Follow TV Tropes


Recap / The Simpsons S 16 E 1 Treehouse Of Horror XV

Go To

Original air date: 11/7/2004

Production code: FABF-23 note 

This year sees Ned gaining the power to predict doom after a head injury, a Victorian-era parody with Lisa and Bart as detectives out to catch a prostitute killer, and a "fantastic voyage" inside Mr. Burns' body.

"The Ned Zone"

Homer attempts to get a frisbee off his roof with a bowling ball. One of his attempts hits Ned Flanders in the head. Later, in the hospital, Dr. Hibbert informs Ned that he nearly died— of a brain tumor. The bowling ball actually saved him by knocking it out of his head. Hibbert shakes Flanders' hand, and Flanders sees a vision of Hibbert falling to his death. In the real world, he freaks out and pulls his hand away.

Hibbert sees how pale he looks, and opens the window to get Flanders some fresh air. The Simpsons come to visit, and Homer asks Dr. Hibbert to get his frisbee off the ledge. While reaching for it, Hibbert falls out the window. He realizes that this is going to hurt and injects himself with a painkiller. That done, he hits the ground and dies— in the exact manner that Ned predicted.

Ned is quite freaked out by this, and tries to reassure himself that it was just a coincidence. This belief is shaken after he catches Hans Moleman after Hans's shoes were thrown over a telephone wire while he was still wearing them, and sees a vision of Hans being attacked by alligators. Startled by the vision, he drops Hans into a sewer through an open manhole, at which point Hans is attacked by alligators.

The now quite freaked out Flanders asks God why he has these visions. He hits his hand against a building, which turns out to be a theater showing Rosie O' Donnell's new musical, which he sees will close after 3 performances. He says he didn't need any power to know that was coming. Homer walks up, looking for his frisbee. Ned tells Homer of his new power of foretelling death, and Homer asks Ned to do it to him.

Ned reluctantly complies, and sees Homer being shot three times from behind— and the shooter is Ned Flanders himself. Flanders pulls away, terrified.

He later tries to move, but Homer doesn't believe that Flanders will kill him and does believe in Tempting Fate. Homer gets Wiggum to give Homer his gun, and gives the gun to Flanders, urging Flanders to shoot. While Homer taunts Flanders, he sees a vision of Homer pressing a button at the nuclear plant— and causing Springfield to be destroyed. Flanders warns Homer, but he's unphased and goes to work anyway.

At the plant, Ned tries to tell Homer not to press the Core Destruct button, but all Homer hears is "Press...destruct...button". He does so, and while Homer is reaching for the button (and taking a long time with it), he grabs a sleeping security guard's gun and shoots Homer... just like he saw in his vision.

Homer proceeds to flop all around the console he's at, eventually pressing the Core Destruct button with his tongue. Springfield is destroyed, and both Ned and Homer go to heaven. They meet the rest of the Simpsons there, and Marge tells him that if he was trying to get out of cleaning the garage, it won't work, as the garage is also in heaven.

At this point, God interrupts and gives Homer "what he deserves"— his frisbee.

"Four Beheadings and a Funeral"

London's prostitutes are being killed by a Jack The Ripper-esque Serial Killer called the Muttonchop Murderer because of his muttonchop beard style. The Scotland Yard investigates, and their chief, Wiggums, says they should dust the latest victim for prints. When his men ask him what he meant, he clarified that the prince was coming by, and he wanted the victim cleaned up by then.

Lisa and Bart show up, as Master Detective Eliza Simpson and her easily amazed sidekick, Dr. Bartley. She asks what clues they've found, and Wiggum says that they've already caught the killer. He shows the suspect, Apu (who does not have muttonchops). He says that Apu is clearly responsible for the murder, and tells the police to "lock him up until we find someone darker". Apu protests that he's not a killer, just a purveyor of disgusting British food like eel pies. Wiggum loves eel pies, and he eats one of Apu's wares as Apu is being dragged away.

After Apu has gone, Marge Simpson shows up, with a story to tell. She says she saw a strange man, who dropped a bloody, curvy knife and then ran away. Wiggums gives Lisa the knife, but says that this case was beyond even her skills. She takes that challenge.

Later, Lisa talks with the Comic Book Guy, a dealer who sold the knife as part of a set, the Seven Swords of Osiris. He tries to sell her a book that goes with it, but she just wants to know who bought it. Comic Book Guy checks his records. While Lisa and Bart look around the shop (and find Ned Flanders as a shrunken head), Comic Book Guy stumbles out of the other room with a record book, crying "Help! Help! Murder!", and then falls down dead, with a curvy knife in his back. The window behind him is open.

