaptation: This film takes a few cues from the 1989 Animated Adaptation - such as Sophie having short brown hair (it's long and blonde in the book), a scene where Sophie witnesses the death of a child, the BFG giving Sophie a new dress to wear and the ending where BFG goes back to live in Giant Country instead of England.
  • Memetic Mutation: When the trailer came out, people unfamiliar with the source material started to make tongue in cheek speculations about the meaning of the acronym title, Big F*cking Guy and Big F*cking Giant being the most popular ones. Similarly, Doom fans complain that it's impossible to hear that title and not think of The Big Fucking Gun.
  • One-Scene Wonder: Penelope Wilton as the Queen - who doesn't appear until well over an hour in and has maybe fifteen minutes of screentime.
  • Slow-Paced Beginning: For some, the film starts off rather slowly but kicks into gear around the time Sophie and the BFG enter Dream Country.
  • So Okay, It's Average: It's not a bad film, but it's definitely not one of Spielberg or Disney's best.
  • They Changed It, Now It Sucks!: Fans of the animated movie weren't particularly pleased with the slightly more human-like redesigns the evil giants had in this movie in stark contrast to the much more bestial and monstrous appearance they had in the 1989 adaptation.
  • Tough Act to Follow: This was following the 1989 animated film, which is considered a children's classic and the only Roald Dahl adaptation to get a standing ovation from the author (something not even the beloved family classic Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory managed to achieve).
  • Visual Effects of Awesome: The entire film, particularly the Giants, who at times it's genuinely hard to tell they're CGI at all. In particular is when Sophie and the BFG share the screen together.


Top