Follow TV Tropes


Headscratchers / Batman: Arkham Asylum

Go To

    open/close all folders 

     Bruce owns the locks 
  • So, Lucius Fox created Arkham's locks. And he works for Bruce. Why could Batman not use Fox's technology and create himself a secret key? Thus he wouldn't need any codes and hacking equipment.
    • It is possible for him to do so, but it will also have the dangerous effect of leaving behind a trail that can risk revealing Batman's identity. Imagine if Bruce Wayne personally ordered a personal overwrite code for all the security systems designed by Wayne Tech, then Batman uses the same code to unlock doors. It will not be too hard for someone to put the two together and discover who Batman really is.
      • I believe in the Arkhamverse, as in the movieverse, Lucius is pretty aware who Batman and Bruce Wayne are. He could personally give Wayne the "key", and set it so the overwrite code didn't leave any log, or left a corrupted log, or even Lucius' own log, which he can later claim he gave Batman after being personally requested since the situation was so extreme. No links with Wayne would even be needed.
    • Investigator: "Batman, how did you obtain the codes needed to hack these unhackable locks?" Batman: "I'm Batman."
    • Inmates escape Arkham far too easily as it is. He doesn't want a system that is "foolproof-but-with-one-single-exception", he wants something that is foolproof period. If Lucius / Bruce can create a secret key, then so can somebody else, assuming it isn't stolen from him somehow. Some of the smartest and most dangerous men and women on the planet are locked up in that Asylum, and you don't throw people like that a bone.

     Why not use the cameras 
  • Allegedly, there are security cameras all over Arkham Asylum, and there are a few places in the game where you can see rooms full of camera screens. Despite this, neither Batman nor Joker seems to take advantage of surveillance devices to find his respective enemy. Instead, Joker is alerted to Batman's presence by the suicide collars on the inmates Batman beats senseless, and Batman just moves from objective to objective without using any of Arkham's security systems to his advantage.
    • My guess that I'm sure has much supporting evidence: Joker (and/or Riddler's) fiddling probably made it difficult for Bats to hack into the security feed (plus the inmates were probably smashing the majority of cameras they find). And the Joker was more interested in having fun.
    • In the beginning of the game when the inmates first escaped, some of the TV screens around the building will show security footage of the prisoners escaping. If you keep on watching for long enough, eventually the escaped prisoners will start smashing the cameras and the footage will turn into static.
    • And given some of the comments the Joker is making regarding Batman's actions, he's clearly watching Batman; the reason he doesn't use this further is because, in his mind, it wouldn't be any fun.

     Why not use the Batplane? 
  • If Batman could summon the Batplane any time he wanted, why not use it to bypass some of the level maps, or fight some bosses?
    • The island isn't that big. That'd be like getting into your car to go next door. Plus, Batman is sneaking around. The Batplane is less than subtle.
    • The Joker hid all those bombs and threatened to detonate them if Batman left the island. If he hops in the plane and starts buzzing around, the Joker might take that as an attempt to flee.
      • Wait, are you talking about the bombs Oracle mentioned at the beginning of the game? Because those were fake.
      • The one bomb they found was fake. That doesn't mean that all of the bombs were fake. It's totally in character for the Joker to fill 99 out of 100 bombs with kittens and marzipan and make the last one real, or vice versa.

     Croc staying underwater 
  • Killer Croc is a mutant, sure, but he's not REALLY aquatic, is he? Even real crocodiles don't have gills. How does he stay underwater for so long?
    • Giant lungs.
    • Maybe the creepy hissing and dripping sounds you hear are Croc coming up for air.
      • Plus, real crocodiles emerge themselves just enough out of the water to let their nostrils above the surface so that they can get air into their lungs. Maybe Killer Croc is doing the same thing, but due to the condition/coloration of the water, Bats doesn't see him doing so.
    • Croc only looks like an animal; he's smart enough to plan ahead and strategize. He may have located a few isolated air-pockets in the drain network that he can grab a quick breath from in a pinch.

     Riddler hacking transmissions 
  • Batman uses some kind of communicator to stay in touch with Oracle, okay, that's fine, and Batman calls her Barbara a lot too, that is also fine. The problem is that Edward Nygma was able to hack into the comms, so if the Riddler can do it, surely he can find out who Batman is... and what's stopping someone else, like the Joker or Two-Face from doing it?
    • But the Riddler wouldn't want to hear Batman's secret identity, because it's the single greatest riddle the Riddler has to solve. And this Troper remembers reading something about the Riddler actually figuring out that Bruce Wayne is Batman, then employing the shrinks at Arkham to have that memory wiped.
    • But isn't "Who Is The Batman" the greatest riddle of all?
      • Precisely. It's cheating if you figure out the greatest riddle of all by simply hacking a radio transmission; he wants to figure it out the hard way, or it doesn't count as a real achievement.
      • In comics continuity at least, Nigma figured out who Batman is years ago, but is literally incapable of telling anyone else because just giving away the answer to a riddle like that goes against everything he is.
      • Actually, in 'Hush', the big blockbuster storyline from a few years back, Eddie actually plans on exploiting his knowledge to all of Batman's foes after it 'came to him' following a dunk in a Lazarus Pit. Batman then promptly tells Riddler that knowledge of his identity is about as useless as a fence sat on by an elephant - Given the number of people Eddie played during the story - Especially Ra's Al Ghul, who would not be best pleased by a criminal using one of his Lazarus pits. So it's more that Bruce's ID as Batman is worthless if he reveals it because Ra's will just kill him.
      • Having just reread 'Hush'... not so much. Batman presents the Riddler with a riddle: "What time is it when an elephant sits on your fence?" The Riddler responds, "Time to get a new fence. Everyone knows that one, it's worthless." And Batman says that's why he doesn't have to worry about Nigma blowing his cover - if everybody knew the answer, it wouldn't mean anything. If he was the only one who knew it, though... well, he couldn't just ruin that. The part about the League of Assassins coming after him for the Lazarus Pit affair was only a threat on top of it. The Riddler's psychological compulsions mean it was never really a huge threat in the first place.
      • I'm sorry to interrupt with something so unrelated, but you guys are saying the Riddler fell in a Lazarus pit too? As did Joker and Clayface in Batman: Arkham City? And Joker in the comics, when he became briefly sane? Tell me, how many of the Batman villains fell in the accursed things over the continuities? I reckoned they were supposed to be rare.
      • Riddler didn't fall in it; he actively sought one out because he was dying. The point is clearly made in this case that because they're rare, Ra's al Ghul will not be very happy with him as a result if he ever finds out.
    • I could be remembering wrong, but it seemed like the Riddler's "hack" was only one-way. It allowed him to talk to Batman, but they never had any kind of back-and-forth. Sure, it could be that Batman was just playing Bat-possum by not responding to him, but wouldn't Bats have a protocol in place for if he thinks his comms are compromised (like changing frequencies or encryption keys)? If I were Batman (and I'm not saying I'm not), I would probably change the frequency/encryption of my chats with Oracle, but keep a second line open with the old frequency so that I could still hear Riddler's chatter (which could contain useful information).
    • Bear in mind what happens when you solve all his riddles/find all his trophies. Batman reveals that he was playing along to buy time while Oracle pinpointed his location and called the police. Is it really that far of a stretch to say that Batman and Oracle, in a Batman Gambit, knew Riddler was at-large and knew he was trying to hack their communications... and so -let- him hack into their systems precisely so they could track him down since they knew he couldn't resist taunting them?

     Doors in Bane fight 
  • Wait, how the hell did the Batmobile get through the locked doors to plow into Bane after his fight? And why are the doors still there after Bane's gone? Shouldn't they be open or blown away?
    • It's Batman. He probably has the doors programmed to open for his car to let it get to different parts of the grounds, probably along with all the other crazy stuff that investing in Arkham lets him do.

     Batman paying for his own tech 
  • Wait... if all of Batman's upgrades are Wayne Tech, why does he have to pay experience points? Doesn't he own the company? Who keeps track of this currency? Is he just telling himself that he doesn't deserve the upgrades? I'm confused.
    • It's perhaps explained by the idea of escalation - Batman isn't bringing out the big guns right away because he doesn't think he needs them just yet. He isn't going to use special batarangs on a pair of mooks just because he can.
      • Also just because he's filthy rich doesn't mean his budget is infinite.
      • Gameplay and Story Segregation? Acceptable Break from Reality? It's not like these upgrades ever get brought up in story.
      • To the troper above; hey dude, if you're the sort of person who brings "Gameplay and Story Segregation" and "Acceptable Break From Reality" to the table, the Headscratcher pages really aren't for you. Every single comment here can be countered with those two tropes. It's kind of the point of headscratchers.
      • That's the thing. Nobody bothers asking on a Headscratchers page "why doesn't my character instantly burn to death when the dragon breathes fire on him?" because it's a damn video game, i.e. Gameplay and Story Segregation. It's not the same thing as asking "why did Superman grab a gun and shoot Lex Luthor?", which just makes no sense period.
      • Like all 'XP', the 'upgrades' are just the game's way of making Batman's tactics and thought processes visible and interactive throughout the game. Most of the updates, really, are just extensions or additions to things he's already got or can already do anyway; he doesn't have to literally pay anything at all, but it's the game's way of showing the point where he decides that, say, adjusting his batarangs so that the sonic functions are active might be a good idea. 'Experience points' are just how much experience he's had in the current situation and how it's influenced his thought processes with regards to the decisions he's making regarding the tools he's using.
      • The above is the correct answer. Dungeons and Dragons explains "Experience" in much the same way. Basically, Batman says to himself "hey, I could really use (insert upgrade here)", and he orders it in.

     What is Titan for? 
  • Here is a good one: the whole Project Titan. It begins with Doctor Young trying to make weak inmates stronger so that they can endure the "treatments" administered to them. This already raise some questions as to what kind of psychological treatment would require such measures. Then, Young experiments on Bane, of all people. The dude who was part of a Super Soldier project, because his Venom formula is exactly what she needs. That's right, to survive treatments in Arkham, you need to be an ultra muscular 15 foot tall behemoth...and it only get worse from here.
    • Ah, but this is actually a Fridge Brilliance moment. Listen to the Spirit of Arkham tapes again and you'll notice how the spirit mentions he's found a young doctor who's akin to him... i.e., a certain Dr Young. From that to conclude that she's a sadistic monster, despite her change of heart, well... and she isn't experimenting on Bane, she's extracting the Venom from his body so that she can create Titan.
      • Considering the Breather Boss died because he used an early version of Titan, it would make sense she'd want to refine it. However it becomes clear that she wants no part of it, once she realizes the danger of the drug.
    • The real question is what is the logic behind Dr. Young's development of the Titan formula? When Batman analyzes it, he discovers that it revolves around making the venom chemical so potent that it can cause a Bane-like transformation without a huge tank. When you consider what Titan's purpose is supposed to be (i.e. making patients stronger so that they can handle more strenuous treatments), wouldn't it make more sense to create a watered-down version of venom that would make weak inmates just a little stronger, as opposed to a tiny amount turning them into hulking monsters? I'm not entirely sure of what the thought process is behind this medicine.
      • It isn't meant to be that strong a formula. The first test subject you fight is one of the Joker's first test runs with his adapted version of the formula. If you listen to the audio tapes, she's stopped working on Titan before the games even begins.
      • The Joker's an accomplished chemist, so, chances are, after he'd gotten the "base" formula from Young, he fiddled with it himself to increase its potency.
      • It's actually explained during one of the voiceovers in the Intensive Treatment centre, spoken by Dr. Young. She was attempting to refine the Titan formula so that it could strengthen the bodies of weak patients. That way, the patients could better withstand treatment. Of course, the question is, what kind of treatment are they getting that requires such a robust constitution?
      • It's not the treatments - the same voiceovers explain that Young believes psychotic episodes are physically damaging to the brain, and Titan is supposed to make the patient strong enough to handle their own psychotic episodes without further damaging themselves.
  • Dr Young didn't intend for Titan to turn people into Bane-like 15 foot behemoths. Joker SUBTLY got her to work on it by faking another identity, providing funding, etc, convincing her that a weakened version of it would help patients recover. She honestly just thought she was helping patients by working on the formula. Joker manipulated the samples she was given and manipulated her results into making her believe this. When she discovered the truth, she immediately stopped all work on it and tried to destroy the formula. So no, she didn't intend for any of that to happen...that was ALL Joker. He just used her to develop the formula HE wanted by manipulating both her and her research.

