Follow TV Tropes


WMG / Black Sails

Go To

Silver and Max will eventually get together
In the original novel, it's mentioned that Silver is married to "a woman of colour" who he leaves to manage his inn when he ships on the Hispaniola. The first episode of Black Sails shows Silver and Max as partners in crime; why shouldn't they end up as partners in businessnote  as well? It would tie up a neat piece of mythology and, more importantly, it would prevent Max from falling victim to any of the many death tropes which probably already have her in their sights.
  • Season 3 seems to have jossed this with a heavy dose of ship-teasing going on between Silver and Madi, Mr. Scott's daughter. We'll wait and see, though.
    • And finally and definitively jossed when the series ends with Silver and Madi apparently still together (although it's implied Silver may have permanently damaged the relationship), and Max back in charge in Nassau.

John Silver is Mephistopheles.
His apparent role in the plot is that of the naive newcomer, an Audience Surrogate providing an introduction to the world of pirates. Except that his actual role is to tempt the other characters and bring conflict to the surface. He tempts Max into turning her back on Eleanor, without her even realising that's what she's doing. He drives Flint to ever-greater secrecy, turning the crew against him until he's forced to murder his best friend. He persuades Eleanor to help Anne and Jack become traitors to their crew. He leaves a trail of dead bodies and broken relationships in his wake, and comes away with clean hands and a ready smile.

It's actually the "old sea shanty" Billy Bones is singing at the beginning of the book ("Fifteen men on a dead man's chest/Yo-ho-ho and a bottle of rum"), and at some point in the series we'll hear somebody sing it.
  • Almost certainly true, if you sing those lyrics from the book along to the music, they fit the melody very well.

Max will turn out to be Mary Read
She has a steadily evolving relationship with Anne Bonny, and Mary will have to turn up sooner or later.
  • There's an interview on youtube with Clara Paget and Toby Schmitz where they're asked about the possibility of Mary Read showing up. The way they talk about it implies that Read would be a separate character from Max — they'd like the dynamic in the relationship to be different from the dynamic between them and Max. Of course, they're not the writers, and supposedly the only people on set that can get backstory out of the writers are Toby Stephens and Zach MacGowan, so who knows how it will develop.
  • Jossed by the finale — Mary Read is finally introduced, and is definitely not Max.

One of the main characters will be the real author of "A General History of the Robberies and Murders of the Most Notorious Pyrates," published in (1724).
I think Rackham, but that's just a guess. I was curious about Woodes Rogers' line to Jack in episode 3x06, that if he wants to control his story he should write a book. The line just stood out to me, like wink from the writers. Turns out the earliest, most famous, and still the primary source of information we have about this era of piracy was written anonymously, with the stated author, Charles Johnson, universally believed to be a pseudonym. This book is where most of our information about Calico Jack, Anne Bonny, and Mary Read come from, not to mention Charles Vane and Blackbeard. As obsessed as Jack is with his name and reputation, this would be a perfect ending for him (especially if Anne is right there with him, making sure he make her look like a badass too).
  • Probably jossed by the finale — a character is seen reading A General History of the Pyrates, with no suggestion that it was written by any of the other characters (of course, in the real world the book wasn't published until four years after Rackham died, so this could be a different book with a coincidentally similar title, but it seems more likely that this is just another example of the series fudging the timeline)

The show will end just as Treasure Island begins
Right before the final credits role, we'll catch a glimpse of Jim Hawkins in a Flash Forward to the opening chapter of Treasure Island.
  • Jossed — not only does the show end well before, but it leaves quite a few plot points still to be set up (most notably, the map; we also never learn how Billy got off the island).

Flint will persuade all but one of Silver's assassins to change sides
Silver has sent six men ashore to find and kill Flint, including Israel Hands. Flint already has one man with him, for a total of seven.

According to Ben Gunn in Treasure Island, Flint buried his treasure with the help of six men, all of whom he then killed. Also according to the book, Israel Hands survived to join the crew of the Hispaniola. There's several ways this scenario could shake out, but my guess: Flint will appeal to the loyalty of his former shipmates, who will change sides. Israel Hands, having no loyalty to Flint, will refuse, and flee back to the ship. Hands will thus have no idea where the cache is buried. Flint, meanwhile, will take those six men on into the island's interior, bury the treasure, and then kill them.

  • Jossed; Flint ends up killing all except for Hands, and then kills the crewman he'd convinced to help him bury the treasure in the first place. It's easy enough to see how this scenario would warp into the story version via retellings of it.

Silver lied to Madi, at the end
All but stated by Rackham, in his monologue about how "a story is true, a story is untrue; as time extends, it matters less and less", but it still needs to be said: There was no happy ending for Flint, no sanatorium with Thomas Hamilton, no peace. Silver shot him on Skeleton Island and left his body in the dirt.

The entire series takes place in Westworld
Westworld demonstrates that the titular Westworld is only one of several parks that the Delos corporation operates. The original film also includes Romanworld and Medievalworld, the sequel adds Futureworld and Spaworld, and the series adds Samuraiworld. Why not a Pirateworld? This explains the various timeline discrepancies for real life pirates, historical deviation from their fates, the addition of fictional characters along side historical ones, the badass upgrades for various characters, and the occasional switch from one actor to another. Joji could be a transplant from Samuraiworld, and Tom Hopper's subsequent appearances in History Channel's Barbarians miniseries and later, Game of Thrones could be Billy's host being re-purposed, first to Romanworld and then to Medievalworld.

Joji is Mexican
A few thousand Japanese Catholics made their way to New Spain between the late 16th century and the early 17th century, before the shogunate started to restrict foreign trade and crack down on Christianity. Joji could've descended from one of these Japanese communities, since there weren't many ways that an East Asian person could've made it to the Caribbean in the early 18th century otherwise. The only alternative I could think of is if he were an East India Company contractor recruited in the Far East who boarded a west-bound ship and went rogue.

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: