In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Homestar Runner, The Ditzy God (Homeslice, Kevin DuBrow, Mr. Dee Williams, The Deckeman, Homestarrunner.com, Lionel Richie) as an Intermediate God under Mindsets (House of Knowledge).
- Strong Bad, God of Reading Fan Mail Beyond the Fourth Wall (Strong Bad: Stong Band, Professor Tor Coolguy, Tip Tappers, Vance Mudgeman, Cara Carabowditbowdit, Dr. Marvin Rubdown, The Leg, Dangeresque) as an Intermediate God under Metafiction (House of Narrative).
- Marzipan, Self-Proclaimed Official Goddess of Political Correctness (Marzy, Fox's mother) as a Lesser Goddess under Order & Chaos (House of Philosophy).
- Ye Flask can be found among the Treasures.