- Awesome Music: The ending theme "Love Psalm" rocks pretty hard.
- Broken Base: The game is one of the most polarizing entries in the entire series, primarily due to the Genre Shift. Is it it something that goes against the franchise, or not that big of a deal considering it's a Spin-Off?
- They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: On the surface, a book that rewrites reality is the perfect idea for a Silent Hill game, especially if one considers the implications of a magical artifact in the setting. Instead, the plot turns out to be rather generic, and a massive waste of potential for the game.
YMMV / Silent Hill: Book of Memories