In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Buffy Summers, Goddess of Vampire Hunters (Buffy the Vampire Slayer, The First Goddess of the Trope Pantheons) as a Lesser Goddess in the Hall of Hunters (House of Profession)
- Willow Rosenberg, Goddess of Lame Redheads (Will, Red, The Slayer's Hex Mistress, Rosenberg the Enchantress, Supreme Witch of Terra) as a Lesser Goddess in the Hall of Hair Color (House of Colours).
- Alexander LaVelle "Xander" Harris, the God with Dangerous Suitors (Sergeant Fury, Xan) as a Demigod in the Hall of Love Other (House of Love).
- Liam, God of Hardened Heroes (Angelus, Angel, The Scourge of Europe, The Vampire with a Soul) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Heroic Attitude (House of Heroism).
- William Pratt, God of Embracing One's Goodness (Spike, Your Friendly Neighborhood Vampire, William the Bloody) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Alignment Changes (House of Ambiguity).
- Richard Wilkins III, God of Values-Upholding Villains (The Mayor, Mayor Wilkins, The Founder of Sunnydale, Olvikan) as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Motivations For Evil (House of Villains)