In the Trope Pantheon, the following were chosen:
3D Era
- Claude, God of Silent Protagonists (Fido, Handyman, Snake Without a Tongue) as a Lesser God in the Halls of Protagonists (House of Characterization) and Voices (House of Quirks)
- Donald Love, God of Unknown Fates (Don, D, DL) as a Demigod in the Hall of Continuities (House of Media and Connectivity)
- Tommy Vercetti, God of Hawaiian Shirts (The Harwood Butcher) as a Demigod in the Hall of Clothing Style (House of Costumes)
- Carl Johnson, God of Customizable Player Characters (CJ) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Game Characters (House of Gaming)
- Melvin Harris, God of Sympathetic Villain Deaths (Big Smoke, El Grando Smokio) as a Demigod in the Halls of Death Archetypes (House of Death and Postmortem) and Anti-Villains (House of Ambiguity)
- Officers Frank Tenpenny and Edward "Eddie" Pulaski, Unholy Duo of Corrupt Police Officers (Community Resources Against Street Hoodlums (C.R.A.S.H. for short) | Tenpenny: Officer Ben Ten) as Demigods in the Hall of Tainted Law (House of Law and Justice)
HD Era
- Niko Bellic, God of Traumatic War Experience (Nikolai, Nicky, Jimmy, NB, Money, Niks, Mr. Mention) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Soldiers and Warriors (House of Military and Warfare)
- Roman Bellic, God of Immigrant Patriotism (Rom, The Janitor, Fatty Roman, Chubby Man) as a Demigod in the Hall of Cultural Values (House of Cultures)
- Dimitri Rascalov, God of Opportunistic Bastards (Dima, Dmitri) as a Demigod and member of the Royal Flush Guardians of the House of Luck and Fortune.
- Edward Low, God of Attacking Someone More Dangerous (Eddie Low, Eddie, Ed, Filth Slayer, No-name killer, Keep-Fit Killer, Head Hunter) as a Demigod in the Hall of Criminal Punishment (House of Crime and Transgressions)
- Luis Fernando Lopez, God of Bouncers (L, Lou, Louis, Double L, Little Louie, Louie, Louise, Mr. Big Shot, Captain Downtown, Lou Lou, Spaniard) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Combat Occupations (House of Jobs and Profession)
- Huang Lee, Divine Saint of Chinese Mobsters (Adonis, Rich kid, Oscar, Mr. 'Know it all', Mr. 'Junior Triad of the year', China boy, Mr. speed-date) as a Demigod in the Halls of Nationalities (House of Cultures) and Organized Crime (House of Crime and Transgressions)
- Michael De Santa, Trevor Philips and Franklin Clinton, Trio of Multiple Playable Characters as Lesser Gods in the Hall of Game Characters (House of Gaming)
