In the story, Papa Smurf is still having desires for Smurfette when he tries on Vanity's "pheromone cologne", which when mixed with his other chemicals turns him into a hairy and horny giant that is after Smurfette.
This story provides the following examples of:
- Carpet of Virility: Papa Smurf with his chest and belly hair in Hulk mode.
- A Date with Rosie Palms: Hulked Out Papa with the Smurfette doll is pretty much this going on, which the Smurfs leave alone to respect his privacy until he returns to normal.
- Double-Meaning Title: The title of the story, meaning (1) Papa Smurf has an amorous interest in Smurfette, and (2) Papa Smurf Hulks out when he inhales the "pheromone cologne" mixed with other chemicals, causing him to smash and crush things.
- Falling into His Arms: Smurfette was on a ladder and starts to descend when one of the rungs breaks, causing her to fall. Papa Smurf, who was holding the ladder at the bottom, caught her in his arms, which was a happy moment that lasted a bit too long for Smurfette's comfort that resulted in her telling Papa Smurf politely to put her down.
- Fix Fic: This is one meant to fix the problem of Papa Smurf's infatuation with Smurfette from "Romeo And Smurfette".
- The Grunting Orgasm: Hulked Out Papa Smurf does this with the Smurfette doll.
- Hulking Out: Papa Smurf when he inhales the "pheromone cologne" mixed in with his other chemicals.
- I Need a Freaking Drink: At the end of the story, Duncan McSmurf goes with Tapper to the tavern for a drink to get the thoughts of Smurfette with Papa Smurf out of his mind.
- Kissing Under the Influence: Papa Smurf in Hulked Out mode seeking to mate with Smurfette and slops one on her when he has her in his grasp.
- Lecherous Licking: Papa Smurf under the influence of the "pheromone cologne" and Hulked Out licks Smurfette's face.
- Love Potion: "Pheromone cologne", which Vanity intended to use on himself and ended up giving to Papa Smurf. He tries it on himself, only for the mist to mix in with his other chemicals, resulting in Papa Smurf Hulking Out.
- Mate or Die: Papa Smurf is affected by the "pheromone cologne" mixed with other chemicals, causing him to be Hulked Out and to have an insatiable desire for Smurfette, which Tracker says Papa Smurf should die or else he could die. Fortunately, Smurfette was spared the squicky fate by the Smurfs creating a life-size doll of her for Papa Smurf to expend his mating energy upon.
- Parental Incest: Thankfully averted in this story, where Smurfette confesses to Papa Smurf that she could never love him as anything other than a father.
- Smells Sexy: Papa Smurf after his Hulking Out moment pursues after Smurfette when he can smell her pheromones.
- A Tankard of Moose Urine: Duncan McSmurf makes a comment about human ale tasting like it came from the other end of a horse.
- You're Just Jealous: Smurfette teases Empath with this when he suggests that Papa Smurf might have some amorous desires toward her that are inappropriate for a Smurf his age and stature.