Lisa takes the ledger, and uses it to learn who bought the Seven Swords of Osiris, while a muttonchop-wearing shadow stalks them. She finds out that they were sold to one C. Ebenezar Burns, evil industrialist and opium addict. They find him in Mao's Den of Iniquity, which is run by Moe. He says that he once possessed the entire collection— but then sold them all to buy opium. Lisa asks who he sold them to. He says he sold them to a fat man with sideburns— like the one in a greatcoat and top hat right behind them.

The man turns out to be Homer. He runs away, but is grabbed by Wiggum. When Wiggum is queried as to why he's in an opium den, he says it's the only way he can get Ralphie to go to sleep.

Lisa and Bart walk through the city, happy that the Muttonchop Murderer has been caught. But then they see another Sword of Osiris in the chest of another prostitute. But that means the murderer is still on the loose, and the guy they have is innocent. Lisa takes out the sword and sniffs it.

The next day, Homer is about to be hanged for the actions of the Muttonchop Murderer. He pleads for mercy, saying that he's not a murderer. Wiggum is about to pull the lever, when Lisa shows up and tells him not to, as Homer is innocent. Her evidence? The blade used in the latest murderer smelled of eel pie— like the one Wiggum is eating at that very moment.

Wiggum defends himself by saying that a lot of people like eel pie, but a police officer then takes off Wiggum's hat to reveal that he also has muttonchops. When Lisa asks him why he did it, he reveals that he wanted to come up with a case that she couldn't crack. He then runs away to a hot-air balloon nearby, and floats away. He gloats to Bart and Lisa that they'll never catch him, before his balloon is ripped apart by Kang and Kodos in a steampunk spaceship.

Wiggum: Remember me for my police work and not the murders!

Kang and Kodos fly into the sunset, laughing about destroying Earth's fleet. We then cut to Ralphie and Wiggum at the opium den, where Ralphie tells his father that he just had the strangest dream. Wiggum informs Ralphie that he's still in it, and we zoom out to an ice castle surrounded by winged dinosaurs, a chicken pulling a carriage, a sea monster, and other Real Dreams are Weirder material. Ralphie and Wiggum fly out on the bed.

"In the Belly of the Boss"

The Simpsons attend a science fair, where Professor Frink demonstrates his latest invention, a miniaturization ray. He uses this on a giant capsule full of nutrients in the form of balls. The ray works as expected, and Mr. Burns eats the pill - only to discover too late that Maggie (who had thought the capsule was a ball pit, and jumped in to play) was inside.
Frink quickly assembles the Simpsons into a crew that can pilot a submarine and go into a "fantastic voyage" into Mr. Burns' body, in order to save Maggie from being digested. After being injected into Burns' body, Frink attempts to guide them from outside, but Homer ignores Frink's instructions and ends up with the sub getting stuck on Burns' heart, requiring effort to get it unstuck.
After using a nerve impulse to reach Burns' stomach, they manage to rescue Maggie seconds before the capsule is completely digested, but due to Maggie's weight, the ship now doesn't have enough power to move. Homer is forced to stay behind, but consoles himself with a marshmallow in Burns' stomach. The ship leaves Burns' body just before its miniaturization reverses, but they are unable to go rescue Homer before he grows again.
The Simpsons - and Burns - go to a restaurant, where Homer complains he cannot eat since there is no hole available, but Burns is confident they will eventually solve the problem and leads him into a dance to the tune of "I've Got You Under My Skin", with the entire ensemble joining.

This episode provides examples of...

  • Anachronism Stew: Subverted. In Real Life, Jack the Ripper's attacks predate forensic identification via fingerprints by just a few years. So, Lou and Eddie are understandably confused when Inspector Wiggum asks them to dust a body "for prints".
    Wiggum: The Prince is coming by, and I want her clean when he looks her over.
  • Animated Adaptation: "In The Belly of the Boss" is a very loose remake of the Simpsons comic "I Shrink, Therefore I'm Small", as both involve Homer shrinking to tiny size and venturing into Mr. Burns. The executions are different, but the Fantastic Voyage motif is the same.
  • Artistic License – Biology: The alligators that attack Hans Moleman are drawn as resembling crocodiles, namely having the lower teeth visible when the mouth is closed.
  • Bait-and-Switch:
    Announcer: We now return to Keepin' It Kodos, starring Kang!
  • Bait-and-Switch Comment: God says he's giving Homer "what he deserves": Homer's frisbee.
  • Body Horror: Played for Laughs, as Homer ends up trapped inside Burns' body after regenerating to his normal size after he was unable to leave with the family. However, he mostly is upset over not having a mouth of his own to eat food and seems to be pleased when he and Burns dance to "I've Got You Under My Skin".)
  • Breaking the Fourth Wall: After learning from Professor Fink that someone from the Simpsons will have to stay behind in Burns' body, Lisa declares that "this is the worst Halloween Horror" they've ever faced.
  • Chekhov's Gun: In "Four Beheadings and a Funeral", Apu presents Inspector Wiggum an eel pie which he eats for himself. After the recent murder, Eliza smells the dagger and discovers a scent of the same pie.
  • Dance Party Ending: To "I've Got You Under My Skin".
  • The Determinator: Homer persistently tries to press the nuclear destruct button, even as he is being shot.
  • Did You Just Flip Off Cthulhu?: After getting his frisbee from God, Homer tells him "you're not the boss of me" to his face.
  • Downer Ending: "The Ned Zone" ends with Ned killing Homer a fraction too late, and sending everyone in Springfield to Heaven thanks to the nuclear meltdown.
  • Fanservice: Marge in third story. Everyone else gets reasonable diving suits for swimming around inside Mr. Burns, but she gets a swimsuit that accentuates her bust; later on she gets attacked by platelets, which inflict about as much Clothing Damage as is possible on network television.
  • "Fantastic Voyage" Plot: The Simpsons tour inside Mr Burns's body.
  • Fluffy Cloud Heaven: Ned finds himself here at the end of "The Ned Zone" together with all the Simpsons and their garage.
  • Foreign Queasine: "Four Beheadings and a Funeral" has gags about how the British foods like eel pie (which Chief Wiggum greatly enjoys) would sound unappetising to American viewers.
    Chief Wiggum: We British sure eat crap!
  • Foreshadowing:
    • In Ned's vision, he's holding a black gun while shooting Homer. And when Homer hands him Wiggum's gun, it's gray. Meaning that he never prevented the vision from coming true.
    • While Mr. Burns points to Homer when giving his description, he doesn’t actually identify him as the buyer, hinting that Homer is not the real killer.
  • Go-Karting with Bowser: During the Dance Party Ending, Eliza is shown dancing with Inspector Wiggum while Moleman dances with an alligator.
  • Groin Attack: Invoked at the end of the "Fantastic Voyage" Plot. Homer tells Mr. Burns that it's a bad idea to defy someone who can kick his balls from the inside.
  • Hated by All: Homer in "The Ned Zone", apparently. When Ned says that he just had a vision of him shooting Homer, Bart responds with "In this neighbourhood, who hasn't?"
  • I'm a Humanitarian: In "In the Belly of the Boss", Homer eats several of Mr. Burns' ribs.
  • I Taste Delicious: In the opening sequence, as the family are all being prepared to eat the Simpson family, Homer consistently eats himself with delight.
  • Jerkass Has a Point: When everyone ends up in heaven (along with the garage), Marge tells off Homer for destroying Springfield just to get out of cleaning the garage. He had one job.
  • Kill the Ones You Love: Ned is forced to shoot Homer, who he describes as his best friend, to save Springfield.
  • Lampshade Hanging: Homer calls attention to how long it's taking his arm to slowly and dramatically press a button.
  • Lost in Transmission: Ned's pleas for Homer to not destroy Springfield.
    Ned: Homer, do not press the core destruct button!
    Transmitted into the booth: Homer, (Static) press (Static) Destruct button!
    (Homer glances at the button, shrugs at Ned, and gets up to press the button)
    Ned: Don't do it! Don't do it! You'll kill everyone!
    Transmitted: (Static) Do it! (Static) Do it! (Static) Kill everyone!
  • Magic Antidote: Comic Book Guy attempts to use one after being stabbed in the second segment, only to spill it onto a stool, who takes on the name Simon Stoolowitz and heads off to America to be in pictures.
