- Diamanda Hagan already did that.
- As did Mr Tardis, all the way back in 2010. He even made the Doctor Rita Repulsa.
- Hopefully it will be a retrospective of the Original Trek series, which debuted 45 years ago this september. Also TNG premièred 24 years ago on the 28th of September, and the immediately preceding video is the last original Trek movie. It would be the perfect time to do a retrospective of TOS and the original movie series.
- Mass Effect: confirmed.
- I had thought that the review was going to be MLP: Friendship is Magic, for some reason. And now Chuck is actually doing the review of it.
- More likely with the revelation that it will be the 2011 Christmas Review. Why would an ordinary TNG episode be the big Christmas Review unless it were meaningful in some other way? And, of course, the 2010 Christmas Review was "A Night In Sickbay", another "0" episode.
- Confirmed
- Potentially, but possibly not. Keep in mind that SF Debris is a father.
- Confirmed, sort of. He did say it was requested. And remember MLP:FIM has a large adult male audience. Like SF Debris.
- SF Debris hasn't done a review of a Star Trek: The Animated Series episode yet.
- The door was officially opened to TAS in this video. The speculation for it is premature, but valid.
- And so it begins... SF Debris is now doing TAS!
- The door was officially opened to TAS in this video. The speculation for it is premature, but valid.
- "Profit and Lace" is de facto confirmed already; in his "Let He Who Is Without Sin..." review, Chuck explicitly says that the only way to go lower than that episode is to "give Quark boobs", which refers to this one.
- And "Profit and Lace" is totally confirmed as the 2012 Christmas review.
- And now "The Way To Eden", while abysmal, has been Jossed as the original series' worst - my money's on "The Savage Curtain", or "And The Children Shall Lead".
- Yep. "And the Children Shall Lead" it is.
- "The Infinite Vulcan" theory confirmed, as he does it for his 2016 Christmas Review?
- Jossed, he did Profit and Lace for Christmas 2012.
- Jossed, it's "Profit and Lace".
- Also Jossed for reviewing TOS for christmas 2013, instead it's another awful Star Trek episode: These Are The Voyages.
- Confirmed, with him doing "The Infinite Vulcan"?
- It's pretty much a given, considering how Q made it to Equestria.
- Semi-confirmed when he gave My Little Pony it's own slot under animation despite having only reviewed one episode.
- And he did!
This idea came from a comment I saw saying the Children of Tama tech support where from the: Debris!Trek-verse". Chuck often points out the weird or out of place, or Unfortunate Implications of this franchise and takes them to the next step in his jokes. If he gets or is big enough somebody will write a star trek fic where everything he said is true. So the entire verse pretty much happened exactly except: Janeway is a crazy dictator, Picard literally laughs when children die, the 2009 Kirk is literally the universes biggest douchebag even more so than Q, the children of Tama run tech support explaining why everything tech problem iso poorly handled in the future etc...
Alternatively if he gets big enough one of the first five episodes of a new trek show will make a reference to him in a season one episode. I say five years because that is how long I imagine it would take for him to get to the level to be noticed by any producer besides one who was already a big fan.
- He's already been referenced... He created the term "Future Guy," which is still canon even in New!Trek.
- Doesn't count. He was being sarcastic when he coined that term.
- Not true anyway. Star Trek fans were using that weeks before he picked it up in his wonderfully Trek-slamming reviews. See September 2014 note at http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Talk:Humanoid_Figure#Lack_of_origin_citation with links to them.
- Doesn't count. He was being sarcastic when he coined that term.
- Chuck appearing on AT4W: confirmed as of episode 200. No word yet on the other half though.
- Chuck also appear in a Review of a Voyager Comic, providing the voice of Parod Janeway?
- Jossed. He played his regular Enterprise intro.
- Lazarus of the Week to Captain Kirk
- Burn Baby Burn for the Vengeance crashing on earth
- Ancient Chinese Secret, huh? to calling the stasis pod ancient
- Jossed. He hated it SO DAMN MUCH that not only did he not give it any awards, he didn't even grade it!
- Come on, megalomaniacal, has those warrior cobalt tarantulas, uses mind control to suppress the will of subordinates, it all fits! I can't wait for him to review Bride of Chaotica!.
- Eh... I'm not sure if this is confirmed or not. Sort of?
- Please, let my dream come true.
- A review of Star Trek Into Darkness.
- A review of (what Chuck considers to be) the worst episode of Star Trek: The Original Series.
- A fanfic which Chuck will read involving a crossover between various Star Trek series.
- A review of the ten-part finale of DS9 like the one he did for the Dominion war arc.
- A non-Trek review. He's ruled out ever doing the Star Wars prequels, but he hasn't ruled out doing the original films and there are three days of "Surprise Gift". He's doing the original Star Wars trilogy!
- It is the Star Trek Online game review.
- All Jossed. The Big Star Trek project was a review of Star Trek: Voyager's finale "Endgame" and his other two Surprise Gifts were reviews of Blake's 7's first episode and Stargate SG-1 episode "Emancipation".
- He did eventually get round to the worst episode of TOS in Christmas 2015: "And The Children Shall Lead".
- All Jossed. The Big Star Trek project was a review of Star Trek: Voyager's finale "Endgame" and his other two Surprise Gifts were reviews of Blake's 7's first episode and Stargate SG-1 episode "Emancipation".
Here's the evidence. There was a TOS episode which involved William Shatner giving us full-frontal Shatner at his most Shatner-iest. The tension of the episode turned on a courtroom scene, with antics a-plenty. And the name of this episode was... Turnabout Intruder.
And yet, there was not a single Phoenix Wright reference in the entire review. Not a one. Not even the obligatory "Objection!"
That led me to believe that it was simply a game series that Chuck was unfamiliar with. Which was fine.
But then he made a Phoenix Wright reference in one of his latest reviews. So either Chuck passed up the easiest joke ever (not entirely impossible), or he had only recently become aware of the series. Which suggests that he's going to cover it, since it's been a while since a non-Gaidan entry in the series has shown up.
In the same vein as the "Janeway Pie" award in Prime Factors, for the sake of the pun.
- Confirmed
Babylon 5 will probably not get an episode review stamped The Worst on the grounds that the two most likely candidates for that title (Infection and Grey 17 Is Missing) have already been reviewed.
- Also, Full Moon, Escaflowne, and Kannazuki No Miko are unlikely candidates since they are being reviewed in chronological order, unlike the live action shows Chuck is currently reviewing.
- Jossed. Star Trek Into Darkness. Incredibly caustic review. I guess "Worst Movie" that year instead.
It shall not be rewarded to the Neelix of Voyager, but Reginald Barclay's Cat, who is also called Neelix.
Small additional point; When Barclay says he has become obsessed with Voyager, Chuck shall make a joke about himself and his Voyager Reviews?
- Jossed. In the case of Neelix, it is actual Neelix for his singing voice.
- Confirmed with Chuck joking about himself, when Reginald Barclay admits to being obsessed with Voyager.
In the Episode, there is an Ensign on the Enterprise called "Janeway". Chuck may most likely make a joke about how, either it's not Captain Kathryn Janeway of Voyager, or have the Episode work as an Origin Story for Parody Janeway.
- Also, his opinion on the ending is going to be more nuanced than we'd assume.
- I mean, Chuck managed to make a nuanced review of freaking Film/Zardoz. He'll see something we don't.