Birthday Forever
- Todd trying to make Reggie feel better after her gifts.
- Reggie’s mom apologizing for her bad Birthday.
The Butt Witch Forever
- Todd poring through Reggie’s outdated puberty books. Similar to the bra scene in the premiere, he doesn’t laugh or get grossed out over the specifics. Instead, he displays a healthy curiosity and doesn’t do anything to make Reggie uncomfortable-at least not on purpose.
Esther Forever
- Todd and Reggie officially welcoming Esther into their fold, even asking to sit with her at lunch.
Guy Pleasant Forever
- Todd and his brother’s relationship.
- Todd’s dad giving him a banjo. It’s not any guitar that Todd was coveting, but it’s still the thought that counts.
Dustin Forever:
- Dustin and Reggie working on a new episode of Space Draculas as a podcast.
Mack and Beefhouse Forever
- Mack and Beefhouse's relationship is shown as mature and healthy, with them talking through an argument and supporting each other.
- When they make up after their Butt Witch-induced fight they read their adorably sweet cards to each other, including sentiments like "For you I'd bench press the world" and "You have my heart in a figure four".
The Mall Forever
- Judy and Esther bonding during the shopping trip.
- After initially refusing them, Judy buys Reggie the outrageous red boots she was admiring to wear to the wedding.
School Forever
- Before the trip to Endless, Reggie's teacher tells her to erase her doodling from her locker door (mainly because he didn't want her to get in trouble for defacing school property). At the end of the episode he gives Reggie a whiteboard to hang inside her locker to doodle on instead.
Secrets Forever
- In Reggie's birthday memory: Kathy, realizing that Reggie's entire class skipped her birthday, tries in her own way to comfort Reggie.
- The Endless Residents compliments to the kids’ memories.
Fancy Forever
- Reggie stating that she’s “rich with friendship” as she’s hugging Todd and Esther. Cheesy, but sweet.
Reggie’s Dad Forever
- The gang giving Sadmantha her own place to stay on Endless. Even through she's still saying sad things, she is genuinely touched by the gesture.
Not Twelve Forever
- Big Deal's plan was to disguise himself as Twelve to ruin her reputation, but instead he begins to enjoy the island residents treating him nicely.
- When Big Deal declares his love of The Butt Witch early on in the episode, she notably doesn't utterly shoot him down. Merely saying it's "unfortunate" that he feels that way, with the implication being she wants to spare his feelings.
- The Butt Witch only somewhat grudgingly wishing Big Deal a happy anniversary (of him becoming her minion), after dismissing the idea of celebrating an anniversary at the beginning of the episode.
Locked Out Forever Part 1
- Reggie is visibly smitten when she first lays eyes on Connelly.
Locked Out Forever Part 2
- Reggie getting a pep talk from her art teacher and snapping out of her creative block.
Todd Forever
- Reggie planning Todd’s party. She even gets Brown Roger to be nice to him.
- Todd and Gwen have apparently grown super close.
Together Forever
- When the kids’ hold hands and say they love each other in the fight.
- For Todd’s birthday, Reggie gives him two tickets to one of his favorite bands. She even encourages him to invite Gwen.
