- How else has Scrooge been around since the 1800s to the present and besides they have found the seven lost cities of gold, Xanadu, dinosaurs, magic and creatures that live beneath the earth and cause earthquakes. It's not to much a stretch to imagine.
- This is actually canon — at least partway! In one Carl Barks story, That's No Fable! from 1953, Scrooge and his nephews actually do find the Fountain of Youth, and are shown drinking from it. Granted, in this particular story, drinking the water only makes you more limber and gives you a huge energy boost (Scrooge spontaneously begins doing cartwheels after drinking!); to get the youth effect you have to swim in it — which they are stopped from doing. Still, just drinking from the fountain may have had long-term effects that the Ducks simply did not realize at the time....
- Don Rosa's own explanation was that the "present" in his DuckVerse Comics all take place in the 40's-50's-60's. In the same era that Barks wrote stories.
- Yes but that only works for his work and Barks', because there have been plenty of more recent stories by recent authors that these stories happen in modern days (sometimes, the date is cited; there as been a story featured in 2001 about the characters celebrating…2001 so how do you explain that with Don Rosa's point of view ?

- What was the first story to feature Goldie after her introduction in Back to the Klondike? The story by Romano Scarpa introducing Paperetta (aka Dickie)! Come on... Scrooge's old flame randomly shows up on his proverbial doorstep with a granddaughter of unknown parentage and asks Scrooge to take her in for no apparent reason. He accepts, also for no apparent reason. Then, almost as quickly as they introduced her, the writers try to ignore her existence and seem determined never to give a straight answer about her origins. Sure, nobody's covering up anything here. Again. Huey, Dewey, and Louie, Rumpus McFowl... this family's got kids out of wedlock running all over the place!
- Considering that she's often found working for Bridget, the question becomes, does Bridget know this?
- Probably yes, and was told by Goldie herself. The one time they met, after all, Goldie encouraged Brigit to pursue Scrooge, and Brigit asked about it. With Goldie admitting the deed so Scrooge wouldn't have an easy way out.
- Lets not forget the time aspect to this - for this to work, Scrooge and Goldie would have had to have concieved when they were doing something that "wasn't a hanging offense". Scrooge didn't have any protection, and neither did Goldie. But then the follow up, Hearts of the Yukon, would have to take place in such a time that she was pregnant, and knew it, but not noticeable - supposing they just gave the hell up on them actually being ducks and just made them people, that means about 5 months. Prisoner of White Agony Creek began in the Spring of 1897, and they were together for a month before the ..... anyway, that means it could have happened in the beginning, considering Scrooge said there was no thaw yet. This means that it happened near mid April. Hearts of the Yukon, their follow up, takes place in January 1898 - a full 9 months after the incident. She couldn't hide a child back in those days. Whatever happened, no-one was produced. Scrooge has no children.
- ...supposing they just made them (like) people. Did they? "It's not a lie unless they have proof." I'd rather just assume they didn't than think about that too much.
- We're still assuming Dickie is Goldie's biological granddaughter: it also may be assumed, since last time they saw themselves Scrooge left Goldie with enough money to take care of herself and the whole Dawson City and when Goldie called Scrooge's help in raising Dickie she was, again, poor and almost forgotten, that Dickie is the offspring of a random family helped by Goldie when she, briefly, regained her fortune, they remained close enough for Dickie to assist her "grandma" when she fell on hard times again and Goldie started to consider her surrogate family. Since Scrooge is also one of the few people dear to her, it's also safe to assume that, when Goldie felt unable to arrange a bright future for her protegeè, she called upon the only duck he could trust. Furthermore, Dawson is also described as an old, quiet town, while Duckburg, brimming with life, was a better choice for a teen girl trying to find her place in the world: the last act of love and charity left to Goldie was sending Dickie away.
- In the theatrical cartoon, "Don's Fountain of Youth
", Donald Duck convinces Huey, Dewey and Louie that the eponymous pool has turned him into a baby — and then into an egg. It's a con, and the theatrical Nephews aren't the All-Knowing Oracles of the Barks tales, but they treat Donald's "transformation" as the logical result of such an immersion. I believe that I've seen references to the "Duck Family Album" in old Disney comics — possibly including those by Barks — which show various Duck characters as "just a baby": i.e., as eggs wearing bonnets or trademark sailor hats.
