After engaging a group of Cylon Raiders, Captain Apollo crash-lands on a planet where a law-deriding thug by the name of Lacerta controls a seemingly indestructible henchman, who turns out to be a Cylon Centurion which everyone calls "Red Eye".
Uncertain as to why a Cylon would be on the planet and working for a human con man, Apollo decides to investigate. During his investigate he meets the young Puppis and his mother Vela. Vela is at first very suspicious of Apollo. Which Apollo later learns is due to her late husband being a Colonial warrior who was murdered by Red Eye. Apollo later learns that Lacerta found Red Eye among the wreckage of a crashed ship. Somehow, he reactivated the Centurion, whose programming got scrambled, and mistook Lacerta for its Imperious Leader.
Apollo returns to town where he confronts Lacerta who quickly calls Red Eye to his defense, and a western styled duel begins. Red Eye draws his gun, but Apollo is quicker on the draw and blasts the Centurion to oblivion. With his powerful henchman defeated, Lacerta is quickly run out of town.
Later, Vela helps Apollo retrieve the fuel from Marten's crashed Viper to refuel his ship. He says his goodbyes to her and Puppis and heads off into space. He is quickly found by Starbuck and Boomer, and guided back to the fleet.
- Battle Trophy: Martin's pistol.
- Cowboy Episode: On alien planet in a series about people who live in space.
- The Dragon: Red Eye serves this role to Lacerta.
- Expy: A fistful of them:
- Apollo=Shane, a warrior/gunslinger who winds up in the town.
- Vela=Marian Starett, a mother who takes the warrior in.
- Puppis=Joey Starett, the son who is drawn to the weapons of the warrior.
- Red Eye=Jack Wilson, a ruthless, laconic enforcer from the world of the gunslinger.
- Lacerta=Rufus Ryker, the Big Bad who is intimidating the citizens of the town.
- Bootes=Frank "Stonewall" Torrey, a citizen of the town who is killed to show off the enforcer's skills.
- Fat Bastard: Lacerta
- The Gunslinger: Apollo proves he's quite the accomplished marksman in this episode.
- Meaningful Name: Puppis, who is very like a Puppy.
- My Boy Back Home: When stranded on Equellus, Apollo often laments he has a son waiting for him. It doesn't help that Puppis' restlessness and childish expectations remind him so much of Boxey.
- Oh, Crap!: Red Eye reacts like this when he realizes Apollo is faster than him.
- Posthumous Character: Martin.
- Quick Draw: Red-Eye proves to be an excellent marksmen.
- Apollo, during his stand-off with Red-Eye.
- Sacrificial Lion: Poor Bootes.
- Space Western: Apollo lands on a planet were people dress like typical movie cowboys and even a Cylon rides around on a horse.
- Whole Plot Reference: to Shane.