- Awesome Music: The show may be awful, but there's no denying "Sexy Pet" seriously rules.
- Critic-Proof: Sort of — Angel signed a ten-year contract with Luxor, so the show had to go on despite its awful initial reception. Still, Angel has enough of a fan base that people did come, and followed him to another production in Vegas at rival casino resort Planet Hollywood after the Luxor production closed in 2018.
- Dork Age and Follow-Up Failure: For Cirque, coming after five acclaimed Vegas shows — the most recent of which was the wildly successful The Beatles LOVE — it definitely qualifies as this, especially since so few Cirque elements survived retooling (verging on In Name Only).
YMMV / Criss Angel BeLIEve