Rebecca re-unites under unusual circumstances with half-brother Tucker (Luca Padovan) and discovers they have many things in common. In an effort to connect with her kids, Paula plans an activity that requires they all to work together. Meanwhile, Nathaniel brainstorms a way to win Rebecca back.
Songs
"One Indescribable Instant (Reprise)" (sung by Luca Padovan and Rachel Bloom)
"I Want to Be a Child Star" (sung by Luca Padovan)
- Former Child Star: This is what Tucker wants to be.
- "I Want" Song: Well, obviously enough given the title.
- Lyrical Dissonance: A happy, upbeat song...about how the singer wants to become a child celebrity and ruin his life.
- Celebrity Cameo: Queer Eye (2018)'s Tan France as the oft-mentioned designer Fett Ragoso.
- Manipulative Bastard: At the age of 12, Tucker manages to manipulate both of his parents and his half-sister to get him to LA and allow him to audition for a musical without anyone realizing he'd planned it. Every step of his plan works perfectly, up until the bit where he fails to get the part.
- Stalking is Love: Subverted once again. Nathaniel gets ahold of Rebecca's childhood diary in an attempt to win her back, genuinely considering it to be a sign of affection. When Rebecca finds out, shes understandably horrified and finally breaks things off with him for good.
