As negotiations begin to determine the fates of the two Eleanors, Michael uses Tahani's house as a meeting place only for the Bad Place demons to turn the event into a party where they walk all over Michael, much to Tahani's dismay. Meanwhile, Chidi and the good Eleanor bond over dinner with Eleanor and Trevor. During the main negotiation session, Michael stands up to Trevor and his demons, declaring war on the Bad Place and promising to fight for Eleanor. Trevor promises to get Shawn, an "Eternal Judge", involved. Michael ultimately throws the demons out of the Good Place. That night, Jason finds Tahani in his "meditation room", demanding to know who he really is. In flashbacks, Eleanor is shown to dislike joining social groups.
- Arson, Murder, and Jaywalking: "Real" Eleanor's description of the Bad Place includes being bitten by flying piranhas, burned by lava monsters, and sitting through college improv.
- Bread, Eggs, Breaded Eggs: When Janet is asked to procure jalapeno poppers.Janet: Sure! Quick question, what is a "jalapeno"? Also, what is a "poppers"? Also, what is "jalapeno poppers"?
- Complete-the-Quote Title: From a Groucho Marx quotation: "Please accept my resignation. I do not care to belong to any club that will accept someone like me as a member".
- Extreme Doormat: Michael is terrified of the Bad Place demons and lets them walk all over him.
- Evil Counterpart: Janet has a Bad Place version of herself known simply as "Bad Janet", who is just as obnoxious as the other demons.
- Evil Is Petty: Trevor and his lackeys never miss a chance to be unnecessarily unpleasant, and the torments of the Bad Place involve a lot of persistent nagging inconveniences (e.g., the train going there makes a million unnecessary stops and the restaurant car is always closed) along with more traditional forms of Cold-Blooded Torture.
- Freudian Excuse: Discussed. Eleanor believes that her terrible parents are partially to blame for how she turned out. However, the "real" Eleanor had an even worse background (bordering on Hilariously Abusive Childhood) but channeled that into becoming an altruistic humanitarian. Moreover, Trevor points out that lots of kids have screwed-up family backgrounds but don't turn into self-absorbed jerks, so it's not really a good excuse.
- Jerkass Has a Point: Mixed with Villain Has a Point - Trevor is a demon who enjoys being evil, but his retort to Eleanor about how her cruddy childhood doesn't give her a free pass or excuse her awful behavior is not far off.
- Precision F-Strike: Michael's speech to the demons ends with him yelling, "Get the fork out of my neighborhood!"
- Your Approval Fills Me with Shame: Eleanor is less than pleased to learn Trevor and the demons are fans of her Earthly behavior and think she'd be happier with them.