- Big-Lipped Alligator Moment: Jay and Silent Bob have a cameo as Gale is storming off the Stab 3 set. Hilarious yes, but still random and out of place.
- Complete Monster: This film's Ghostface, Roman Bridger, Sidney's half-brother, born of Maureen Prescott being raped during her Hollywood career, is revealed as the instigator of the entire series. Ghostface decries his birth mother as a whore and stalks her extramarital liaisons in Woodboro. They use the evidence to mastermind the original killing spree in the first movie, killing Maureen and their own friends, and letting the original Ghostface take the fall (this also makes him indirectly responsible for the killings of the second movie). Ghostface grows jealous of Sidney's fame as a survivor and sets out to frame her for his own kills. Ghostface disguises himself as a low-budget movie director and kills off the Stab 3 movie's crew while tormenting Sidney with mind games of her traumatic past. Ghostface claims to be a tragic victim who is lashing out at the world, but Sidney points out that he's self-deluding himself and simply enjoys killing people, prompting him to fly into a rage. His sole attempt to connect with Sidney during his death is subverted when seconds later he gets up to try to kill them all again.
- Critical Backlash: Some fans don't find the film to be as bad as it usually gets painted as. While still regarded as the weakest in the franchise, some find it to still be a solid enough film.
- Ensemble Dark Horse: Jennifer Jolie is hailed by several fans to be the only redeeming aspect of the movie, and is almost unanimously agreed to be the best thing about it.
- Harsher in Hindsight:
- Gale and Dewey apparently tried to live together in Woodsboro but Gale couldn't handle it and called it quits. Although they make another try for it, by the fourth film the same thing has happened to Gale again. Doubly so with the foreknowledge that the actors would eventually split up too.
- Finding out Maureen Prescott was a victim of systematic gang-rape by the Hollywood elite becomes extra skin-crawling after Harvey Weinstein (who produced all the "Scream" films) was ousted from his own company thanks to a mountain of sexual harassment suits. It also doesn't help that in the film, Bianca Burnette (Carrie Fisher) says that she lost out on the part of Princess Leia because she wouldn't sleep with George Lucas. And Angelina is revealed to have slept with the director to get the part.
- Hilarious in Hindsight:
- Parker Posey's character is named Jennifer Jolie. This movie was made five years before the beginning of the whole "Brangelina" saga.note And Jennifer Aniston co-starred on Friends with Courteney Cox, who plays Gale in all four movies. Eerie. Oh, and in the same movie, there's also a character named Angelina. Even better, Gale tells her she's sorry things didn't work out with Brad Pitt.
- In light of the fourth film, many events and scenes in the third become this. The plot of Stab 3 is about the main characters returning to Woodsboro... which is the exact plot of Scream 4. Just before her death, Sarah complains to (who she thinks is) the director about how the script is constantly being rewritten... and production on Scream 4 saw several rewrites to the script. One of the characters in Stab 3 is a Suspiciously Similar Substitute for Randy, who was killed off in the second film (in both the Scream and Stab universes)... and in Scream 4, the character of Robbie serves the exact same purpose as the film's replacement Meta Guy, complete with a name similar to Randy's. Honestly, it's a miracle that none of the cast got killed during production.
- Jenny McCarthy stars in this a few years before starring in Scary Movie 3, the first film in that series to not parody the Scream films. In this her character complains about being too old to play a 21-year-old - and she plays a teenager in Scary Movie 3. She also complains about having to die naked in the shower, when in Scary Movie 3 she dies in the bath.
- In early drafts the killer was going to be Angelina, the new Sidney wannabe. Again this is oddly prophetic of Scream 4 where the killer is Sidney's cousin Jill, who wanted to get famous by playing the Final Girl image to the public.
- Stone mentions having been a bodyguard for Julia Roberts and is later murdered by Ghostface. Julia's niece, Emma Roberts, plays Jill, one of the killers, in the fourth movie.
- Cotton complains that "I'm risking my reputation as the host of this country's number one nationally syndicated talk show to do a cameo is some cheap slasher pic." Flash forward to 2006 where Dr. Phil is making a cameo in Scary Movie 4.
- While The Reveal that Roman is the killer can be surprising to the audience, the impact is lessened when you realize Sidney never met the guy once prior to this scene and probably doesn't even know who he is, unlike the other killers, who were all people more or less close to her.
- While running from the killer, Angelina takes the time to freak out and reveal she got her part via the Casting Couch. And Emily Mortimer delivers it in the most ridiculously hammy way possible.
- One-Scene Wonder:
"This is the scene where you come with us..."
- Kincaid's partner is easily one of the more entertaining characters in the film, but gets less screen time than most of the others.
- Carrie Fisher has a small role as a receptionist who was The Other Marty for Princess Leia. She too gets some fun lines and is quite memorable.
- Jenny McCarthy has two scenes, but she is also very memorable, confusing Psycho with Vertigo and hamming it up ridiculously when she's doing her line reading on the phone.
- Only the Creator Does It Right: Many blame the lesser quality on Ehren Kruger replacing Kevin Williamson.
- Retroactive Recognition: Inverted. If you're wondering where you've seen Tyson before, dig up a rerun of The Cosby Show — it's "Bud", all grown up.
- Sequelitis: Widely considered a step down from the first two, in particular for being less of a Deconstructive Parody and more of a straightforward slasher.
- Values Resonance: And Values Dissonance. The film's portrayal of Horrible Hollywood and the manner in which actresses are mistreated can swing in either direction depending on which character it's focusing on. On one hand, Maureen Prescott's backstory, in which she had been raped by a Hollywood producer as she tried to get her foot in the door, rings far more relevant in light of powerful producers like Harvey Weinstein being exposed as serial rapists who exploited the Casting Couch for sex and power. On the other hand, Angelina's characterization as somebody who eagerly slept with the producer herself to get famous can come across as far more questionable today, for the same reason. Nowadays, the power dynamics surrounding the casting couch and sexual abuse in Hollywood are far better understood than they were in 2000.
- WTH, Costuming Department?: Gale's hair, specifically the bangs. One gets the impression she singed the front of her hair and just had to cut the burnt bits off.
YMMV / Scream 3