Follow TV Tropes


Recap / Star Trek: The Next Generation S2E8 "A Matter of Honor"

Go To
"Exactly where are your loyalties, Commander?"

The Enterprise-D visits Starbase 179 and takes on some replacement crew as part of an Officer Exchange Program. Picard notes that Starfleet thinks it would be a good idea for someone from the Enterprise to participate as well—and mentions that there is a Klingon vessel, the Pagh, in the area that would agree to take on an exchange officer. Inspired, Riker volunteers to participate because "nobody's ever done it before." He has a slightly rocky start, but manages to develop a camaraderie with most of the crew of the Pagh. Most of the crew, anyway—the overly paranoid Captain Kargan is a different story.

Meanwhile, the exchange officers on the Enterprise are adjusting. The overly-eager Ensign Mendon, a Benzite, irritates Worf with his constant suggestions for improvement and apparent arrogance, and when he discovers a potentially dangerous bacteria on both the hull of the Enterprise and the Pagh, he waits overly long to inform Picard of the discovery. When questioned, he states that it is a Benzite regulation to wait until they have a full analysis and resolution before reporting the problem. Picard informs him that if there is a potential for danger to the ship, he should inform the bridge immediately and continue his analysis. Upon discovering that the bacteria is chewing a hole in the hull, and that the Pagh is even more susceptible, the Enterprise changes course to intercept the Klingon ship to warn them of the potential danger.


Unfortunately, Kargan is convinced that the Enterprise deliberately spread the bacteria to them and orders his crew to attack. Riker continues to uphold his oath of loyalty to the Pagh, but before the order to fire can be given he tricks Kargan into taking the emergency transponder that Worf gave him—and Kargan is promptly beamed onto the Enterprise. Worf stuns Kargan before he can attack the bridge crew, and Riker takes command of the Pagh, and orders a bemused Captain Picard to surrender and repair the Klingon ship. Both ships are repaired, and Riker returns command to Kargan, growling at him and allowing Kargan to punch him to retain his dignity. As Lieutenant Klag (Brian Thompson) helps Riker up, he muses that Riker has handled himself well.

Klag: You understand the Klingons better than I thought, Commander.
Riker: Thank you, my friend.

As the Enterprise finishes fixing the hole in the Pagh, Riker returns to his ship. Picard congratulates him and tells him to go to sickbay. As Worf escorts them there, Riker notes that the Klingons are a very brave and unique people and that he's glad to have Worf with them on the Enterprise. "Thank you, Commander," Worf says, "and welcome home."

This episode provides examples of:

