Follow TV Tropes


Series / Mystery Diagnosis

Go To

Mystery Diagnosis is a TV docudrama that airs on Discovery Life and TLC showcasing people with rare conditions and diseases that ran from 2005-2011.

Tropes for Mystery Diagnosis

  • Abuse Mistake: Some parents are accused of being Abusive Parents because a child's condition involves heavy bruising or unusual birthmarks. One example is a little girl named Julia, who turned out to have a blood disorder called Glanzmann thrombasthenia, a rare genetic condition which can cause severe bleeding from even minor cuts.
  • Arc Words: Mystery Diagnosis is very fond of these. They include:
    • Bizarre
    • For some unknown reason,...
    • In healthy individuals [explanation of how a healthy body works.] But in patients like [patient name], [explanation of disease's effects.]
    • "Nothing short of shocking" is used to describe test results often.
    • "Nothing could have prepared [X] for what [Y] revealed/what happened next/what they saw", etc.
    • New symptoms are always described as "emerging" or "stopping [X] dead in their tracks." New symptoms are also often characterized as "frightening," "even more frightening," or "bizarre."
    • Towards the end of the segment, expect a variation of "But why did it take so long for the doctors to diagnose the condition?". This is almost always worded as He/She/They "can't help but wonder" why the condition took so long to diagnose.
    • Each episode also has variations of comparisons between patients, because some of them have symptoms too debilitating to ignore, while others' symptoms act like a sleeping giant, and still others have symptoms, but don't do anything about them for a long time.
    • Advertisement:
    • "Head-to-toe exam" and "thorough head-to-toe exam" are also used a lot.
    • There will often be a reference to "If you hear hoofbeats, look for horses, not zebras," and an admission that this condition was in fact a zebra.
  • Adult Fear: The reason the show is rated TV-14. This is especially true of the parents you see on the show with babies or young children. Actually, the whole thing can be rather freaky (see below).
  • Babies Make Everything Better: Maria Lazazarro, the mother in "The Girl Who Stopped Growing," invokes this trope. She explains that her daughter's being born with mysterious disabilities took a toll on her marriage and that when she and her husband decided to have a second baby, they figured it would fix things. The baby, little Samantha's brother Jake, was born with the same disabilities, later diagnosed as Cockayne Syndrome. The couple divorced after Jake was born.
  • Big Eater: The patient in the second half of "The Boy Who Couldn't Stop Eating," Connor Heybach, has Prader-Willi Syndrome. It's a condition in which the hypothalamus malfunctions, keeping the person with it from ever feeling full no matter how much or often they eat.
    • Also occurred with little Haven Fowler in "Trapped Inside their Bodies." One of the main symptoms of her ROHAAD Syndrome is rapid weight gain/obesity and eating great quantities of food in your sleep.
    • Completely inverted with Samantha Mina, who suffers from SMA Syndrome. This affects one of the arteries in the intestine and makes it impossible to eat without vomiting, cramps, and extreme pain.
    • In addition, commonly inverted with anyone whose symptoms include significant stomach issues, which often leads to weight loss and total or almost total loss of desire to eat.
  • Body Horror: To varying degrees depending on the episode you're watching. In some, the worst you'll get is a close-up of a blood draw. In others, you'll see close-ups of horrific rashes, bruising, or in one case, a home video of a boy whose psychological symptoms made him act in "bizarre" ways, such as exhibiting motor and verbal tics at an alarming rate. In the episode focusing on MSU Disease, surveillance footage is shown of the child afflicted with the condition convulsing violently on a hospital bed. In The Boy with the Strange Stare, footage of the baby affected with Paroxysmal Tonic Upgaze is shown, alternating between them crying weakly and then suddenly moaning in pain as their eyes are locked upwards, they begin vomiting profusely and begin to cry 'as if they were on fire', to quote the child's mother.
  • Color-Coded for Your Convenience: A mild and perhaps unintentional example. Patients and their families are usually shown sitting in front of red or yellow backgrounds (usually red for patients, yellow for family). Doctors are always shown with blue backgrounds.
  • Critical Research Failure: In Universe. Both literally on behalf of incorrect diagnoses, and figuratively in the case of one of the show's catchphrases ("But why did it take so long for the doctors to diagnose the condition?") - Never have any of the diseases featured not been known to science and medicine, but they often masquerade as other conditions, such as the improper deployment of Anti-Yo Antibody damaging the cerebellum, causing Paraneoplastic Cerebellar Degeneration being mistaken for dementia.
  • Darker and Edgier: Mystery Diagnosis is aired on the Discovery Fit and Health Channel, which is also home to Monsters Inside Me. Like MD, the stories featured on that show usually involve someone falling prey to symptoms which cannot be pinpointed. Unlike MD, the fates of these contributors can be pretty grim. In fact, several sufferers actually died from the parasite they contracted. To make it even worse, those victims are often children.
  • Digital Piracy Is Okay: While it's unknown if the producers of the series actively encouraged it, several doctors featured on the show have released segments of episodes relevant to their research on the internet for others to view.
  • Doctor Jerk: Some of the doctors on the show act like this, especially the ones who are treating children (notably girls) and tell the parents the kid is just being overly dramatic, when the parent knows something is really wrong or the child is clearly in pain or distress.
  • Downer Ending: Sometimes the diseases have no cure, are terminal, or were diagnosed too late, such as a woman whose muscles turned into bone and died before the episode premiered.
  • Early Installment Weirdness: Quite a bit of it, mostly due to the change of narrators from David Guion to David Scott. Guion's voice is softer and more modulated, but he has some pronunciation issues. In one episode, he drops the "p" in "symptom" and very nearly drops the "m" when talking about a woman named Kim.
    • The show also originally had three "medical mysteries" of about twenty minutes each. By about the second season, this was dropped in favor of two half-hour stories.
    • In the earliest episodes, narration was exclusively in past tense ("Kathy took Isaac to the pediatrician" rather than "Kathy takes...") From about season two on, narration was in present tense except in cases where past tense was absolutely needed.
    • Initially, more common diseases were featured, such as Pulmonary Hypotension, Trigeminal Neuralgia and Emphysema. Eventually, these episodes were phased out in favour of the more rare and mysterious conditions.
    • The show also featured lesser quality re-enactments until season 5 or so. For example, whenever they show a re-enactment of a patient having symptoms from season 1-5, it would often be blurred. They would also use real footage of the patient often. Starting from 2009, the re-enactments were of noticeably better quality. The footage is also much better, not being blurred anymore.
  • Edutainment Show: Of course, nothing is a substitute for actual medical advice, but if you're a big fan, you will learn a lot about rare diseases and symptoms.
  • Eye Take: Happens a lot (see below).
  • Gross-Up Close-Up: Sometimes, particularly if the patient of the day is suffering from a flesh-eating disease (which happened a few times). This can also happen with large amounts of blood, or even diagrams (such as those that show cholesterol building up around a heart).
  • I Just Want to Be Normal: Lampshaded and played straight. Naturally, contributors' illnesses make them feel this way, and they say it. Many parents fear that mysterious conditions will keep their kids from being "normal" children as well.
  • Ill Girl: All the kids featured on the show. A couple also fall under Littlest Cancer Patient.
  • Incurable Cough of Death: If an episode involves a respiratory condition, expect plenty of coughing, which can be mistaken for this. Justified in that sometimes, the respiratory symptoms do all but kill the featured patient.
  • Mama Bear: Some of the moms of young children on the show who, when confronted with doctors who basically tell them to go home and quit stressing over their kids, tell the doctors to shove it and start doing their own research.
  • Medical Drama: The show type itself, being centered around mysterious illnesses and diagnosis.
  • Once an Episode: Often multiple times an episode, usually before commercials, the camera will do a close-up of someone's eyes, usually the eyes of the person the featured disease tried to ravage.
  • One Steve Limit: Averted; several featured patients have the same first names. The series has hosted:
    • At least two Amandas (Koveler and Nixon)
    • Two Ashleys (Wolf and Mulinax)
    • Two Connors (Heybach and Rowley)
    • Two Katies (Wells and Faust)
    • In a last name example, a Len Geiger and a Jake Geiger.
    • No less than three Teresas (Rachlin, Killarney, and Zadansky).
    • It even happens with the doctors; for example, geneticist Paul Benke was featured twice. However, no one doctor is ever featured in both halves of the same episode.
    • Symptoms and illnesses are not immune from this trend, either.
      • For babies, expect Colic or the Common cold to frequently be mentioned by doctors in the initial diagnosis.
      • Cancer, Dementia, Neurofibromatosis and Dermatitis also show up fairly often.
    • In another variant, some episodes feature the same diseases. Fibrous ossificans progressiva (FOP) has been featured twice, for instance, in the stories of Ashley Kurpiel and Matt Horick.
      • Cancer has appeared a few times, though in different variants, such as one rare form of leukemia and an inflammatory form of breast cancer.
  • Papa Wolf: The counterparts to the Mama Bears, though this happens less than with moms.
  • Stock Footage: The series uses some to show the changes of the seasons, such as a red autumn tree and snow flurries in a pine forest. Some episodes also use Stock Footage of hospital hallways.
  • Stock Sound Effect: Especially in the early seasons, the series used some of these. Notably, electric crackling sounds always accompanied narrations of extreme pain. In stories of patients dealing with extreme thirst, you would sometimes hear the gurgling/glugging sound of water being drunk or poured. Coughing was sometimes used during narrations of respiratory symptoms.
    • Perhaps unintentionally, the episode featuring Montessa Pittman used a very distinctive sneeze when it mentioned her getting a cold. The sneeze sounds much like a high-pitched hiccup. Several seasons later, Mystery Diagnosis ran the story of Sadie Jones, whose severe hiccups were caused by achalasia. Her hiccups sounded remarkably like Montessa's sneeze.
  • Title Drop: Done by at least one doctor.
  • Trademark Favorite Food: A variant; it's more of a Symptomatic Favorite Food. Applies to any illness that makes the patient crave certain foods to get the nutrients or ingredients in them. Salt is a common craving-inducer, which usually indicates a kidney problem. One patient in particular, a young child with ADH deficiency, had an intense craving for water due to her condition causing her to drink but never feel quenched. She eventually drank so much water that she dealt incurable damage to her brain from it swelling up.
  • Two First Names: Patient Kylie Monica and Dr. Carrie Judy (from two separate episodes).
  • Woobie of the Week: The patients understandably become so distraught over their illnesses, they pretty much have to be this. Especially true in the case of kids.
  • Your Princess Is in Another Castle!: Happened a couple of times, where the actual diagnosis was not a diagnosis itself, but a hallmark of some other disease. Examples included cold agglutinin disease as a hallmark for undiagnosed leukemia and Crohn's symptoms as a cover for a disease called Hermansky-Pudlak syndrome.
    • Sometimes happens because the guests are diagnosed with some type of common or mild disease. They are given medication that seems to work for awhile or clears up the symptoms completely, but then stops working or doesn't respond to a new symptom. Can also happen in cases where the treatment or side effects related to the real diagnosis are actually more devastating than the disease itself.
    • Also happens when doctors persistently diagnose or treat what they think is one disease, but turns out to be another. Examples include:

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: