On her first recon mission, Billie gets spotted by the Homeland Security agent Murphy. Piper organizes a speed-dating event at P3 and invites Paige. Phoebe rushes her relationship with Dex, and Billie accidentally casts a spell on them. A demon teams up with an Imp master to kill good Samaritans. The sisters realize that living with fake identities might be harder than they thought.
- Suspiciously Similar Substitute: The Charmed Ones offer to provide help to Agent Murphy. This effectively makes him a substitute for Darryl in the few episodes where he appears.