  • Absentee Actor: La Forge and Troi do not appear, in LeVar Burton's first absence from the series.
  • Alien Lunch: Before his transfer, Riker indulges in Klingon cuisine, which includes serpent worms called gagh. Later on, in the Klingon mess hall, he discovers that Klingons actually eat their gagh while it's still alive. Despite initial hesitation, he eventually takes the plunge.
    • This scene became an extremely extended Brick Joke when a much later-written expanded universe novel had Riker reminiscing on the reason all the Klingons laughed when he just swallowed the live gagh: you're supposed to semi-ritualistically chew them until you're sure they're all dead, as a miniature recreation of the hunting process. Actually swallowing a live gagh worm leads to a rather nasty intestinal parasite.
  • Artistic License – Biology: Yes, you heard correctly. Data did say "subatomic bacteria." Also counts as Artistic License – Physics.
  • Chekhov's Gun: The emergency transponder that Worf gives Riker before he leaves for the Pagh. It isn't shown or mentioned again until the climax, when Riker uses it to trick Kargan into beaming off the Pagh.
  • Conflicting Loyalty: Kargan accuses Riker of this.
    Kargan: I am still Captain of this vessel and you are still crew and sworn to obey me. You gave me your oath.
    Riker: Yes, sir, I did.
    Kargan: Then fulfill that oath and serve this ship as you swore to. Tell me of the surest method of attack against the Enterprise.
    Riker: I won't.
    Kargan: You must. It is a matter of honor and loyalty to your oath.
    Riker: I will not surrender the secrets of the Enterprise to you.
    Kargan: If your word is no good, then how can we ever trust Starfleet?
    Riker: I will not break any vow I have taken in the past. I have also taken an oath a loyalty to your ship. I will not break that.
    Kargan: They are in conflict!
    Riker: No, sir, they are not! I will obey your orders. I will serve this ship as First Officer, and in an attack against the Enterprise I will die along with this crew. But I will not break my oath of loyalty to Starfleet.
    Kargan: If you had told those secrets about the Enterprise, I would have labeled you a traitor and killed you where you stood. But instead you will die with us. You'll die like a Klingon.
  • Culture Clash: A major point with Mendon. In his culture, offering criticism is considered normal. In Starfleet? He comes across as a self-entitled jerk. Furthermore, not reporting a problem immediately nearly gets the Enterprise destroyed.
  • Early Installment Weirdness: Although this episode establishes many of the standard concepts for the TNG Klingons, there is one odd moment when Klag tells Riker that, to a Klingon, his career is everything and family is less important. This is very much in contrast to concepts of Klingon family-based honour that would soon be introduced. Also, in the same conversation Riker castigates Klag for refusing to contact his father (due to said father's supposed dishonour), angrily reminding him that "he is your father"... But later on, in "The Icarus Factor" we find out that Riker himself is estranged from his own father, and hasn't seen him in 15 years.
  • Fish out of Water: Riker as the only human on a ship full of Klingons, and to a lesser extent, Mendon trying to adjust to Starfleet protocol.
  • Heroic BSoD: Mendon goes into one after screwing up in matters of protocol. Wesley helps him snap out of it in time to solve the bacteria problem.
  • Identical Stranger: Peculiar example with Mendon the Benzite, who looks identical to Mordock from "Coming of Age" (and is played by the same actor) and is initially mistaken for him by Wesley. He says that all Benzites from the same "geostructure" look identical. Apparently this was a case of Real Life Writes the Plot: the script calls for an exchange officer who's not familiar with Starfleet practices, so they couldn't use Mordock—but they still wanted to use the same actor, because the Benzite head cast was molded to fit a specific individual, and hiring the same guy to play Mendon was cheaper than making a new cast for someone else.
  • Idiot Ball: Kargan is convinced that the bacteria is a deliberate attack by the Enterprise. Even when his own crew points out the holes in his logic, he insists that the Enterprise gave them the bacteria simply by scanning them.
  • Klingon Promotion: Discussed early on by Worf and Riker—it's expected that if a Klingon captain is too weak or unfit for command, his First Officer will assist in his "retirement." During the climax, Riker uses a Downplayed variant—he doesn't kill Kargan, but tricks him into getting beamed off the Pagh for a while, leaving Riker as the ranking officer.
  • Meat Moss: Both ships are infested with a fuzzy, rust-colored bacterial colony that doubles in size every quarter-hour and feeds on the metal of their hulls. Getting rid of it serves as the B-plot of the episode.
  • Mistakes Are Not the End of the World: Bendon messes up by not immediately reporting the bacterial colony which is growing on the Enterprise hull because on a Benzite ship, one would never report such a thing until they had completed their full analysis and come up with a proposed solution. He feels that he failed and can never recover, but Wesley tells him that he just made an error, that "Captain Picard may not like them, but he knows they turn up from time to time."
  • Secret Test of Character:
  • Stock Footage: Most of the Klingon Bird-of-Prey shots are taken from Star Trek III: The Search for Spock and Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home.
  • Talk to the Fist: Riker's response to Klag's challenge. The ensuing Curb-Stomp Battle helps him earn the crew's respect.
  • That's an Order!:
    Riker: Cloaking shields off!
  • A Threesome Is Hot: When two Klingon women seem to show interest in Riker, and one of the men suggests that they want to see how well Riker can endure them, he responds, "One or both?" This show of bravado endears him to the Klingons, including the women.


How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: