Follow TV Tropes


Headscratchers / [PROTOTYPE 2]

Go To

Folders for preventing spoilers.

    open/close all folders 

     Alex and Dana 
  • Okay, in this game, it's fairly clear Alex and Dana hate each other. Dana thinks Alex is a monster rather than her brother, while Alex releases a virus into Manhattan while she's still there (mirroring the human Alex Mercer, who was far more evil than Blacklight Mercer was at his worst), locks her in a bank vault, and seems to blame her for something that's never explained. I... have an even harder time imagining this happening than Alex's Face–Heel Turn in general. The first part of Alex's Character Development in the first game was starting to actually care about Dana as something other than a source of information. Even when he was still willing to let the rest of the world burn for the sake of his vengeance, he wanted her safe. She was his Morality Pet, and I have a hard time imagining the Mercer from the first game suddenly not caring about her, even if he were to turn evil.
    • Dana outright claims that Alex isn't her brother anymore citing that there was once a young man named Alex who, "played games with her, went skating with her, and would watch scary movies with her", and that the loving brother she once knew is dead now and all there is now is a monster in the image of her brother. Alex claims that all the animosity between them is of her own choosing and that in his new viral form he has risen above such concepts as "life" and "death" and that what has happened to him is a gift, not a curse. Even after all that Alex never kills Dana even though he could crush her like a bug, Dana is still Alex's morality pet as he simply wanted her on his side.
      • What I find most interesting is that he never made her an evolved.
      • Maybe she didn't want to become one, and Mercer didn't want to force his will on her (at least not at that time).
      • Problem with the interpretation that he still cared about her — he released the virus in Manhattan when she was still there. That was likely to kill her no matter what else happens. It's kind of the thing that the original Mercer did that proved he didn't care about her or anyone else. Not to mention that the idea that the virus is a gift is a complete reversal of his stance in the original game, where he characterized himself as "less than human" because of his status as a viral entity — he was sure as hell glad not to really be Alex Mercer once he found out what the real one was like, but he took a dim view on the fact that he was something made to consume and infect and destroy.
      • I for one was shocked at Dana talking so fondly about the original Alex Mercer. It just seemed so jarring since her brother was a violent sociopath who only talked to her because she could provide him with information and had no problem with releasing a deadly virus that he worked on while she was there. I thought that he was supposed to be cold and distant in the past, but Dana makes him out to be the best brother ever. There really doesn't seem to be an explanation beyond "Just go with it".
      • When Dana talks about Alex watching movies, playing games, and whatever else with her, it's possible that she meant they did those things as children. It's also possible that the original Alex Mercer didn't become a terrible, horrible sociopath until later in life - and to be fair, even then he may not have been a complete sociopath, since it was implied in the first game that he had a terrible childhood, and became a scientist for GENTEK to escape from all that, but unfortunately had a huge breakdown and released the virus into the city. To be fair, in the first game, it sounded Dana had a distant relationship with Alex until he needed her, but she herself never found out that Alex was using her for his own ends. This of course is added to by the fact that after Alex was killed, the virus took his place - which Dana never found out about - and saved her life. That alone would probably have earned Alex immense trust, but even disregarding that, it was revealed that Dana had some sort of Big Brother Worship type thing going on with (the original) Alex, and he was a sort of Parental Substitute for her, since neither of them seemed to know their father. Hell, as far as Dana was concerned, Alex was the model of perfection... She never learned about any of his evil deeds, nor that the "real" Alex was dead and replaced by the virus... The only thing she knew was that Alex went crazy in the sequel, released the virus, and decided to turn humanity into a Hive Mind. That all said, while it's true that Alex released the virus in Manhattan while Dana was still around, it seemed like he never intended any harm to come to her. He probably kept a watchful eye on her and made sure neither Blackwatch or his infected bothered her for the most part. The fact that she was alive and uninfected for so long certainly says something.
      • A far more likely explanation than any of the above was that the writers for this game didn't really pay much attention to the previous one. It's not just that the characterization clashes like this; it's that there's not the slightest hint of acknowledgement that the characterization, backstory, and views of the characters we see in Prototype 2 bear no resemblance to the original. Nothing in-game in Prototype 2 suggests that Virus!Alex ever had a shred of humanity, compassion, or humanity to him at any point, or that Human!Alex was ever anything but a paragon of virtue; the most likely explanation was that the writers for 2 were going off of a plot summary of 1 and didn't realize they were getting it wrong.

    Why are Blackwatch helping Gentek experiment on civilians? 
  • Blackwatch was created and tasked with the mission of detecting, containing, and concealing viral outbreaks on US soil, hence their using the Marines as cover in the first game while they worked to contain the virus. Their methods were extreme, but at least they were trying to stop the virus. Yet now they're kidnapping civvies for Brawler chow and have their logo plastered all over the city. Did they forget what they were supposed to be doing? You hear occasionally about a Marine patrol in the Red Zone - after all, that was how Heller got infected - but did someone switch up the roles here?
    • They experimented on Civilians before; IIRC Hope was a pure Blackwatch project, no Gentek involvement, and the only reason Greene was at Gentek's HQ was because Randall handed her over to them. I'll readily grant that in the original, it appeared that Blackwatch and Gentek were slightly less batshit insane than P2, where they seem to have borrowed the Umbrella Corporation's manual for testing biological horrors, but doesn't stop the fact that they did experiment on civilians. Hell, I think in the Web of Intrigue in the first game, Randall rants to a soldier about how to learn to fight an enemy, you actually have to fight them. As for why they're in the forefront, I'm guessing the plotline reason is that somewhere along the line covering up their existence became untenable. A Meta reason would be the game seems to be striving closer to Black and White Morality than the original, so they minimize the number of times Heller interacts with (and therefore fights) Marines trying to save people, and does so by dramatically increasing Blackwatch's presence (and dog-kicking).
      • Original poster here - Blackwatch was in charge of the Hope project, yeah. But after the virus mutated into Redlight (the virus Mercer later turned into Blacklight) and took over Hope, Blackwatch was re-tasked with the mission it had in Prototype 1. Far as I saw Gentek was just supplying the techs. It still makes no sense why they didn't just incinerate Greene and eradicate the virus, but I suppose that was part of that shadowy Illuminati-esque conspiracy that was hinted at in Prototype 1. Blackwatch went from Well-Intentioned Extremist to skipping giddily over the Moral Event Horizon. And it seems Gentek's been recruiting from Aperture Science. Part of this problem seems to be that these groups weren't fleshed out enough in the original, but it still doesn't make sense.

    Why are the Supersoldiers Treated as a New Thing? 
  • So, why exactly are the Orion Project Super Soldiers presented as being a newly developed thing, when Blackwatch had Super Soldiers in the first game over a year ago?
    • I think the implication is that these ones are somehow different (and strong enough to take on Heller's level of power), as shown by how they had "Phase Twos" in development.
    • The Orions are more powerful and dangerous. Its not so much that the idea is new, but that the Orions are much more dangerous than the old version.
    • Really? I could've sworn the original D-Codes were much harder to beat, rather than the suplex fodder that is Orion. Plus they all had inborn viral detectors.
      • I had absolutely no problem killing the D-Codes. Theyw ere slightly more challenging Hunters. The Orions are much harder to deal with.
    • I think they were trying to imply that Heller was stronger on all counts than Mercer. Hence why the "new" Orions are the same strength level approximately but seen as newer and better.
  • So what's with the Orions not being able to detect infected nearby like the original D-Codes? Blackwatch seems to have reloaded their concept of viral detectors, now being unable to be sabotaged so easily. So why not extend the concept to improving Orion awareness?
    • Well, the Orions weren't exactly done. Maybe that part of the Orion Project hadn't been completed yet before they had to start pushing them into battle?
      • Also, keep in mind that Koenig and his team had a hand in the project. Something tells me that giving the Orions the ability to detect the infected probably would not be a very high priority for them.
    • They're also new in the sense that neither Heller nor Guerra is aware that they existed. There may have been rumors of their presence before, but neither of them had encountered the originals, let alone the Orions.
  • There's is also the possibility that since the original tactical application of the super soldier was to detect Blacklight-based organisms while being set up primarily for hand-to-hand combat, it effectively translated to hunting down Alex Mercer as one of the primary purposes of D-Code deployment. In the first outbreak, the most widespread infection was the Redlight strain aka DX-1118A, like Elizabeth Greene and all her hunter pets in their hives. Filtering out Blacklight-based creatures like Alex Mercer of the DX-1118C strain, would give fairly little false positives to the detectors. In the second outbreak, everything is based of Alex's strain. Detectors configured to pick up Alex's signature will pickup everything else; Brawlers, Juggernauts, Flyers, Evolved, and the new wave of regular zombies, even James Heller. Lots of things will show up on the detector's radar, but it most likely would not be Alex Mercer. This means Blackwatch and Gentek's quest to subdue and pacify their number one target since the first game would be less cost-effective using this method.
  • Plus, the D-Codes weren't exactly finished either. In their introductory WoI memory, the scientist protests that they're not ready for deployment, but Randall ignores him.
    • Exactly. Which means that the Orion Phase Ones were a little closer to being finished, or were even a possible front-line model. If they were working off a spiral development program (put each phase into deployment and upgrade them as improvements are made possible) then had Heller not eaten the Phase Two, we probably would have had a bunch of Orion 1.0 and 2.0's chasing us around the city.

     Alex's Face Heel Turn 
Okay, so we PC gamers don't get this for awhile, so I'm not gonna even try to avoid being spoiled, but what's with you-know-who's Face–Heel Turn? Wasn't he at worst an Anti-Hero at the end of the first game?
  • The prequel comic duology, ''The Anchor'', explains that after the end of [PROTOTYPE], Alex travelled the world trying to regain his faith in humanity, only to discover that Humans Are Bastards everywhere he goes. For more extrapolation: He returns to the US and settles in an isolated community, where he finds the first truly nice people he's met - a man and his daughter. Alex helps save them from some mobsters, only to discover that the man is an ex hitman. Alex does what he does to the father, and asks the daughter to come with him, having fallen in love with her. She proves just as self-serving as the rest of humanity, and Alex snaps, eats her too, and decides to Kill All Humans.
    • I'm certain he saw a hundred worse things in Manhattan.
      • While he may have seen worse things in Manhattan, that was kind of the result of the massive self-aware viral infection and the psychotic military force sent in response. In this case, Mercer is encountering ordinary people away from insane crises like the aforementioned.
      • He infiltrates towns under the control of drug barons, enters combat zones and civil wars. And Blackwatch is utterly human. Hope was a "progressive" project that took entire families, infected them, built a town for them and then watched to see which of them would die first and how. If humanity's cruelty is the reason he decided we were worthless, why the heck did it take him that long? Just how slow on the uptake is he supposed to be? (And why does he think the virus is any better? His strain was designed to kill, absorb, copy and infiltrate living beings - in short, it's backstabbing-in-a-beaker. Even Greene's strain saw the lesser Infected being used as resources by the ones higher up on the hierarchy.) At some point, the logic stops being a failure on the character's part and starts being lazy writing.
      • Forget that. Doctor Ragland from the first game worked for Gentek until he had an attack of conscience over their work. So he's willing to forgive someone who worked for an outright evil company that tried to have him killed if they decide it isn't the life for them anymore, but having been a hitman before retiring means you need to die?
      • We don't know what Ragland actually did while at Gentek. all we know is he refused to work on BLACKLIGHT. Gentek might of had some less then evil projects at the time.
    • Let's just pretend this Mercer was a clone. It's better that way.
      • I like this one, it would make sense, Alex is off traveling the world trying to find his own sense of self, GENTEK use what little biomass they found to make an "ZEUS 2.0" said clone is then experimented on, gains none of Alexs' conscience, breaks out and goes greene, because I feel that this version of Alex went alittle too off the rails too fast.
    • I would say that Mercer has an Assimilation Plot not a Kill All Humans motive. If he just wanted to kill everyone, I think he could do it a lot easier than the plan he had here. And I didn't feel it was that out of place really, even without reading the comics.
    • I can understand Mercer viewing the virus as the next step in human evolution. One has to admit that the kind of powers that Alex Mercer possesses are incredible and would be desirable for anyone to want to have. However the problem I have with it is that Mercer was trying to force this evolution using a mass infection that nearly destroyed New York 2 years prior, the same New York that he heroically saved from Gentek erasing it off the map with a nuke. Ideally he should have examined what makes the virus in his body tick and isolate the desirable shape shifting powers he has and remove all the Zombie Apocalypse, Eldritch Abomination stuff about the Blacklight Virus. That is far more sensible than condemning millions of people in New York and billions more if it spreads outside of New York to death and mutation.
  • Even given The Anchor, his methodology really doesn't make any sense. He says that humanity is dying, but he rereleased the virus on purpose, which is causing humanity to die. He says that all of humanity deserves to suffer, but is directly opposed by someone who has a sizable amount of empathy, more than he himself, and knowing that at least Bradley Ragland and his sister Dana were decent people. He says that all of humanity is corrupt, but he practically sought out people to prove this viewpoint, whether repentant or not and blamed humanity for people caring about living before concerning themselves with people who they might not even know. He says that he will end disease... by infecting all of humanity with a disease, and being a walking, talking, Blacklight sample. For these reasons, he decides to cause a Zombie Apocalypse to "force evolution" on the populace.
    • Keep in mind that Alex ate Greene, Randall, and hundreds of Blackwatch troops and scientists. I doubt he is entirely sane or rational at this point.
  • In the first game, upon Alex's realization that he is "not human" and that Alex is "just a role [he] plays", what made him want to connect with humanity like the Anchor comic would seem to suggest? Does it have anything to do with Alex being "something more" despite being "less than human"?
  • Okay, even with the explanations above, I still have a problem with this. For one thing, it's an abrupt and bizarre reversal of his entire character arc for the first game. His entire character development revolved around growing a conscience, learning to care about others, and growing into more of a genuine hero, culminating with his saving Manhattan in what could have been a Heroic Sacrifice if he hadn't proved so resilient. Second, even disregarding the sudden reversal, how does he go from deciding that for all his power, he's a subhuman monster — as a viral entity that exists to feed and infect and destroy — to deciding that the world would be totally better if everyone was like him?
    • I'll tell you why. To make way for James "I am generic revenge-seeking tough guy" Heller. It seems that, in an effort to improve upon the original, they thought that getting rid of the hero was a good idea.
      • This is sort of the crux of the entire argument. Mercer had already gained so much power that he was more or less invincible (to the point where not even trying to Nuke 'em actually killed him). It wasn't about "making him think humanity deserved it" in the case of the comic. It seems more like they simply believed that Alex Mercer could not be improved upon any further to validate a sequel. Not as a fan of one series over the other, but their supposed "rival" series seemed to do well enough at that by disabling some of their main character's more advanced abilities and giving a different, more powerful antagonist to necessitate gaining new powers (in this case, perhaps a better Stealth Consume, the other Mutations you can gain, Biobomb, Pack Leader, Viral Sonar, and Tendrils, among perhaps upgraded vehicles). Apparently in the case of this series, they didn't consider that option, hence what many consider the Sudden Sequel Heel Syndrome.
      • Mercer wasn't invincible, the nuke would have killed him had he not gained enough distance away from the explosion, besides powerful viral entities like the Supreme Hunter are capable of consuming him and enough damage from conventional weapons can still kill him in game play. Besides there is still the threat of PARIAH that would have validated Mercer becoming even more powerful than ever before, the first game had a ton of foreshadowing how if Mercer and PARIAH ever met it, "could be the end of the world." PARIAH could have been like The Beast from inFAMOUS, an overshadowing threat that the protagonist must prepare himself for to save the world, The Beast is foreshadowed in inFAMOUS and then appears in inFAMOUS 2 justifying Cole's increase in powers. For a so-called rival series Prototype didn't follow that model very well. James isn't as invested in the back story and overall story arc of the game as Alex Mercer is.
      • If they felt Mercer was so powerful then what the hell will they do about Heller if they do a third game? Make him evil? Because any other option they go with will have people asking why they didn't do that with Mercer.
      • Heller's got his daughter and apparently wiped out the virus in NYZ. Why would he stick around?
  • Regarding the comic book that elaborated on the time spent between the original Prototype and 2; are we honestly supposed to take the romance he had for a human female seriously? How can Alex Mercer have anything resembling a normal human relationship especially in a romantic sense and spend his life casually with all these powers? Was he expecting the white picket fence life style where he and his love interest would live peacefully, he just gets to settle down and not have to worry about the horrifying implications of what his powers have done to his humanity? I find it silly that he would even think along those lines when he claimed that he had become something, "more than human", and even more silly that his face heel turn is based off of things ending badly with with his love interest, one bad experience ruins his entire perception of humanity that's good writing.
    • Going off of that, wouldn't he have learned his lesson from Karen Parker from the original Mercer and not pursued romance again? This is a man-shaped creature who has developed true empathy...but bases his entire view of humanity on two people and one other separate who are selfish outside of a war zone.
    • I viewed what happened during the Anchor as being what finally pushed Mercer over the edge. It's not that he based his entire view of humanity around what they did. It's just that it was enough to finally cement his already spiteful view of humanity.
    • So Cross didn't matter? Dana didn't matter? Ragland didn't matter? And the virus - his "true" family - wasn't exactly welcoming. Greene told she was his mother, yes, but she smacked him around, kidnapped his sister, and then smacked him around some more. And the Supreme Hunter manipulated and betrayed him as effortlessly as anyone else. Sure, what happened in The Anchor was awful, but it's an incredibly weak justification for the viewpoint "Humans are scum because all of them are out for themselves. I will use the virus to make humanity perfect." Not at least because that viewpoint isn't even properly borne out in his actions. His Evolved betray him and bicker among themselves, his favorite ate him, and despite their otherwise slavish loyalty they don't exactly come across as having "one body, one mind, no suffering." It's just so...inconsistent. Non sequitur. It does not follow. (Especially because he keeps acting like he's still the original Mercer and was changed like Heller, instead of what he really is. No mention is made of that reveal at all.)
    • Cross died long before Mercer got to know anything about him, Ragland isn't mentioned, and Dana no longer considers Mercer to be her brother. The latter of which he locked in a vault instead of killing. So it's not as if Mercer has decided to kill everyone. And about the "One Body, One Mind" thing. It seemed as if that was only going to happen once Mercer spread the virus around the world via Whitelight. One memory stated that Mercer would have been able to control every drop of 'contaminated' Whitelight, even down to it's molecular level.
    • That's the thing. So much isn't mentioned. Why doesn't Dana think Alex is her brother any more? She seemed completely convinced of his good intentions in the first game and he willingly played into her beliefs. What happened to Ragland? The very last we see of him, he was taking care of Dana. This isn't about Mercer wanting to kill everyone, it's about his weird reversal of values over such a strangely petty thing and there is very little examination of the lead-up or aftermath. Just the effect. Alex is just...suddenly villainous, and takes on villainous mannerisms that he never exhibited before. As above troper said, he may as well be a clone or an evil twin.
    • Well, we see Cross turning against Blackwatch because he didn't agree with their plans. He at least had sympathy for civilians and regret over what had happened. He even helped Alex until he was eaten by the Supreme Hunter. Cross was probably the best example for why humanity wasn't hopeless. This guy was an enemy, and tried to kill him several times, but he didn't have the Crush. Kill. Destroy! mentality of Randall. If there is good in an enemy, then humanity can't be all bad. It's not important that Mercer didn't know Cross very long, it's that the man turned against his organization because he thought they had gone too far.
    • Though what strikes me as strange is that Alex would leave Dana in Manhattan. I haven't actually read the comics, but it involves him going on a soul searching trip around the world. And he left Dana, the one person in the world that he truly cared about, in a city with a bunch of Infected, Blackwatch, and Gentek. There's no indication that he helped her get out of the city in Prototype 2, just that he seemed to come back and they had a falling out. There's so much that's left unexplained, though I don't think there's really any amount of explanation that could justify Alex's complete 180.
  • Does it have anything to do with this quote?
    Alex Mercer: "My name is Alex Mercer... They call me a killer, a monster, a terrorist. I'm all of these things."
    • No, not really. Alex was never a good person. We know it, he knows it, everyone knows it. (And Heller is no better; he says so.) Alex is violent, ruthless and bloodthirsty. But he wasn't megalomaniacal, and he did not want the virus to spread even when he found out he was it. Alex was far more of a conflicted Anti-Hero who, to paraphrase V for Vendetta, was born from something monstrous which thus made him a monster than he was the Weskalike he's characterised as in the sequel. He feels guilt for his deeds, he's outright disgusted at Blackwatch for their hypocrisy, he's relieved when he learns he's not human because the human he was once condemned millions to death...he knows he's a bastard, but that doesn't mean he couldn't recognise other bastards or want to punish them.
    • Though looking back at the quote after P2, it's either amusing or somewhat disturbing.
    • That quote was important because it highlighted Alex's progress as a character. Yes he was a monster, but as he consumed more people, he grew a conscience and became a better person. Despite being a killer, he grew to really care about Dana and trusted Ragland enough to entrust her with him. It was an important part of his character arc in the first game. The second game threw that all out in favor of turning in into a villain with a poor motivation and a terribly-written Start of Darkness. What happened was poor writing that completely destroyed Alex's character.
  • Maybe he's not "Alex" anymore in much the same way that a person at 20 years old isn't the same person they were when they were 8. Consider: People gain the urge to reproduce after going through puberty. Elizabeth Greene had been infected for almost 50 years by the time we met her. Alex/Blacklight is about two years old by Prototype 2. Result? It's not a normal Face–Heel Turn: he went through Blacklight puberty. A few more years and he would've developed a Voice of the Legion. Even if this is true, the writing still sucks; they should've put more effort into describing it. This also implies that it'll happen to Heller in a few years...
  • And it's not just his motives and actions that are stupid. They're just the worst part. Literally every aspect of his character is changed. In Prototype 1, he had little mind for tactics, and mostly just charged in claw-first. In Prototype 2, he's orchestrating a pointlessly complicated plot, even being called a "brilliant strategist" at one point. In Prototype 1, Taggart hit his Berserk Button so hard it got stuck by deliberately putting other people in harms way to protect himself. In Prototype 2, he commits Revenge by Proxy and tries to vivisect a child. In Prototype 1, he's quiet, blunt, and to the point. In Prototype 2, he never shuts the fuck up. It's like somebody went down a checklist of his character traits and made sure to invert every single one.
    • As much as it pains me to defend an abortion of writing like this one, I have to make a point of order: of all of the above, the Brilliant Strategist bit is actually quite defensible, and something that might've even been a valid character evolution that's foreshadowed in the first game. It might *seem* like Mercer has little mind for tactics in Prototype 1, but read between the lines. Take a look at a number of the strategies he - and you the player - can and sometimes even have to use. By all accounts, he strategically consumed VIPs, tactically sorted out his powers and used them in combat(which you *need* to do to get past Cross at all), and even *used the enemy's resources against them* through things like calling in strikes while disguised as an officer or hijacking vehicles. Heck, take a look at Patsy. This power *would not exist* without the ability to GET in the enemy's head on a very, VERY fundamental level and manipulate their fears and instincts in order to get them to kill each other off. That's why the "Alex Mercer, strategic mastermind" bit was just about the only thing that *didn't* bother me or come off as a derailment from the original character. That doesn't stop the rest of your post from being absolutely true, though.
  • Again, all of this just comes off as a desperate attempt by the developers to force the new character onto the franchise. Given the negative reaction to Heller, it is safe to say they failed.
  • My hypothesis is that after Alex consumes someone, he starts out with their appearance and memories. As he goes along, he becomes more and more like the people he consumes. So, just as he consumed Greene in the first game, he eventually gained the craving to continue her Assimilation Plot. Although he tried to fight it at first, the consuming of mobsters, drug dealers, warlords and thieves only made him lose control of his memories and begin his Face–Heel Turn. And maybe that is what the alternate Zombie Mercer Skin could be: a side effect of consuming all those infected in the first game.
    • The Prototype 1 entry on this wiki points out that "Mercer tells Dana how the memories of everyone he eats are swirling inside his head, and by the end of the game, you will likely have consumed a third of your total kill count." Additionally, in the game proper, there's a moment where he temporarily loses control and groans: "So many minds at work... All talking, all dying...". And who's made up a good chunk of Alex's kill count by the end of the game? Blackwatch nuts and evil scientists. Yup.

So they didn't do anything with the sequel hooks from the first game? Nothing about Pariah, or the true nature of the virus? Kinda disappointing.
  • One Agent Barnes Griffin (a consumption target late in the game) has his name mentioned as being currently assigned to "Project Codename: PARIAH". That's pretty much it. It's in those "file-flipping clip show" type things while someone talks about someone else, and doesn't even get a direct mention in dialogue.
  • Maybe they're saving it for a sequel?
  • PARIAH is currently sitting in some military base far away from NYZ. How would they involve him?
    • The same way Alex went globe-trotting between games despite being the most wanted terrorist ever?
  • Wait, PARIAH wasn't supposed to be the explanation for why Cross was suddenly a super-powerful Infected at the end when he'd previously been a seemingly normal human? Wow, totally misread that one.
    • I originally thought that too but it actually turned out that the Supreme Hunter simply absorbed Cross. PARIAH is still in Gentek custody.
      • It is. There's a cutscene that heavily implies they fought, and he's not seen in the flesh until the final battle of the first game. Pariah is still in custody.
    • Or more likely, still in Blackwatch custody, since a memory concerning an exchange between Randall and McMullen reveals this.
      • That still brings into question what agency Barnes Griffin works for. It's unlikely that they'd have agents in plainclothes go into a war zone.
      • Well why wouldn't they? Anybody in a uniform is a target for Heller, but the soldiers get flashed an ID and Griffin is on his merry way.

