- Annoying Video-Game Helper: Did you know that you can call Terry and Clay for backup? Don't worry, because Jim will be sure to remind you at every opportunity. Terry and Clay themselves are plenty useful, though.
- Base-Breaking Character: Johnny is perhaps the most contested of the three GTA IV protagonists, many people do like the fact that he is a total badass, his relationship with most of his fellow members is well-liked, and that his background makes it easier to justify going around murdering people compared to Niko or Luis. On the other hand, he is nowhere near as sympathetic as Niko or Luis thanks to doing a lot of hypocritical things after he becomes chapter president. One thing universally agreed upon however is that his death in Grand Theft Auto V was considered to be in very poor taste to the character even considering the situation.
- Best Known for the Fanservice: Back when the game came out everyone was talking about a certain scene. Let's put it this way, reports of gratuitous male nudity in TLAD have been greatly exaggerated.
- Demonic Spiders: Grenade using enemies are easily the number one cause of death for players in gang wars. They are difficult to spot in a heavy firefight and if you are within their effective range they will almost always instantly kill you regardless of your body armor and at best they either kill your whole gang or leave you with almost no health and no armor or both. They also throw with perfect accuracy, their grenades have a much larger blast radius than yours and explode faster. And because later gang war enemies are Made of Iron your grenades won't do the same thing to them, in fact they will just spread them out making the war harder to win and your own grenade mooks are more of a danger to you and themselves then your enemies.
- Genius Bonus: The Grenade Launcher introduced in this episode is modeled after the Heckler & Koch HK69. Could be a coincidence, but it's less likely than not, considering Rockstar's interest in the number 69.
- Guilt-Based Gaming: The memorial wall in the Lost's clubhouse might leave certain players inclined to reload countless times to ensure the survival of the minor character allies that will join you in gang wars and certain missions.
- Harsher in Hindsight:
Johnny: We are free Brothers. We aren't dead and we aren't in jail. How long will it last?Clay: I hope forever.
- Billy Grey gets arrested by the police after a heroin deal gone wrong with the Triads. He blames Johnny for this, which ultimately leads him to go State's Evidence against the Lost and set up the final showdown. However, Ballad reveals that Billy actually meant for the setup to kill Johnny. Also, Billy's first action back from prison is to commit a murder on the doorstep of the Lost's clubhouse. You learn not two missions later that said murder causes the LCPD to keep an eye on said clubhouse.
- While hanging out with Terry and Clay post-story, this discussion might trigger:
- Thomas Stubbs's record as a wasteful Congressman is justified by his calls for a hurricane protection system for Liberty City. Following Hurricane Sandy a few years later, that proposal seems somewhat less ludicrous.
- Jerkass Woobie: The Lost themselves, or rather, what remains of them the end of the game can qualify. Sure, they're murderous, backstabbing criminals, but they didn't deserve many of the tragedies they suffered, because most of these were direct or indirect results of their involvement with the diamonds and heroin, which they just had the rotten luck of being roped into.
- Moral Event Horizon: See here.
- Most Wonderful Sound: The triumphant guitar riff that plays during the autosave after completing most missions.
- Narm: "IIIIII'll see you later!"
- Nightmare Fuel: Jim's torture at the hands of Ray Boccino - mainly involving his face and a blowtorch.
- Paranoia Fuel: One of Stubbs' "Dirty Laundry" missions involves bugging Deputy Mayor Bryce Dawkins' Infernus to expose his secret homosexual affair with Bernie Crane. That same car is later given to Niko as a reward for helping Bernie. The fact that you're driving a car bugged by one of the other protagonists is paranoia fuel as is, but it gets worse. After the mission Stubbs gives Johnny a phone number that will let him listen to the bug. At first it's just Bernie singing along with the radio or thinking aloud about how Gay Tony's bodyguard is attractive, but eventually you'll start hearing the sound of a different Serbian guy running from the police. Yep, not only is it implied that Johnny could listen to Niko at any time without him knowing, it's actually possible in-game. Yet another reason to park that car somewhere safe and never drive it.
- Player Punch: Interestingly, Player Punch scenes in GTA IV become missions here and vice versa. And Jim's death could qualify as one, considering how much time you spend with him during the game.
- Spiritual Licensee: Of Sons of Anarchy. The characters and story are similar, the clothing and bikes are an almost exact match, the tone and setting are if anything even darker, and the game pretty much plays like it's centered on the Liberty charter of SAMCRO rather than Charming's. Watch this fan vid for proof.note
- Tear Jerker: By the end of the game, Johnny has lost his closest friend, killed his chapter's former leader and his childhood friend, and burned down the chapter's club house. What does he have left?
- That One Level: "Buyer's Market", which comes close to The Computer Is a Cheating Bastard territory in terms of the amount of firepower Johnny has to overcome in order to survive. Made more vivid by the relatively easy "Blow Your Cover" level from GTA IV which is supposed to be the same mission but it's from a different perspective and in that one the player has backup, as well as a much less contested path. Fits the criteria for the trope as a number of players have complained about the level's difficulty on the boards (especially when compared to the GTA IV counterpart), while others have stated the mission isn't that difficult.
- Uncanny Valley: Billy has an unusually wide mouth. It makes him look seriously off compared to the other characters.
- Unintentionally Unsympathetic: It can be hard to feel too sorry for Johnny and Jim by the end of the game, as most of their misfortune was brought on by them stealing two million dollars from a mobster, half of which both the main game and a conversation between Ray and Johnny note shows he would've given them anyway. If they hadn't, Jim would still be alive, and his wife would still have a husband, his child a father. That Jim accepted the money at all only makes things worse, since he should've known perfectly well the dire straits his family would've been in if he died.
- There's a chance this is meant to be justified, at least in Johnny's mind given his stated belief that he had been betrayed by Ray's goons and by extent Ray after the deal went bad.
- Wheelchair Woobie: Angus lost the use of his legs in a biking accident involving Billy Grey. Despite his injury preventing him from riding a motorcycle ever again, he still stays on as the Lost's chief mechanic and runs a business exporting (stolen) bikes. He could be an example of Inspirationally Disadvantaged if he weren't a criminal.
YMMV / Grand Theft Auto IV: The Lost and Damned