Follow TV Tropes


Crippling Overspecialization
aka: Crippling Overspecialisation

Go To
Let's hope he never gets jock itch. note 

"It's simple: Overspecialize, and you breed in weakness. It's slow death."
Major Motoko Kusanagi, Ghost in the Shell

Competitive Balance exists so that there is some symmetry between specific advantages and the Necessary Drawback. If someone can hit hard but is easily hurt, they are a Glass Cannon. If they are unstoppably strong but slow-moving, they are a Mighty Glacier. If they are incredibly fast but go down quickly when hit, they are a Fragile Speedster. A crippling overspecialization occurs when an obscenely powerful advantage makes a trade-off that limits how effective it is.

In some Real-Time Strategy games, unit types are often specialized beyond all reason. They often have only one weapon, effective against just one particular kind of enemy, and usually cannot defend themselves at all if their particular weapon is ineffective. The most prominent examples can be seen in this genre: explosives will deal low damage to infantrynote , while Anti-Aircraft cannons can't defend against ground units. This is usually a result of game balance. After all, if tanks are effective enough against other tanks and infantry, then why build anything else? Additionally, units in games are traditionally depicted with only one weapon. A few might have a second gun used for attacking enemy fliers, but that's about it.

Can result from a Tactical Rock–Paper–Scissors design scheme, from intensive Min-Maxing in a character build, or a case of Highly Specific Counterplay. People who do this for Elemental Rock-Paper-Scissors are suffering from Poor, Predictable Rock.

See also Anti-Air, Cumbersome Claws, and Strong Flesh, Weak Steel. Compare to An Adventurer Is You, where this is used to force players to work together. See also Sacrificed Basic Skill for Awesome Training for a characterization equivalent and Single-Task Robot for a robot equivalent. Severely Specialized Store is a comedic variation. Diminishing Returns for Balance is when a game forces this by having a combat build that invests everything into one aspect being less effective than a more well-rounded playstyle.

Don't confuse "having a weakness" or "not being the best at everything" or even "not being quite good enough" as being this trope. Don't be tempted to list something because it failed in some way unless you can point a finger at its crippling specialty! Also don't list something just because it's specialized: as long as the specialization works and is useful, it is not crippling.

The opposites of this trope are The Red Mage, Jack of All Stats, and Master of All. At the other extreme that loops right back is Master of None, where the character has no great specialization... but sucks at everything anyway.



Video Example(s):

Alternative Title(s): Crippling Overspecialisation, Cripplingly Overspecialized


Magneto Versus a Wooden Gun

Mr. Fantastic takes advantage of Magneto by threatening him with a wooden gun, which Magneto's powers are useless against it because they only work on metal.

How well does it match the trope?

4.88 (25 votes)

Example of:

Main / CripplingOverspecialization

Media sources: