In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
Strongest Team
- Lucy Heartfilia, Goddess of Magical Battle Helpers (Princess) as a Lesser Goddess in the Hall of Support Magic (House of Magic and Sorcery)
- Gray Fullbuster, The Always Shirtless God as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Fanservice Attires (House of Costumes)
- Erza Scarlet, Goddess of Hyperspace Wardrobes (Titania, Armor Girl) as an Intermediate Goddess in the Hall of Combat Clothing (House of Costumes)
- Wendy Marvell, Goddess of Young Mages (Sky Sorceress, Goddess) as a Lesser Goddess in the Halls of Child Archetypes (House of Childhood and Adolescence) and Magic Archetypes (House of Magic and Sorcery)
Sirius Team
- Makarov Dreyar, The Short and Elderly God (Titan, The 3rd, 6th, 8th master of Fairy Tail, Gramps) an Intermediate God in the Hall of Body Sizes (House of Shape)
- Cana Alberona, Goddess of Hard Drinking Party Girls as a Lesser Goddess in the Hall of Alcohol (House of Food)
- Levy McGarden, Goddess of Semantic-Based Powers as an Intermediate Goddess in the Hall of Power Archetypes (House of Power and Abilities)
- Juvia Lockser, Goddess of Love at First Sight (Juvia of The Deep, Rain Woman, Juvia of the Great Sea) as an Intermediate Goddess in the Hall of Romantic Interest (House of Love and Affection)
- Gildarts Clive, God of Ignoring Doors (Ace of Fairy Tail, That Old Guy, Gildarts of the West) as a Greater God in the Hall of Tics (House of Quirks)
- Mavis Vermillion, Goddess of Breaking Curses (Fairy Tactician, Fairy Heart) as an Intermediate Goddess in the Hall of Magic Mixed (House of Magic and Sorcery)
Other Guilds
- Jellal Fernandes, God of Cartesian Karma (Siegrain, Mystogan) as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Karma (House of Luck and Fortune)
Villains
- Zeref, Creator of Eldritch Tomes (The Black Wizard, The Killing Mage, Emperor Spriggan, Zeref Dragneel) as a Greater God in the Hall of Magical Items (House of Magic and Sorcery)
- Acnologia, God of Hating The Species He Was (Dragon King, Black Dragon of the Apocalypse, Darkwing Acnologia) as a Greater God in the Hall of Self-Hatred (House of Hatred and Rancor)
- Mard Geer Tartaros, God of Those Who Deem Humanity Insignificant (Underworld King, King of Hades, Absolute Demon) as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Contempt (House of Hatred and Rancor)
- Spriggan 12Members , Deities of Antagonist Abilities (Shields of Spriggan | August: Wizard King, Disaster, Calamity, Grandpa, General of the Spriggan 12 | Irene: Scarlet Despair, Scarlet Scourge, Queen of Dragons, The Sage Dragon, Lady Irene, "Wendy Belserion", Leader of the Irene Squad | Larcade: White Dragneel | Invel: Winter General, Chief of Staff | Brandish: Nation Destroyer, Country Demolisher, Leader of Brandish Squad | DiMaria: Warrior Queen, Leader of DiMaria Squad | Neinhart: Leader of Neinhart Squad | Bloodman: Grim Reaper | Ajeel: Desert King, Leader of Ajeel Squad | Wall: Judge, Leader of Wall Squad | Jacob: Assassin | God: Eight-Dragon, Hybrid Theory) as Greater Gods in the Hall of Villainous Powers (House of Villainy).
