Follow TV Tropes

Following

Incorrect Animal Noise

Go To

All owls hoot, all big cats roar, all bears growl the same way, all rodents (and rodent-looking animals) squeak, all monkeys hoot and screech like chimpanzees, and all birds of prey scream like the red-tailed hawk (because a bald eagle's cry MUST be awesome). Except, in real life, they don't.

Animals have a variety of noises and even relatively closely related animals can sound completely different from one another. This applies even to animals within the same species—certain tiny dog breeds have deep barks because they're either sized-down versions of large dogs or they were bred for their bark (for example, beagles).

Advertisement:

This is often due to mixing up species. Animals who look similar or belong in the same general family are assumed to sound alike, when in reality they don't. Common examples include foxes, wolves and hyenas sounding like dogs, all big cats sounding like tigers, all seabirds sounding like herring gulls, zebras sounding like horses, and penguins sounding like ducks. Special mention must go to frogs. Only one type of frog goes "ribbit", the Pacific tree frog. It lives in Hollywood. Go figure.

This trope often occurs due to Reality Is Unrealistic. An animal's real cry might not sound "powerful enough", so they're replaced with a "cooler" or "more appropriate" sounding cry. This is why lions are often given tiger roars and bald eagles are often given the cries of red-tailed hawks, and giving them their correct respective cries may be jarring for those conditioned to hear the replacements.

Advertisement:

Animals making the wrong noises isn't specific to fictional works. Even some educational documentaries will re-dub animals' voices or add in incorrect noises because viewers expect animals to sound a certain way.

Sub-Trope to Noisy Nature and Artistic License – Biology. Comedic, intentional examples go under Silly Animal Sound. Compare Misplaced Wildlife, with which this often overlaps — not only is the animal making the wrong noise, but it's in the wrong place, as well — along with its subtrope Jungles Sound Like Kookaburras. Related to The Coconut Effect.


Advertisement:

Examples:

    open/close all folders 

    Advertising 
  • In the "Green Sense" commercial, a starling's call is overdubbed with the far cuter, far less cacophonic robin's song.
  • In one Axe hair gel commercial, a man (using a different hair gel) impales fish on his hair while cliff diving and is attacked by a seagull screeching like a hawk.

     Anime & Manga 
  • In Azur Lane The Animation, Enterprise's bald eagle screams like a red-tailed hawk.

     Films — Animation 
  • The Lion King:
    • The franchise as a whole almost never uses lion snarls. The lions use tiger snarls instead. Actual lion roars are only used as howls of pain.
    • Hyenas in The Lion King (1994) often make dog noises, with the exception of the hooting laughter of the spotted hyena. Despite their physical resemblance to canines, hyenas are actually closer related to cats than dogs.
    • Lion characters purr in The Lion King II: Simba's Pride. Lions can't purr. To boot, they used leopard snarls almost exclusively.
  • The Magic Voyage. A shark who roars like a cougar is just icing on the WTF Cake that is this animated feature.
  • The Rugrats Movie features a wolf whose growls sound more like some sort of big cat than a wolf.
  • The mythical Golden Herons in Kubo and the Two Strings are voiced by the Common Loon.
  • Tarzan:
    • The gorillas all make chimpanzee sounds. In reality, gorillas grunt, scream, belch and (oddly enough) purr, but they don't 'pant-hoot' like chimps. Granted, Kerchak does make gravely grunts, snorts and roars, which are at least semi-realistic.
    • Alongside the cliched use of cougar sounds on leopards and jaguars and the real leopard snarls, Sabor also sounded off with tiger snarls.
  • The Cossack cats in An American Tail snarl and growl like leopards. Justified because they are seen from the perspective of mice, to whom a domestic cat is as dangerous as a big cat would be to a human. Other felines in the movie, however, are capable of speech.
  • Finding Nemo:
    • Finding Nemo has a roaring barracuda and a screeching anglerfish. Given their respective scenes are particularly heavy on Nightmare Fuel, this is most likely a case of Rule of Scary. The giant squid from Finding Dory also utters a few guttural growls and snarls.
    • Speaking of roaring barracudas, a barracuda seen briefly during Tip and Dash's song in The Little Mermaid II: Return to the Sea roars like a grizzly bear.
  • In Dumbo, a striped hyena laughs (which only spotted hyenas do in real life) and a gorilla produces a roar similar to Tarzan's yell. Although the striped hyena is usually silent, they are capable of laughing. Unlike the loud giggles of the spotted hyena, the striped hyena's laugh sounds more like a high pitch chatter.

