Growing the Beard: While the first season was well-received, the following seasons were received far better due to the show's embrace of increasingly weirder Speculative Fiction.
LGBT Fanbase: The fact that Melody has a wife who becomes more and more involved in the story as the podcast goes on is a big draw for queer fans. To the point where the show removing this relationship grew to be a point of contention.
The show:
Artistic License – Space: If there was a comet named Kharon that had been discovered in 1784 and was visible from Earth even more frequently than Halley's comet, it seems unlikely that one of Pluto's moons would have been named after the same mythological figure two centuries later.
