Follow TV Tropes


YMMV / All-New X-Men (2016)

Go To

  • Broken Base:
    • Even before volume two bowed fans were split on Dennis Hopeless, primarily based on how much readers enjoyed his previous work. It wasn't helped by Broken Base over Avengers Arena and Undercover.
      • The first couple issues have done little to resolve the situation, with opinions remaining decidedly split. Particularly over his characterization of Wolverine.
    • Pickles in volume 2 is either a cute addition to the cast in the book that's not meant to take itself too seriously, or an irritating Ridiculously Cute Critter worthy Jar-Jar Binks levels of backlash, especially as Hopeless has already said that he's his favorite member of the cast. The fact that if his sole purpose on the team is to act as the team teleporter, despite fan-favorite characters with that power set such as Pixie not being used by the other books, has only added fuel to hate.
  • Creator's Pet:
    • Pickles in volume 2 is Hopeless's self-admitted favorite member of the cast, with his presence in the book earning backlash — particularly with other teleporters like Pixie available, but unused — a mere four issues in.
    • While fans wanted to see Madelyne Pryor appear after her resurrection during X-Men, the Maddie who did get used was instead the alternate universe version Hopeless created for Secret Wars: Inferno. That he chose to use his Maddie rather than Prime!Maddie didn't exactly please many fans.
  • Fan-Disliked Explanation: Even before the explanation for Laura's out-of character behaviornote  was revealed, fans were rejecting it as there being nothing plausible enough to explain it. That Hopeless has also been trolling X-23 fans' reaction only exacerbates it further. The actual explanation — that Laura has been a Stepford Smiler who continues to struggle with her discomfort letting people get close the entire time, is acting out because she doesn't want to be seen as the Emotionless Girl, and thinks this is a way to be perceived as normal for Warren's benefit — hasn't been particularly well-received, either. Especially because fans view it as a Retcon of all of her Character Development in the very well-received series by Marjorie Liu.
  • Fan-Preferred Couple: As above, the preference for Laura and Scott continues into the second volume. While Larren has a few fans, the overwhelming preference for matching her with Scott prevents it from becoming outright Ship-to-Ship Combat. Their reasoning is especially highlighted in issue 12, when Laura's own private thoughts muse that Scott is one of the only people who actually understands her, while it's made abundantly clear that Warren doesn't.
  • Informed Wrongness: After being relaunched as part of the All-New, All-Different Marvel initiative, the 'Cyclops is a villain' theme has been re-affirmed as, following a timeskip, Cyclops did something that has made him become regarded as one of the worst monsters in the Marvel Universe after the reveal about Terrigen Mist's effect on mutants were revealed. As we've not actually been told what it is that Scott did, and the fact that he did said act in response to the fact that mutants are being killed and sterilized by the Terrigen Mist cloud, which was released by Black Bolt without checking if it would harm anyone first, makes it hard for fans to accept him in the wrong. It doesn't help that Teen!Cyclops' description of his adult counterpart's actions leading up to it don't gel with how he actually acted, making him look like, at best, an Unreliable Narrator. And the fact it turns out he didn't even do what was said he did.
  • Strangled by the Red String: As bad as the fan reaction was under Bendis, readers have objected even more strongly to Hopeless' use of X-23 and Warren's relationship, to the point that the conflict between them has virtually overwhelmed their presence on the book. Everything is about their relationship, with accusations that the characters (especially X) are being twisted grossly out of character just to make the entire thing work.
  • Wangst: Warren's attempt to show Laura he understands her in issue 12 because of his own inner darkness he struggles to control falls flat considering that his inner darkness was entirely self-inflicted: While Laura was tortured, abused, and forced to kill against her will, Warren willfully grabbed the Black Vortex without hesitation in an attempt to prevent his future from coming to pass.
  • They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: The handling of the relationship between Laura and Warren. Many fans felt that Laura's background of abuse (and the fact she was a victim of statutory, if not actual, rape during her time as a prostitute) would have made for a much more interesting source of conflict in her relationship with Warren, particularly as difficulties maintaining healthy relationships are very much Truth in Television for real life abuse and rape victims. The actual cause became a Fan-Disliked Explanation even before it was fully revealed.