     Why is Heller so Powerful? 
  • How is it that James Heller becomes so powerful that he can fight on par with and consume Alex Mercer? Mercer has had control of these powers of his for 2 years now so he should have considerably greater speed, strength, and endurance in comparison to a guy that Alex himself infected only a short time prior. Also what about Elizabeth Greene and the Supreme Hunter, not to mention the hundreds or maybe even thousands of infected he consumed? None of that did anything to increase his already Physical God power?
    • It seems plausible that he lost a sizable amount of biomass when "Operation: Firebreak" (the nuke) detonated. He seemed to barely be able to consume the raven to regenerate. Furthermore, he used his own biomass to recreate the infection, and see how big that was. He also had an A God Am I complex by the time they met. Maybe he thought he couldn't' be beaten, being "the top of the food chain". It does seem odd that he wouldn't develop mutations that the Blacklight Abominations and his Evolved had and more, and that "supercharging" himself didn't really help, but there's also the problem of gameplay consistency. If one would go on the idea that he can lose given more experience and time than his opponent, there's also the idea of how he lost. He had his arms torn off twice (seemingly making him lose his Hammerfist, Whipfist, and one of his Claws for some reason), and lost all of his power, being consumed. If we were going on feasibility, the fight would have been longer and hopeless, either a Hopeless Boss Fight or Heads I Win, Tails You Lose.
    • It seems likely that Mercer stopped aggressively evolving and instead shifted his attention to being the leader of the Infected; any mutations he engaged in likely involved directly controlling the Infected over direct combat. His subordinates developed their own mutations while working out in the field, but Mercer himself didn't need to mutate any new combat powers or abilities. Heller, meanwhile, is aggressively developing his combat mutations in the field by constantly fighting Blackwatch and the infected and absorbing powers from Mercer's minions. That, and he's really fucking pissed.
    • So essentially, Alex stopped gathering personal combat strength in favor of expanding his army, where Heller spent pretty much all the time up until they fought gathering personal combat strength. Even with the boost provided by consuming the Evolved, and given Heller's extreme emotional investment in winning (which Alex lacked), Heller simply outmatched Mercer. Though given Alex's last line and the way the virus works, one has to wonder if it wasn't a Xanatos Gambit. Either Alex consumes the Evolved and Heller, thus gaining the power of them all combined, or Heller consumes Alex along with the Evolved and proves himself a worthy successor. Gives a new dimension to the taunt about infecting Maya, for one thing. Enraging Heller into going all out...
      • I was expecting that reveal from the start, and was confused when it didn't happen. The idea that this was all an elaborate ploy to groom a successor makes a hell of a lot more sense than "Remember how Alex's entire character arc in the first game was about growing from a vengeance-fueled sociopath into a genuine, if dark, hero? Forget all that. He's totally evil now."
      • Also, Alex seems to have taken a heavily Social Darwinist mentality, which would mean that he would be at peace being defeated, so long as his successor was superior.
    • Heller was a highly-skilled and incredibly confident melee fighter even before his infection - when stranded in the Red Zone he didn't even bother looking for the shotgun he must also have been carrying, preferring to rely on his combat knife, and then he managed to kill a Brawler single-handed. Mercer, on the other hand, was a scientist (not that he even remembered that). Even given Mercer probably ate a lot of people with the same amount of training as Heller had, maybe the actual lived-through experience is more valuable than just getting the knowledge second-hand from some poor sucker's brain?
      • Human powers are a lot different from viral induced powers like shape shifting, super strength and speed. Mercer should have much greater mastery over those powers than James does. Even without that keep in mind that experience should matter. Just as a human Mercer would be a noob as a fresh Marine compared to a human James that is a war veteran and has experience as a Marine, a fresh viral James should be a novice compared to a veteran viral entity like Mercer who has had these powers for much longer.
      • As noted above, Mercer has seemed to be focusing his powers less on direct combat and more on controlling the Infected. Heller, meanwhile, has been focusing on both strengthening his own abilities and consuming the powers of Mercer's subordinates. He's simply evolving and mutating faster, and remember that Heller started close to where Mercer was at the end of the first game (he has most of Mercer's abilities, save for activated powers) and he only gets stronger.
      • Doesn't that make James Heller pretty Sueish? It just doesn't seem realistic that he could mutate at a faster and more explosively powerful rate than Mercer was capable of in two years. I call huge Game play and story segregation on this nonsense, I bet if we were playing as Mercer he would have won the fight no problem.
      • No, it doesn't make Heller "Sueish" because there's a lot more to being a Sue than just "character is more powerful!". (that and Mary Sue is so distorted by now that it has as much relevance to characterization as custard pie has to railgun research. Use a real term to describe a character!) I just pointed out why it would make sense: Heller started close to where Mercer was originally, and Mercer hasn't been aggressively improving his combat abilities and focusing on controlling the Infected, and Heller has been aggressively eating all of the Evolved with new and unique mutations to rapidly make himself stronger. Mercer's greater experience is reflected in his ability to control the Infected. And what do you mean, "it doesn't seem realistic"? We're talking about a fictional supervirus that alters biomass to allow you to tear apart tanks, leap over buildings, and telepathically control millions of infected zombies and mutants. Going on about things being "realistic" is ridiculous when we're dealing with a reality-warping psychic viral infection whose exact mechanisms are entirely unknown. We don't really have enough data to say that it is "realistic" or not.
      • Alternatively, it could be a case of diminishing returns or just a hard cap on how strong Evolved can be. Mercer reached the peak of power for Evolved over a year ago, Heller reached it just before the end of the game, they're on a par with each other and Heller wins through sheer determination and better close-combat skills.
      • There is no point in arguing about any of this if we can't put a decent limit on what is possible for the virus to do and how probable it is for it to advance at a particular rate, whether a certain ability comes from technology, biology, or magic there needs to be some sort of rule to let the audience know how it ticks, otherwise it comes off as an ass pull. Saying, "It's a fictional virus, it can do whatever it wants!", is a lame cop out. Mercer evolved at a fairly incredible rate over the course of 3 weeks in the first game so I don't even mind James becoming as powerful as he does, Alex proved that something like that could be done, it just seems strange that he would give up on doing the exact same thing that made him powerful the first time around. Plus aren't these Evolved entities coming directly from Mercer in the first place? How does he not have access to the collective power of the Infected if he is their Hive King? Did Mercer become lazy, complacent? Did the nuke do permanent damage? Something?
      • Alex proved that something like that could be done, it just seems strange that he would give up on doing the exact same thing that made him powerful the first time around. Once again, he didn't give up on evolving, he simply shifted his focus. He's not focused on combat, he's focused on controlling an entire army. Heller started close to Mercer's level and kept on getting more powerful by charging around, aggressively killing and eating and fighting, while Mercer focused on controlling his army and directing the Whitelight plan and Gentek/Blackwatch infiltration.
      • Plus aren't these Evolved entities coming directly from Mercer in the first place? How does he not have access to the collective power of the Infected if he is their Hive King? Because the virus does not appear to work that way. Once you create something, it evolves on its own and the only way to gain its genetic mutations is to consume it yourself. The Evolved developed their own unique mutations but Mercer couldn't access them without eating his own minions.
  • What probably made him stronger was one of the principals of the evolved. As we've seen, most of the evolved had a version of one of Mercer's abilities. The one that Heller got was the power to consume other lifeforms, as it appears no other Evolved have this ability. As he consumed each infected creature, he gained that creatures abilities.
    • Is there an explanation or theory on how Heller did the Red Zone-wide "disinfection" after consuming the final boss?
      • Mine is that Heller became one with the Blacklight virus and sent his tentacles out to detonate the bulk of the plague like he does when he's finished with the Hunters or Juggernaughts.
  • Personally, I chalked it up to the baseline the Blacklight virus had with each man. I can see your upper limit of personal power being determined by how strong you were as a human being. Alex Mercer was a brilliant and devious man, but he was still a pasty, physically weak scientist before his infection. James Heller was clearly already at the upper limit of human potential with no viral interference at all, as he was durable enough to stay on his feet after being hit by Mercer, fast enough to avoid Mercer's strikes during their second bout, and possessed enough endurance and willpower to outrun the Goliath and kill the Brawler with his knife. He was also better trained in combat, and clearly had a natural affinity for it, since he only had normal Marine training and not any sort of Special Ops.
  • There's another possibility - Mercer started from zero and had to work his way up to physical god status by eating everything in sight. Then Mercer, who's been eating his veggies (and Marines, and Blackwatch for dessert) goes and infects Heller, bringing him up to a similar level as Mercer was at the end of Prototype 1. Obviously he's not going to bring Heller up to his current level, which is why Heller lacks the various biomass powers. Heller's not starting at barely-above-baseline-human like Mercer did.

     Why infect Heller at all? 
Is there any reason, aside from carrying the Idiot Ball, that Alex decided to infect Heller? It seems that by that time he already had most of his evolved in place. Aside from overtly screwing with Blackwatch, what could Heller really do for Alex? Seriously, giving anyone the potential powers he gave to Heller's weird; but giving them to someone who really, really wants you dead is just stupid. In addition, after giving Heller these amazing powers, does Alex closely monitor him to ensure Heller's not going to learn what he's up to? Naw, just sit back and don't do anything until after Heller eats a mad scientist you were discussing your evil plans with, no way that could possibly backfire.
  • Maybe Alex just wanted someone to succeed him in case he was somehow killed and destroyed. Second, Roland isn't exactly powerful enough to control the Evolved. So Alex just needed another second in command. Turns out, Heller in a way is Alex's legacy, as he is now the most powerful person in the world.
  • It is entirely possible that Mercer figured Heller would come over to his side after Blackwatch tried to experiment on/kill him, and indeed, Heller does favor Mercer's viewpoint at first. However, he eventually turns on Mercer, and once Mercer notices that Heller is acting against him, he immediately tries to kill him.
  • Considering how Koenig, Gallagher, and Roland were completely devoted to Mercer and his cause, maybe this is a known side-effect of the viral evolution, and Mercer was expecting it to work on Heller as well? In which case, the reason for choosing Heller is obvious - Mercer needed a Dragon, and Heller is a highly skilled melee fighter and ridiculously tough even before he gets the virus. He killed a Brawler with a combat knife while already exhausted and wounded!
    • It's simpler than that: Galloway clearly state that all but two evolved are mind controlled by Alex, and those two are herself and Heller. She also say pretty much say that making evolved is not an exact science. She got an advanced version of the "viral sonar" and isn't under Alex control, Roland is under Alex control, but he has a spiked shield no one else demonstrate, that evolved girl with the whipfist etc. Whenever Alex is making an evolved, he's playing russian roulette as far as what the evolved capabilities will be, and he simply got the loaded chamber with Heller.
    • Well, Mercer did say he wanted Maya Heller partly because she "shares her father's annoyingly resistent genetics" Heller's daughter pre-prototype would not be genetically special unless Heller was somehow special even before Alex "infects" him. Maybe that is why a: he infected heller, or B: chose Maya Heller to be the spawnmother for whatever his master plan was, or C:all of the above. Which raises the question: What exactly is so special about Heller's original Human DNA?
      • Genetic resistance or something, same as any virus. He infected Heller because he was impressed, and he turned out to be a big problem.
      • Genetic Resistance? Do you mean the stubborness that makes Heller such a badass? his ability to stop mercer from Consuming him?
      • Not the stubborness, but his DNA itself. Like how some people that are infected have the genetics to become Runners, Walkers, or various other creatures, Heller had the genetics to resist the virus. It might explain why he became so powerful, but it's explained to be the reason why Mercer couldn't kill him, and why Mercer wanted Amaya.
  • I've been wondering the same exact thing. Mercer's plan was to have Heller by his side when he destroyed Blackwatch... and then what? By then, Heller would already be very powerful, and he certainly wouldn't want to take part in the next part of Mercer's plan, which is world domination. It also seems very odd that Mercer reacted so angrily toward Heller tearing his plan apart after learning the truth, considering their entire "relationship" was built on Mercer lying to him about who killed his family. Like, what did you expect he would do? Just suddenly go along with your plan? And why even lie to him in the first place then if you expect his cooperation? Mercer clearly did not think his plan through.

