On his third birthday, Wyatt turns three toys (a soldier, a cowboy and an Indian) into people. Billie tortures a possessor demon, who escapes and vows revenge. A parolee of Henry's flips out after being denied a loan and takes everyone in the bank hostage, including Paige and Billie.
- Disappeared Dad: Deconstructed. The toys are partly an outgrowth of Wyatt's mind. They search for a missing Leo, while expressing frustration and guilt over him seemingly breaking his promise to always be there.
- It's All My Fault: Wyatt doesn't understand why Leo is gone and blames himself.
- New Powers as the Plot Demands: Averted. Paige's healing power kicks in when it's needed most, but it's already been demonstrated with Wyatt that a half-witch/half-Whitelighter can have healing powers.
- Traumatic Superpower Awakening: Paige's healing power is triggered when she has to save Henry without being exposed after he's shot.