- In the DuckTales (1987) episode "Sweet Duck of Youth
", when they actually find the Fountain of Youth, they discover it merely makes your reflection look young. The triplets all turn into eggs when they look in it, just like Donald pretends he has been youthenized into in "Don's Fountain of Youth".
- Graphic proof
◊ from Marco Rita's From Egg To Duck, although the comic it is from is non-canon in many regards (such as saying that Donald was a lost egg found and raised by Grandma Duck and Scrooge).
- In the theatrical cartoon, "Don's Fountain of Youth
- Wacky theory: Dickie was intended to be Scrooge's grandaughter and the contradictions with what we know from Don Rosa's writings are simply due to different writers with different interpretations. The comics revolving around the Duck Clan aren't any different from other comic books in regards to continuity and timescales.
- Yes, time can never be trusted very far with comic books.
- Especially since the Italian Duck stories take place in a universe very different from Don Rosa's vision. There are several Duck canons that only vaguely overlap.
- Ducks come from eggs, as mentioned above. I don't think it takes 9 months to hatch an egg.
- Since the actual process is never clearly defined, you can make up any rule you want.
- (I think that the cartoon with the triplets scamming Donald above was actually based on a Barks comic? I recall reading the same story once.) The egg idea gives a possible loophole to make both canons work: Goldie may have not been able to hide a child, but instead gave away the egg to be hatched by someone else. (We can assume that she would have been as ashamed as protective about her reputation in Klondike.) So the child was probably raised somewhere else, while Goldie got older and matured herself. She was feeling increasingly responsible which peaked when Scrooge himself and his nephews showed up. She went on to seek out her child, only to be told that he or she was dead or disappeared, but - to her surprise - has left behind a daughter who is a good girl and works hard to support herself, but just can't help causing trouble with her modern ways. Goldie realizes that she deserves a better chance at life in Duckburg and takes her with her, but never tells her her true origins.
- Considering that she's often found working for Bridget, the question becomes, does Bridget know this?
- In the Don Rosa series, it is filled with real money, but it's only Scrooge's coin collection kept for sentimental reasons. The vast majority of his wealthis where it should be, in banks and investments. That said, there's a LOT there, and it's not like the Beagle Boys are really capable of stealing 65% of a computer company or something.
- Technically it's all the money he earned on his own, not counting investments, interest etc. He's THAT rich that he can afford to store so much money in such an impractical manner, since he has plenty more.
- I vote sham. How else could Scrooge dive into a pile of solid coins with no ill effects (the coins would have to reduce Scrooge's speed/kinetic energy gradually, and I don't think a pile of metal has much give).
- No it doesn't work that way in the real world of course, but then again that's an Incredibly lame pun ya know, 'liquid assets'.
- But when other characters try to dive into a pile of money, they land on top of it painfully. Scrooge being able to defy the laws of physics this way is just Rule of Cool meeting Rule of Funny or another sign of his signature badass-itude.
- It's been shown time and again that Scrooge had super strength when he was younger. It's faded with age, but the presence of so much of his own hard-earned cash rejuvinates him enough to pull that kind of stuff.
- In another story of Don Rosa we are shown that it is indeed filled with money when Donald Duck starts to mine for rare coins (which Scrooge hoards by the hundred)
- Sure, but let's go back to the Carl Barks stories. You know, Scrooge's creator. He showed in the story against the Marahaya of Huduyustan that Scrooge indeed only has a few billions in sight. But then there's a hidden hatch, which really showes us 3 cubic acres of cash. In another, his vault is so full he needs to spend money, or his bin is going to burst. It it were fake, he would probably have put it in the vault. In yet another one, Scrooge fill the bin with water to drown the Beagle Boys out, who are digging a tunnel under the money bin. They would, if there wasn't the coldest night in years, which makes the bin burst open and 3 cubic acres of ice slide down. The end shows the Beagles scraping the money out of the ice, in the part which is usually 3 cubic acres deep.