     Where's the Bloodtox? 
  • Okay, Blackwatch - you have a substance that is in no way harmful to humans, is toxic to the virus and has proven to be easily distributed in both a liquid and vapor form, not to mention having had enough of it in Prototype 1 to PUMP IT INTO THE NEW YORK UNDERGROUND. Why are you not using it?!
    • Alex grew an immunity to Bloodtox in the first game and he's the cause of the outbreak in the second game, seeing as how he released the virus directly from himself so maybe Blackwatch already tried, but the new infected inherited the immunity?
      • Right, and keep in mind that their plan for Whitelight was largely the same; pumping large amounts of the aerosolized chemical in order to kill the infected. If it hadn't been for the evolved sabotaging it, Blackwatch apparently would've deployed it in the same manner as bloodtox.
      • When did Alex gain an immunity? Not even Greene had an immunity. She had to make that huge shell around her to protect her from Bloodtox. Alex was always affected by Bloodtox, he just got rid of the dispensers. The use of Bloodtox was still a plausible route.
      • To be specific, he was growing an immunity. It's pointed out during one of the conversations with Cross/Supreme Hunter. Besides, one of the above Tropers already stated that Whitelight was created to do roughly the same thing.
      • I think the Bloodtox was originally going to be in the game but got dropped part-way through development. The concept art booklet includes a Blackwatch truck full of chemical drums, labelled "bloodtox transport".

     Why are the evolved so confident? 
  • This has really been bugging me. Why are all the evolved so arrogant? they all tell Heller things like "stop being such a wimp" or generally proclaiming their superiority. The best example is probably Commander Gallagher, the evolved soldier from the first mission when whitelight is mentioned. He insults Heller, then runs off telling Heller how slow he is when I am never more than a foot away from him. He then hijacks a helicopter and tells me "thats the difference between you and I Heller, I can think outside of the box" That doesn't really make any sense. Gallagher is a commander. That's a fairly high rank. Therefore he would have to know that Heller destroys about 3 helicopters per failed Blackwatch ambush at a rate of about 1 ambush PER HOUR. 24/7. Hell, he should know that anyway, seeing as how he is an Evolved himself. It just gets weirder and weirder as the game progress, since most evolved never change their arrogant attitude even though It should be obvious that Heller has been killing hundreds of their fellow evolved with all the difficulty of stepping on a bug.
    • Typical mook bravado done badly is all. Sure, they shouldn't act that way, but they probably think "it's inevitable that Mercer wins" or something because MERCER thinks that and controls them.
    • There's also the "we are legion" attitude. A lot of them don't seem to be much for self-preservation, and it's noteworthy that later on in the game they start getting flung at you in larger and larger numbers with little regard for their own safety. Not to mention that they all seem to be a little Drunk on the Dark Side.
    • Another thing to consider: every one of the individual evolved that we are introduced to is college-educated (being a scientist or military officer), with a good chunk of them holding Doctorates. Heller, on the other hand, being a sergeant, explicitly DOES NOT have any higher education. They are thinking themselves superior to this uneducated brute.

     Dr. Koenig double cross 
  • When Koenig sets Heller up, he calls on Blackwatch to kill Heller. This implies that Blackwatch knows about Koenig's interactions with Heller. If that is the case, why do they allow Koenig to sick Heller on Project Orion? At the very least, even if Blackwatch doesn't know the specifics, they know that Koenig is going to contact Heller for the double cross, so they should have figured out that Koenig sicked Heller on Project Orion. What gives?
    • Heller has demonstrated, by that point, an uncanny ability to show up in exactly the wrong place at the wrong time, from Blackwatch's perspective. As far as they're concerned, it's just a thing that happens. All Koenig has to do is say that Heller stole files or ate an underling who happened to know about Orion while he hid in the closet, and provide some plausible excuse for having Mercer's number.

     Evolved Loyalty 
  • We know that most of the Evolved are fanatically devoted to Mercer. Is that because he controls them like he does with viral monsters, because Evolved are power hungry assholes and Mercer made them so powerful, or just because they believe in Alex's Assimilation Plot master plan?
    • It's implied that he psychically controls all of the Evolved except Sabrina Galloway and Heller, especially from their conversations. This includes why the newly Evolved from Whitelight also attack Heller on sight, despite having no prior information that he was even him.
    • It's also implied that having those powers is a case of Evil Feels Good. It's a little bit badly done, but it's possible they're grateful to Mercer for giving them these godlike abilities.

