Follow TV Tropes

Following

What Could Have Been / The Undertaker

Go To

The Undertaker is one of the longest-tenured characters in WWE, if not all of pro wrestling, (and so is the career of the man who portrays him, Mark Calaway) so of course he's bound to have lots of these.


  • Mark Calaway originally wanted to be a pro-basketball player.
  • WCW had their chance with Mark, who wrestled there in the late 80's, but true to WCW style they fired him because they thought he'd never catch on.
    • According to Kevin Nash, they nearly coaxed him back in 1999 to come in as himself, in between better money offers and being tired of playing the Deadman at the time, but between his long injury hiatus and WCW cratering in quality around the same time, he decided against it.
  • The Undertaker's original manager, back when he was "Kane the Undertaker" (get a load of that name)? Brother Love. Now just imagine how the character would have evolved if Brother Love had stayed his manager.
  • Mark almost became The Gobbledy Gooker! Vince McMahon wanted Mark to debut by being hatched from the egg as "The Eggman" (yes, written like that Eggman), but was persuaded by Pat Patterson to take up the Undertaker persona he had created.
  • The Undertaker long knew he was taking some time off in 2000 to heal up from some injuries, and wanted to come back with a new gimmick, as he felt the Deadman had run its course. This ultimately led to Bikertaker. One of the ideas bandied about was that Jake Roberts would "save" the Undertaker and he would come back wearing all white and basically be a reverse of his Phenom character. Taker rejected this, as it would have been worse than the deadman character, and ultimately the biker gimmick was born.
    • Not too long after he started the gimmick, Limp Bizkit came out with "Rollin'" and Taker's theme music was switched to that to cash in on its popularity, and then the demonic aspects of the character were dropped because they didn't fit in anymore. If Limp Bizkit hadn't written Rollin', we might never have had Bikertaker as we know him.
  • The Streak has dozens of opponents who nearly fought Undertaker:
    • Several fans have remarked about what might have been had the Ultimate Warrior resolved his differences with Vince McMahon after the 1991 SummerSlam and continued his feuds with Undertaker and Jake Roberts. These hardcore fans wanted to see — after disposing of Roberts — a final, ultimate showdown pitting Warrior and a still-heel Undertaker at WrestleMania VIII, with Warrior gaining a decisive victory. Surely, Undertaker's push would have been squashed (as his credibility as an unbeatable, more-dire-than-usual force would have been destroyed) and certainly there would never have been anything close to resembling "The Streak," much less Calaway remaining with WWF/WWE all these years, and certainly not as the Undertaker.
    • Thrice over at WrestleMania 21:
      • The original plan was for Taker to feud with then newcomer Religious Zealot Wrestler, Mordecai. Vince, Taker, and Mordecai were all set on the idea, but the plan was scrapped after Mordecai was fired for getting involved in a bar fight.
      • The second plan was for Taker and Kane to reunite to face Heidenreich and Snitsky. Taker refused as he wanted to face Randy Orton so he could help build the future of the company.
      • Taker actually wanted to lose to Orton, but Orton flat out refused out of respect. This was probably also why this was the first year that The Streak itself became a major built part of his Mania match.
    • According to Kurt Angle, he was considered to end Undertaker's streak at WrestleMania 22 in a match for the World Heavyweight Championship instead of at No Way Out 2006. Undertaker was willing to take the loss because he hadn't had a 5-Star WrestleMania match and the writing team was willing to do it to keep Angle looking strong as champion.
    • Tommy Dreamer mentioned that he had worked out a deal for Abyss to come to WWE, and they were even considering him as an opponent for The Undertaker at WrestleMania 23. Unfortunately, Abyss got cold feet about leaving TNA, and backed out of the deal at the last minute.
    • Bobby Lashley was heavily considered to challenge him and possibly end the streak at WrestleMania 24, but Lashley leaving the WWE before then put an end to those plans.
    • Twice over at WrestleMania XXVII:
      • Sting was approached to wrestle the Undertaker, but turned it down because he disliked Vince McMahon's treatment of former WCW talent. The fact that the Undertaker's eventual opponent that year Triple H used part of Metallica's "For Whom the Bell Tolls" for his entrance was taken as proof of this, as for a while in the late 90s in WCW, Sting had used a live version of "Seek and Destroy" as his entrance theme, and it's assumed that WWE had already paid for the rights to use a Metallica song and decided to use it regardless of Sting appearing.
      • There were also plans to have Wade Barrett vs. Undertaker at quite early on, which appears to be evidenced by the rather sudden beatdown by The Nexus upon the Undertaker at Bragging Rights 2010.
    • Plans were for Undertaker to originally face John Cena at WrestleMania 32 and WrestleMania 33 (before they finally faced off in WrestleMania 34), and Taker himself handpicked Cena to potentially be his final opponent. However, there are two separate reasons why it was called off:
      • WrestleMania 32: Cena was still recovering from his latest injury (although he briefly showed up to help The Rock fend off the Wyatt Family), resulting with Shane McMahon taking over in Cena's place.
      • WrestleMania 33: Vince replaced Cena with Roman Reigns because he wanted to build on future stars instead. Cena brought this up and lampshaded it during a SmackDown segment with The Miz and Maryse (with whom he was set to face off at WrestleMania 33 in a mixed tag team match, teaming up with his then-girlfriend Nikki Bella) when The Miz accused him of being a backstage manipulator.
        Cena: If I were really this "black-arts manipulator", pulling all the strings this close to WrestleMania, you really think I'd be standing in a ring toe-to-toe, face-to-face with YOU!? Hell no! I'd be standing face-to-face with the Undertaker!
  • Former WWE writer Brian Gewirtz revealed on Twitter that there was discussion to have Kaval, better known as Low Ki, become Undertaker's secret long lost son. Ultimately, the idea wasn't discussed for long nor was it pitched to Vince McMahon. Hilariously enough, Kaval became the NXT rookie of Taker's wife Michelle McCool and Layla.

Top