    Films — Live Action 
  • The swan in Hot Fuzz honks like a goose. The common white swan is more properly known as the "Mute Swan"; it is capable of making some sounds, usually hissing at predators (or people who get too close), but not honking.
  • Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban: Harry, Ron, Neville, and Seamus eat magical sweets that cause them to make sounds. Ron eats a lion roar sweet, but instead makes a leopard snarl.
  • The Chronicles of Narnia: Aslan the lion's roars are instead the throaty growls of a tiger and a leopard. It's downplayed since there were a few lion roars and snarls occasionally edited in.
  • The giant mutant ants in Them! are quite noisy for creatures without vocal cords. The sounds are actually Spring Peepers (small frogs found in the eastern USA).
  • All fictional lizards (the cute ones, at least) seem to make the same weird nasal growling noise (which comes from, of all things, a baby jaguar). The trailer for Nim's Island featured an impossibly talkative bearded dragon. They only hiss — and they'll do that only if you try to give them a bath.
  • African elephants frequently use recordings of their Asian counterparts in film. This is likely due to the fact that fewer African elephant recordings exist in public domain sound effects libraries (helped by the fact that the two genera sound similar enough anyway that only an expert is likely to notice the difference).
  • A documentary on big cats gave a cheetah a fierce roar. When they fail to point out that cheetahs do not roar (they chirp!), one can turn off the TV and take refuge in the encyclopedia.
  • The most hilarious recent example can be heard in this trailer for Oceans. Err, those aren't baby ducklings...
  • The roaring shark comes from good old Jaws: The Revenge. It certainly doesn't help that the roar sounds suspiciously like Jerry's roar from a Tom and Jerry sketch either. Like Bruce IV's famous bellowing in Jaws: The Revenge, Brucette in Jaws 3D growled whenever she opened her mouth (it was a very deep watery sound that you might miss most of the time), and a soft echoing roar is heard when Bruce's decapitated body sinks into the abyss at the end of Jaws (though that's merely symbolic, and was the same roar from Spielberg's earlier film Duel). Sharknado 2: The Second One also had roaring sharks and was likely inspired by this.
  • There's a roaring shark in Shark Attack 3: Megalodon too.
  • Caesar the chimpanzee is heard roaring like a lion in a trailer for Rise of the Planet of the Apes. Did they give him that ability as a test run at the lab, before giving him a human-level intellect?
  • In Conan the Barbarian, the vulture that tries to eat Conan when he's nailed to the Tree of Woe sounds like some type of seagull, which is doubly wrong because Conan is biting its neck and it shouldn't be able to vocalize at all.
  • The ferrets in The Beastmaster make some very un-ferret like sounds. Real ferrets make very little sound most of the time, but often hiss, grunt, and make a sort of chortling sound when playing.
  • Kimble's ferret in Kindergarten Cop similarly makes lots of squeaking, chittering noises that ferrets don't really produce.
  • A roaring giant squid in the adaptation of Peter Benchley's The Beast. The squid actually made a distorted shriek/screech, like a giant mechanical eagle (or red-tailed hawk).
  • In Mel Gibson’s Apocalypto, at the beginning of the film a tapir is shown except it squeals like a pig. In reality, tapirs make chuffing noises or high-pitched mouse-like squeaks instead of squealing like that.
  • When they're not howling, the wolves in Beauty and the Beast (2017) very noticeably roar like leopards.

     Live-Action TV 
  • In Skippy the Bush Kangaroo, Skippy's trademark 'tchk tchk tchk' noise was entirely fictional. Kangaroos make no such sounds.
  • Flipper's famous chatter? That's a sped-up kookaburra.
  • The Colbert Report has an opening sequence has a red, white, and blue bald eagle making a red-tailed hawk's cry. The show being what it is, it's either intentional or would be if they knew.
  • Kamen Rider Zi-O: A T-Rex goes after Sougo when he walks out of Time Majin in the Mesozoic era and trumpets like an elephant. While we can't know what T-Rex sounded like, it definitely was not the sound of an angry pachyderm.

    Radio 
  • Long-running soap opera The Archers frequently got caught out this way. It took the BBC a long time to realise that in a drama about farmers, they better had get the sound effects absolutely right. Merely ordering up "a sheep" or "a cow" from the BBC sound effects department wasn't going to cut it, not with a professionally aware audience. Farmers and shepherds would write in and complain - pointing out that if Dan Archer was out in the fields in February lambing a ewe, why then was the sheep he was tending to not making the distinctive noises of a ewe in labour? And for a supposedly newborn lamb, why was its bleating sounding like an eight-month old lamb in the fields? Oh, and that wasn't a cow Walter Gabriel was tending, you do realise you were playing a recording of a bull in heat just about to service a heifer? And them chickens what Clarrie Grundy was feeding, they weren't Rhode Island Reds at all, they was Belgian Red Wattles, completely distinctive clucks. The BBC gave in, and sent people out to farms with tape recorders to talk to thep professionals and to get some really accurate animal sounds.

