In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Mordecai and Rigby, Godly Attractors of the Strange (Mordecool, Mordo, Mad Man Mordo, Mordy, Riggs, Rig-Bone, Mysterious Mr. R, Trash Boat, Mordecai and the Rigbys) as Demigods under Mentalism Other (House of Mentalism).
- Benson, God of Visible Anger (Death Dragon, the Fifth Disc Master) as a Demigod under Anger (House of Emotion).
- Skips, The God Who's Seen It All (Walks) as a Lesser God under Sources of Information (House of Knowledge).
- Pops Maellard, God of Alleged Bosses (The Naive Man from Lolliland, Marvolo the Wizard, Mega Kranus, Chosen One, The Embodiment of Pure Good as a Demigod under Authority Figures (House of Leadership)
- Death, Bargainer of Souls through Competition as an Intermediate God under Life/Death Manipulators (House of Life and Death).
- Randall Ross, God of Time Portals as a Greater God under Time Travelling (House of Time and Space).
- Quillgin's Box can be found in Treasures under Magical Artifacts.