Follow TV Tropes

This is based on opinion. Please don't list it on a work's trope example list.


Nightmare Fuel / The Strangers: Prey at Night

Go To
  • The intro where Dollface and Pin-Up Girl stalk Uncle Marv and his wife before killing them off-screen.
  • The kids finding their aunt and uncle's disfigured corpses.
  • In a way, Dollface being unmasked comes off as super creepy. Just seeing this otherwise normal young woman turning out to be a remorseless monster that murdered someone's mother in front of them in unsettling.
  • This scene:
    Kinsey: Leave us alone!
    Pin-Up Girl: *appears right next to her* But we've just started.
    • It's actually a lot more terrifying that aside from Dollface, it's rare to hear Pin-Up Girl speak, especially in regards to the first film.
  • The ending, which is either a product of Kinsey's paranoia, or a hint that the nightmare may not actually be over.
    • Or considering all three of the Strangers died (Pin-Up Girl being stabbed to death by Luke, Dollface being shot in the head, and The Man in the Mask set on fire and getting his neck snapped with a baseball bat), it's possible Kinsey is completely scarred from her experience and her mind is making her believe that Dollface has returned.
    • Advertisement:
    • The Alternative ending, while not too scary, still adds punch: It plays off like the original, except Kinsey opens the door and sees a bloody smiley painted on the door...only for the lights in the hallway to slowly go out, before the lights in the room go out, causing her to scream.

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: