Follow TV Tropes

Following

YMMV / Sucker Punch

Go To


  • Alternate Aesop Interpretation: Pick a card, any card — there are many to choose from and that's without the alleged Family Unfriendly Aesops.
  • Alternative Character Interpretation:
    • The "Distant Planet" promotional animation portrays the robots protecting the bomb on the train as freedom fighters. The upper-class citizens of the city (who may or may not be robots themselves) have forced the lower-class robots into ghettos, keeping them down with martial law. One robot sees his wife's horrified reaction when she watches a newscast of a protest being put down, decides he has had enough degradation, and joins the rebellion. The last scene shows the robot looking at his wife's photo before picking up a gun and shooting at something... the silhouettes of Baby Doll, Sweet Pea, and Rocket. Cue the narrator, who had been explaining the oppressive nature of the regime and the motivations of the rebels, saying a line about how we are all the same in one aspect, because we all have a time to end.
    • Advertisement:
    • Short #2: The steampunk German WW2 soldiers are resurrected after falling in battle without souls. The one depicted starts remembering his old life just before he is killed by the girls' mecha.
    • "Dragon": Humans and orcs are Not So Different.
    • It's interesting to look at Amber and Blondie's characters, at least from how they appear to be. Amber appears to be the timid one of the group, and she's the most nervous before any plan. She even opts to the pilot in the fantasy sequences, doing the least amount of fighting. But if you look at what she does in the film, she proves more to be Silk Hiding Steel - she's able to seduce the Mayor and think on her feet stealing the knife right after Rocket is stabbed. Blondie meanwhile is presented as the tough one, but she's the one who breaks and confesses to Blue - suggesting that she may not be as tough as she seems.
  • Advertisement:
  • Anvilicious: "My most precious possessions" said by Blue pretty much drives the point home in the standard version of the movie.
  • Applicability: Zack Snyder believes the movie seeps ideas into one's brain, but the viewer has to discuss, debate, reinterpret and rethink various scenes in the movie.
  • Audience-Alienating Premise: Nobody could figure out whether it was supposed to be a straight Animesque action film or a Deconstruction of that genre. The result was that nerdy audiences turned away because they felt they were going to be insulted while audiences who'd be interested in a deconstruction thought it was just another action movie. The film's attempt to juggle female empowerment and Fanservice turned off women who wanted the former and men who wanted the latter, as well as feminists of all genders who only saw it as the latter with a thin semblance of the former.
  • Awesome Music:
  • Best Known for the Fanservice: A cadre of incredibly hot young women (check), long kick-ass action sequences (check-check).
  • Better on DVD: The film works better on the small screen with the extended DVD cut - lengthening the fantasy sequences, Foreshadowing a lot more plot devices, making the Male Gaze deconstruction a lot more obvious and adding an additional ending for Baby Doll. Word of God is that the ending in the extended version was intended for the theatrical release but had to be cut due to Executive Meddling.
  • Broken Base:
    • The biggest debate was whether this film is feminist or not.
    • A close second was Emily Browning's performance. As she's playing someone who's gone into shock after suffering so much trauma, the debate centered on if she just used Dull Surprise or was accurately conveying the emotions in a subtle way.
  • Catharsis Factor: Blue finally getting his comeuppance when he forces himself on Baby Doll, and she responds by stabbing him in the shoulder and declaring "you'll never have me". One YouTube commenter said she was ambivalent about the film, but admitted to cheering at the top of her voice when that happened.
  • Complete Monster: Blue Jones is the corrupt head of the Lennox House asylum who receives a bribe from Babydoll's abusive stepfather in order to lobotomize Babydoll. Depicted as the ruthless owner of a brothel in the dream world, Blue Jones has no hesitations punishing those who defy him. Catching Babydoll and the other brothel's prostitutes attempting to rebel, he murders two of his prostitutes to make an example and then attempts to rape Babydoll. After Babydoll sacrifices herself in order to get lobotomized, it was revealed that in the real world, Blue Jones forged the asylum psychiatrist's signature, something he has been done before, in order to make his own patients, including Babydoll, his personal sex toy after being lobotomized. Exposed by the police, Blue Jones tries to incriminate Babydoll's stepfather as a last-ditch effort to save himself.
  • Critical Backlash: From critics and audiences, largely regarding the perceived messages and supposedly feminist aspects of the movie. This whole argument was contentious.
  • Cult Classic: Has a small subset of very dedicated fans. Also has a small but committed fanbase of feminists and whatnot.
  • Darkness-Induced Audience Apathy: The movie is very dark - Baby Doll loses her mother and sister and gets committed to the asylum (as well as overhearing that she'll be lobotomised) all in the first ten minutes! And the fantasy sequences take on a much darker tone when you note that they're there as escapism for the protagonists. As one reviewer put it, the whole movie is essentially a Lie Back and Think of England scenario for victims of rape.
  • Fanon: Although the real world version Sweet Pea is in the asylum is never stated, fans take the conversation between Rocket and Baby Doll to mean that Sweet Pea willingly committed herself in order to look out for Rocket.
  • Gut Punch: Amber and Blondie's deaths are rather jarring and unexpected.
  • Harsher in Hindsight: Babydoll's little sister dies in the beginning of the movie. After the death of Snyder's daughter Autumn Snyder in May 2017, this already dark scene became almost unwatchable.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight:
    Well you built up a world of magic/Because your real life is tragic/Yeah you built up a world of magic...
  • "Holy Shit!" Quotient: The movie is rather off-the-wall.
  • Idiot Plot: The plot relies on the police not trying to question someone who is suspected of assault and murder before/after sedating her and letting one of her alleged victims and primary beneficiary drive her away and institutionalize her, or for at least five days afterwards, and for an apparently ethical lobotomist and therapist to not even think of verifying the paperwork on a lobotomy that the latter didn't think was necessary before performing the procedure. And this has apparently happened multiple times without anyone getting suspicious. The movie requires almost everyone in authority to be stupid or as corrupt as Blue.
  • Iron Woobie: Babydoll who loses both her mother and sister within the first fifteen minutes, gets committed to an asylum and knows she'll be lobotomised in five days. Yet she never cracks and instead comes up with a plan to escape her fate. There is one moment where she cries but it's early in the film and she keeps on.
  • Jerkass Woobie: Sweet Pea may be a cynical and seemingly cold-hearted snarker at the beginning. But she's got a little sister to look out for, implied problems at home, and of course her status as the 'Star of the Show' in the brothel world is her coping mechanism for being repeatedly raped and abused in the asylum.
  • Les Yay:
    • The scene between Amber and Blondie where Blondie explains to Amber how to seduce the Mayor.
    • Not to mention Amber and Blondie are paired up in almost every group scene and even die together.
    • It's much more subtle, but it is there in abundance with Babydoll and Rocket.
    • Babydoll and Sweet Pea shared quite a lot of meaningful looks.
    • In Babydoll's fantasies, she imagines all the girls in skimpy clothing.
    • Rocket is very hands on with all the girls, especially Babydoll and Blondie.
      • And with Sweet Pea too. In the fantasy sequence, at the dungeon entrance, she slaps Sweet Pea's butt to signal her to move forward. It's a blink-and-you'll-miss-it moment, but it's there. She slaps Sweat Pea's thigh. It's a surprisingly well researched depiction of stacking up and breaching a doorway. It just looks a lot less sexual when the guys doing it are marines or police in full combat gear.
      • She also slaps Sweet Pea's butt in the bordello fantasy, before "finishing her tour". Kinky.
    • "I don't bite (too hard)" is said outright by Rocket.
  • Memetic Mutation: There are many many videos on YouTube showing the "real dance" Babydoll did that the audience never got to see. Mostly guys dressed up as she was or wearing troll faces.
  • Moral Event Horizon:
    • After Babydoll's mother dies, her wicked stepfather tries to rape her, and when she resists, he attempts to do the same to her sister who accidentally gets killed by Babydoll, and then has Babydoll institutionalized... in a Bedlam House run by a crooked orderly who has a lobotomist coming in five days from the date of committal. Oh, and he forges signatures.
    • Other than Blue agreeing to arrange a lobotomy for a patient who he knows shouldn't be in the asylum and does not need a lobotomy in exchange for a lengthy amount of bribed cash, he shoots Amber and Blondie, and then tries to rape Babydoll twice. The shooting and first rape attempt happened in the bordello reality, so we don't know how much of it actually happened. Word of God is that the former didn't really happen.
  • One-Scene Wonder:
    • Alan C. Peterson as the Mayor. In his brief appearance, he steals the scene with his utterly badass pimpin' entrance and Leitmotif: a mash-up of "I Want It All" and "We Will Rock You".
    • The Highroller only appears briefly in the extended cut but Jon Hamm's charismatic performance and the genuine kindness he shows Babydoll make him very memorable.
  • Retroactive Recognition: Jamie Chung is better known thanks to Once Upon a Time, Premium Rush, The New Mutants and Gotham.
  • Rewatch Bonus: Little lines and implications make sense with more viewings.
  • She Really Can Act: Vanessa Hudgens prompted this, as High School Musical was still very fresh in people's minds. Blondie goes from being The Big Guy to suddenly a huge Woobie in the third act. Her shock at Amber being killed because of her is a massive Tear Jerker.
  • Shocking Swerve: Who the real narrator is and who really survives the asylum. Also how Blue actually comes off in the real world.
  • They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: Many felt the whole prison framing device wasn't needed and the movie could've worked fine as a straight up fantasy movie within its own unique world.
  • Unintentionally Sympathetic: The baby dragon and his/her mother. The baby does nothing villainous and the girls slit its throat to steal the crystals inside. Of course thankfully they're not actually real and it's only a metaphor for Amber stealing the lighter.
  • Values Resonance: The way Blue controls the asylum and uses the girls as his sex slaves has become startlingly resonant as of 2017 - with numerous women coming forward to accuse noted Hollywood moguls of sexual abuse. Despite a powerful woman in charge of the asylum, Blue still undermines her authority to abuse the girls and controls them through fear. Notable is the scene where Blue murders Amber and Blondie after the latter has confessed. Rather than demonising Blondie as a traitor, the film presents her as a victim who did what she did entirely out of legitimate fear.
  • Visual Effects of Awesome: Pretty much the purpose of the "dance" sequences. The final one is especially blatant, with a number of slow-motion shots of robots getting broken in detail.
  • The Woobie:
    • Babydoll. She loses her mother, is almost raped by her stepfather, shoots at him in self-defense which accidentally kills her younger sister, and is taken to an asylum that just screws more with her already tenuous grip on reality.
    • Blondie becomes quite a big one as her tough facade breaks quite easily once Blue reveals he's onto them. When she breaks down sobbing, it's a very sobering moment from a character who was a Deadpan Snarker beforehand.

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report