Follow TV Tropes


Web Video / The Fanfic Critic

Go To
Hello, I’m the FanFic Critic. I read it, you listen.

Megan Wessels is The FanFic Critic, a reviewer on YouTube who reviews fanfics, bad or good, with currently over 2,000 subscribers. She's known for being honest and harsh about the stories she reviews, and is often Driven to Suicide when the story is particularly awful.

Her YouTube channel is here. She was one of the hosts and creators of the now-former The Net Dwellers, and she also contributed to Reviewers Unknown and Manic Expression.

Following a yearlong hiatus, on October 30, 2015 Wessels announced that she was ending the show.

The following year; in April, 2016; Wessels returned to reading fanfics on a new Youtube channel. Her new series, named "The Fanfic Critic Vlog", is not a continuation of the Fanfic Critic but rather Wessels reading the fanfics as herself. Her new Youtube channel is here.


Not to be confused with The FanFiction Critic.

Tropes featured in her show include:

  • Acting for Two: FanFic Critic and Susan are both played by the same person.
  • Berserk Button: Bad grammar and spelling, characters that are Out of Character, Real Person Fics, the list goes on.
  • Breather Episode: Almost any episode that features a good fanfic. Episodes that are mainly storyline could also count as this as well.
  • Brick Joke/Call-Back: Episode 189 has FFC mentioning "blondey-brown" hair.
    • Susan in Episode 192 by making fun of FanFic Critic's critique of the word "okay".
  • Catchphrase: The page quote.
  • Corpsing: While rare, it does happen from time to time.
  • Cute Kitten: Episode 183 had a cat jumping onto the desk a few times.
  • Deadpan Snarker: The Fanfic Critic and Susan.
  • Death Glare: See the page image above.
  • Driven to Madness: Episode 08 finally drove FanFic Critic over the edge.
  • Driven to Suicide: First in Episode 03, where she reviewed a Slash Fic starring The Nostalgia Critic and The Angry Video Game Nerd, and 100 episodes later when she reviewed the sequel to said fic. She's attempted other suicides, but her cousin is always there to stop her.
  • Advertisement:
  • Drowning Her Sorrows: Susan in Episode 180.
  • Funny Background Event: In older episodes, sometimes Megan's sister would walk in and suddenly leave, or you can hear her mother telling her to keep it down. Justified, as she still lived with her parents at the time. Still happens from time to time, especially if she has someone else in the room.
    • Every now and then, one of her cats comes in. In Episode 197, the two of them are sleeping on her bed, and sometimes react to her screaming. They then suddenly get up at once, and leave half-way through when she reaches the end.
  • Gilligan Cut: In Episode 129, this effect forces FanFic Critic into reviewing the infamous Cupcakes.
  • Go Mad from the Revelation: FanFic Critic has had this happen a few times. One example is reading a bad, albeit well-written, story from an author she had encountered before. During her Sanity Slippage, she sings a parody of "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds".
    • Susan, after reading a horrible fanfic in Episode 161, calmly grins at the camera as her mind snaps. She then shoots herself in the head with her own phaser. Thankfully, the phaser was only on stun.
  • Hostile Show Takeover: Susan takes over the show in Episodes 161 and 192.
  • I Need a Freaking Drink: Has been becoming more prominent the worse the story is, especially if the fanfic involves psychotic ponies.
    • Episode 184 had her drinking by the end of the story.
  • Laser-Guided Amnesia: Susan, after being killed and then brought back to life by FanFic Critic, went nuts. FanFic Critic, feeling guilty for her role in Susan's insanity, made sure her memories of the incident were erased. Susan got them back eventually in a much later season.
  • No Kill Like Overkill: In Episode 81, FanFic Critic rips up printed papers of a bad The Land Before Time fanfiction, proceeds to slice it up with her straight razor, and then eats it.
  • Old Shame: The first season (Episodes 01-20), which is lampshaded by both FanFic Critic and Susan.
    • In one episode from Season 3, she does a long summary review on a Sweeney Todd story that she wrote.
  • Ooh, Me Accent's Slipping: The "English" accent Megan does for Susan is just terrible. "The Fhan Fhic Critac". It sounds more Australian than English.
  • Only Sane Woman: Susan, though she's slowly becoming like her cousin (see Episodes 140 onwards).
  • Playing Drunk: On the episodes where she hits the bottle, but she was actually drunk during Episode 191.
  • Real Song Theme Tune: Her opening theme is the opening theme of Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street.
    • Episodes 181 and onwards use music from Doctor Who.
  • “The Reason You Suck” Speech: She dishes these out on occasion, especially if the fanfic has atrocious grammar and/or awful content.
    • She'll also fire them off at authors who promote the following in their fanfics: Rape, child abuse, bestiality, and over-the-top and unnecessary violence inflicted on one or more characters.
    • Susan ends up on the receiving end of one in Episode 192.
  • Running Gag:
    • Susan preventing FanFic Critic from committing suicide.
    • FanFic Critic trying to find a third thing to say at the end of her videos.
  • Screw This, I'm Outta Here!:
    • She tried reviewing the first issue of the infamous Sonichu webcomic, but she finally became so disgusted that she quit three-quarters of the way in it.
    • Happened again in Episode 189 with a My Immortal-esque Justin Bieber story. She only got through an eighth or less of the story.
    • Once more in Episode 194.
    • The cats in Episode 197.
    • Episode 203 about half-way through the second chapter she was reading because of the grammar and bad pacing.
  • Spelling Nazi: Her habit of pointing out spelling mistakes in stories is fine, but her habit of spelling out the right word may make one feel like they're at a spelling bee. Understandable in her early seasons, though, seeing as she didn't have the power to screen capture, yet.
  • Tomboyish Ponytail
  • The Voiceless: FanFic Critic's landlordnote 
  • Weapon of Choice: FanFic Critic has a straight razor and Susan has a phaser.
  • We Are Experiencing Technical Difficulties: Done twice in her review of Sweet Apple Massacre.
    • In Episode 203, Megan forgot to edit out her setting up for the review.
  • Wingding Eyes: The smiley-face eyes.


How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: