- Base-Breaking Character: Dylan Weir. Some people like her for being an Action Girl who goes through various stages of development, and for her chemistry with Evan. Others, however, see her as a boring Mary Sue who doesn't contribute much to the cast.
- Broken Base: The theme song. Fans can't decide whether or not it's better than the original Primeval theme, if it's just as good, if it's not as good as the original, but still enjoyable, or if it's complete trash. The theme's so divisive that someone posted the old theme over this show's opening, because the old theme seemed better to the user.
YMMV / Primeval: New World