YMMV / Table Flip

• Broken Base:
  • Suzy in the earlier episodes: is she just being too serious and keeping everyone from making hilarious jokes, or is she making sure that everyone keeps focus so they can continue the show without derailing.
  • Belated Media's performance. He's either a hilarious show-boating Large Ham or an annoying show stealing Scrappy.
  • The Anachronism Stew humor and the whole Victorian motif. Some think it's hilarious and helps give the show an identity; other think it’s distracting, incredibly forced and adds nothing to the show, and it would have been funnier without it.
• Just Here for Godzilla: One of their episodes was about a game called Kill Doctor Lucky, but Jojos Bizarre Adventure fans were more interested on the fact that Octopimp was cosplaying William Anthonio Zeppeli.
• Nightmare Fuel: In Betrayal at House on the Hill, Arin is terrifying as the cannibal at times, even severely startling Barry at one point. The rest of the time, however...
• Nightmare Retardant: Cannibal Arin is terrifying at times, but some of his lines lessens it. Man-meat, anyone?
• Obvious Judas: In Shadows over Camelot, Markiplier grows less and less subtle in his attempts at treachery as the game goes on, culminating in his falsely accusing three of his fellow players of being traitors to incur the penalty and then using the extremely valuable Holy Grail on himself when he didn't need it.
• The Scrappy: CaptainSparklez, due to his lackluster improv and general silence throughout Metagame. The fact that he couldn't come up with an original backstory, instead basing it on Around the World in Eighty Days, compounds the negative reaction to him.
• So Okay, It's Average: What most think of the show, believing that, even though it's not bad, it's not as great as Game Grumps, Steam Train or Grumpcade. The main problem is due to the nature of board games: since most of the games they play are new and unfamiliar to most viewers, the viewers have to learn how the game works before being able to understand what's happening.

---