- This isn't supported by the episode "The Money Vanishes", where the Beagle Boys steal Gyro's furniture mover ray and trick Scrooge into spraying his money so they can teleport it to their hideout. The money disappears layers at a time until Scrooge falls to the bottom of the money bin, while meanwhile the Beagle Boys' several-story hideout is full to bursting with money.
- About a month or so before the reboot premiered, Disney challenged a certain YouTuber and mathematician who happened to be a fan to calculate the worth of the Money Bin's contents.note Even the most conservative estimate would be enough to crash the global economy, while the highest (and most likely) one was over 500 times as much money that actually exists in any form as of this writing.
- And he can tell of every single coin when, where and how he acquired it. We're talking about millions, if not billions of coins here. That's some super memory.
- He can also smell money.
- Then there was this time the Beagle Boys made of with a load of his cash. Scrooge was walking down the street on the other side of town, but stopped dead when he felt what he described as "an empty feeling in my wallet".
- The Beagle Boys actually did trick Scrooge out of his fortune one time; he asked that before being evicted that they grant an old duck's wish: to swim around his wealth just one more time. After watching him dive through the coins like a porpoise, naturally the Boys want to give it a go themselves. The resulting concussions they get from diving head-first into the nearly-solid mass of gold and silver coins allows Scrooge to capture the crooks and reclaim his fortune.
- Three cubic acres of money make some sort of a five-dimensioned amount of cash.
- you know what other creature can do all that? dragons! Scrooge is half dragon and the money bin is his hoard!
- One story shows these abilities as genetic and inheritable. Donald has the right gene, but due to his general lack of mental faculty, it activated only for a short time (don't ask, it's a comic book). This is just one step away from superpowers, as well as implying that the triplets may exhibit these abilities too, in a couple of years. Makes one shudder...
- Which would pretty mean that virtually all Donald Duck stories are non-canon, including the one where he can stay in his rich uncle's cabin for Christmas which coincidentally is the same story that first shows Scrooge. It would undo any Scrooge story, giving Don Rosa no reason to start making Scrooge comics including the The Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck, making this WMG one big paradox. No, Don Rosa wouldn't want to do that to himself. Continuing: Carl Barks would run out of ideas by 1955, stop Disney comics leading to the discontinuation of the Donald Duck comics somewhere around the 1970s/1980s if not earlier.
- Or he is simply a Kappa-level
psyker.
- Supported for how Donald reacts when he see his mother on Dream of a Lifetime.
- That also explains Matilda's short temper and strong resent towards Scrooge in A Letter from Home, so much differently from her young self. She was already disgusted by Scrooge's attitudes years prior, but was also hoping that someday he would snap back to reality, apologize for his behavior and reconcile with Hortense and her. Losing her little sister without that ever happening took away what was left of Matilda's faith in Scrooge and broke her spirit, turning her into a cold, disilluded person.


- That would explain why that guy looks all mangled and burned: he's never been the same since his bratty sons set off a firecracker under his chair.
- That makes too much sense for my liking so I would like to declare officially that I hate for totally raping that last bit of lovable childhood I had.
- That WMG is negated by the story "The Duck Who Never Was" by Don Rosa. In the alternate reality where Donald was never born, the triplets still exist, therefore Donald isn't their father.
- Wasn't that alternate reality just a dream?
- The genie who granted that wish doesn't think so.
- Technically you could argue that the genie either created a convincing illusion or an alternate reality to teach Don a lesson. Whatever happens in it doesn't necessarily accurately reflect the "reality" of Donald Duck's universe.
- Even it was just an illusion, it shouldn't have such logical impossibilities that would be easily noticeable by Donald, in order to be convincing for him.
- Wasn't that alternate reality just a dream?
- Actually, more or less confirmed by Word of God! Check out this comment
.
- According to Don Rosa's timeline
, Della would have been 20 years old when she had the boys.
- I think the whole point is that no one could agree on what happened that day, and people were making up all sorts of explanations both mundane and fantastic. In "Hearts of the Yukon", Scrooge himself claimed that he broke free when a boiler exploded... then goes on to claim that he "licked a baker's dozen [of Soapy Slick's men]! And the baker!"
- Quack Pack was a spinoff of DuckTales (1987) that was more of a tribute of the original Donald Duck cartoons (with a 90s flavor) than a sequel to the aforementioned show. The reason that it was so different from Duck Tales was because Donald never left the Navy. During Duck Tales his carrier ship was torpedoed, resulting in everyone aboard being killed. As he was drowning he began hallucinating about what his future could have been with Daisy and his nephews. Scrooge does not appear because he would have died in-between Donald coming home for good and re-adopting the boys. The reason for the references to the old Donald Duck cartoons is because his brain is also trying to find comfort to counter the very frightening (and painful) experience of his lungs filling with water. The series ends when Donald finally expires.
- The only problem being that one exists in a world populated by humanoid animals while the other has never shown speaking animals, much less the type seen in the Scrooge-verse.
Thus, theropods evolved into birds, their intelligence developed and they took on a more humanoid shape, and became the dominant species. And some dinosaurs avoided extinction altogether like the ones from the Duck Tales episode "Dinosaur Ducks". Mammals eventually gained some kind of a foot hold, and became Dog Faces.
Donald returned to raise his nephews in 1946, after Della had remarried and they had hospitalized the new husband, and became their sole guardian when Della and her new husband ran away. He continued raising them until 1950, when he was recalled in service for The Korean War, and left them in Scrooge's care. And, as DuckTales (1987) shows, for some reason Donald was assigned to a carrier in service in the Atlantic instead than to a ship on the war theatre...
- Half-confirmed: Donald joined the army during WWII, and briefly joined the Nazis.
- Confirmed: Donald has been retroactively promoted to Seargent and then granted an honorable discharge for his services in the 80's.
You may cry now.
- Possibly partially confirmed by Go Slowly Now, Sands Of Time on the Life And Times music album, which is based on the Rosa canon.
- Apparently confirmed by a fan interview where Don Rosa allegedly revealed he had wanted to make a story where Scrooge faked his death (only letting Donald, Huey, Dewey and Louie be in the know) to return to Goldie and live his remaining years with her. This would have gone against the established Duck universe "canon" that Scrooge is meant to permanently live in his money bin, however, so Disney sadly refused him to write it.
- A Volta do Zé Carioca (1955)
, José's very first story made in Brazil, seems to confirm that he was actually born in São Paulo, lived for some time in other places (likely Rio and Bahia, and maybe the United States as well) and returned to his home city, where he settled down. It should be noted, however, that virtually all Brazilian stories made after that seem to retcon this, as they take place in Rio (not in Bahia, as written above). That doesn't entirely rule out him at least being born and raised in São Paulo, though.
Having faced every challenge in his life head-on and gained many treasures in the process (and not just of the material variety), Scrooge’s lust for adventure was finally satisfied. As Donald, his nephews, Gyro Gearloose, the Beagle Boys, and the police left him to his rest, he died in his sleep that very night, a tear down his cheek, and a smile on his face. With a lifetime of adventure, wealth beyond imagination, a family who cared for him and for whom he cared for (in his own special way), and the love of his life, Scrooge McDuck died the richest duck in the world.
- There is an alternate explanation; it has been implied that Calisota is something of an independent state, since it has its own embassy abroad (not completely independent, but kind of how Monaco is not exactly just a part of France without being totally independent either).
- Unlikely, as we know that Duckburg was the site of a battle in the American Civil War where Donald's namesake great-grandfather gained the Medal of Honor for single-handedly disrupting the Confederate defensive line by blowing up Fort Duckburg.

- Confirmed and Jossed by a more recent story: after retiring from thieving, Fantomius time-traveled to a time where the world would need a new Fantomius and choose Donald as his heir, making up the lottery won by Gladstone as a covert mean to pass his legacy to him and personally delivering (in disguise) the property.
- Alternatively, and less insulting to Donald, he uses Obfuscating Stupidity and lack of competence to get on his irritating uncle's nerves.