     Why Manhattan Again? 
  • All things considered, why the fuck did Mercer decide to restart his plans in Manhattan? The Anchor showed him travelling the world in the year between games. If he wanted to destroy humanity, pretty much any other place in the world would be a better starting point; Beijing, Moscow, New Dehli, pretty much any city with a high population density would suffice. Granted, he had planted moles in Blackwatch and Gentek, but wouldn't it have been more simpler to go someplace outside Blackwatch's jurisdiction to start spreading the virus? Was he just so amused by the irony of restarting the infection at Penn Station he decided that overrode any pragmatic considerations?
  • He likely wanted to finish what Greene started: turning New York into an infected hive. After that he'd probably move on to Washington D.C and other capitols. If Heller hadn't stopped him, probably every part of the world would be inhabited by Evolved and infected.
    • Yes, but why does he want to finish what Greene started? Is there any purpose, other than dramatic irony of starting the virus in the same place, that makes Manhattan the best place to start to spread the virus again? Accepting the Anchor as canon, he could've infected literally anywhere else in the world; and one would assume Manhattan suffered a large drop in population due to the zombie virus and martial law; plenty of other cities would've offered a larger pool of potential infectees. Greene infected Manhattan because she was trapped there, he chose to return to Manhattan; and the only place he has uncontested control over is the island.
    • Also, keep in mind, it's not like there was a large amount of infected waiting for him to take the reins, they were being exterminated by the end of the original without Greene, and its even mentioned Blackwatch got NY under control after her death. So he wasn't finishing what she started, as much as he was restarting from step one (and again, he could've tried that at any other city).
    • Mercer gets a little to dramatic at times. Not only that, but considering New York has lots of places to spread the virus further, like airports and boats, it would only take a couple canisters of Whitelight on a plane or boat to spread the virus across the country in a day or two.
      • Beijing has all of these advantages, plus a larger, denser population and not being on an island. Even London, DC, or San Francisco would be better if he wanted to stay in the English-speaking world.
  • By infecting NYZ Alex could draw Blackwatch into the open, allowing him to take the greatest threat to his plan over from the inside. That also allowed Alex to test his plan without giving it away, as there would be less suspicion if the virus resurfaced in the same place. Once Whitelight was proven effective, Alex could start planting his Evolved all over the world and using them to move Whitelight into position. With Blackwatch actually working for him, there wouldn't be anyone left with the knowledge required to stop him. Once everything was set, he could infect the entire world in one move. The world's population would become one mass of Infected/Evolved with him as the focus of the hive mind.
  • Probably the real reason; the developers didn't want to too much focus on improving the open world in the sequel (focusing more on tightening the controls and combat systems) so they just mildly retooled the map from the first game.
  • Blackwatch probably still had forces in the city, and by hitting them in NYZ again (instead of at Fort Dietrick where Blackwatch is based and would be the strongest) he can draw them out into the open and hit them hard. He probably still had a grudge from the first game. After all, they shot him. A lot.

     Why Doesn't Mercer Consume Someone Important? 
  • Why doesn't Mercer consume someone like the president or another world leader?. Seriously, it would help to influence his plan further. He wouldn't have much trouble getting past a couple guys in black suits that are guarding a doorway. All he'd have to do is disguise himself as one of them or just kill all the guards with his powers.
    • And such a blatant attack on an important government figure would be reported before he'd finished eating said important government figure.
      • Not if he disguised himself as a Secret Service agent and stealth-consumed.
      • You don't seem to get how heavily-protected important individuals like that are. Stealth-consume only works in-game because everyone's situational awareness is negatively comparable to turnips. Bodyguards will be watching intently, and all it takes is a single sentence over the radio to instantly ruin any attempt to stealth-consume an important figure.
  • Another thing, Mercer isn't in much danger from getting shot at. At the end of Prototype, the only thing that could even have a chance of killing him storywise would have been a nuke. And he even survived that by swimming away from just as it detonated. So even if the government tried to kill him for trying to eat their leader , it be be futile unless they want to blow up an entire state.
    • Which is irrelevant. The usefulness of taking over a leader is predicated on that leader's knowledge and authority. Said leader's knowledge would be invalidated immediately; all access information would be changed instantly. Authority would be repudiated immediately as well. There would be little point to taking a leader like that, because anything useful they knew would be destroyed or changed immediately.
      • Now, Evolving a world leader by working his way through their underlings on the other hand, might be a viable technique. However, someone with enough will and authority to get to that position might try and take over his little plot. Such a plan would take a long time, and he can only infiltrate one major organization at a time since he has to evolve people personally.

     Heller's Appeal 
  • So...what's Heller's appeal supposed to be to players, again? It seems to me that he has no personality outside of Angry Black Man, constantly yelling at his allies and just being unlikeable in general. One particular example that stuck out to me was when in a side mission, Heller found out about a scientist he wanted to consume. Whilst describing the scientist, Heller says (paraphrased) "Likes a member of MENSA...what a douchebag." Sorry, liking a sport that's not popular in America makes you a douchebag? Are we supposed to laugh with Heller in this scene? Add to the fact that Heller rarely displays any emotion other than anger (I think there's maybe two scenes where he acts sad about his daughter and wife before immediately switching back to anger?) and I really have to wonder about the meta reason for why Heller was designed that way. In-universe, sure, that's just the sort of person he is, but outside of the universe, what's his appeal supposed to be? Being angry is cool?
    • Angry and swearing a lot, apparently. It's safe to say they failed at making him appealing.
    • It's funny that people are so upset with Heller's characterization, when he is more or less a black version of Kratos. Heller's MENSA comment makes sense when you think about the fact that highly educated people tend to talk down to people without the same level of education. The cricket comment I can't even defend, because I like cricket myself. I think it's less about anger being cool, and more about losing your family being a Berserk Button. But then again, people see me as nothing more than an Angry Black Man so maybe I'm biased.
    • To be fair, the only one of his allies Heller really yells at is Galloway, who got on my nerves too. He snarks at Father Guerra and at Dana, but he's not particularly rude to any of them. As far as calling the scientist a douchebag goes, he's probably starting from the baseline of "guy works for Gentek or Blackwatch? Douchebag." Considering every single one of the collectible recordings we find and the memories we see and the experiments we witness feature Blackwatch and Gentek being horrible people, it's hard to blame Heller for assuming the scientist was a douche. Plus, Heller was a Marine sergeant, and the scientists he's run into have universally been sanctimonious asshats anyway. If anything, Heller's not really an appealing character, but he is something of an interesting character if you factor in that most of how he acts are classic signs of PTSD. It's even noted in the psych eval in the intro cutscene that he's got PTSD and has a homicidal fixation on Mercer.

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: