It's about Rudolph, Santa Claus's ninth reindeer and son of Donner. Rudolph, to the shock of his parents, is born with a red nose which glows when he gets excited. Santa, who's kind of a Jerkass throughout, tells Donner that he'd better cover up his son's red nose or Rudolph will never get to pull Santa's sleigh. Donner tries but eventually the mud on Rudolph's nose falls off and exposes his secret, leaving him to be mocked and ostracized by the other reindeer.
A second plot thread follows Hermey, one of Santa's elves. Unlike all the other elves, who are content to hammer out toys for all the good little children of the world, Hermey has dreams of being a dentist. His rage-prone supervisor won't tolerate this talk of dentistry, however, and Hermey runs away. He meets Rudolph, and they run away together. Together they meet a prospector named Yukon Cornelius, who is searching the wilds of the frozen north for gold. They have adventures that include finding an Island of Misfit Toys where unwanted toys go, and they have to flee from the scary giant Abominable Snow Monster. The whole story is narrated by Sam the Snowman, voiced by Burl Ives.
Rudolph was created in 1939 by Robert L. May, an advertising copywriter for the Montgomery Ward department store chain, after his employer asked him to come up with a short Christmas-themed storybook to give to customers during the holiday season. The Rudolph story was further popularized a decade later when May's brother-in-law, songwriter Johnny Marks, adapted it into a catchy ditty, which was subsequently made into a #1 hit record by singing cowboy Gene Autry. The song became a Christmas holiday standard, and eventually inspired the creation of the TV special (in which Burl Ives performs the tune).
The lyric "All of the other reindeer" can be misheard as the Mondegreen "Olive, the other reindeer", and has given rise to another fictional character, Olive. Similarly, the lyric "and they shouted out with glee" has evolved into a tongue-in-cheek misinterpretation itself, "and they shouted out, 'With glee!'" — prompting singers to shout "With glee!" in response to the line. (This can clearly be heard on at least one recording of a live performance of the song aired during the 2009 season.)
The song in its Finnish translation, Petteri Punakuono, has led to Rudolph's general acceptance in the Finland's folklore as Joulupukki's, the Finnish Santa's, lead reindeer. However, in Finland, Santa's reindeer do not fly. Mike Eheman made the newest version of the song with the actual flying reindeer so Santa can land on rooftops.
Directly followed (with diminishing returns) by Rudolphs Shiny New Year in 1976 and the crossover movie Rudolph and Frosty's Christmas in July in 1979, while the characters re-appeared in the 2001 direct-to-video CGI film Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer And The Island Of Misfit Toys (also made by GoodTimes, ironically.)
Now has a Character Sheet that could use some wiki magic.
The Rankin/Bass Christmas Special and its sequels provide examples of:
- Abusive Parents: Some of the things Rudolph's father says and does are seriously close to the border of emotional abuse. Although considering the time when the creators were growing up and when the movie was released, it probably wasn't intended to come off as abusive and was meant to be a typical father-son relationship. Men being hard on their sons was considered the norm, whether it was fair or not, and could still be considered reasonably well-adjusted. To be fair though, the narrator does state that Donner felt pretty bad about the way he treated Rudolph when Rudolph runs off.
- Adaptation Expansion: Rankin/Bass added a lot of details even to the basic story for their adaptation, including making Rudolph the son of Donner and Mrs. Donner (his parents were unnamed in the original story), having Santa show up at his birth to taunt him about his nose (he originally didn't meet Santa until the end), and making the "Reindeer Games" into an official competition to pull Santa's sleigh (rather than just young reindeer playing around). It makes the story seem a lot crueler.
- Of course, that's in addition to all the things obviously added just to pad out the story - Rudolph running away, meeting Hermey and Yukon Cornelius, finding the Island of Misfit Toys, and so on.
- Adaptational Jerkass: Speaking for even general legend, Santa isnt exactly the jolly, warm father figure that he's always been in this special. In fact, he's kind of a complete asshole until the third act. The first time we see him, he's insulting and dismissive about the elves' singing. Later, he angrily tells Donner he should be ashamed for Rudolph's nose.
- Adorkable: Rudolph, both as a child and as an adult, especially with stuffy, pouty voice.
- All of the Other Reindeer: It's a given, considering Rudolph is the Trope Namer. Except for Clarice, every young reindeer who finds out about his nose starts calling Rudolph by such offensive nicknames as "Firesnout", "big nose" and "Rainbow Schnoz". And Comet encourages them to make him a social outcast.
- Alternate Continuity:
- The Rankin-Bass specials take place in a timeline distinct from the original Robert L. May book and its sequel Rudolph Shines Again.
- The DC Comics miniseries takes place in its own distinct continuity as well. Its also an official part of the DC multiverse despite DC only licensing the character, with Crisis on Infinite Earths: The Compendium stating they're set on Earth-Twelve.
- Ambiguously Gay: Some have thought this about Hermey. It doesn't help that his quest to become a dentist unintentionally resembles a Coming-Out Story. In fact, the story of both Rudolph and Hermey could be seen as one, separately.
- Animated Adaptation: The Rankin-Bass special, of course.
- Artistic License Biology: Santa's "reindeer" do not even remotely resemble real life reindeer. They, in fact, seem to bear all the hallmarks of the white-tailed deer commonly seen in temperate regions of North America, in both size and body shape, and the fact that the females are depicted without antlers (in real life, female reindeer grow a smaller, but still very impressive set of antlers). Interestingly, it's actually the males who should be lacking antlers around Christmas time, not the females (males shed their antlers around early December, while females keep theirs until summer.) Then again, these are magic reindeer.
- These antlers also seem to be capable of emoting as if they were an animal's ears (watch closely and you'll see the antlers of the adults curl up from time to time). Obviously, real antlers cannot do this, and it may simply be a product of cartoon logic.
- Award-Bait Song: There's Always Tomorrow.
- Berserk Button: The Head Elf finds the idea of Hermey as a dentist ridiculous, until he needs a dental appointment.
- Bigfoot, Sasquatch and Yeti: Bumble, the Abominable Snow Monster.
- Big "WHAT?!": A recurring line for the Boss Elf, especially in his reactions to Hermey wanting to be a dentist.
- Brains Evil, Brawn Good: Yukon Cornelius is a big, strong, tough guy; and he's the only adult who isn't mean to poor Rudolph. Not that he's exactly dumb, more just incredibly quirky, but it doesn't change the fact that the strong guy is the nice guy.
- Christmas Elves
- Christmas Special: A Trope Maker.
- Cursed with Awesome:
- In the eyes of some viewers — and offscreen, in-universe children — some of the misfit toys fall under this.
- Rudolph himself. He's considered a freak, but his nose has its uses.
- Hermey too. His talent makes him an outcast among the other elves, but he uses it to save his friends from the Abominable. Indeed, this Trope seems to apply to all the "misfits" in the special.
- Damned by Faint Praise: The rehearsal of "We Are Santa's Elves" is met with a lukewarm reception by Santa, but praised by Mrs. Claus, and the Boss Elf criticizes the elf choir afterwards:Santa: Hmm... Well, it needs work, I have to go. [Santa leaves the room]
Mrs. Claus: What does Papa know? It's beautiful! You keep it just the way it was. Papa? Papa?
Boss Elf [after Mrs. Claus leaves]: That sounded terrible! The tenor section was weak!
- Deadpan Snarker: Queen Camilla, the Queen Hippo of Castaway Cove in Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer and the Island of Misfit Toys, sums it up in this exchange:Hermey: (As Rudolph is considering plastic surgery to get a normal nose) But, what if there's another foggy Christmas Eve?Camilla: Santa can't afford headlights?
- Defeat Means Friendship: The Abominable Snowmonster.
- Depraved Dentist: Hermey is a rare heroic example. In the climax, he rips out the Bumble's teeth with pliers. In the 2001 sequel he gives him dentures as a Continuity Nod.
- Digital Destruction: Early pressings of the Blu-Ray made Yukon Cornelius' coat look green instead of blue. Thankfully, the 50th Anniversary Edition has it changed back to blue.
- Disney Death: Yukon Cornelius and the Abominable Snow Monster both survive the fall, because Bumbles are bouncy.
- Double Take: The Boss Elf's reaction to Hermey wanting to be a dentist:Boss Elf: Hermey! Aren't you finished painting that yet? There's a pile-up a mile wide behind you. What's eating you, boy?
Hermey: Not happy in my work, I guess.
Boss Elf: What?!
Hermey: I just don't like to make toys.
Boss Elf: Oh well, if that's all... [pause] What?! You don't like to make toys?
Boss Elf [mockingly]: Hermey doesn't like to make toys!
- Dying Moment of Awesome: Subverted: Yukon appears to fall off a cliff while wrestling the Abominable Snowmonster, but they both survive. See Disney Death.
- Edible Ammunition: One Misfit Toy is a squirtgun that shoots jelly.
- Extremely Short Timespan: While the first special takes place over the course of at least a year, Rudolph's Shiny New Year starts immediately after the end of it and is set in the span of less than a week.
- Feathered Fiend: Eon the Terrible from Shiny New Year, though it's hard to blame him if you look at things from his perspective.
- First-Person Peripheral Narrator: Sam the Snowman. Apparently, his only raison d'etre besides telling the audience the story is to sing and perform on the banjo songs that are only tangentially related to the plot.
- Fluffy Tamer: Yukon Cornelius and Hermey who extracts Bumble the Abominable Snowman's teeth.
- Fluffy the Terrible: Bumble is quite a cute name for a malicious giant monster with More Teeth than the Osmond Family.
- Forbidden Romance: Clarice's father forbids her from socializing with Rudolph on account of his red nose.
- Friendship Song: "We're a Couple of Misfits".
- George Jetson Job Security: The Boss Elf threatens to fire Hermey unless he starts getting back to work; subverted when Hermey decides to resign, and he even makes this clear in "We're a Couple of Misfits":Hermey: You can't fire me, I quit, seems I don't fit in.
- Hand Wave: How do Rudolph and especially Hermey survive a night in the open at the North Pole before Yukon Cornelius finds them? "Somehow", that's how.
- Haven't You Seen X Before?: "What's the matter? Haven't you ever seen a talking snowman before?"
- In a way, it almost lampshades Frosty the Snowman...
- HeelFace Turn: Boss Elf finally realizes that Hermey's dentistry dream really does have potential after hearing how he pulled the Abominable Snowmonster's teeth and lets Hermey open shop as dentist, with the first appointments set for as early as the week after Christmas. (Ironically, Boss Elf is the first one who needs an appointment, it seems.) The Abominable Snowmonster itself makes the turn after Yukon outwits it with Hermey's help.
- And Jerkass Santa? Chalk it up to Laser-Guided Karma hitting him in the form of the Big Snow (he was apparently more of a jerk than usual that year, whereas in the previous year he came across as more reasonable when visiting Donner) and teaching him a rather valuable lesson.
- The Toy Taker in Island of Misfit Toys after Santa acquaints him with his long lost owner's daughter.
- I Am What I Am: Rudolph's nose.
- Immediate Sequel: Rudolph's Shiny New Year starts on the very same night that Rudolph made his famous flight to save Christmas.
- Immortals Fear Death: Aeon's motivation in the sequel. He's not technically immortal, but he's clearly lived several millennia, and as such, he's terrified of dying, and thinks he can stave off death by kidnapping the New Year. (And he succeeds, just not the way he figured.)
- Informed Flaw: One notorious point of contention is that the doll on the Island of Misfit Toys doesn't seem to have anything wrong with her. Word of God is that she's depressed.
- Ink-Suit Actor: Burl Ives' Sam, again.
- "I Want" Song: "Fame and Fortune" before it was changed back to "We're a Couple of Misfits" fits the bill, also the first half-minute of "The Most Wonderful Day of the Year".
- Jerkass: While All of the Other Reindeer naturally qualify, Santa Claus himself is actually quite abrasive in this edition, first tersely dismissing the elves' song, and storming out, and later, after Rudolph's nose is made public, he not only doesn't stop the other reindeer from ridiculing him, but actually treats Rudolph just as bad as they do. Clarice is an exception though. Not only does she not ridicule him, but she also compliments him, and even becomes his girlfriend in the end.
- He even tells Donner he should be ashamed for his son's uncontrollable, uncurable physical abnormality.
- They all have a Heel Realization upon hearing Rudolph and Hermey's story about their travels and realizing their abnormalities can be put to good use after all (It is important to note that Donner and the Head Elf are both depicted apologizing to Rudolph and Hermey before the revelation about the usefulness of the nose.)
- The head elf is especially bad, and initially refuses to let Hermey be a dentist. He eventually relents and allows him to open a dentist's office after Christmas.
- He even tells Donner he should be ashamed for his son's uncontrollable, uncurable physical abnormality.
- Karma Houdini: Except for Mrs. Donner, Yukon Cornelius and King Moonracer, all of the adults around Rudolph treat him in a way that borders emotional abuse. They never get called out or face any consequences, his Informed Deformity just turns out to be useful, and they accept him. (The exception being Donner, who we get an apology from before the big Santa epiphany.)
- Large Ham: Yukon Cornelius.Cornelius: We'll all be rich, with the biggest silver strike this side of Hudson Bay! SILVEEERRR!Hermey: But I thought you wanted gold.Cornelius: I CHANGED MY MIND!
- The Head Elf seems incapable of talking without bellowing.
- Laser-Guided Karma: The Big Snow is hinted to have been caused by Santa's unusually jerkish behavior over the past year; earlier in the special he came across as a bit more reasonable, whereas the next year he's shown to be putting down the elves' premiere performance of "We Are Santa's Elves" (and the elves decide that Hermey is to blame for not being there to back the tenor section) and chewing out Donner for his part in deliberately hiding Rudolph's nose. That's right, the man who puts coal in the stockings of naughty children was being naughty himself that year, and just after he voided his Karma Houdini Warranty by coming to Rudolph for help when Donner goes missing, the Big Snow hit and almost caused Christmas to be cancelled. At the very least, it taught Santa a valuable lesson in humility and tolerance. In the sequel Rudolph and Frosty's Christmas in July, however, it's revealed that the foggy weather was caused by the warlock Winterbolt, in an attempt to prevent Santa from making his Christmas Eve rounds.
- Living Toys: The Misfit Toys. Well, sort of. Apparently, the idea is, they are like this because they're neglected and unwanted, which is why they qualify for this Trope. (The special suggests that all toys are Level 2 on the Sliding Scale of Living Toys.)
- Lonely Together: Rudolph and Hermey most certainly.Hermey: Hey, what do you say we both be independent together, huh?
Rudolph: You wouldn't mind my... red nose?
Hermey: Not if you don't mind me being a dentist.
Rudolph: It's a deal!
- Lyrical Dissonance: The song that the Misfit Toys sing sounds happy and cheerfulnote , until you realize it's about how lonely they are because they're unwanted.note
- Matryoshka Object: One of the Misfit Toys is a clown nesting doll, whose smallest doll contains a wind-up mouse.
- Mean Boss: Hermey's unnamed Boss Elf, although he warms up at the end.
- Money Song: Burl Ives' song "Silver and Gold" sorta straddles the line.
- More Teeth than the Osmond Family: Bumble has a mouth full of sharp teeth. Hermey pulls them out when they defeat the beast.
- Mrs. Claus: Who admonished Santa for not eating enough, and that kids wouldn't want a skinny Santa.
- My God, What Have I Done?: Donner deeply regrets how he treated Rudolph after his son runs away.
- Narrator: Sam the Snowman in the original special, and Father Time in Shiny New Year.
- New Year Has Come: Rudolph's Shiny New Year deconstructs New Year's Eve as being an ordained and necessary ritual that must occur at midnight on December 31st for time to continue flowing.
- No Celebrities Were Harmed: Charlie-in-the-Box, the sentry on the Island of Misfit Toys (voiced by Alfie Scopp), sounds similar to old Vaudeville and Radio-era comedian Ed Wynn.
- No Indoor Voice:
- Yukon Cornelius. "LAAAAAAAAAAAND HOOOOOOOOOO!"note
- Also the elf foreman, who sounds exactly like Yosemite Sam.
- No Name Given: In the original special, the tall elf with glasses is nameless, until Rudolph and the Island of Misfit Toys, when his name is revealed as Hank.
- Nothing Is Scarier: The Abominable Snow Monster is a terrifying presence in the first half of the special when he exists only as a frightening roar while a giant pair of legs go striding by, and the scene becomes very dark. Once we see the whole creature, he's not that scary any more.
- Older Than They Look: It's implied that Santa's elves are this.
- Older Than They Think: In-universe, with the story of Nestor the donkey.
- Only Friend: Clarice is the only deer who does not laugh at Rudolphs nose.
- Opinion Flipflop: So, Rudolph is now popular because they figured out a way for his red nose to be useful. His father chimes in, saying "I knew that nose would be useful someday."
- Our Elves Are Different: Hermey very literally is! Not only does he want to be a dentist instead of making toys, he's the only elf at the North Pole with round ears instead of pointy ones.
- Overprotective Dad: After Rudolph takes Clarice home, her father sternly rebukes Rudolph after seeing his shiny nose:Clarice's Father: Clarice!
Clarice's Father: You get back to your cave this instant!
Clarice: But I -
Clarice's Father: This instant, young lady!
Clarice: Yes, sir.
Clarice's Father [to Rudolph]: Now, there's one thing I want to make very plain: No doe of mine is going to be seen with a red-nosed reindeer.
- Papa Wolf: Donner goes out to look for Rudolph when the big storm hits:Sam the Snowman: Now you can bet old Donner felt pretty bad about the way he had treated Rudolph, and he knew that the only thing to do was to go out and look for his little buck. Mrs. Donner wanted to go along, naturally, but Donner said: "No, this is man's work."
- Inverted when Rudolph goes to the Abominable Snowman's cave to rescue his family and Clarice's.
- Porky Pig Pronunciation: The stuttering, sinking toy boat on the Island of Misfit Toys. "Or a b-b-b-boat that can't sta-stay a...float!"
- Product Placement: The special was originally commissioned and sponsored by General Electric, which was selling new smaller Christmas tree lights — that looked very much like Rudolph's nose....
- Prospector: Yukon Cornelius.
- Ragtag Bunch of Misfits: Rudolph and Hermey, who are later joined by Yukon Cornelius the prospector, and treated hospitably by King Moonracer.Lampshaded by Hermey's and Rudolph's "We're a Couple of Misfits":
Hermey: I am not such a misfit, I am not such a nitwit, You can't fire me, I quit, seems I don't fit in!
Rudolph: Why am I such a misfit, I am not such a nitwit, Just because my nose glows, why don't I fit in?
Rudolph, Hermey: We're a couple of misfits, we're a couple of misfits, What's the matter with misfits? That's where we fit in.
- The residents of the Island of Misfit Toys, including Charlie-in-the-Box, the train with square wheels, the cowboy who rides an ostrich, and the jelly-squirting gun.
- Reality Ensues: Somewhat. Rudolph was born with a special ability. How did the other reindeer initially react? By laughing at him because he was different.
- Reality Is Unrealistic: The 2001 sequel depicts Rudolph with stumpy antlers only slightly larger than his younger form. This looks like a continuity Snap Back, but (male) reindeer in fact shed their antlers around winter. But then again, he is also smaller for some reason.
- Reasonable Authority Figure: King Moonracer. Though he only permits toys to be permanent residents of the Island of Misfit Toys (or, as Yukon Cornelius puts it, "Even among misfits, you're misfits!"), he does allow the protagonists to stay the night and requests that when they get back to Christmas Town, they ask Santa to come pick up the toys and search for a home for each of them.
- Re-Cut: More times than some might expect for a 50-minute TV special.
- The original 1964 broadcast differs from later versions through Rudolph's and Hermy's performance of "We're a Couple of Misfits," Donner expressing pride in his son guiding Santa's sleigh, Yukon Cornelius striking peppermint, and elves dropping presents from the sleigh during the end credits.
- Beginning in 1965, "We're a Couple of Misfits" was replaced with "Fame and Fortune," and "We Are Santa's Elves" lost an instrumental scene with physical humor, to make room for commercials. Also, at the request of viewers, a new scene featured Santa collecting the Misfit Toys from the island and a new credits sequence showed elves delivering them to unseen households. As a result, Donner and Yukon Cornelius's witnessing Santa's flight was removed. This is the same version Family Home Entertainment and Golden Books Family Entertainment sold on VHS.
- Platypus Comix's review of a 1979 broadcast note reveals a version which cuts all of "We Are Santa's Elves," as well as a brief moment when Donner asks his wife to Stay in the Kitchen. (The author claims every other version he's seen contains the latter moment, suggesting it was reinstated during the mid-1980s.)
- In 1998, CBS came to the rescue and restored "We're a Couple of Misfits" and "We Are Santa's Elves" to the special, but still included the scenes of the Misfit Toys becoming presents. Due to the retaining of those scenes, the special still does not include the original ending or end credits sequence.
- Beginning in 2005, Rudolph got screwed by CBS when they decided to make room for commercials by cutting the "We Are Santa's Elves" instrumental and Donner's and Yukon Cornelius' scenes of the ending again, and also syncing a shortened "We're a Couple of Misfits" to the animation of "Fame and Fortune" (this edited version is, to put it bluntly, a mess). They also time-compress the show slightly.
- Most DVDs, Blu-Ray Discs, and digital copies released by either Golden Books Family Entertainment or Classic Media feature the cut that most closely matches the original broadcast. It includes "We're a Couple of Misfits" and the uncut "We Are Santa's Elves," and also places Donner's and Yukon Cornelius' final scenes right before the scenes of the Misfit Toys becoming presents. However, it does not include the original end credits sequence (as the original color version was presumed lost for some time until a 16mm copy was discovered by a random collector in 2018, with plans to eventually include it on a Rankin-Bass documentary), and Classic Media DVDs produced from 2005-2006 are inexplicably missing Donner's and Yukon Cornelius' final scenes.
- Some airings cut out "There's Always Tomorrow".
- Role Reprisal: Billie May Richardsnote provided the voice for Rudolph in every Rankin-Bass special featuring the character until her death. A curious example occurs in the 2006 special, where Kathleen Barr from the Goodtimes animation reprises Rudolph, despite the interpretation following the Rankin-Bass continuity.
- Santa Claus: Probably as bad a depiction as you can get without breaching the guidelines of children's programming.
- Saving Christmas: Santa thinks they might have to cancel Christmas due to the fog — that is, before he sees Rudolph's nose.
- Shared Universe: The sequel Rudolph and Frosty's Christmas in July shows that Rudolph takes place in the same world as Frosty the Snowman. Nestor, the Long-Eared Christmas Donkey likewise takes place in Rudolph's world.
- Sneaky Departure: Rudolph feels he's endangering the others because his glowing nose always exposes them when the Abominable Snow Monster is near, so he leaves them in the middle of the night.
- Society Marches On: In 1964, the squirt gun from the Island of Misfit Toys was a misfit because it squirted jelly rather than water. Now it's a misfit because it's a toy gun that looks like a real gun, which is no longer legal or acceptable.
- Spell My Name with an "S": Is it Hermey, Hermie, or Herbie? ("Hermey" seems to be the official spelling.)
- Spinning Paper: This is how the special begins, with live-action footage of people stuck in snow while newspapers fly up at the screen, with headlines screaming about a cold wave bringing snowstorms so severe that they threaten to postpone Christmas.
- Stay in the Kitchen: When Donner's wife asks if she can help look for Rudolph, he responds, "No. This is man's work." Joined by Clarice, she follows up, though, and it gets worse for both of them when they all get captured by the Abominable Snow Monster.
- Suddenly SHOUTING!: Altogether now, everyone: WHY WEREN'T YOU AT ELF PRACTICE?
- Super Drowning Skills: The Abominable Snow Monster has only one weakness - he sinks like a stone.
- Tap on the Head: Yukon Cornelius does this to the Abominable Snowman to allow Hermey to extract all his teeth.
- Taking You with Me: Subverted. Yukon Cornelius tackles the Abominable Snow Monster over a cliff, but they both survive.
- Tertiary Sexual Characteristics: Clarice. Red bow and huge eyelashes!
- Elves have this too.
- Through a Face Full of Fur: Rudolph blushes after Clarice compliments him.
- Titled After the Song: Most Rankin/Bass Christmas shows would fall under this trope, though it's sort of justified in how they're usually retellings of the song's lyrics.
- Took a Level in Badass: Finally through with running from his problems, Rudolph finds his family and Clarice at the mercy of the Bumble and wastes no time fighting the creature off to save them. He proves horribly outmatched, but his bravery after months of fleeing from the creature cannot be understated.
- Took a Level in Kindness: Bumble gets redeemed after his Disney Death and helps Santa's elves prepare Christmas. Santa and most of the adults are also considerably nicer in the sequels.
- Trademark Favorite Food: Hermey lures the Snow Monster away from the reindeer by squealing like a pig, after Cornelius tells him, "I've never seen a Bumble turn down a pork dinner for deer meat." And it works.
- Under the Mistletoe: Clarice catches Rudolph under it during "Holly Jolly Christmas" towards the end.
- Viewers Are Morons: The Toy Taker doesn't know the meaning of the word "surrender", just for the sake of having it be explained to the target audience.
- Vocal Dissonance: During the opening for the "We are Santa's elves" song, the Head Elf jarringly switches from his normal Yosemite Sam-esque growl to a nasally Porky Pig-like whine, clearly voiced by a different actor, for several lines with no explanation.
- Waxing Lyrical: Several times.
- "Well Done, Son!" Guy: Rudolph and his father's relationship can be summed up this way.
- Well-Intentioned Extremist: The Toy Taker in Island of Misfit Toys abducts toys with the purpose of protecting them from kids he believes are neglectful and abusive. As it turns out, he is in fact a teddy bear who spent a lot of his life forgotten and accidentally sent away by his owner.
- What Happened to the Mouse?: Initially played straight. In the original 1964 presentation of the special, the Misfit Toys are never seen again after Rudolph leaves their island (though it's strongly implied that Rudolph did come to Santa about this when Santa assures him he'll find them homes). This was then averted when viewer complaints about this led to the first Re-Cut; see above.
- What the Hell Is That Accent?: Mrs. Claus sounds vaguely Italian or Slavic.
- Why Couldn't You Be Different?: Santa's harsh reaction when Rudolph's fake nose cap comes off leads Coach Comet and the others to shun Rudolph, embarrasses Rudolph and makes Donner feel ashamed of his son.
- Woodland Creatures: Used in "There's Always Tomorrow".
- Woobie, Destroyer of Worlds: If you think about it from his perspective, Aeon the Terrible from Shiny New Year—Yes kidnapping an infant and trying to avert the coming of the new year is a jerk move, but Aeon can only live for one aeon (hence his name) and if the new year comes, that deadline will finally be up and he'll be reduced to ice and snow. In short, Aeon isn't so much malicious as he is terrified of dying. Fortunately, Rudolph and Happy manage to avert that fate for him.
- Worthless Yellow Rocks: A squirrel chucks a gold nugget away after discovering it's inedible. Also, Rudolph thinks that Yukon's desire for silver means he's looking for tinsel.
- Writers Cannot Do Math: The opening title sequence lists the copyright date in Roman numerals as MCLXIV (1164) instead of MCMLXIV (1964).
- Your Size May Vary: The Abominable is clearly much bigger in his first scene, where he's so big you can only see his legs striding by, never see his torso at all, and Rudolph can jump down inside his footprint (at least 35-50 feet). When we see him in a full body shot, he's only a little taller than twice Yukon Cornelius' height (12-14 feet).