- Author's Saving Throw: Fans were disgruntled by the anime adaptation for favoring Charlotte by limiting the other brides' screentime and for giving them few romantic scenes with Teppei. The 2-part H-OVA rectified things by excluding Charlotte to focus on Teppei's relationships with Sylvie and his maid, Yuu.
- Base-Breaking Character: Charlotte. Being a Harem series, a lot of folk dislike her for making the harem completely lopsided in her favor; taking up a good portion of the screen-time with Teppei while Sylvie, Yuu and Seika remained mostly Out of Focus. Being the only girl to have a Story Arc involving her didn't help. Of course, there are those who like Charlotte's character and want her to end up with Teppei anyway.
YMMV / Princess Lover!