- When Tommy and the two made men enter the "initiation room", what clued Tommy at the very last moment that he wasn't going to be made at all?
- The fact that the room was empty. If he'd actually been there to be made, there'd have been a group of guys there to welcome and congratulate him before the ceremony began.
- Also, at the very least, maybe some food and drink, a nice comfy chair to sit in, some music. Not just a card table with nothing on it.
Headscratchers / GoodFellas