Rev. Putty preaches about how the best thing to give to God is a lost soul to save, but his heart's not in it because it's not like there are any sinners in Moralton. Orel and Doughy decide to go over to the neighboring town of Sinville to find lost souls for Rev. Putty to save, and unknowingly pick up prostitutes, with the result that Rev. Putty finally loses his virginity. A more relaxed Putty says that all Christians should experience such glory. Taking it at face value, Orel unwittingly starts a prostitution ring in Moralton, which all the men eagerly take up, leading to an outbreak of STDs. Orel is caught when he realizes Clay was calling for two souls to be 'saved', and Clay tells him he will see him in his study...in one hour. He then continues to try to order two prostitutes from a now unnerved Orel.
Tropes present:
- Earn Your Happy Ending: Easy to miss, but Principal Fakey's ex wife is seen in Sinville, when she seems happier and more adjusted than before.
- Faux Horrific: While in Sinville, Orel and Doughy were seeing all the depravity the city offered. But what really scared them the most, to the point to scream and run, was a man revealing to them he was actually... Catholic!
- Literal-Minded: When Rev. Putty thanks Orel for the gift of the "lost souls to save", he casually said that all Chrsitians should experience it. Orel then decides to make sure they will all experience it, and brings more prostitutes to the town to get them saved.
- Sexual Euphemism: Orel just brought a lot of "lost souls" so all the people in Moralton can help save their souls. Of course, all the men then started just to talk about "saving souls" whenever they wanted to hire a prostitute from Orel.