     Video Games 
  • Averting this trope is discussed in Where in Time Is Carmen Sandiego? (1997): The player can give Anne Tikwitee a bird whistle that corresponds to a bald eagle. What plays isn't the (incorrect) high pitched screech many people expect — it's actually the (correct) eagle chirp. Anne then says "Whoa! For a big bird that's one small call!"
  • Early on in Deadly Premonition, a cutscene shows squirrels that sound like chimpanzees.
  • Impressive Title has a giant manta ray boss known as the Monster Ray, which occasionally emits a loud cacophonous sound that many players have likened to a cow's "moo" note  despite the fact that rays don't have vocal cords.
  • A very strange example, as it swaps out an awesome-sounding call for a rather cuter one: in The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess, Wolf Link gives coyote howls instead of wolf howls. This is probably because a coyote's howl sounds more musical for the Ocarina of Time-style howling melody sections.
  • The Bloody Roar series is guilty as charged with most of the characters' animal forms, though the most glaring example would be Yugo, the roaring wolf.
  • The Barn Owl (famous for being silent fliers) in Fly Like a Bird makes sound as its wings flap.
  • During the dramatic opening of Final Fantasy IX, there's a close-up of a pigeon crying like a red-tailed hawk.
  • In Ori and the Blind Forest, the Big Bad Ominous Owl Kuro vocalizes with the aforementioned red-tailed hawk call. In the sequel, the Sand Worm in Windtorn Ruins has a stock tiger roar, as does Howl the dire wolf(who never actually howls) at the beginning of the game.
  • In Fate/Grand Order, this is Played for Laughs by Tamamo Cat, who, despite her name, emits barking sounds like a dog in-between mangled Ice-Cream Koan and Pun-filled speech. Then again, her legend thinks she's a fox when she's actually a jackal, and she's a Ninja Pirate Robot Zombie variation of the more serious Tamamo-no-Mae in Fate/EXTRA.
  • Far Cry 3: The cassowaries that appear in this game sound absolutely nothing like cassowaries. Real cassowaries make low, sub-bass booming sounds, almost ape-like hoots and elephant-like grunts.
  • In Super Mario 64, Klepto the Condor's cry is actually the call of a goose.
  • Yakuza 2: The tigers Kiryu faces in a boss battle are bizarrely given leopard and lion recordings as sound effects. This is all but completely averted in the remake; save for one lion roar, all their sound effects are tiger recordings.

     Western Animation 
  • Perry the Platypus from Phineas and Ferb makes a distinctive chirping chatter that is notably his only vocalization. Real-life platypuses make a soft growling purr when agitated (which admittedly sounds somewhat like Perry's noises).
  • In an episode from The Wild Thornberrys, a hungry male lion trying to hunt Eliza briefly gets stuck in a thorn bush and roars like a grizzly bear.
  • The Sovereign from The Venture Bros. makes the typical Red Tailed Hawk call when he turns into an eagle. But then he's a nameless shapeshifter pretending to be David Bowie pretending to be an eagle...
  • The bats that flutter across the screen at the start of the opening credits for Scooby-Doo, Where Are You! all chitter their little heads off. Disturbed bats generally book it without emitting cries that humans can hear, as they're too busy echolocating so they don't run into one another.
  • An in-universe example in Batman: The Animated Series episode "On Leather Wings". Batman (as Bruce Wayne) brings a recording of bat-like sounds to Dr. March, an expert in bats, and claims that the sounds are coming from his chimney. Dr. March later calls and says that the sounds are from brown bats and starlings, probably fighting over a nest. Batman runs the combination through his computer, which states the sounds do not match either species and proving that Dr. March is lying about something.
  • The Lion Guard:
    • In one of the most jarring departures from the films, zebras make horse noises.
    • As usual, hyenas still yelp like dogs.
  • The episode "Britrock" from Jem features a fox that makes dog noises.
  • Played for Laughs in Tom and Jerry where Jerry was capable of making an absolutely horrifying guttural monster roar when he needed to frighten or intimidate Tom. Feast your ears. Hilariously, this same sound effect was apparently also used for the shark in Jaws: The Revenge, making a scene with a roaring shark even more Narmy because to many viewers it was a shark roaring like a cartoon character.
  • Whenever Magilla Gorilla tries to act like a wild gorilla, he produces a Tarzan-esque yell. This is carried over to Magilla's cameo in Scooby-Doo and Guess Who?.
Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report