  • Major Injury Underreaction: Mr. Burns is fully awake while the Simpsons recover Maggie from inside his body. When an explosion goes off inside him, his reaction is extremely subdued.
    Burns: Well... That hurt like hell.
  • Mistaken for Undead: While analyzing Selma's fresh corpse, the twit Bartely believes that she was killed several days ago because of her hideous face. Selma wakes up long enough to confirm that was stabbed only five minutes ago.
  • Must Not Die a Virgin: As Homer's character in "Four Beheadings and a Funeral" is about to be hanged after being found guilty of murder, he pleads: "Please spare me. I'm not a murderer, I'm not. And I've never known the pleasures of a woman or a proper eating apple."
  • Nice Job Breaking It, Hero:
    • Ned's attempts to avoid killing Homer and preventing him from destroying Springfield are what ultimately lead those events to happen.
    • His vision of Hans Moleman's death is also his fault — his vision gives him such a shock, he drops him into the sewer where the gators feed on him.
  • Not Even Bothering with the Accent: Noticeably in Four Beheadings and a Funeral (with the exception of the first victim), every member of the Simpson family speaks with an English accent, but everyone outside of it doesn't.
  • Not Helping Your Case: Homer in the second segment is found in an opium den, and it's revealed he resembles the man who bought Mr. Burn's prized sword. He actually is innocent of the crime. Then to escape the detectives, he starts tossing the addicts' bodies at them and run.
  • Not Hyperbole: When Inspector Wiggum chews Lou out for revealing him as the murderer, he claims that Eddie never says anything bad about him. Lou then points out that Wiggum cut off Eddie’s tongue, leaving him incapable of complaining.
    Eddie: E ai, ee. (He’s right, Chief)
  • O.O.C. Is Serious Business: Ned is so freaked out over his vision of killing Homer that when the man starts Tempting Fate Ned, a hardcore Christian, warns him about upsetting the gods.
  • Opium Den: The Victorian segment excurses into an opium den operated by Moe. Mr. Burns is a customer.
  • Or Was It a Dream?: Four Beheadings and a Funeral ends with Ralphie telling his father that he'd just had the strangest dream— only to be told that he was still dreaming.
  • Profane Last Words: Ned shoots Homer to stop him from pressing the core destruct button but Homer ends up dying next to the button...only for his tongue to end up pressing it.
    Ned: Oh, you stupid, son of a—
    (city explodes)
  • Self-Fulfilling Prophecy: Ned's vision of Moleman's death causes him to drop Moleman to said death. His attempts to stop Homer from blowing up Springfield also result in just that.
  • Sewer Gator: How Moleman gets killed.
  • Shout-Out:
    • The opening sequence, Keepin' It Kodos, is this to many sitcoms of the 1980s, and the opening song (and closing credits) is the Perfect Strangers theme song.
    • When the title screen comes up, the "XV" is hammered into the steel plate by Kodos, a la the Mark VII Limited logo.
    • During the Four Beheadings and a Funeral segment, Lou and Eddie arrest Peter Pan for child abduction.
  • Skewed Priorities:
    • When Ned tells Homer not to go to the plant due to the risk he could kill anyone, Homer still goes because as it's Lenny's birthday they are having ice cream cake.
    • Marge believes that Homer blew up the town just to get out of cleaning the garage.
  • Sole Survivor: In the sitcom-style opening segment where Kang and Kodos serve up the Simpsons during Dinner with the Boss, Bart manages to survive being eaten. His concern about having outlived his whole family is quickly resolved when the aliens offer to adopt him.
  • Take That!: When Flanders predicts that The Rosie O'Donnell Musical would close after three performances, he comments he didn't need his power to see that.
  • That Poor Cat: An offscreen cat yowls after one of Homer's attempts to use a bowling ball to get a frisbee off the roof.
  • Too Dumb to Live: Granted, most people wouldn't listen to a man talking about seeing the future. However Homer doesn't even pause for thought when he thinks Ned is telling him to press the core destruct button. Not even when Ned tells him, even through the static interferance that it will kill everyone.
  • Vitriolic Best Buds: Despite everything, Ned describes Homer as his best friend in "The Ned Zone."
  • You Can't Fight Fate: In the process of trying to prevent his second vision of Homer pressing the core destruct button, Ned ends up fulfilling the first vision (that he would shoot Homer). Then the second vision comes true anyway when Homer manages to hit the button in his death throes.
  • Your Princess Is in Another Castle!: When it seems like the Muttonchop Murderer is caught, Lisa and Bart find yet another murder, and conclude that the murderer is still at large.