Follow TV Tropes

Following

Nice Job Breaking It Hero / Marvel Cinematic Universe

Go To

Bruce: Tony, maybe this might not be the time...
Tony: Really? That's it? You just roll over and show your belly, every time somebody snarls?
Bruce: Only when I've created a murder-bot.
— Tony Stark and Bruce Banner on creating Ultron, Avengers: Age of Ultron

As brought up in Captain America: Civil War, superheroes, individually or as in a group, tend to directly or indirectly cause an amount of the conflict they themselves have to fix later on. This can be attributed to toying with things they don't understand to not sticking around to personally supervise or help with the clean up.

Advertisement:

Spoiler Warning: lots of unmarked spoilers below, with some of them being It Was His Sled by this point.

Major Characters.

These characters end up breaking a lot of things, due to 1) the scale of the thing (such as Odin Banishing Thor) and/or 2) Frequently causing little things over time, that build up to something big.

Due to the interconnections of the franchise, many things in one work can spill into others.

T'Chaka

  • Everything that happened in Black Panther could be blamed on King T'Chaka. When confronting his brother N'Jobu over stolen Vibranium, T'Chaka killed him to protect Zuri and abandoned N'Jobu's son in the slums of Oakland to preserve the secrecy of Wakanda. Said child would grow up to become the super-terrorist Killmonger who would start a civil war in Wakanda to avenge the death of his father.

Odin Borson

  • Odin's banishing of Thor helps show Nick Fury that the Earth is not ready to engage the galaxy, helping him become more paranoid, leading to many of Fury's experiments, including the Phase II experiments to draw enough energy from the Tesseract to create weapons of mass destruction, which drew the attention of Thanos and Loki.
  • Advertisement:
  • Long agonote , Odin banished his daughter Hela to an unknown dimension; after his death, because he had never told anyone else alive about Hela, she was able to escape and conquer Asgard, forcing Thor to destroy his own kingdom to stop his sister.
  • Odin's biggest mistake was how he treated Loki. By favoring Thor over Loki, lying to Loki his entire life, and letting the boys grow up thinking that Frost Giants were irredeemable monsters, Odin positioned Loki to have a psychotic break once he learned the truth — which leads to Loki desperately trying to prove he's a worthy son who's loyal to Asgard while decrying any link to the "monsters," even if that means tricking and murdering his birth father Laufey, sending the Destroyer against Thor, and trying to destroy all the Frost Giants for good. Loki's actions in The Avengers likewise stem back to Odin's bad parenting choices.note 
Advertisement:

Nick Fury

  • Nick Fury's experiments -
    • Literally opened the door for Loki and others, saying that the Earth was ready for interstellar war.
      • This also causes power shifts in areas like Hell's Kitchen, leading to the rise of The Kingpin.
    • Him forming the Avengers to fight for Earth, enables Earth to defend itself, but also makes it interesting to Thanos, a galactic conqueror.
    • In Spider-Man: Far From Home: he leaves the Earth and has a pair of well-meaning but under-qualified Skrulls pretend to be him and Maria Hill. Talos and Soren have no idea how to handle the crisis that unfolds, don't know how to contact any superheroes besides Spider-Man, and buy Mysterio's lies wholesale until it's nearly too late, leading to Mysterio's Frame-Up of Spider-Man and revealing his identity as Peter Parker.

Thor Odinson

  • Giving Malekith the Aether might have been the only way to stop him (though, let it be said, he was warned by his father, grieving and bloodthirsty as he was), but in doing so:
    • Helped put Loki in charge of Asgard (again).
    • Forces Agent Coulson (noticing a pattern?) to do a cleanup crew in London.
  • Perhaps his biggest one was not killing Thanos immediately out of vengeance for the deaths of many Asgardians, Loki and Heimdall included, and stopping to gloat, allowing Thanos to cause the Decimation.

Steve Rogers

  • Captain America bringing down S.H.I.E.L.D. due to HYDRA infestation, also:
    • Put Agent Coulson's team through much difficulty, making fugitives from the law.
    • All the loyal SHIELD agents who survived the Hydra purge are now pariahs and wanted as terrorists, because governments don't discern between the two.
    • As part of the Cap's plan to bring down HYDRA, Black Widow leaked all of HYDRA's files onto the internet. Helmut Zemo was able to find valuable secrets among the documents, which enabled him to enact his Roaring Rampage of Revenge against the Avengers.
  • Steve Rogers' standing up for Bucky Barnes divided the Avengers worse than ever before, effectively making most of the team fugitives as well. His actions in Romania because of this likely killed or seriously injured several people and he nearly kills Tony in Siberia.
    • By withholding the truth about Howard and Maria Stark's murders for over two years, Steve destroys all trust that Tony ever placed in him and ruins their friendship.
  • It's the fault of the whole team, not just Cap, but the "time heist" in Avengers: Endgame very nearly gave Thanos everything he wanted. The Avengers travel back in time to recover the infinity stones from earlier in their timelines, in order to undo the snap. It all goes off without a hitch, until a past Thanos from 2014 (the year the events of Guardians of the Galaxy took place) discovers the time-traveling Avengers, and captures the present incarnation of Nebula, allowing him to travel back to the present, where the Avengers have already assembled an Infinity Gauntlet for him from Iron Man's armor, essentially stopping just short of gift-wrapping it. Even worse, when this Thanos learns to what lengths the Avengers have gone to in order to undo the snap, he realizes that leaving half of the universe alive was a mistake because the half that remained would always remember what they lost and resent Thanos for it. As a result, Thanos resolves to use the gauntlet to destroy the ENTIRE universe this time, and create a new one where everyone worships him. That's right, Endgame is the movie where the Avengers not only turn Thanos into an Omnicidal Maniac, but also nearly give him all the tools he needs to put his beliefs into action!note 

Tony Stark

  • Iron Man films:
    • In Iron Man, Iron Man unintentionally causes the destruction of an Air Force F-22 that attempted to intercept him (before they knew he was a good guy). In his defense, he made sure that the pilot's ejection suit worked properly.
    • Tony Stark revealing himself as Iron Man in Iron Man allows Ivan Vanko to come after him directly in Iron Man 2 in revenge for the transgressions of Howard Stark against Anton Vanko, with all the incidental casualties that may have caused.
    • Similarly, in Iron Man 3, calling out the Mandarin on live television (giving the terrorist his home address and daring him to make a move) means his Malibu house gets bombed, almost killing him and Pepper Potts.
  • Tony, under the influence of Wanda's vision and with the help of Bruce Banner, used the Mind Stone in order to create Ultron - an AI which should've ensured the survival of Earth. Then Ultron turned against the Avengers.
    • Captain America: Civil War added another layer to that one: the destruction of Sokovia caused numerous casualties, among them was the family of Helmut Zemo, whose Roaring Rampage of Revenge caused the events of the movie.
    • Spider-Man: Far From Home: Tony Stark taking the credit for one of his technicians' virtual-reality projects, giving it a demeaning name and then firing the guy means technician Quentin Beck becomes Mysterio, the guy who almost destroys London and outs Spider-Man's identity while also using a Frame-Up to turn him into a Hero with Bad Publicity. In fact, Mysterio's entire crew are ex-Stark Industries employees (one of whom was the man on the receiving end of Obadiah Stane's "box of scraps" rant) who feel slighted.
      • However, Quentin's story should be taken with a grain of salt for three reasons: 1) he works for Stark Industries, meaning that every project he works on is Stark Industries' property and, by extension, Tony's, 2) Tony himself admits that the name he gives to that project is a shitty one that had to be changed and 3) Quentin mentioned that everyone laughed at the name but, in truth, Captain America: Civil War shows that the audience never actually laughed. Quentin admits he was officially fired for being "unstable", which seems fairly accurate.

Wanda Maximoff

  • Her lack of control over her powers in Civil War causes the last incident that help the Sokovia Accords get sanctioned. After Crossbones detonates a bomb in an area full of civilians, she, while trying to save the people near the explosion, accidentally throws the blast into a building full of people, causing a lot more casualties than it initially would have.

Peter Quill

  • In Avengers: Infinity War, Iron Man, Doctor Strange, and Peter come up with a plan to ambush Thanos and get the Infinity Gauntlet away from him, ending the threat he poses. The plan is going off without a hitch when Peter discovers that Thanos murdered Gamora and, instead of helping the others, he instead angrily strikes Thanos. This forces Iron Man to stop trying to remove the gauntlet and causes Thanos to snap out of the trance Mantis put him in. Spider-Man had just succeeded in getting the gauntlet off of Thanos's hand but him waking up when he did meant that he was able to reclaim it. Thanos was then able to get the Time Stone from Doctor Strange, then go to Earth to get the Mind Stone from Vision and, with all six stones, kill half the universe.

Peter Parker

  • Spider-Man: Homecoming: This is pretty much all Peter does. The entire movie is Peter trying to be a hero, botching it, then later is forced to neglect his normal responsibilities as Peter in order to clean up the mess he made as Spiderman, further botching it, and repeat, until he is able to finally apprehend Vulture.
  • Spider-Man: Far From Home:
    • Peter hands the E.D.I.T.H. glasses to Quentin Beck, considering him a better choice for "the next Tony Stark". Less than a minute after Peter leaves, it turns out that Mysterio was Evil All Along and was only faking his friendship with Peter to get access to E.D.I.T.H. and use it to cause, then "stop" a catastrophe in London so people will consider him a hero.
    • To his credit, Peter goes to a trusted adult to confide in once he has more information - unfortunately, said trusted adult is just another one of Mysterio's tricks, Mysterio going out of his way to make it look like Nick Fury shot him as part of the trick, and he gives Beck the information he needs to go after MJ, Ned, and Betty.
    • More humorously, his Building Swing date with MJ is a wreck. From his super-powered perspective, swinging above the NYC skyline is a fun adrenaline rush; for her, it's downright terrifying.

Minor Characters

Unlike the above, the people mentioned here have a lot smaller breakings, due to smaller scale, intent or frequency.

  • Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.:
    • In the penultimate episode of season 1, Fitz - knowing that he and Simmons are about to be executed regardless of what they do - uses an EMP pulse to disable The Clairvoyant's life support system, nearly killing him. Unfortunately, this leaves Raina to inject her dying leader with an unstable, untested cocktail of drugs she was halfway through preparing for him... which makes him super-strong and extremely insane.
    • In the season 2 premiere, we learn that Simmons left S.H.I.E.L.D. because she thought Fitz's recovery from the brain damage he sustained would progress better if he didn't become dependent on her. Unfortunately, this backfires hard: Fitz is literally unable to cope with her leaving, having a complete breakdown that ends with him hallucinating a version of Simmons that he relies on for companionship, support and assistance. Oh, and the effects of his brain damage - already more severe than he realizes - are getting worse as well, possibly because of his breakdown, possibly because Simmons was also his medic and there doesn't seem to be anyone else working towards his recovery. This is later subverted when it turns out Simmons was actually infiltrating HYDRA and Coulson did not want to risk revealing this information to anyone else.
    • In the mid-season finale of season 3, Coulson defeats Ward, the HYDRA agent who betrayed Coulson and his team, became a major adversary of Coulson's, killed numerous S.H.I.E.L.D. agents, tortured and seriously injured Bobbi, tried to have May's ex-husband Dr. Garner aka Lash assassinated, and murdered Rosalind Price, the woman Coulson was in love with. Faced with the option of abandoning him to an almost certain death on a barren planet or killing him right then and there, he chooses the latter. This allows Hive, an Inhuman so dangerous, his own kind banished him to another planet, to assimilate Ward's corpse and return to Earth, as well as accomplishing HYDRA's primary objective of bringing Hive back.
  • Jessica Jones (2015):
    • Jessica Jones tries very hard to ensure Kilgrave is arrested and tried to allow Hope to get exonerated. In doing so, due to Kilgrave's powers and connections, many people end up dead or their lives shattered, forcing her to have to let him get ahold of her so she can close enough to kill him herself. She does come out better for it, thanks to being exonerated in court by Jeri Hogarth, but had she killed him from the outset, she and Hope would have been in jail, but a lot of innocent lives would not have been taken in the process.
Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report