Peter Vollmer (Dennis Hopper) is a young Neo-Nazi who is trying to get followers, but is struggling due to being very unassertive and uncharismatic. His elderly friend Ernst Ganz (Ludwig Donath), a Holocaust survivor, knows of his activities and disapproves of them, but allows Peter to regularly crash at his apartment out of pity for him.
Peter is visited by a mysterious, shadowy figure who regularly gives him advice on how to win over crowds. Soon, Peter has many followers. On his benefactor's advice, Peter murders a follower named Nick (Howard Caine) and claims the Jews did it, creating a martyr for his cause and bringing in more followers.
One day, Ernst disrupts one of his rallies and orders everyone to stop this foolishness. Ernst says back when he was young, nobody bothered to stand up to Adolf Hitler when he was doing the things Peter is doing now, and it led to the Holocaust. Now, he will not make that mistake again. Peter tries to get Ernst to go away, but Ernst humiliates him and causes his followers to desert him in disgust.
Later, the shadowy benefactor berates Peter for screwing up. Peter angrily retorts that he is doing all the work and demands his benefactor reveal himself instead of hiding in the darkness like a coward. Enraged, the man says: "Mr. Vollmer, I was writing and delivering speeches decades before you could read or understand them! I was fighting battles when your only struggle was to climb out of a womb! I was taking over the world when your universe was a crib! And as for being in darkness, Mr. Vollmer... I INVENTED darkness!" He steps out of the shadows — revealing he is Adolf Hitler (Curt Conway) himself.
Hitler says he is done giving advice. From now on he gives orders. He hands Peter a gun and orders him to kill the Jew, Ernst, telling Peter that weakness is no longer tolerated. Peter is to become steel.
Peter confronts Ernst in their apartment and threatens him with the gun. Unafraid and mildly disappointed, Ernst tries to persuade him to turn back to the light before it is too late, but Peter shoots him in the gut, declaring that he is made of steel. With his last breaths, Ernst reminds Peter that ideas, like freedom and equality, cannot be killed with a mere bullet.
Hitler congratulates Peter on his kill and asks how he feels. Peter declares that he felt like he was immortal. Hitler roars, "Mr. Vollmer, we are immortal!"
Later, the police confront Peter, saying he is a suspect in Nick's murder. Peter tries to escape and is gunned down. In shock at his pain and blood, Peter goes insane, screaming, "There's something very wrong here... Don't you understand that I'm made out of steel?"
Disappointed, Hitler fades back into the shadows, searching for another candidate to spread his vile messages of hate.
This episode contains examples of the following tropes:
- Abusive Parents: Peter admits his father was a violent alcoholic who'd slam him against the wall for minor reasons while his mother suffered from some sort of mental disease that left her emotionally absent to him.
- As Long as There is Evil: Serling uses this in his closing narration.
- Badass Boast: Hitler's "I invented darkness!" rant to Peter, quoted above.
- Calling the Old Man Out: Peter tries to do this to his mysterious mentor, only to run away when he reveals himself to be Hitler.
- Emerging from the Shadows: The reveal of Hitler's identity.
- Even Evil Has Standards: Peter is reluctant to order Nick's murder, and later agonizes over the possibility of killing Ernst. Possibly subverted in that he goes through with both of these deeds anyway.
- Evil Is Hammy: Doesn't get much hammier than a Hitler-wannabe orator played by Dennis Hopper.
- False Flag Operation: At Hitler's urging Peter has chubby Butt-Monkey Nick killed so that he can blame the group's enemies.
- Hypocrite: Peter condemns those who disagree with him as "communists" yet tries to justify his own views as just "differing opinions".
- Ineffectual Sympathetic Villain: Peter comes across as one in the opening scene, being unable to win over even the smallest crowd due to his lack of charisma.
- Manchild: According to Ernst, Peter at his core is still the same sad and lonely boy who still runs to him for comfort. It's the only reason he hasn't entirely given up on Peter yet.
- Odd Friendship: It doesn't get much odder than a Holocaust survivor and a Neo-Nazi.
- Oh, Crap!: When Peter's mysterious benefactor steps out of the shadows and reveals his true identity, the look on Peter's face is a bugged-eyed, slack-jawed expression that, frankly, only Dennis Hopper could pull off.
- Paper Tiger: Peter, as lampshaded by Hitler:Hitler: You have the voice of a lion and the instincts of a rabbit.
- "The Reason You Suck" Speech: Ernst delivers one of these to Peter in front of his audience:Ernst: I can tell them what you were saying. I've heard it before. On a hundred different street corners. It was drivel then and it is drivel now...
Well, what is this one here? The new model? A 1963 Führer right off the assembly line? Well, this one is not so new. He's not so fresh. This one is nothing but a cheap copy!
... Well, let me tell you about this one.
About the breed, the species.
They're all alike. They are all alike...
Problem children. Sick, sad, neurotics who take applause like a needle...
Listen to me, Peter. And let them listen. Or else I'll tell them about a quaking, whimpering boy who cried on my couch; who still cries on my couch...
Yeah, put me down, put me down. Shut me up. Stifle me— why don't you? WHY CAN'T YOU?
[grabs Peter's armband] Because this is your courage right here. This is your strength. And the torchlights and the crowd and the Sieg heil!
[Peter hits him] The rebuttal. The only sort of answer your kind knows how to give.
[turning to audience] This is your Führer. He's yours. I give him to you. A gift from the sewers.
- Villainous Breakdown: Peter has one throughout the episode, culminating in his death.
- Villain Protagonist: The main character, Peter, is a violent Neo-Nazi thug.
- While You Were in Diapers: Hitler gives Peter Vollmer a speech to this effect, quoted above.
- You Cannot Kill An Idea:
- In his dying words, Ernst tells this to Peter.
- This also applies to Hitler as Rod Serling's ending narration reminds the audience that he will continue to live so long as hatred and prejudice exist.