In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Roy Greenhilt, God of the Struggle Between Good and Order as a Demigod in the Hall of Heroic Outlooks (House of Heroism)
- Elan, God of Wandering Minstrels as a Demigod in the Hall of Fantastical Jobs (House of Jobs and Profession)
- Varsuuvius, God/dess of Effeminate Elves (V) as an Intermediate God/dess in the Hall of Humanoids (House of Otherness)
- Durkon Thundershield, God of Token Religious Teammates as an Intermediate God in the Halls of Friends and Companions (House of Friendship) and People of Faith (House of Religion and Faith)
- Xykon, God of Proud Villainy as a Greater God in the Hall of Villainous Reputation (House of Villainy)
- Redcloak, God of Sunk Cost Reasoning as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Extrovert Flaws (House of Personality)
- General Tarquin, God of Unpreventable Initial Villain Triumph (Tarquin) as a Demigod in the Halls of Villainous Success and Failure (House of Villainy) and Narrative Actions (House of Narrative)
- Haley Starshine, Divine Miser Advisor of the Pantheon as a Demigoddess in the Hall of Economic Mindsets (House of Commerce)
- The Monster in the Darkness, God of Monster Delay as a Greater God in the Hall of Character Actions (House of Characterization)
- Miko Miyazaki, Goddess of Lawful Stupidity (Samurai of the Sapphire Guard, Loyal Vassal of Lord Shojo, Daughter of Eyko, and Paladin of the Twelve Gods of the South, Ethnocentric Bitch), as a Demigoddess in the Hall of Tainted Law (House of Law and Justice)
