In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Sherlock Holmes, God of Deductive Reasoning (The Consulting Detective, Sigerson, Holmes, Sherringford), as a Demigod under Analysis & Records (House of Knowledge).
- Dr. John H. Watson, God of Exposition Requesters (The Scourge of Three Continents), as a Quasideity under Character Roles (House of Characterization).
- Professor James Moriarty, God of Criminal Masterminds (The Napoleon of Crime, Jim, Richard Brook, the Storyteller, Jamie Moriaty) , as a member of the Criminal Triad in the House of Crime.
- Irene Adler, The Goddess Who Was Promoted to Love Interest (The Woman, Jamie Moriaty) as a Quasideity under Love Interests (House of Love)
- Inspector G. Lestrade, God of Police Officers Aided By Great Detectives (Giles, Greg, Gareth, Gordon, Sholto, Gavin, Graham, Geoff, Giles) as a Quasideity under Officers (House of Justice).