Alternative Character Interpretation: "The Black Friday Incident": Did the Pixar animators create that disturbing short film because they were driven to insanity from stress or was it their way of giving the meddling executives the proverbial middle finger? Given that one of them killed himself shortly after finishing it, you might assume the former, but there is something interesting about Woody's actions in the short film—he writes the word "EDGE" on the wall in blood (the executives were constantly demanding "more edge" for the movie) and tauntingly asks "Don't you want it!? Don't you love it!?" to the audience (aka, the executives that the footage is being screened for).
The Slender Man. Either one of the scariest and original monsters of the modern era or an overrated monster that has overstayed his welcome. Much like Jeff, the general dislike is due to overexposure.
Cliché Storm: An interesting example - the Creepypasta Wiki even has a list of "Creepy Cliches".
Papercuts involves the narrator and their friends being captured by a creepy and mysterious figure who mutilates his victims in experiments involving papercuts. There's enough cliches to make an F5 tornado seem like a light summer breeze.
Creepy Awesome: Quite a few monsters 'pasta authors dream up can turn into this.
Critical Research Failure: "There was no text asking me to switch out." from "Snow on Mt. Silver". At this point, the player had only Typhlosion since rest of the team got frostbitten to death.Of course there would be no text to switch out!
Similarly, "Blue Tears" has a sequence where Blue challenges Red to a battle. It's claimed that "there was no option to run away"...which should be obvious because in Pokémon you aren't allowed to run from trainer battles.
The Lost Superman Cartoon is about a lost episode where Superman murders Stalin via his Eye Beams. The thing is, Superman didn't have heat vision in the 1940's, not even in the Fleischer cartoons!
Abandoned By Disney's writer didn't know that Disney doesn't call any of their characters mascots. They're cast members. It's a minor detail, but it can break the willing suspension of disbelief right before The Reveal.
Using "Hyper-realistic" to describe anything is heavily discouraged by the Creepypasta Community, as the word has suffered extensive misuse and overuse, and is consequently seen as pure Narm.
In general, use of supernatural elements in creepypastas has been dying out thanks to frequently less than stellar overuse of it in many creepypastas over the years. Cryptids are sometimes able to skit by, but over the years creepypastas have shifted towards underground conspiracies/organizations and unusual real world phenomena that can be done in real life such as optical tricks or other 'mind hacks' you can pull on yourself. While creepypastas about supernatural horrors will continue to be made, it often takes a lot of effort to keep it from becoming Snark Bait in the community.
Lost Episode creepypastas also got hit with this for similar reasons to video game creepypastas: overuse of cliches, protagonists being Too Dumb to Live, glossing over why said protagonists don't simply unplug the TV/computer, and being some of the worst offenders of the 'hyper-realistic' overuse.
"Deep Web [[Clickbait True Story]]" tales got hit with this when it became easier for the average person to access the deep web and discover what's actually in it.
It doesn't exactly help that nearly every 'true deep web story' are the exact same plot, with a few things having their order switched around. Typically, our protagonist goes on the Deep Web to buy drugs/films/do horrible things/go on for no reason, magically stumbles into a Red Room, then all of a sudden Russians/Chinese/Masked Men instantly break down the door and throw the protagonist into a Red Room where they then die/get their delicate parts hacked off.
Draco in Leather Pants: Jeff the Killer, good god. The amount of people who unironically fangirl over him is insane, and there were so many creepypastas made as an excuse for their OCs to hook up with him that it's become a cliche and a huge source of Snark Bait in the community.
A lot of the more popular monsters can get this from parts of the fandom, not just Jeff the Killer. Some good examples being the Slender Man, X from Sonic.exe, and Laughing Jack.
Fridge Horror: These stories can sometimes be composed of stuff that becomes more horrifying when you think too hard about them. In the case of Pokémon Scary Black and Pokémon Lost Silver, one must wonder who would be sadistic enough to make such hacks, and why they would distribute them on plastic cartridges rather than on the web.
Made even worse by the fact that the cartridges were apparently old enough to predate the technology required for them to be hacked to that extent. So either someone at Nintendo has an incredibly sick sense of humor, or the explanation is of a more... supernatural nature.
The story "Abandoned By Disney" has the narrator discovering, in a previously locked room in an abandoned resort, the corpses of the employees and the... thing that killed them. He runs and escapes with his life, but he makes no mention of having re-locked the door. Whatever was in that room may have just escaped into the world at large.
The story "Ability" revolves around the protagonist encountering a homeless man who keeps muttering strange things, and eventually learning that he possess the psychic ability to know what the last thing somebody ate was. It appears like a case of What Kind of Lame Power Is Heart, Anyway?...except for the fact that one of the things he mentioned was "Human", and that he said it while an ordinary-looking businessman passed him.
A few years after Squidward's Suicide Nickelodeon would go on to release an actual SpongeBob SquarePants episode called "Are You Happy Now?" where the reoccurring joke is Squidward is depressed and looks like he might commit suicide. Some people have theorized that someone on the writing staff did it on purpose as a nod to the Pasta.
The commercial for the Rap Rat board game says "He's no ghost, he's the most!". Guess which very character would become central in a popular creepypasta years later?
The title of "Snow on Mt. Silver" became this when Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver actually included a snowy part of Mt. Silver, as well as the even more snowy Sinjoh Ruins.
Psychopath Mode involves a fan-made PC port of Dead Rising that the author downloads due to losing his copy of the game. A few years after the story was written, the game was officially given a PC release.
Idiot Plot: More than a few creepypastas are the result of the protagonist doing something that nobody in their right mind would do and/or continuing to poke at the Obviously Evil thing they've found over and over again before it predictably retaliates. The now-defunct Trollpasta Wiki had an entire category on this, "Stupid is as the main character does".
The premises of some creepypastas can be rather unsettling until an absolutely absurd detail is given, like in "Mereana Mordegard Glesgorv", where the detail that the viewers of the video gouged their eyes out then mailed them to YouTube's main office is given, which implies that they could somehow still write neat addresses on envelopes without being able to see, and while blood is busy gushing out of their empty eye sockets.
If one stops to think about the disturbing imagery associated with Creepypasta, many of them turn to nightmare retardant quickly, since most of the shocking pictures are just obvious photoshop. For example, the image for Smile Dog. While painted as a frightening, evil demonic entity in the pasta, that picture is really a photoshopped image of someone's dog. Smile Dog is actually a Siberian Husky - one of the most beautiful and photogenic breeds of dog.
The Trollpasta Wiki is devoted to poorly-written tales (intentional or otherwise), such as the infamous WHO WAS PHONE?
This is par for the course in video game and lost episode pastas. Whatever the story does right, it doesn't change the fact that you're reading what's essentially a Dark Fic of a silly, idealistic, and generally nonthreatening work like Pokémon, My Little Pony or SpongeBob SquarePants. On the other hand, if the source material is already serious and cynical, then people are expecting something dark, which isn't good since most of these pastas rely on Surprise Creepy. Pastas about an original Show Within a Show, such as Candle Cove, tend to fare better because they aren't burdened with the reader's expectations of the work.
The long-deleted Kirby's Deadland, in which characters with names such as "Whispy Woods" are written completely seriously, despite the Nightmare Retardant their names entail. The Bad Creepypasta crew pointed out how the names of Kirby's rogues gallery are so non-threatening, that they'd be right at home in a series such as Jackanory.
Papercuts is supposed to be a serious story about a mysterious figure mutilating people, but it's hard to take seriously because of the fact that the villain's agenda involves papercut experiments, of all things. The narrator's friends abruptly dying also ends up killing the mood.
Some of the ways you have to acquire artefacts in the Holders series go beyond trying too hard to build suspense and fly straight into the realm of Narm.
The Harbinger Experiment is mostly creepy, but the fact that the monster's arrival is heralded by Tiny Tim's "Livin' in the Sunlight" can feel silly — especially if you associate that song with Spongebob Squarepants.
Speaking of SpongeBob, the "SpongeBob Bootleg Episode" has a still of SpongeBob that is stated to blink if looked at long enough. And if you look at the actual image long enough? He does...because the it's a gif. There goes the Willing Suspension of Disbelief.
"Digimon: The Unseen Episode" includes the opening of the show being messed up, which the narrator describes as being like a YouTube Poop.
Abandoned by Disney and its sequel Room Zero, are this for anyone who's been to a Disney park. "Room Zero" is the most paranoia-inducing, between the author's descriptions of being followed and finding Mickey-Mouse silhouettes everywhere, the "corpse disposal" procedure, the Gascots, the eldritch happenings on the waterslides, and the implication that Disney had an old woman murdered for talking about one of their darkest secrets. The crowning moment of Paranoia Fuel, however, has got to be the big reveal: there's a bomb shelter under Disneyworld, sealed off and filled with a park's worth of long dead patrons as well as... something, possibly the demonic force responsible for the events of the first story. All right under everyone's feet. Even worse, it's implied that they're still haunting the park, and are not only responsible for the horrors in both stories but also possibly cursing the entire Disney corporation.
The grand finale of the Abandoned by Disney saga, Corruptus, and the revelation within it that the bomb shelter and possibly the Gascots were a corruption doesn't help one bit. Just what are these things slowly corrupting everything Disney? What do they want? Why are they here? Who knows?
Kids in the Dark, mainly because you never know anything about what was making the noises, why it was making the noises, or why it was climbing into the narrator's bed at night for comfort. Honestly, anything by Slimebeast counts.
Anansi's Goatman Story has this in spades. The titular creature is a shapeshifter, and inserts itself into the protagonists' group repeatedly over the course of the story, and most of them remain unaware of it. Worse, one of the characters who was keeping watch saw it sneak into the room where they were sleeping while it thought he was asleep. He sat there, too scared to move, watching it for the rest of the night, and then it walked back to civilization with them. Plus, why it did this, what it wanted from them, or even what "it" ''was'' is never revealed.
The Dad's Tapes r/NoSleep series by EZmisery gives us the Friends, demonic beings from an entirely different world. They outnumber humanity, and their sole purpose is to cause suffering and death, but they can't interact with our world in their natural form. They have to take over a human body by entering through the tear ducts, and they're so good at mimicking humans that it's almost impossible to distinguish them from people. Once a host is caught, they move on to someone else, leaving behind completely fabricated memories. They could be possessing anyone, anywhere, including the people closest to you, and the worst thing you could ever do in the presence of a Friend is say yes to anything they say.
After reading The Harbinger Experiment, you'll probably jump every time you hear "Livin' in the Sunlight" by Tiny Tim.
The Scrappy: Clockwork: Your Time Is Up is often considered to be one of the worst Creepypastas of all time, and the main character, Natalie, is the fandom's equivalent of Ebony Dark'ness Dementia Raven Way for personifying the fandom's more infamous Mary Sue traits. Unlike Jeff the Killer, whom she is clearly based off of, she has very few defenders.
"Seinfeld" Is Unfunny: More than a few creepypastas that were once regarded as some of the best ever made have long since become prime examples of how not to write a creepypasta. A prime example would be Jeff the Killer: originally regarded as one of the scariest creepypasta slashers, he's now regarded a bland villain who overuses gore to downright offensive levels.
Sequelitis: NoEnd House suffers from this. While the first two installments are considered good, the third throws the everything out the window by giving the house a cliche backstory involving witches, veering away from the horror, and being incredibly brief.