     How did Riddler place the trophies? 
  • Here's a big one: How the hell did Riddler hide all those trophies? Seriously, they're hidden behind walls, metal grates, on miniature islands outside the batcave, and generally placed in spots that require Batman to use the full extent of his multi-thousand dollar costume and gadgets, but a spindly little prick like Riddler was able to hide them with what he could get from Arkham?
    • Remember how in the Riddler's first interview he was revealed to have been beaten by his father for allegedly cheating? This happened in the comics too, but it was more regular than implied in the interview and more because Edward's father was jealous of his son's genius intellect. This caused him to compulsively reveal any deceit he makes, it just so happens that riddles also tied into his childhood and he can get around his impulse to tell the truth by leaving a riddle because if solved it does expose the truth.
    • One of his interview-tapes suggests that Joker'd let Riddler in on his plot. It's possible that Riddler's part in events was to slow Batman down through making puzzles for him in order to give Joker extra time to set everything up.
    • Rule of Fun.
    • Moreover, why the hell would Riddler hide maps that show the locations of his riddles? Theoretically, one could argue that it's because he wants to prove that you can't solve the riddles without hints, but even if you do collect them, he still goes into a berserk rage and accuses Batman of cheating when the police arrive to haul his ass away.
      • The answer is because he has to. Seriously. It's part of his obsessive-compulsive disorder. He literally has to leave the clues to his riddles where someone can find them. In fact there's an old Batman comic where the Riddler tries to commit crimes without leaving clues and riddles for Batman to find, and he discovers he just can't do it. It would be like Adrian Monk trying to not wipe his hands after he shakes hands with someone or trying to not touch every parking meter as he walks down the street. He can't. He's compelled to. Almost obsessively compelled, you might say...
      • Alternatively; the maps aren't for Batman's benefit, they're for the Riddler's. It's quite clear that, for all the Riddler's taunts and boasting , he's not nearly as smart as he likes to think he is, and not nearly as smart as Batman. He creates and hides the maps to remind him where he's previously put a riddle / trophy or where he's found a secret message so he doesn't accidentally double-up.
      • Ultimately, the maps are more a tool for the player than either of the characters; there's a thin layer of justification in calling it a "Riddler Map" and having the Riddler gloat a bit when you find one, but really it's simply so that the player doesn't have to run around for countless hours trying to find riddles without any clue whatsoever and making the whole sub-quest a joyless grind.
    • Because he's insane? Part of that insanity is that his compulsive need to create riddles and clues because he believes he's so smart that even with said clues, no one can figure it out. That's precisely why his ending is the way it is. He simply cannot believe that someone -could- figure out his supposedly enigmas. It also ties into his backstory via the interviews - he won a school trivia contest or some other contest involving high intelligence... by -cheating-. If he - the Riddler - had to cheat for stuff he himself thinks are enigmas, things he believes to be enigmas to others then -must- also be solved by cheating. A bunch of Insane Troll Logic sure but again... he's insane.
      • Every single one of you missed the point of the question entirely. He asked how he hid them, not why.
      • He paid off others? Considering you find the Ratcatcher's gear in a vent, it's not that big of a stretch to think that Riddler would have paid off different people to hid stuff while they're escaping or working.
    • Right, how he did it. Well, the Riddler's interviews reveal that he's been compulsively leaving riddles around Arkham during his earlier confinements. Could be that the sum total of riddles and trophies have been put there across a great number of years, originally to test the doctors and orderlies of the asylum. When Batman arrives, Riddler can't resist the opportunity to challenge him to find every single one of them. As for the ones behind walls, one might figure that the walls are weak because something was put behind them. Most prisoners would dig tunnels to escape - Riddler would do it just to test if someone would be smart enough to find his hiding spot.
    • For some of the more out-of-the-way and difficult to access ones; he hid those while he was escaping in the past; a sort of 'catch-me-if-you-can' little taunt to the wardens and police to see if they could figure out how he did it. The fact that a whole load of them are clumped together might indicate a frequent escape route he takes, which is gradually closed off to him the more that Batman finds. In particular, the trophies; they're gloating little markers to indicate that 'the Riddler escaped through here, peons!'
    • Not to mention that Riddler isn't above getting henchmen of his own or teaming up with others. Or for that matter, being an Insufferable Genius. He may have challenged or asked others to place trophies where he couldn't access or where they thought he might not be able to figure out. He figured it out, gloats, and leaves it there with a different hint to see if anyone can rise to his challenge.
    • Truly the ultimate riddle.
    • It's implied a Riddler trophy in the Penitentiary was a trap set by Harley. Maybe he had some of the other inmates hide some for him.
     Why not start with all the gadgets? 
  • If Batman is capable of carrying all his equipment at once (zipline, batclaw, batarangs, etc.), why doesn't he start off the game with all of it? It could have been easily Handwaved by having the Arkham guards insist that Batman leave all (or most) of his stuff behind for security reasons, or that the Crazy-Prepared Batman doesn't always know exactly which of his toys to bring.
    • The explosive gel is used to blast objects on the side opposite its own. This is why an Explosive Gel takedown requires a wall between it and the mooks. So when Batman gelled up his hand and punched Titan Joker with it, wouldn't Batman take the worst of the attack, not Joker?
      • In a way, he did. After the scene, you'll notice that Batman's arm is hanging limp at his side, which almost certainly means he broke it. I.e., Joker received a punch, to the face, with enough power to break bones. Good thing he was in super mode, else he'd be dead!
      • A gel takedown doesn't require a wall to hurt people. You can just pop some on the ground, then detonate it when the enemy get too close - it's a cheap way to handle Knife Nuts. With the auto-detonator upgrade, you can use it as a landmine.
    • Escalation and need. For instance, the sonic batarang. Up until that point, the suicide collars weren't being used so there was simply no reason for him to use them as they'd be no more effective than the batarangs he was already using. And while he could carry any and all toys he has, there'd be little reason too - no sense in packing an entire set of scuba gear on the off chance you might have to swim for 10 minutes. Explosive gel for instance while handy, is also not something someone who relies on stealth would ordinarily use especially when he operates in an urban environment where he can't always guarantee that innocents won't get hurt (and he probably doesn't want to go around blowing up people's houses like that either). One of the reasons I can see his liberal use of it in the game is because he -knows- where all the good guys are and the amount of damage the Joker has already done (and any potential traps left over) would necessitate renovating Arkham anyway. Redundancy also plays a factor - other than pure horizontal movement, the grapple is more or less superior to the zipline - the grapple is also superior to the batclaw in most cases. As the initial post said, he doesn't know what to bring - the game implies then, that he brings the general all-purpose tools that work in most situations and is relying on the player to assume this. On a gameplay level, it simply allows for exploration. On a story level, it allows for development and mimicking the comics where Batman's ingenuity for having what he needs (or making what he needs) at the right time. Note the ultra-batclaw is not something he had but something he made. It's also a way to demonstrate how Batman doesn't -need- his toys or fancy gimmicks; you, as a player, can beat the game using only the single batarang, grapple, and no upgrades beyond the required ones if you so wish. For instance, right about the time you can earn the advanced combat moves is right about when the game starts throwing larger groups of mooks and Elite mooks - i.e. Batman doesn't need to throw or insta-takedown small groups of unarmed/gun wielding mooks because his basic tactics work perfectly fine. Once they start using knives and stun batons which he can't necessarily defend against as easily (try taking away a sharpie pen from a little kid that doesn't want to give it to you. Now imagine that each line he makes on you is a knife wound), then he starts getting more brutal. The only thing that can't really be explained away would be the health upgrades - though it can sorta be handwaved in that the progression at which you can get armor upgrades also matchs the size and strength of the mooks you're facing meaning, symbolically, it's representing Batman's increasing determination and will.
      • Oh (and to break up the last bit), one reason I could also see him being willing to use the explosive gel so freely in Arkham is evident only by looking carefully. Note that the security system in Arkham is Wayne Tech. So, he has an ulterior motive for doing a little creative demolitions (even without the gel) - then he can jump in as Bruce Wayne and fund the re-construction of the place. This would allow him intimate knowledge of the place and to influence and install whatever he wants, figure out how the Joker infiltrated (and how others escaped), and resupply/expand/rebuild the Batcave there. It also allows him to recover any technology he may have left there.
    • In Arkham city, when Batman sends a request for his line launcher, Alfred suggests that Bruce might want to wear a bigger belt to carry all his stuff. Bruce replies that it slows him down too much, so he only grabs what he thinks he needs.
    • In addition to the above: He was delivering an already captured prisoner to a secure location. The fact that he carried any gadgets at all at the beginning is a sign of a healthy paranoia.
      • To be fair, it wasn't like he was just ferrying the Joker around from one place to another; the game makes it clear that he'd just taken down the Joker after yet another escape and attempt-to-destroy-City-Hall style plot, during which his gadgets would likely be very necessary, and was returning him to Arkham after having apprehended him yet again. It wasn't just paranoia.
      • And also, he was ferrying the Joker to Arkham Asylum. If there's a place in the universe where it is more than justified for Batman to approach it with at least a little paranoia, it is Arkham Asylum.

     Bizarre rooms in Arkham 
  • Among all the other cracks to be made at Arkham Asylum's nutcase architecture, there's several rooms that just don't make sense. Not just the Lampshaded bell-tower Batman locks himself in, but other places like the top floor of the library or an office with Harley's memorabilia. If you look around, there's no actual way to get to these otherwise completely ordinary rooms without crawling through air-vents and other videogame antics, meaning only Batman or a very dedicated janitor could reach them.
    • As I read somewhere else, possibly on this site, Arkham is a very old place, and it's possible that these rooms are part of old sections that have been built around and walled off as new additions have been made.
      • The above statement can be further proven at Harley's old office. Granted, the way in is via an air duct, but if you look around the outside, you'll notice an oddly walled-off area with a heater set in front of it - both in the middle of the hallway. This indicates that they sealed her room off after she changed to Harley Quinn.
      • Not to mention, this ties in neatly with the very Arkham attitude of not actually dealing with a problem, but rather sealing it away forever and ever, and simply forgetting all about it

     Joker's mooks killing Batman 
  • Why is the Joker so very A-Ok with his Mooks killing Batman? Giving his The Only One Allowed to Defeat You attitude, you'd think he'd be pissed off when a Mook guns you down, rather than laughing and taunting you.
    • Because he knows your death is only temporary.
    • Because Batman being beat up by Mooks isn't funny/what he wanted/expected out of Batman? And if Batman's going to be a poor sport and ruin the joke/Joker's big moment, the Joker's not going to have anything to do with it. Screw Batman, in that case, he'll go find some other play mate like Superman that will 'play along'.
    • Because he's the Joker. If he decides that "Batman gunned down by random thug" is as funny as "Batman driven mad by my elaborate scheme" on a whim, he'll do it. Besides, the chances of Bats actually getting killed by his goons are pretty low if you know what you're doing.
      • Bingo. If you listen to the Joker's commentary during Predator sequences, he seems to find their getting picked off entertaining to watch (when he isn't annoyed at his mooks' incompetence). In addition to buying him time, he acts like the whole thing is a prank on his own men.
    • Besides all that, after you 'die', there's usually a scene of the Joker looking over you and making some comment, which implies that the thugs have only beaten Batman up enough for the Joker to finish him off.
    • In some challenge mode endings (and I think somewhere in the main game?) there is a quote that effectively explains this: "Yaaawn-a-roony. We both know you eat thugs like those for breakfast! I've got some real surprises in store for you!" While you do get an ending if you lose, canonically, no-one ever beats the Bat like that, and the Joker is perfectly aware that sending half a dozen hardened criminals with semi-automatics, as well as giant monsters, is not sending an army to fight one man, but equivalent to sending a few unarmed, crippled old men into a pit containing several large, starving lions.
      • ...Okay, extreme simile, but still accurate. Except that Batman is much, much more dangerous.
    • Actually, Joker is very Genre-Savvy. It's safe to say that he "knows" Batman will not only defeat all the mooks, but make his way to a final showdown. He knows Batman too well to be taken down by average thugs, or even super-mooks. All of this is just for his kicks.

     First aid kit 
  • If Batman is crazy prepared, why does he not have a first aid kit?
    • That's... actually a very good question. I suppose you could argue that the health regeneration you get after you defeat mooks is supposed to symbolize Batman using a first-aid kit on himself.
      • This is probably the correct answer. Go on, try using a First-Aid Kit when people are actively punching/shooting at you. I'll wait.
    • He doesn't need one since he just spontaneously heals between encounters, of course!
      • That would mean they just gave Batman superpowers.
      • You're implying that he didn't have some before.
      • No, Batman is just so Badass Normal that punching people gives him enough of a morale boost to shake off minor wounds.
      • His spontaneous healing is him using his first aid kid.
      • So Batman spontaneously heals after every fight, and the amount of health he recovers is dependent on the number of enemies you fought. Isn't this basically identical to the Life Drain mechanic found in other games? You need health, just go find some enemies to beat up and steal their life energy. It's as if you're playing as some sort of

     Bullet drop compensator 
  • Why does Batman, well known for never using guns, have a bullet drop compensator in his zoom scope?
    • Because he still has devices that shoot things, just not bullets.
    • Sleep darts. Worked for Solid Snake, will work for Batman.
    • Batman is known for not using guns against people. Doesn't mean he never shoots a gun that uses bullets at all.
    • Also, it's probably just Wayne Tech stock lenses from an experimental night-vision cowl or something. It probably came like that.
    • Also, while Batman might not shoot guns himself he often investigates people who have. If he's, say, investigating a sniper (Deadshot, for example), he can work backwards and use the bullet drop compensator in his scope to get an approximate idea at least of how far away the sniper was shooting from.

     Supposedly non-lethal 
  • How is knocking someone out and leaving them face-down in a stream/pool of water considered "non lethal"?
    • It isn't - that's why such devices are called less than lethal not non-lethal.
      • The only way it would be less than lethal is if someone came along and pulled their head out of the water. It's particularly ironic given the scene where Batman drops a mook into a room full of happy gas, and then says "I can't just leave him to die".
      • Seeing as the beaten mooks disappear from the fighting sites, I guess they are promptly carried away and treated by their comrades.
      • Or carried away and tortured and murdered for failure, as Joker implies many times.
      • "I won't kill you, but I don't have to save you."
      • That line was actually the worst thing about Batman Begins. In all of his incarnations, Batman doesn't just hate killing people, he also hates letting them die, and has a huge need for saving everyone he can. Talk about "not doing their research", huh?
      • Really? I thought it was one of the best things. The only problem I ever had with the Batman (post- Adam West, that is) is that he sometimes verged on Lawful Stupid in his insistence on saving mass murderers in circumstances where they would otherwise die of their own actions- so they could go out and murder some more.
      • The whole point of that anyway is that Bruce left Ra's to save himself (which is why there was a while shot dedicated to showing him breaking that window), so the quote doesn't really work here because those thugs are unconscious and can't do that, as opposed to Ra's just not jumping off the train and choosing to go down.
    • Couldn't resist adding this somewhere, and this folder seems to be the most appropriate place to put it. Exactly HOW do you punch someone who is already face-down, in the BUTT so hard it knocks them unconscious? (Yeah, I know, I know. "It's Batman." If anyone could figure out how to knock someone unconscious by punching them in the ass, it's him. Maybe my sense of humor is a little juvenile, but I find it incredibly funny on the rare occasions that this occurs.)

     Strange weather 
  • Why is the medical facility's sanatorium the only area in Arkham to be experiencing a thunderstorm?
    • I know we're supposed to explain stuff In-Universe, but this one can only likely be answered with "they left it in the code and forgot to pull it out". I bet the developers planned for a lot more thunderstorms, then realized the code was insanely huge or impossible to pull off by deadline, and they cut it...but left in the sanatorium thunderstorm.
    • In universe - Arkham is under a curse, as the scarab audio logs clarify. On this night, with Batman, the Joker, the Riddler, Bane, Poison Ivy and Croc all coming together at once? The spirits are very restless.
    • The Return to Arkham remaster fixes this by having it rain outside now.

     Conservation of mass 
  • I know, I know, I shouldn't ask this, but... when a goon is shot by a Titan Dart and grows, where does the extra body mass come from?
    • It's just full of hot air.
    • I've always just assumed it's like how it is with any other Applied Phlebotinum that makes people/things grow. It causes growth on a cellular level. Just like a baby growing into an adult, only much, much, much faster. Could also explain why Joker looks so old and withered in the teaser trailer for the sequel. Now as to where does the energy come from? Ya got me.
      • Comic book physics - they're funny that way.
      • The Meat dimension, a la Wolverine, perhaps?

     Batman can't swim 
  • Batman is at peak physical condition, can take on dozens of thugs without taking a hit, could easily compete in the Olympics, and... can't swim?
    • Hey, all that equipment (plus a soaking wet cape) is heavy.
    • He does swim. Fall into the water around the docks, or anywhere else that isn't off a cliff and then into the ocean, and Batman will simply pull himself back out. In fact, in Croc's lair, if you tumble into the water, Batman surfaces without trouble and treads water for about half a second — before Killer Croc drags him down to his death. Batman can swim just fine, he just never needs to swim in the game.

     Ivy's Titan form 
  • Am I the only one who was disappointed at seeing Ivy in the boss fight? Given that she was injected with Titan, I was actually expecting her to look like the Hulked-out superheroines in the current World War Hulks storyline (i.e. tall, thick, and with even more exaggerated curves than what was already there). And yes, I know that it "affected her differently", but still, I'm rather disappointed by that.
    • You may be the only one who was disappointed by that. Bothered? No, I'm right there with you. But I wasn't disappointed, per se. But in all seriousness, a big part of Ivy's shtick is her seduction. She also doesn't fight people hand-to-hand, instead using plants, since she's no threat on her own. It makes a weird sort of sense that giving her something that would give her superpowers a massive boost would affect her that way. Ivy's powers, in the simplest terms possible, are growing plants and being sexy. The Titan formula really helped with that.
    • Ivy wasn't injected with Titan, the plants were.
    • Also, a minor quibble with the first reply to this question. The Titan formula wasn't designed to boost superpowers, it was implied to have been designed to help patients withstand "therapy" by exposing them to a modified strain of Bane's Venom to enhance their physical capabilities. "Therapy" such as electroshock therapy or even worse therapy that would kill normal people. See this link and scroll down to the Trivia section to see why Dr. Young believed this would work. Basically, she thought the patients' genetics had to be stronger to deal with her "treatment". Dr. Young has issues.
    • Ivy isn't fully human anymore, remember? I'd assume Titan would affect a human/plant hybrid differently.

     The marzipan and kittens bomb 
  • Okay, we are told that the "bombs" the Joker scattered around Gotham to keep people away from Arkham were in fact just marzipan and kittens. This raises two questions: First, when the police discovered this, why didn't they send backup to Arkham Island? Second, if the Joker actually did bother to scatter crates full of marzipan and kittens around Gotham... well, why didn't he just plant real bombs instead?
    • What part of "completely insane" do you not understand? As for why... the police couldn't be sure that it wasn't exploding marzipan and kittens. It would be entirely in character for him to do something like that.
      • But the point of these "bombs" was to discourage people from helping out Batman on Arkham Island. By not planting real bombs, Joker was risking his entire plan, which sounds more stupid than insane. Essentially, Joker's plan was counting on the Gotham police department to be complete morons (which they admittedly probably are, but still!).
      • We're told that one of the bombs is Marzipan and kittens. But this is still the Joker we're talking about. He could have 99 kitten bombs around the city, and one real one just to screw with you. Remember the episode "Wild Cards"? Some of the bombs were real, some of the bombs were duds just to fuck with the JL's heads.
      • It could also be a case where he wanted to distract the cops but also keep others focused on him when the time was right, if bombs were going off around the city he might not have had a chance to get that new helicopter to record his victory over Batman as they would have been busy covering the destruction.
      • Not to mention the fact that the general public doesn't know about the marzipan and kittens. The cops would still have to deal with the mass hysteria in Gotham. Batman said as much to Gordon after beating Bane. Which makes Two-Face's bank robbery at the end much easier to accomplish.
    • Hast learned nothing from survival horror games? Nothing Is Scarier. The rule for Half-Life fan levels is "A headcrab in every vent? Not scary. A head crab in every fifth vent? Scary." Imagine knowing that some of the bombs are only kittens and cake, but some of them aren't. Now you not only have to deal with the Joker, his crazy, and his bombs, you also have to fight yourself to keep from relaxing in the face of real and deadly danger, making everything that much harder.

     Missing Titan dart 
  • When the Joker shoots himself with a Titan injection before the final boss fight, why is there only a puff of smoke? Shouldn't the same thing that hit Batman when he jumped in front of Gordon have lodged itself into the Joker's throat?
    • Maybe it got stuck in the barrel?
    • If that were the case, Joker would have never been injected with Titan......
      • I think it meant the dart hit Joker, then got stuck in the end of the barrel.

     Gordon captured the second time 
  • Did they explain how the Joker captured Commissioner Gordon again? Boyles captures him, Batman moves Heaven and Earth to save him and finally gets him to a police boat to go get control of the city. Then he just abruptly appears in the cell block for the Joker's big finale. If he got jumped by his own men twice in the same night, he really, really needs to invest in better background checks.
    • Maybe it's Clayface?
    • Nah. You see Clayface in his cell after Gordon goes back to Gotham.
    • Note that the "Arkham guard" on the boat has a visor over his face, and his voice was muffled. It's entirely possible that that was a slightly less burly thug in disguise.
    • Replaying the game after so many years of its initial release, I was thinking the same thing, and then a few clues came into mind that I didn't think of before. One, it's already established that communications have been cut off all around the island, so they can't call for backup. Two, Joker even announces that if anyone DOES try to reach the island, he's detonate bombs hiding around the city. And yet, despite these two facts, a GCPD boat has arrived on the dock. Anyone think this was part of Joker's plan all along?

     Why not double dose Batman? 
  • I know, I know, I shouldn't be thinking like this. But if the Joker was so upset that Batman was 'resisting the change' while injected with Titan, why didn't he just shoot him again ?
    • Maybe Joker wanted to dose both Batman and himself the whole time? It'd explain why he just stops chasing Bats and sicks henchmen on you; he got bored, sent them in to wear you down, and decided to take you down himself once you shocked him with the generators.
    • Titan's a pretty unstable drug to inject into a man. A double dose would probably be fatal to anyone, including Batman.

     Croc eating Scarecrow 
  • Something that makes me wonder is why Killer Croc attacked Scarecrow. Weren't they supposed to be allies against their common enemy the Batman?
    • Killer Croc is little more than a wild beast at this point. The need to feed overrode everything else.
    • Besides, there's no indication that Killer Croc was a part of the Joker's plans.
    • Yes, but he should at least has some understanding of who is the real enemy and who could be a helpful ally to him.
    • I assumed the Joker put them both up to it as some kind of theatrics to fool Batman, but we'll see in the sequel.
    • I actually found this to be a highly realistic depiction of insanity, as far as Bat-media as a whole is concerned. A horrendously big ego, couple with lack of foresight, tend to be hallmarks of criminal insanity (especially the flamboyant kind that the Bat-Rogues possess). In other words, Croc didn't care that Scarecrow might have been able to help him, because in his mind, he didn't need any help.
    • May I add that Scarecrow was going to throw the fear toxin into Croc's sewer? Killer Croc needed Scarecrow stopped as much as Batman did.
      • Agreed. Killer Croc probably doesn't want to be reliving memories of his abusive aunt, does he?
      • Or to have hallucinations of how much worse he's going to mutate in the future.
    • Croc wasn't allied with the Joker (or anyone else for that matter), he pretty much just does what he wants.
    • Scarecrow (and, hence, Batman) was treading into Croc's territory. Chances are, to him, anyone that wanders into his lair is easy prey.
      • Plus, Croc is just plain hungry, and Crane is a lot weaker of a physical combatant than Batman or any mooks that he might otherwise single out to attack. Easy meat, no matter his brains or agenda.

     Batman ignoring Ivy 
  • Something which bugged me which I put down as a What an Idiot! moment for Batman. Shortly before Doctor Young died, she told Batman that there was a secret lab in the asylum gardens where Titan was being manufactured but she dies before having a chance to tell him where the lab is. Immediately after this, Batman goes chasing after Harley Quinn who has taken the warden hostage. The chase leads him through the cell-block for the super-powered inmates, where a pained Poison Ivy begs Batman for help as she can feel the suffering of the plants in the garden. His reaction to this news is to tell Ivy that he doesn't have time to deal with it and warns her not to try escaping because he has enough to worry about without her running loose. Granted that Batman is going to put the Warden's life first, but you might expect him to take this information and try and use Ivy as a means of locating the lab, since Ivy - crazed as she is - is usually depicted as being fairly honest when it comes to protecting "her babies".
    • Priorities. To Batman, Joker is priority #1, anyone in his way is #2 (just look at how he treats the mooks at the party before Joker unleashes the Titans!), everyone else is a distant third. Knowing Batman, he probably knows that leaving Ivy alone is going to bite him in the ass, but he needs to get to Joker.
    • You might also expect him to keep quiet on exactly how bad the situation is, if only to discourage Ivy from trying to make things even more difficult.
    • At that point, Batman has no evidence to draw any connection between Titan and the plants' suffering. He only realizes it's made with plants after he wrecks the lab.
    • Plus, this is Poison Ivy we're talking about here — she's always ranting on about how plants are suffering and in pain (usually due to those evil humans) whenever Batman encounters her; he probably thinks she's just dealing in her usual shtick and doesn't have time for it.
    • As for honesty, I might have had exposure to different stories than the OP but 'babies' or not, in most, if not all of their past dealings, Ivy has rarely, if ever, given Batman a reason why he should believe a single word she says under any circumstances; she has zero credibility with him. For all he knows, she is lying — and even if she's not, then for all he knows she's going to take the first opportunity she can to attack him, plants or not. Batman has no reason to trust Ivy under any circumstances, and she hasn't given him a reason why he suddenly should start trusting her now.
      • He has no reason not to trust Ivy when it comes to plants and pain. Several Batman villains have their schtick that they simply wouldn't lie about. If the Mad Hatter tells you Alice in trouble, she's in trouble. If Two Face is worried about his coin, his coin is in trouble (it may not be in your best interest to fetch it of course) and if Ivy says her plants are in pain then they are in pain. That doesn't obligate Batman to do anything and she IS going to take the first chance she gets to attack him most likely. Batman effectively made all the worst choices when dealing with Ivy.
      • Of course he has reason not to trust her; he has ample reason not to trust her. Not only is she, you know, one of his most dangerous enemies, but she's also one who frequently uses manipulation and seduction as key parts of her M.O. Batman doesn't share Ivy's affinity for plants, has a lot on his plate at that point, and has ample examples of times in the past where Ivy's tried to exploit a man's pity, sympathy or attraction towards her to lull him into a false sense of security and get the drop on him for her own benefits; as far as he's concerned, she could just be playing possum. And even if he does trust that Ivy is genuinely feeling some problem with the plants, if he lets her out of the cell to help then he knows full well that she'll try and take advantage of it at some point and that all he'll have done is create a new problem for himself to solve later on. In short, Batman has no reason to trust Ivy and would, frankly, be a fucking idiot if he was to unquestioningly take her at her word and let her out of that cell.
    • Arkham's grounds are huge in this game. Who's to say Ivy wasn't whining about an entirely different bunch of plants, e.g. some flowerbed that a random pyromaniac inmate happened to be torching?
  • That part bugged me for a different reason. I mean, I get that Western Civilization is all about punishing criminals rather than rehabilitating them, and Arkham doubles down on that while pretending to avert it, but Batman's cold treatment of Ivy is part of why she is as lost as she is. She doesn't feel human because no one treats her as such, no one makes the attempt to show interest in her interests. Yes she's a dangerous and psychotic criminal, but she didn't get that way purely on her own. Batman treats Harley in a similarly cold manner, and it's just really off putting to see him treat women who are as much victims as they are criminals like they actively and independently chose to be homicidal criminals.
    • Batman has usually managed to be fairly equal opportunity when it comes to his violence and certain iterations of Two-Face and Mr.Freeze aside (in the Animated Series he has a real soft spot for Two Face and Arkham City shows he and Mr. Freeze can almost get along, a little less testosterone on both accounts might have changed their encounter.) he doesn't care what your malfunction is. As for Ivy's interests there are lots of groups IRL that presumably exist in one way shape or form in the D Cverse that share her interests. Greenpeace just off the top of my head. She's an eco-terrorist. Anybody marching around with a save the tree sign is showing interest in Ivy's interests. Ivy got where she is more or less completely on her own, certainly anybody who cared about rare plants a great deal has no more or less reason to be a criminal than she does. Now I've often wondered if Ivy was sane enough that if given the reins of a foundation with the means to accomplish her goals through non-criminal acts if she would but that's not Batman's priority for better or worse.
      • Well, to be honest, her main goal is essentially the destruction of humanity. Now, given that she's actually, so far as I know, a chosen conduit of the Green, it's at least vaguely possible that if her homicidal tendencies could be resolved that she'd be more of a well-intentioned extremist, or even outright force for good. As it is, she believes that plants are subjugated by animals. She may not have chosen to have her mind broken, but she is seeking a goal which can pretty comfortably be called "evil."
      • The fact that they are essentially broken human beings (and even the word "human" is kind of stretched with Ivy) does not change the fact that neither Harley nor Ivy has much of a problem with murdering people. Batman's a vigilante, not a psychiatrist. His goal is just to stop crimes from happening - he has neither the time nor energy nor training to spend trying to rehabilitate criminals on top of that.
  • There's something that appears to have been easily ignored or overlooked in all this. When Batman first encounters Ivy, she's howling and screaming about the plants suffering, yes. Same when Harley encounters her. But when Harley actually lets Ivy out, what does Ivy do? Stroll out of the cell as calmly as you please, purr "Much better," blow Harley a kiss and stroll off without an apparent care in the world. Apparently her pain and suffering was instantly cured the second someone let her out of her cell. While she might not have been lying about being affected by what the Joker was doing to the plants in some way, it almost certainly wasn't affecting her as badly as she was claiming. She was playing Wounded Gazelle to get someone to let her out. Batman was entirely right to regard her with distrust and ignore what she was saying.

     The mooks and Batman 
  • The mugs, thugs, and lugs can all fire heavy-duty machine guns at Batman and never ever once hit one of their own. Even when he's waded into a crowd of mooks.
    • Presumably the guns are given to sharpshooters, rather than just anyone.
  • I don't know about you, but if someone fires a rapid, propelled grappling hook at me, even if I know its coming, I can't just 'shrug-dodge' it.
    • You're presumably not a huge, muscle-bound thug though.
    • An explosion powerful enough to destroy a wall or floor only stuns thugs.
      • Note that Batman's own detective mode notes that the walls that the explosive is bringing down are practically falling apart anyway — you can see right through them in detective mode, even without it there's usually large holes in it, and once you get the final Bat-Claw you can pull them down fairly easily without explosives. Presumably the explosive is very mild but is nevertheless capable of bringing those walls down.
    • Batman can get worn down or tired out until he falls. The thugs must be knocked out cleanly and fully.
      • The mooks get pretty 'worn down' as well — usually, after you knock them down the first time, there's a moment where they just lie there dazed. Thing is, there's usually several of them and one Batman, meaning that if one of them goes down for a moment there's others to keep going while they get their wits back, while if Batman goes down that's it for him — note that one of them usually shouts "get him on the ground and stomp on his face!", meaning that if Batman goes down all the mooks assembled just keep whaling into him until he doesn't get back up again.
    • Until this game, I was unaware that knives and electric stun-batons enhance your health and serve as personal force fields.
      • IIRC, the mooks with knives were "high security patients" or something like that — perhaps the reason that they're high security is because they're really buff or whatever, and take more force to bring down?
      • Perhaps it's the other way around; they were dangerous, so the guards around their area carried knives and electric batons to deal with them. When the breakdown started, they were the ones near the guards with these weapons.
      • The stun batons, sure. Knives? Guards wouldn't be issued edged weapons in a medical facility, even in Gotham City. More likely the prisoners raided the Asylum kitchens for cutting utensils, and they wound up in the hands of the toughest dudes because they'd beaten the stuffing out of any not-as-tough dudes who dared to lay claim to them.

     Batman's "stay put" policy 
  • Is anyone else bothered by the fact that Batman telling someone to stay put because 'you should be safe' is pretty much the kiss of death? Seriously, with the exception of Cash and a few doctors in the medical wing literally every person Batman saves and gives the whole 'it's ok, you're safe now!' speech to dies a horrible, grizzly death the instant Bats turns his back. It all seems to stem from the fact that he doesn't bother to restrain any of the mooks he takes down with non-lethal force. A few hours later, these guys are waking up and they're still pissed over the pain of taking a batfist to the balls and they're looking to work that rage out on someone.
    • I agree, it made Batman look terribly ineffectual and having your triumphs constantly undone because cutscene-Batman wouldn't take his opportunity to put the Joker down was frustrating.
      • And to make matters worse, he shows more emotion when his car gets trashed than when the guards and orderlies get murdered. Save some guards, come back later to see their corpses strung up like piñatas and Batman won't say a thing (and if he does it's in a tone of vague annoyance). Go check on the Batmobile after its alarm goes off and Batman says, with noticeable anger in his voice, "Harley trashed the car..."
      • 'Ineffectual'? The man who essentially puts down an entire asylum of rioting prisoners practically single-handedly in one night? A bit harsh, surely? As for showing no emotion upon murdered orderlies, that's true in a few cases (but he perhaps reasons that finding and stopping the people who did this to them would be a more effective way of honouring them rather than breaking down and angsting about it), but then there's the scene in the Botanical Gardens where, after the Joker narrowly escapes from him, he comes across some orderlies he'd previously saved that the Joker killed. He sounds a lot more angry and sickened about that this than he does when his goons trash his car.
    • This isn't entirely fair to Batman. For one thing, in most cases of this kind of chatter it's not actually Batman who's saying that they're safe; it's the guards who upon seeing Batman sigh things like "it's okay, it's safe, we've got things under control now"; it's actually Batman who's telling them that they still need to be on the alert, and that the Joker is unpredictable and that things might happen that they might not expect. They're armed with machine guns and work at Arkham of all places, and he can't be everywhere at once and protect everyone; he can surely be forgiven for assuming they aren't going to just stand around with their thumbs up their asses and can take care of themselves to some degree. If memory serves, those who Batman does say are safe are those who he's just plucked from the clutches of death and are a bit freaked out and need some reassurance (and most of whom, if memory serves, actually do end up okay). He also presumably assumes that they understand that he's speaking relatively and that they shouldn't put their feet up and read the newspaper just yet; 'should be safe' isn't the same as '100% safe', after all.
      • Not to mention, you guys just pile everything on Batman's shoulders, don't you? You're saying Batman should not only beat inmate unconscious, but also zeal for the safety of the guards who were supposed to be doing the job he is doing for them? If Batman breaks someone's arm in a takedown and then the guy gets up later, and with his ragtag bunch of bat-broken-bones-brothers kill security guards who are not only healthy, but also wearing better protection equipment and better weapons, I'm blaming the guards ineffectuality at defending themselves. If it's not the thugs Batman breaks who kill the guards, but Joker himself or Harley Quinn, well, he can hardly be blamed for not having Superman's hearing to know the guards are in danger or Flash's speed to get there in time to save them. He did all he could given the situation.

     Mooks are shoeless 
  • Why don't any of the mooks wear shoes?
    • Perhaps there was a rush of violent shoe-murders at Arkham in the past...
    • Dangerous asylum inmates generally aren't allowed hard footwear, both to ensure they don't hurt anybody with them, and to make escape attempts more difficult. Presumably they decided to use the same standard on the Blackgate inmates while in Arkham.
    • I was in a stage production of One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest, which takes place at an asylum. Most inmates(and in that show, they're treated more like inmates then patients), at least the ones believed to be curable, wore soft footwear (slippers). One inmate, a lobotomized fellow, did in fact go barefoot. Considering what Arkham Asylum is, the lack of shoes (or inmates deciding to ditch the slippers) is not surprising.

     Croc's cell of skeletons 
  • Why is Killer Croc's old cell filled with skeletons? Like, seriously, there were like 30 or so skulls in there and two full skeletons. Are those real? If so, why weren’t they cleaned when Croc was confined to the catacombs before the start of the story and given a proper burial. If they are props, then who the heck gave him those and figured it would help rehabilitate him?
    • Probably real skeletons, and the Arkham staff just didn't care enough to get rid of them. They're not exactly a paragon of human decency.
      • Could be he's been grave-robbing to decorate his lair, and to feed himself from any recent burials of deceased inmates. Somebody dug up Amadeus Arkham's coffin, after all.
    • FWIW, I don't think the staff at Arkham had any plans to rehabilitate him. If they did, they wouldn't leave him sealed up inside the catacombs. Wandering unsupervised through the sewers and eating dead cows can't be any better for Croc's mental health than sleeping in a room full of skulls. Clearly they've given up all hope of curing him. Well, maybe Dr. Young had aspirations to cure him, but she was young and naive despite her (alleged) medical brilliance. If she'd been working there as long as some of the other staff, she'd know better.
    • Why the hell was he even kept in Medical in the first place? Aren't there only doctors around there? And if you look at his jail cell, the bars have been torn apart. If he's meant to be shown as a monster, why didn't he go around killing all the doctors in Medical?
      • Considering that Croc can be described as a 'special needs' inmate, perhaps keeping him in Medical was initially thought the logical thing to do rather than the cell block? And presumably there would have been guards in the medical facility as well. And perhaps when he first came to Arkham, he wasn't quite as monstrous as he is now. Of course, it's also possible that when we look at that cell we see the reason they don't keep him there anymore?
      • There could have been a time where they were more actively trying to reverse his condition, and so he was in Medical on extended stay for more extensive testing. But they eventually realized that he was going to keep transforming and gave up. But his medical health was more serious than the other patients' initially perhaps (none of the others were actively losing their human anatomy).

     Why not use the batarang? 
  • Why doesn't Batman Just Batarang Joker in a few cutscenes? I know the justification for the elevator scene (it might have sent Joker falling to his death...not that Batman couldn't CATCH him, but that's beside the point), but Batman's face-to-face with Joker in several other scenes. The one that really got me was the cutscene preceding the time you fight a real Titan mook. Or rather a pair of them. Joker is RIGHT THERE, with only two, easily-dispatchable untransformed mooks between you and him. Batarang or Batclaw Joker right then and there, and boom, game over.
    • The reasoning behind Batman's non-killing of villains is that if he takes the law into his own hands, he admits the system is so hopelessly broken that his claims of fighting for justice are meaningless. Killing the Joker would prove him right and mean everything Batman claims he stands for is a lie told for the sake of convenience. Not to say this is a perfect moral stance by any means, but Batman's goal is to help the police in their work, not replace the entire justice system with himself. In the latter cases, I don't think putting Joker down for a short time would really have helped any, and had he missed he'd have hit the cases of Titan formula and probably killed the lot of them.
      • Actually, the reason is that Batman thinks that killing the Joker is "too damned easy" and if he killed him he might not be able to stop. Do remember that while The Joker is the worst of these monsters, the majority of them are still bad enough in their own right and still murder plenty of random people themselves, so if he is willing to kill the Joker he doesn't really have much excuse to not kill, say, the Scarecrow, the Riddler, or Ras Al-Ghul (especially Ra's Al-Ghul, even- that’s probably even easier to justify than killing the Joker). The above is somewhat true, but this is the deeper reason- his own deep-seated fear that he is Not So Different from the lunatics he battles every night. And if Batman jumped off the slippery slope, nobody could stop him- after all, he's Batman.
    • The cases do get hit in the ensuing battle, with a small green explosion, as the Titan henchmen charge into them (Also, if you manage to beat the Titan Mooks without them destroying the tanks, you then have to do it yourself with some gel before the story will continue). That's why Batman says the production facility is "destroyed" even though he never does anything after the battle. A better justification might be that the Joker would just dodge it, since even regular Mooks can dodge Batarangs and Batclaws when they see it coming, and the Joker is probably quicker than the average Mook.

     Why not enlist Ivy's help? 
  • Why didn't Batman try to turn Ivy *against* the Joker when he first encounters her? She BEGS for his help because her 'babies' are in pain (presumably from being experimented on by the Joker), and, instead of taking this golden opportunity to pit a villain with actual superpowers (who he can, nonetheless, easily take down later) against the Joker, Batman is just a dick to her, and it ends up biting him in the ass later when she gets Titan'd. It really shows an uncharacteristic lack of planning on Batman's part.
    • Because he's Batman? Not only is releasing a dangerous supervillain something he, by definition, would never do, but Ivy could've easily killed the Joker (something Batman wouldn't allow) and she could've been a far bigger threat for the city (the Joker's bombs were fake and he was focusing on him, but we know a previous attack from Ivy would've killed everyone in Gotham if Batman hadn't stopped her) and she's both insane and unreliable... Not to mention, Batman doesn't know the Joker is going to release Ivy because he doesn't know the Joker needs Ivy. If she's in her cage, she's not a threat, but if he releases her, he knows for sure he's going to have to defeat her later. And you think Batman isn't planning?
    • At that point in time he did not know Titan was produced with plants. There was no information he could give her, even if he wanted to.
    • Still. How much effort would it have taken to humour her and say, "Sure, Ivy. Tell me where those flowers are and I'll try to help them out. Or at least not step on them." It's not like he had to actually follow through.note  Every other villain in this damn place is on the loose, you'd think that taking a very simple precaution against one of them hating his guts and being out for his blood once she inevitably escapes would at least be a consideration. Also, if he had been a little nicer, he may not have had to strangle one of her "babies" to get her to help him, thus royally pissing her off. Nice move, genius.
      • Ivy is an insane murderous plant-monster supervillain. She is not, and never will be, on Batman's "side" and he damn well knows it. The very first thing Ivy would do if Batman set her loose is kill him and then kill anyone else who crossed her path. Batman would have to be a drooling moron to trust her for even one second.
      • I didn't say he should let her out or, god forbid, trust her. Because you are exactly right: She is insane. Hence why I didn't even mention opening her cell. I simply suggested that maybe being slightly less antagonistic toward a psycho when other psychos trying to kill you could easily let her out to hunt you down as well might have been a decent idea.
      • Just because she's mentally unbalanced doesn't mean she won't respond to intimidation and coercion. And Batman is all about intimidation and coercion. Also, if I may bring comics continuity into the discussion for a moment, it's been explained that Batman has much more to lose by acting "nice" to criminals than he has to gain. His #1 weapon is his ability to inspire fear. He can't inspire fear if it starts getting around how "nice" he is.
      • Yes, Ivy is insane. But why does Batman trust her when she says that the counter to Titan is hidden in Killer Croc's lair? Shouldn't he think "Hmm, I just pissed her off royally and she's sending me to the most dangerous place on the island." Maybe he should have checked everywhere else before going there. Hey, he could have thought about that plant hidden in a secret lab in the medical building or something.
      • At that point, they clearly have mutual goals; Batman's realized that she was right about the Titan, Ivy's already out, has no reason to lie and makes no secret of the fact that she wants Joker stopped, it's only later when the Titan's affecting her that she changes her mind. Sending Batman on a fool's errand is just going to delay her goals, so she has no reason to. In any case, the whole point of lying to someone in order to manipulate them into a trap is to make them think they're going somewhere reasonably safe but where there is actually an unexpected danger so that they're unprepared, not to tell them up front that there's huge danger waiting for them if they go there (say, a huge, pissed-off crocodile man who's made no secret of his desire to eat them) but they have to go there anyway for realsies; that way, they're already prepared for danger. And by that point, Batman's hand is kind of forced; he still clearly doesn't trust Ivy as far as he can throw her (even if he now does believe she was telling the truth about the plants), but he's on a bit of a clock and doesn't have the time or resources to scour the entire island before he goes to where she's sent him just in case she's lying.
    • Ivy in the game's continuity (as in other continuities) is a manipulative bitch who likes to play the Damsel in Distress card to get men to do what she wants. Presumably Batman knows this, and he's rough with her because he knows that if he gives an inch, she'll take a foot, and from there every acre of Arkham Island. Also, Batman's not the type to lie about what he's going to do, and he may have wanted to leave his options open in case it became necessary to burn the whole greenhouse, or something.
    • Plus, for all he knows at that point, she's lying, or is just dealing in her usual "plants are suffering because of those evil humans!" shtick, and it's not like he's got copious amounts of free time to humor her at that point.
    • The problem here is that Ivy, like the majority of Batman's Rogues gallery isn't insane as in random. She's insane with her gimmick. It was unlikely that she was lying about her babies being in pain and while letting her out wasn't really an option being polite was. Even let out the larger reason not to let her out isn't that she's be a threat to Batman but that she might kill Joker.
      • No one's saying she's random; they're saying she's untrustworthy. Unlikely isn't impossible. It also wasn't unlikely that as soon as Batman opened the cell, Ivy would say something like "Oh... thank you Batman. My babies are feeling much better now," and attack him. Batman doesn't share Ivy's affinity for plants, and so has no reason not to suspect that she's just playing possum to try and get him to let his guard down around her.
    • As mentioned above; in a later cutscene, when Harley eventually does let Ivy out, what happens? Ivy slinks out as calm as you please, apparently without a care in the world, purrs that she's much better, blows Harley a kiss and struts away. While she probably does sense what the Titan is doing to the plants on some level and isn't happy about it, Ivy's "suffering" was just her playing possum to get someone to let her out. Had he tried to enlist her help, Ivy would almost certainly have tried to twist it to her advantage and lead Batman into a trap of some kind. Batman was right not to trust her.

     Is Batman weaker than the mooks? 
  • At the beginning of the game, Batman has about as much health as the mooks he's fighting. However, Batman's in a suit that's at least semi-armored, while the inmates have just their prison clothes, and because he's Batman, he's presumably going for maximum damage with every strike. The inmates can also get up after being knocked to the ground two or three times. Wouldn't you think that the superhero who routinely trains could do more damage than the men who have been sitting in prison for who-knows-how-long?
    • Word of God on the main page deals with your "maximum damage with every strike" theory: He's not. A guy studying a martial art for two months can potentially kill a man with one punch-Batman is pulling his punches by an insane degree because he has to focus on dealing with half a dozen guys (or two dozen...) at once. You'll notice that when only one remains, Batman can put them down very quickly.
    • Not necessarily. Prisoners work out too, remember? And realistically, "training" only goes so far when it comes to increasing the amount of damage you can do with a punch. Batman may be Crazy-Prepared but he's still a normal man with no special powers. He can only hit so hard.
    • Who says Batman has same health? Mook goes down in 3 hit combo, rolls around and unless knocked out by Ground Takedown, he will get up after a while. Compare Batman, who can take numerous punches, knife hits, stun batons and bullets and still keep going before he finally falls down from exhaustion. Only reason why we don't see him getting up is that usually there are several thugs ready to beat him while he is down, AKA Batman gets mug version of Ground Takedown. In 1-on-1 fight, Batman wins without much of a fight, 3 punches and while the guy rolls around trying to get his bearings, Batman punches him into face hard enough to knock him out. It's just that usually there are at least 3 mooks who don't want you to finish with one guy.

     Ground takedowns 
  • Specifically, the inability to cancel them or interrupt them in any way, shape or form. Normally, this wouldn't be a problem, but one of the Cosmetic Awards requires you to use a ground takedown in a combo, and enemies usually try to attack you just as you're in the middle of one. Couldn't Batman, say, backhand his attacker while squatting on the guy on the ground, preventing him from getting while preventing his enemy from doing damage?
    • You can do a ground takedown at the end of a combo, such as when you've got three of them and they're all dazed on the ground. Still annoying though.

     Sharpe taking the credit 
  • This technically has more to do with the sequel, but my problem springs from something in this game. OK, Warden Sharpe took credit for the defeat of the Joker and used that to springboard a successful mayoral campaign. But here's my question: how did he take credit for that? The final battle with the Joker was seen by several news helicopters, and it would be easy to tell that it was Batman who beat the Joker once and for all. The best I can think of is that Sharp claimed that he gave Batman a lot of advice on how to move through Arkham and take down the inmates. Granted, the sequel isn't even out, so it's possible there's a good answer to this that hasn't been revealed yet.
    • Well, do we know that the news copters were broadcasting the footage live? If not, then Sharpe could have somehow intercepted the footage and prevented it from being aired. I don't know how he would do this, but if he somehow did, then he could make up whatever story he pleased. The only people who can credibly argue against him would be the people on the helicopters at the time, but he could just pay those people off. Alternatively, he could have claimed that Batman just beat the Joker up at the end and it was Sharpe's leadership that held Arkham together and allowed the staff to regain control of the facility. A savvy political campaign coupled with a series of generous payoffs to silence whistle-blowers (and maybe a healthy dose of ballot fraud) could easily carry that message to an electoral victory.
      • Just checked Youtube. Yeah, at least one of those copters was broadcasting live. Your second theory sounds pretty good, though.
      • There's still a time delay of anywhere from 10 seconds to 10 minutes on "live" broadcasts, so that the censors have time to insert a bleep if someone says one of the Seven Words You Can't Say On TV. While it doesn't answer the question (the correct answer is below this one), it does mean that (depending on the length of the broadcast and the length of the delay), that interception is still possible.
    • In the sequel, he claims that he organized and led the counter efforts to the breakout and Batman was working with Sharp, following his instructions. He was also being supported by the League of Shadows, to get Strange in place to launch Arkham City.

     Using the internet 
  • Why is it so degrading to use the internet to find everything the Riddler left out? Isn't it in Batman's style to use every resource he has to best the bad guys?
    • Fridge Brilliance!
    • ...Okay, fair point. But when dealing with the Riddler, the typical (or stereotypical) way Batman defeats his riddles is by simply thinking them out in his head. Likely an artifact from the days of the Silver Age when there was no internet to search for the answers.
    • Being Batman's style to use all resources doesn't mean the Riddler isn't going to take the piss out of him for getting answers, rather than solving the riddles himself.
    • No doubt someone like the Riddler, who places great premium on pure intellectual ability in unpacking complex puzzles, is going to view looking up answers on Google as 'cheating' somehow. It's also worth noting that accusations of using the Internet start coming less when the Riddler's in 'smug gloating' mode and more in 'getting pissed off now' mode; he's angry and hurling around accusations because it beats considering the alternative that Batman's just cleverer than him.
    • As said elsewhere, Riddler is insane. In Arkham City, he accuses Batman of cheating while cheating himself (the Have a Nice Death hint even says Riddler is cheating if you fail the shell game).
  • It doesn't even make sense for the Riddler to accuse Batman of looking up answers on the internet. All his challenges are custom-made, so nobody would know anything about them to be able to put that information online. The only internet that could be of help to Batman is the one that exists beyond the fourth wall.
    • The Riddler's a pompous egomaniac incredulously watching Batman solve a whole bunch of puzzles he'd thought were unsolvable. He's clutching at straws to salvage his pride, basically.

     The party list 
  • What was the Joker planning to do with all the people on his party list? The list, as shown when Batman took it off Harley, read Selina Kyle (Catwoman), Harvey Dent (Two-Face), Jervis Tetch (Mad Hatter), Basil Karlo (Clayface), Waylon Jones (Killer Croc), Oswald Cobblepot (Penguin), Arnold Wesker (Ventriloquist) and Luke Oliver (?). All the names except Karlo, Jones, and Oliver are crossed out. There are frowns next to the first three names, smiles next to the next two, and the others are unknown due to Batman's hand being in the way. Most of the people on that list don't show up in the game, and the only villains who are in the game to make it on the list are Clayface and Croc (And Clayface doesn't even contribute to the story). What does it mean?
    • Knowing the Joker? He might have just been, honest to gods, planning to have a party once Batman was out of the way. The first three probably have frowns because they're unable to attend (read: not in the game), while Clayface and Croc are smileys because they are in the game.
      • And Crane, Zsasz, Bane and Ivy weren't invited (In fact Ivy was definitively mentioned as not being invited)?
      • Crane would spike the punch, Zsasz would cheat at pin the tail on the Bat by stabbing people, Bane is a horrible dancer, and Ivy won't share her stash.
      • Crane would fuck up the party with a fear based power play (so, yeah, spike the punch); Zsasz has no pizzazz, just pure homicidal mania and a fixation on self-mutilation (Joker is all for murder, but he distances himself from such lowbrow fare); he counted on Bane only being a speedbump to Batman; and Joker canonically hates Ivy, and vice versa, all because of Harley. Ivy is always trying to convince Harley to stop going back to Joker, and Joker mistreats Harley.
      • Regarding Luke Oliver, he was the winner of a Gamestop contest to get your name and likeness in the game. His face was used for the bearded thug in the red jumpsuit in the cell near Clayface.
    • Pained as I am to present a serious answer to the question after this wonderful little theory, it seems obvious - the frowny faces denote that the person in question is susceptible to the Titan formula. Think about it - Killer Croc and Clayface are the only two on that list with notably different biologies, due to being, respectively, reptilian and made of mud. Makes sense that they wouldn't be affected by the titan formula, or at least, not in the way the Joker wants. Presumably these are the people he's planning on turning into Bane 2.0. If nothing else, Luke Oliver's presence shows it's not big-name-exclusive. Those guys are probably the first names to come up. Plus, it would perfectly fit the Joker's warped sense of humour to have his army composed of his colleagues/allies/rivals/nemeses/whatever the Joker thinks of them this particular Tuesday.
      • There is no reason why it couldn't be both. Joker makes a list of potential guests to invite to his party. He puts smiles by those who are immune (Clayface, Croc), crosses out those who won't be there either for Titan immunity or just not being able to show (Catwoman, Penguin, Clayface, Croc), and then invites everyone whose name isn't struck through to to his "Dead Bat" party. Then, while everyone's guard is down, bam! Titan army!
    • Well, Catwoman is pretty much a good guy, and Two-Face is out robbing banks, so obviously they wouldn't be able to attend (besides the fact that Selina is never in Arkham anyway...). Mad Hatter already has his own tea party (it is sort of his thing), so he wouldn't endorse the Joker's non-Wonderland themed party. Scarface is found in Arkham, so we can guess that Wesker is currently 'cured' of his condition. The Penguin, meanwhile, is presumably out being the Penguin somewhere in Gotham. Meanwhile, Killer Croc, Clayface and Luke Oliver (aka the Tri-Limbed Menace) are in the Asylum, but Joker hasn't got around to inviting them yet: Killer Croc, because he's rampaging; Clayface, because he's disguised; and Luke, because no-one actually knows who he is.
    • Isn't it obvious? All the names that had smiles next to them (Croc, Clayface, & Luke Oliver) were still on Arkham Island once Joker took over, so they could still make it to his party. Everyone else either wasn't there or high-tailed it the hell out, so their names were crossed out and had frowns put next to them.

     Lack of doors 
  • Why don't the indoor guard posts, along with a number of other areas, have doors? Why is Arkham just relying on an electric force field to keep their staff safe in the event of a riot? Breakouts at Arkham might be easier to prevent, or at least contain, if every area of the building had actual, physical doors. Instead of, you know, a force field, because when that thing fails due to someone simply cutting the power, you now have absolutely nothing between your guard post and all of the lunatics in the building. Sure, a lot of the doors lock electronically — and therefore can conceivably be unlocked the same way — but at least you can blockade a door. Considering people in this game aren't affected by the Insurmountable Waist-High Fence clause, shoving a desk in an open doorway once your force field fails won't help much.
    • Agreed. Most of the survivors from the night are ones that happened to be able to shut themselves behind a door or barricade of some sort, e.g. Doctors in the medical facility, Warden Sharp etc.
    • In the case of the indoor guard posts, the guards are probably well trained enough to put a round or two into an inmate if they get antsy. Go on, charge a position when one or two guys with big guns are aiming at the only way you can get in. I'll wait.
    • It's possible they do. Maybe there's some sort of failsafe that drops a three-inch metal door in place if the power cuts out. Of course the real answer is because it gave the devs a reason to include the frequency-matching mini game.
      • Totally agreed on the part about the dev team. In-game, however, it makes little sense. Wouldn't it be far more sensible (and, hell, cost efficient) to simply have plain old doors? Because if there really is a failsafe, clearly the safety part was a failure. Good old-fashioned doors still seems like the best option. I mean, make the doors as high tech as you want — lock electronically, require an assprint scan to open, whatever. But at least have them be reinforced doors that open inward. All a person would have to do then is shove a desk or other heavy object(s) in front of the door. Presto! Instant barricade. I'm not saying it'd be a perfect defense, but it's gotta be better than nothing at all.
      • Possible Fridge Brilliance: Warden Sharp is clearly making an effort to trump how 'modern', 'up-to-date' and 'effective' Arkham is as a psychiatric unit as part of his mayoral campaign (just look at the whole 'Arkham Care' branding and the advertisements in the Medical Facility), and part of this is getting stylish, up-to-the-minute electronic security doors rather than 'out-dated' regular ones. As with most things about Sharp, however, they sound a lot better on paper than they do in practice.
    • The electronic doors have a number of advantages over real doors. They can be activated and deactivated remotely. A lot of people are mentioning the defensive capabilities of regular doors while forgetting that these things work in both directions. Electro doors prevent the inmates from barricading themselves in with the same efficiency. You can see through them so you can know for sure if it's safe to open the door or if they just got very quiet and hoped you went away. They are harder if not impossible to brute force open where as regular doors are great, until Croc and Bane decide they they want out bad enough to team up.

     Batwing's lack of stealth 
  • Why is the Batwing so loud? In the comics, it's got a stealth mode that's depicted as so silent that it could hover right above you and you wouldn't notice, as well as having an intimidation mode that is used to scare enemies into submission through its engine's thunderous roar. I don't get why Batman would have its engines running at full noise level if there's no one to intimidate after the botanical gardens Titan fight. Or is it that there's no stealth mode on that one? Or is it just to create a very epic Moment of Awesome for the Batwing?
    • The "stealth mode" is probably an active system. Not running it when it isn't necessary (like when Batman is in an empty room with no one to hide from) saves power and fuel.
    • Plus, even with 'stealth mode' a large jet plane is only going to be so quiet when it's right next to you. It's not a UFO, after all.
      • Just to put a real-world example on the table: Modern stealth technology (the B-2 and F-117) are more concerned with reducing radar and infrared signature, not reducing noise. Even though they're subsonic, the idea is that by the time you can hear it, you're about to be VERY dead. I can't find any information on how many decibels the B-2 and F-117 produce, and it's probably classified information anyway; but at a distance of 100 feet, the engines of a commercial airliner produce around 140 dB. (For comparison, OSHA regulations won't allow you to work for more than 15 minutes at more than 115 dB without protection; the NIOSH, which is part of the CDC, sets the threshold even lower, at 100 dB.) Inside the cockpit, the pilot would probably be subjected to around 75 dB if he wasn't wearing a headset.

     Joker and Titan effects 
  • Why isn't The Joker's mental clarity and voice affected after he changes to a Titan? Everyone else that's injected ends up roaring, growling and charging at Batman, but the Joker is still able to taunt him and wave at news choppers. Granted the Joker is differently insane, but why doesn't his voice change?
    • If the devs are really the Batman fanboys they seem to be, maybe they were squeeing so hard at Mark Hamill's Joker voice that they couldn't bring themselves to distort it.
    • Batman was able to resist the change for a while, so it's possible that the Joker was able to resist the mental changes while still letting himself become a monster.
    • The Joker states outright that he is experimenting and asks nobody to even LOOK at him or they would ruin the surprise. He was actively testing on himself with what parts of the formula he DID know. He's also always been a master chemist, and his biology could very well be unique if he did take a dip in an acid bath. Also, the Joker is ALWAYS obeying whims, doing what he wants to. His voice never changed because he was always in line with the effects of the transformation. Also, it was THE PUNCHLINE. The Joker, Clown Prince of Crime, and the Bat dueling in front of all of Gotham as the monsters they really are... At least that was the plan. Bats turned him down, which made the entire point of the takeover lost. That's why the Joker loses interest in the fight, the party was ruined so he focused on the still fun future of tearing apart Gotham and having fun with that. It is a bit of a tragedy that Bats never changed, it would have been interesting to say the least. Lastly, his Titan at the end was definitely the good stuff, refined and tested thoroughly, he probably brought out the good China. Batman would have most likely maintained his sanity, or the lack of it, since the point was to have Bats experience what was already within him. In fact the controllable nature of that batch of Titan was probably why he could resist the effect. Batman was given a choice to accept his insanity and monstrous side with the extra incentive of being on equal footing with the Joker in that battle. It was a trap to fight Bats on even grounds, with Batsy and the Joker transformed into their inner beasts. The Joker would not have even cared if he LOST that battle, if it had happened the way it was meant to.
      • "It is a bit of a tragedy that Bats never changed"? Not in my book. That would have meant the Joker's warped worldview would have been entirely validated. That would have been the tragedy.
    • I thought about this one too and came up with a different explanation: Joker had been working on the Titan formula directly, refining and perfecting it. The Joker's transformation at the end of the game is physically very different from the others: He's far more dangerous than any regular Titan Mook. It's most likely that the Joker formulated the drug specifically for himself. Drugs are complicated things: To make a transformation like that possible, you'd need to take into account all sorts of factors: Weight, physical condition, prior medical history...The darts that he used were likely made to be a perfect match for him alone, thus allowing him to keep his voice and mind, and change even more dramatically than the standard thugs. He'd probably make targeted batches for his mooks, too, but that would take more time than he has and besides, it's funnier to turn them into hulking, subhuman beasts.
    • Dude, it's Joker. The Titan can't screw up his mind any worse than it already is.
    • To build on the idea of Joker perfecting the formula: the original formula as created by Dr. Young was supposed to make the patients' bodies stronger to withstand treatments, not to turn them into drooling monsters. Presumably, Dr. Young was envisioning her patients keeping their minds (losing their minds further wasn't part of the treatment). So maybe while Joker was fiddling with the formula, the drooling and incoherence were part of the side effects he hadn't fixed yet. Though I like the explanation that Joker's ALWAYS this crazy much better.

     Joker strapped down 
  • When he's navigated through the opening sequence, the Joker is carted through Arkham in his Hannibal Lector-style shackle trolley. Fair enough. So why didn't the guards keep him in it until they got him to his cell? The whole game could have been averted if they had.
    • Well... there were stairs on the way. Maybe they thought it was too much work to carry the shackle trolley all the way to Joker's cell, with all the stairs and stuff.
    • Joker did have a guard (whose name escapes me) working for him. Maybe he was the one who decided to take the Joker out of his restraints?
      • Frank Boles, just so you know

     Dealing with Joker 
  • Why have none of the Arkham guards (or Orderlies, or Sharp himself, for that matter) just murdered the Joker quietly? Sure, Batman is insane, so continue to adhere to a code of behavior that continually results in an increasing body count of innocent people in order to justify his own existence, but surely one of the hundreds of people who have lost friends or family to the Joker would have said "You know what? Enough is enough." and just shot him in the head while he was helpless in Arkham. To me, the failure of some random individual in Gotham to permanently remove some of the more extreme Bat-rogues shatters suspension of disbelief. By this point in the continuity (As of right before the Aug 2011 DC-reboot), the Joker's body count is in the tens of thousands. SOMEBODY should have decided to murder him while he's in custody by now.
    • Probably something to do with the bystander effect. Everyone wants him dead, but nobody wants to be the one to do it, figuring someone else will do it eventually anyway. There's also fear of retaliation; what would Harley do to the person who killed her puddin'?
      • Plus, people have tried to kill the Joker while he was in Arkham. They all failed, because he is never 'helpless' in the Asylum. As stated time and time again, the Asylum is his home, but he's only ever there so long as he wants to be there. He's no doubt prepared for anyone deciding to try and kill him.
    • And this is the Joker we're talking about; as much as everyone wants him dead, everyone is also shit-scared of him, with good reason. Even leaving aside the fact that the Joker is a vicious psycho with a knack for murdering people in gruesome ways, he's also got a habit of playing mind-games and labyrinthine schemes which make people think they're doing one thing when in fact they're actually doing something else which is what he totally wants them to do — so if you're alone in his cell with a gun pointed at his head, part of you is probably going to wonder whether the reason you're there is not because you're so badass that you're gonna be the one to take out the Joker, but rather because he wants you to be there. On top of this, he also has a knack for coming back from the dead. Seriously, every time the Joker's been in a position where it looks like he's dead, he's totally back right as rain not long after. This would tend to build up an impression that he's practically indestructible. And yeah, as noted above, he's probably going to be really happy at the person who put him in that position in the first place. Basically, there's a whole mystique that's built up around the Joker that means that anyone who isn't Batman, much as they might want him dead, is probably too fucking scared of him to go anywhere near him if they don't have to. (And incidentally, the whole "Batman is insane" part is perhaps a tad unfair, but that's a discussion for another day.)
    • What makes you think that some 'random individual' is going to have any better luck dealing with the Joker than Batman of all people? Batman is a brilliant, brave and resourceful detective and vigilante with combat training, psychological insight, wealth and resources up the wazoo, and even he is frequently driven to the edge of his limits by the Joker. Is there really anything to plausibly suggest that some random schmuck with a gun is going to be better equipped to take care of him for good?
      • The problem is Batman is specifically not killing Joker, it's not a matter of being properly equipped it's a matter of having the will power. It's some kind of miracle that nobody has offed the Joker. Not someone like Redhood who has the appropriate training to encounter the Joker even at his peak and have a decent chance of coming out, not Lex or one of the other villains who've undoubtedly had a plan or two screwed up by Joker just being Joker. No nurse or doctor giving the Joker an overdose while he's already half dead from a Batman beat down, hell nobody seems to have just neglected to feed him which I hear is fatal even if takes a week. Depending on the continuity this is a guy who's filled entire graveyards.
      • "Sure, Batman is insane, so continue to adhere to a code of behavior that continually results in an increasing body count of innocent people in order to justify his own existence" — Please never talk about Batman again, because you clearly have a severe misunderstanding of the character.
      • Indeed. Batman refuses to kill in an effort to prevent his own Sanity Slippage, not because of it.
      • Let's be clear here. Refusing to kill a clear and present threat to people's lives, someone who has repeatedly proven that he can easily break out of prison, because if you let yourself kill just one person you'll go on a murderous rampage of everyone who breaks the law, is not really the mindset of a sane man.
      • Of course he's not entirely sane, he's running around every night beating criminals to a pulp while dressed as a bat, for crying out loud! He's seen the worst of humanity on a daily basis and is basically walking on the knife edge of sanity, but he recognizes this, which is why he refuses to kill, for any reason. If he kills the Joker, he has no reason to stop at just the Joker, he could start killing other members of his Rogue's Gallery, and eventually any one who tries to stop him from killing, including the police, his allies, the Justice League (most versions of Batman have contingencies in place to take down the Justice League if necessary) and no one would be able to stop him.
    • If you listen to the Spirit of Arkham messages: Someone did try it. Warden Sharp They failed - Joker was ready for them. He was ready for a someone able to order the guards and doctors away, and approach him in his cell, alone. What makes you think the Joker is defenseless?
      • Of course, this doesn't account for someone who would simply shoot the Joker (as an example) in plain view of everyone, either figuring that them going to jail is a fair price for being rid of the Joker, or thinking that no jury would convict them of murder even with a mountain of evidence. Hell, all the times Batman has left the Joker incapacitated to be picked up by the cops, sooner or later one of them would just kill him and say they "found" him dead.
      • Because that would mean pissing off Harley and as 'Harley Quinn's Revenge' shows she is way more dangerous and brutal after Joker dies, (she's able to capture Batman and nearly kill him!) And even without her, Joker himself has a surprisingly loyal gang in this continuity who would likely try to avenge him which would convince any average person or cop who wants to kill the Joker that, they might not live very long afterwards if they succeeded.
      • Same poster as above: Having seen Assault on Arkham, I have another reason why people wouldn't kill the Joker besides being terrified of him: They probably think he can't be killed at all, He was trapped in a falling helicopter that exploded when it hit the ground and Batman didn't have time to save him and yet he came back perfectly fine. You can chalk that up to Joker Immunity, but that alone would probably convince people that any attempt they make to kill Joker would not only fail, it would turn them into his next target (would you really want to be Joker's target?).

     Keeping Cash on the job 
  • Anyone else bugged by the fact that Cash is clearly disabled, yet still allowed to keep his job guarding dangerous mental patients? Or would his hook provide a reasonable alternative to let him continue working?
    • Depends on what his duties are. I'm pretty sure Cash has an office so he's probably some kind of supervisor who doesn't have to physically restrain any of the patients. You don't need both your hands if most of your job is to sit at a desk and fill out paperwork.
    • Plus, Cash is one pretty tough cookie; aside from Croc for obvious reasons he displays little fear of the inmates (he's even willing to talk back to Joker), he can handle himself pretty well compared to most of the other Arkham employees, he's obviously quite strong, he seems pretty intelligent, capable and savvy... in short, hook or not, he's the kind of guy you want in a place like Arkham Asylum. And let's be honest, if you had to knock some sense into a inmate who's giving you grief, a bloody sharp hook isn't the worst thing you could ask for.
    • In the comics, Jeremiah Arkham (Arkham's director) actually begged Cash to return to his job, since he was the only one who could keep the inmates even somewhat in line. Of course, Jeremiah doesn't exist in this continuity...

     The Scarecrow hallucinations 
  • The third time you get all hopped up on Scarecrow toxin, Batman's hallucinations get a little... odd. The first two times, they centered around Batsy's immediate fear for Gordon's life, plus his lingering guilt issues and trauma over the Waynes' murder. Par for the course. The third time, however, all the hallucinations seem to imply that he's afraid he, himself, is insane. The Joker and Harley haul him into Arkham. We see numerous crazy Batmen. Scarface even calls him a "classic case of multiple personality". Now, I admit that I'm not especially well-versed in Batman canon, but this is the first time I've ever seen Bruce presented as even having his own disturbed nature give him a moment's pause - much less fear that he is or will turn into a crackpot. He always seems quite assured that what he is doing is perfectly rational, shrugging it off completely should anyone tell him otherwise, even disregarding it when people like Alfred and Leslie question whether dressing up like a cute fuzzy critter and punching people is healthy. So what's up with the seemingly sudden fears for his mental state?
    • Probably has something to do with Scarecrow shooting him up with enough fear toxin to kill an elephant.
    • That, and I do believe that the fear of Batman also being insane has been touched on in the comics.
    • He might brush it aside, but it's kind of a running theme for others to question whether he's any more sane than the people he's after.
    • Plus it turns out at the end that the point of the whole game has been about Batman and that. If he gives in the Joker wins. Which fits in nicely with the first scare, where he fails and lets Gordon die. This time he fails and lets the Joker show how the supergood vigilante is no different from an insane criminal.
    • A lot of the game is based on the comic "Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth". In that comic the theme of Batman's sanity is definitely explored.
    • It's the origin of his Thou Shalt Not Kill philosophy. Batman feels that if he lets himself excuse the death of just one person, even a monster like the Joker, he can't trust himself to not go on killing for less and less reason. He's always been afraid of himself going nuts, it's why he binds himself so tightly.

     Thug placement in Arkham 
  • Well, why are so many of Jokers thugs in Intensive treatment and not in the penitentiary where they belong? And wouldn't these lunatics that are released by Joker when you get the cryptographic sequencer fit better in Intensive Treatment? One could argue that you have to be crazy if you work for Joker, given the Warden's state of mind. And it's better to have "normal" enemies to teach you the basics of fighting instead of charging lunatics, but still..
    • They're from Blackgate. Remember, it was burned down just before the start of the game, so they're holding the prisoners at Arkham until they can move them someplace more correct. You just saw some of them being escorted away from intensive treatment while you were escorting Joker in, so presumably that's where at least some are being held.

     Effectiveness of mook incapacitation 
  • Anyone else bugged by the way Batman just incapacitates thugs and leaves them on an unsecured island? I know he had no other choice, but throughout the game I felt, I'm knocking these guys out but with the island less and less in control, is that doing anything? In the one night idea of the games timespan that still means that Batman is probably going to be knocking the same guys out multiple times(unless he's hitting them hard enough to risk brain damage). It just didn't feel like he was achieving much. On the other hand it would be a Fridge Brilliance way to explain why Joker has such a vast number of disposable mooks. (Although he did have a prisons worth to start with)
    • But what else, practically, is he really supposed to do? He kind of has a lot on his plate, it's pretty urgent that he stop whatever the Joker's planning and get him securely contained ASAP, and he doesn't really have time to find somewhere secure to hold all of these mooks he's kicking the crap of and transport them back and forth once he's done beating them up, or no doubt enough cuffs to restrain what is pretty much the entire population of a prison (and that's at least hundreds of guys to start with, and any number of their comrades could happen upon them) and even if he did under the circumstances any number of their comrades could happen upon them and release them, thus rendering it pointless from the start. If they're knocked out, they're at least not really going to be any good to anyone for a while, until they regain consciousness and come around from the concussion, so he can focus on getting what he needs done at that moment without having to worry about them.
      • Thing is, Bats is not simply knocking them down, he is effectively breaking their bones and twisting their joints, causing concussions and etc. Even if they wake up, they won't be able to fight again, at least not in the exact same night the game takes place in.
      • That doesn't really change the essential point that he doesn't really have much time to do anything else with them, though. On the contrary, it makes it more reasonable that he just leave them there — after all, someone who's arm is broken is unlikely to be much of a threat for a while.

     Bane's attack 
  • Why did Bane attack in the first place? While it wasn't confirmed until the second game Bane in the Arkham verse is clearly an intelligent tactical individual. Attacking Batman serves absolutely no purpose and he's demonstrated in the past not only a willingness not to fight Batman for no good reason like in No Man's Land but occasionally to team up with Bats for when they have the same cause. Unless Venom drives you really really insane in the Arkhamverse Bane's response to being pumped full of Venom should have been a polite thank you to Joker followed by brushing Batman casually aside and going after the Brujah.
    • I thought he was being pumped full of Titan as well, which does drive you insane. And even if he wasn't, he's clearly been 'drained' of Venom by the time Batman and Gordon find him, and then he suddenly gets a whole crapload pumped directly into him all at once — rapidly going from a completely clean system to drugged up to the fucking eyeballs with something like that has to have some kind of destabilizing effect.
      • Withdrawal + torture + sudden overdose of advanced steroids + extreme dislike of Batman = anger.
      • Perhaps I've read all the wrong comics but I had the impression that Bane's doesn't especially dislike Batman. He's a mercenary who happens to end up opposite Batman more often than not but their interaction in No Man's Land clearly demonstrates he's not fighting Batman for free. His lines and general attitude during the fight don't show him to be particularly insane but the Troper who suggested it's probably Titan not Venom and Bane just had a better reaction to it than the normals. Most likely because he's built up some sort of immunity to Venom so he just got really aggressive instead of outright crazy.
      • In addition to the above, note that Bane and Batman are not hostile when they first meet. Bane begs Batman to cut him down, and Batman asks in a genuinely horrified voice, "Who did this to you?" It's only when Bane gets shot up with Titan that he attacks Batman.
    • Remember that Bane isn't Comics!Bane, he's Arkhamverse!Bane - he has elements of Comics!Bane, but they're distinct characters. The comics aren't necessarily a perfect guide to their relationship.
    • Titan is not Venom. Batman remarks after the fight that Bane was more aggressive and less stable than usual. Part of that can be attributed to his treatment by Dr Young, but considering how everyone else who gets shot up with Titan turns into a snarling, feral beast, it's not surprising that Bane loses his usual rationality and relative composure.

     Batman gas mask 
  • Why does Batman lack, of all things, a gas mask? Between Joker Venom and Fear Toxin there are a lot of enemies who use poison gas weapons. Shouldn't a Crazy-Prepared Seen It All genius have one of these on him? (Or at least in the Batmobile, Batcave, etc...)
    • Considering how often Batman is attacked with various gases all the time in both this game and other media, why Batman doesn't have a Gas Mask on or at least carrying one at all times is a bigger question.
    • Gas masks don't work like they're often portrayed in fiction. They have to have filters custom tailored to keep out specific pathogens, meaning he'd need a separate mask for each individual gas. Even if Batman did this, most of the filters for dangerous pathogens have a very finite time frame in which they work. There are several that aren't good for more than 10 or 15 minutes. Batman's current approach of analyzing the current toxins being used by his foes and synthesizing antidotes and vaccines for them is the most logical way to do it.
    • In Batman: The Animated Series, Batman used gas masks quite a few times. Though almost always it was against basic poison/nerve gas.
  • Speaking of which, where did Joker and Scarecrow get their Joker gas and fear toxin from? They started off the game in prison, where they most likely did not have access to them. Is this stuff so simple to synthesize that they could whip up a batch with whatever ordinary household chemicals and medical supplies they could find upon breaking out?
  • If the The Animated Series is to believed, Joker Venom really is that simple to make considering he made some in an escape during Joker's Wild. As for Scarecrow, considering two riddles involve finding a hideout with his stuff (which contain security photos from Batman entering at the start) and a couple fear gas cans stored behind a wall, it's probable Scarecrow was able to covertly get what he needed from inmates or the outside considering it's obvious he can get out of his cell without anyone knowing.

     Joker and the Batmobile 
  • Anyone notice that Joker would likely have been in better control inside the Batmobile at the beginning instead of inside a giant mental asylum/prison? For that matter why doesn't Batman build a special cell for Joker and other supervillains?(since it has been proven countless time that Arkham Asylum wasn't enough to hold those kinds of people.)
    • Do you have any idea how many counter-measures and fail-safes that the Batmobile has? Neither does The Joker, but he would probably suspect that anything he does try would only serve to hurt him, or at least make things more difficult to carry out his plans. And besides, his scheme didn't involve taking the Batmobile for a Joy ride.

     Skimpy asylum attire 
  • Kind of a minor quibble but...did anyone else find themselves wondering what the hell happened to Ivy's pants? Obviously the skimpy attire fits her seduction M.O., but why does she seem to have been issued an Arkham Asylum shirt without pants to go with it? And if she just decided to strip down a few layers to seduce a few guards, why don't we see her pants lying around anywhere in her airtight cell? And, for that matter, why don't the guards seem to have any problem with an asylum inmate cavorting around bottomless 24/7?
    • She took them off. We don't see them lying around because we don't really see much of her cell at all. And what are the guards supposed to do? Hold her down and force the pants back on her?
      • Actually, as seen in this video, we get a pretty complete view of her cell. Not only are her discarded clothes nowhere to be seen, but her cell is also completely unfurnished (without even a mattress in sight), also raising the question of how she manages to sleep and bathe.
      • She does actually have a bed and mattress. It's possible the pants are stashed under that, or that they were removed from the cell when she refused to wear them for much the same reasoning that asylum patients might not be allowed shoelaces.
    • Adding to the question: why is the remaining top half of her uniform so revealing? Rule of Sexy presumably applies, but how did she get an inmate's uniform to expose that much cleavage? It doesn't look rough enough to have been altered by hand, and it's hard to imagine an Arkham inmate having access to scissors and sewing gear.
    • I just assumed that the staff let her wear less because she's part plant. It's like giving an inmate with an allergy to certain foods a slightly different menu.
      • My guess is that it helps with her hyper-sexuality, you know, her desperation to be visually appealing to the male guards. It's basically a necessary exception to keep her at bay, and forcing her to wear pants would only add fuel to the fire anyways. The personnel must've figured that having her look so promiscuous would help suppress her mood swings, and considering that the more emotional she gets, the stronger the connection with her babies, I wouldn't disagree.
    • Surprised no one had mentioned this already. But especially considering how poorly run this place is, it seems perfectly believeable the guards have no problem with her lack of pants just because they like leering at her.
    • Ivy is part plant. She probably need to expose her skin to light to stay healthy; Batman even remarks that she's been in the dark too long.

     Why bring Joker to Arkham? 
  • My main question with this game was: if Batman suspected Joker gave up too easily and wanted to return to Arkham, why did he take him there in the first place? Obviously Arkham Asylum is equipped to deal with Joker; but with the recent influx of Blackgate prisoners, not to mention Harley in residence, wouldn't it be smarter to take him somewhere else? Belle Reve perhaps? (I'm aware that the game wouldn't exist if it weren't for Joker being in Arkham, but since Batman was completely aware that Joker was planning something it seems odd he would give him what he wants.)
    • Where else is he supposed to take him? Arkham Asylum is where the Joker's supposed to be incarcerated, taking him somewhere else just means him breaking out and causing more havoc until he eventually gets back to Arkham, and unless Batman has his own personal jail or feels like carting the Joker around with him forever, he's got to take him back there eventually. He might not like it, but what other option does he have?
    • The police probably wouldn't have been too happy with Batman if he tried to detain the Joker. In fact, I think Batman tried to mention his concerns to Gordon at the beginning. At that point, it was out of Batman's hands and he was following GCPD and Asylum protocols, most likely.
    • Not to mention, as someone else pointed out above, we're just demanding that Batman do everything aren't we? Not only is he supposed to catch all the criminals, not only do we frequently criticise him for not funding all of Gotham's educational and welfare programs to completely eradicate crime, now he's supposed to personally run the jails and asylums and monitor the criminals as well. Batman doesn't imprison the Joker because that's not his job; to paraphrase Shawn Spencer from Psych, the actual authorities really do have to start chipping in at some point in this whole process.

     Why didn't Batman detain Poison Ivy back in the botanical garden before the Joker injected her with Titan? 
  • I know that at that point, getting the antidote for the Titan was his #1 priority, but knowing Poison Ivy, no doubt the most dangerous meta-human on the island, why didn't he at least attempt to detain her? I don't mean dragging her all the way back to the Penitentiary, but at least making sure that she won't add to the chaos. That's not really a plothole, but more of a lingering question I've always had since completing the game.
    • She just wasn't a priority at the moment and any energy used attempting to detain her would take away from getting the antidote for Titan. It's easy to forget since it's a video game but the clock was literally ticking at every point he met Ivy. The better question I've always had was why not be cordial? Ivy for all her crazy problems she's fairly consistent and a tiny act of kindness with Batman swearing he'll find out what Joker is doing to her baby's and stop him (which he was doing anyway) could quite possibly have made the difference between her attacking him later and making a b-line for Joker. Which I honestly don't understand why she didn't do anyway. Titan injected Ivy was by far the most powerful being on that island.
      • This is discussed in a different folder above: basically Batman's number 1 weapon is his ability to inspire fear and acting nicely to any of his major enemies would compromise that if they spread that info around. Plus Ivy is far from trustworthy and Batman was going to have to deal with her sooner or later, since one of her consistent goals is killing every human in the world and she was already loose. As for why Ivy didn't make a b-line for Joker, she probably didn't know where he was and after she was injected with Titan (or was it her plants that were injected with Titan, I can't remember) she was driven insane like everyone else who took Titan.

     Why are Penguin's canes on display in Arkham? As well as Catwoman's gear? 
  • Unless part of Arkham is utilized as a "Batman Museum" there really should be no reason as neither villains are insane and have nothing to do with Arkham. Catwoman being nothing more than a thief to the eyes of Gotham. And Penguin I can safely say is probably one of the (if not THE) sanest members of Batman's Rogue Gallery. (Depending on which version)
    • Writers often forget that Arkham is in fact an asylum and not a penitentiary. So often Batman's entire rogues gallery ends up there. Though I think those items were just put in because of Rule of Cool and no other reason Bane in this reality is a resident of the Asylum and he's not insane at all. He reacts a little badly to Titan (really well by comparison to everybody not named Joker honestly) but that's it. So in the Arkhamverse perhaps Arkham is a super max similar to Belle Reve?
      • Well, the Batman canon I was always more familiar with was BTAS in which Penguin was always sent to Blackgate (Or Stonegate as they called it) though keep in mind that I'm pretty sure Bane was there not as a patient but to extract his venom for the titan project (with him being brought along with the Blackgate prisoners in the first place)
      • In the canon of the game, Blackgate has been deemed unfit to hold any criminals due to a fire (which could possibly have been a part of Joker's plan to group all the rouges together) which explains why all the non-insane inmates are currently at Arkham. Perhaps Penguin's cane and Catwoman's gear were some of the things salvaged from the fire, and the guards just put them on display for mere collectors' sake?
    • If nothing else, Arkham City depicts the Penguin as someone who has his own fair share of psychological issues, including violent sadism. In this universe, it is highly likely that he's been an inmate of Arkham at some point.

     What would happen if Poison Ivy had defeated Batman back in the botanical garden? 
  • Before I go any further, I want to reiterate that this is completely hypothetical, and just a stupid question of mine. Assume that Batman got was knocked down by her toxic spores back in the greenhouse during the game, and she used her vines to suffocate him underground. Afterwards, Ivy killed Joker, not having the same moral dilemma that Batman had, and basically took over the island. Say two months later, wouldn't she be suffering from Titan poisoning just as Joker was? Of course, Joker took so much that it basically entered his bloodstream, making it incurable, but with Ivy's internal system, I'd imagine it would be hard extracting the Titan strain out. I know this is a pretty pointless "What if" question, but I'd appreciate any replies, no matter how sarcastic. Thanks!
    • The Arkham City Stories in the sequel confirm that Poison Ivy did have Titan poisoning and was dying, but the Sharp allowed a priest to come in and give her last rites. He had pollen from a rare plant on him, that fell onto her, and with her unique biology synthesized an antidote for herself. So if Batman and Joker were dead by that point, she would likely have found a cure for it and therefore have taken over all of Gotham and probably killed everyone on the planet or was stopped by Superman or some other superhero.
      • It's also hinted in City that Joker's case of Titan poisoning is fairly unique. Not only caused by Titan, but by Titan reacting with all of the other interesting chemicals in his bloodstream due to the accident that made him Joker in the first place.

     Batman's cape while hanging 
  • So I'm going to go ahead and assume that when Batman hangs upside down from a gargoyle, he's using some kind of rope or magnet on his feet to keep himself from falling. Okay, that's fine. But how the hell is his cape staying up? Shouldn't it be draping over him?
    • Some Batman source books claim his cape has metal tips at the end to allow for stunning people with a cape swing, so it's possible Arkham Bats has them in order to stick to the magnet idea.
    • I was under the impression that he held it tightly around him. But maybe that's just me.
    • I don't remember where I read it, but I remember reading something about Wayne Enterprises making a cloth that goes rigid when subjected to electricity. They couldn't find a use for it, however, so they just stashed it away until Wayne found it and used it to make his Cape. He has a small battery pack that applies the voltage when he's falling, and that's why his Cape holds its shape while gliding. Presumably, he does the same when he's hanging upside down.

     Cash's imprisonment 
  • When Cash was tied to a chair in the Arkham mansion earlier in the game, couldn't he have used his hook-hand to cut the ropes and free himself? By the looks of it, it'd seem like it would've done the trick.
    • IIRC Cash was in a room with several armed mooks and he himself had no weapons to speak of (besides his hook). If he were to escape he probably would've gotten himself of the other hostage killed.
     Detective mode in Visitor's Centre 
  • Why didn't/can't Batman use his detective mode when he's inside the Visitor's Centre at any time in the game? He would have seen that the Joker mannequin is actually the Joker himself, the criminal he's trying to arrest throughout the game. Batman could have easily ended all the violence and destruction right at the beginning.
    • "How do you beat the Dark Knight, the Bat Detective? You place a big clue, put it right under his nose, and wait!" It's from Batman: Arkham City but it's a telling sign that Batman tends to go for the more complicated theories rather than the obvious. It stems back to the 60's Batman where each clue or riddle was more convoluted. It stems from the animated series where he thinks the streets are not safe or someone is a crook and it turns out he's wrong, where he checks, double checks, triple checks Penguin until he sees Cobblepot genuinely wants to reform. And it stems from Batman Forever where the Riddler leaves...what's the word, riddles that when figured out are obvious numbers to letters but initially he works from the idea of how clocks, matches, chess pawns and tennis fit.
    • Maybe the Joker was only there for the final time, and all the other times it was actually just a mannequin?
    • In game, it's less that he can't and more that he just doesn't. As far as he's concerned for most of the game, he has no reason to scan the Joker since it's probably just a mannequin. In any case, all that Detective Vision would tell him would be if it was a human, in which case he might just assume it's a dead body that the Joker's dolled up (no shortage of them that night). And besides which, he's usually got some other pressing matter to be taking care of at that point, like a hostage to rescue or something. The opportunities to the enter the Visitor's Centre before the end are usually when Batman's making his way from one part of the island to another to find a hostage who is in immediate peril or some potentially time-sensitive crisis, and even if he was to accost Joker at that point, Joker would just remind him that okay, he can waste time beating him up all he wants, but Commissioner Gordon is going to get iced or something. Outside of the game, the writers wanted to give the player at least one surprise twist that Detective Mode couldn't spoil.

     Graves in the Graveyard 
  • So near the Botanical Gardens, there's a graveyard with a huge coffin laying half-buried but still uncovered enough to see it clearly. What happened here, did inmates decide to dig up a grave and stop halfway through?
    • The grave belongs to Amadeus Arkham, there's a riddle to be solved by scanning the grave. Considering the revelation that Quincy Sharpe carries the spirit of Amadeus Arkham within himself, it's possible that part of this process involved him, in a fit of madness, digging up the grave to see the body, or something similar
    • Given the general level of decay and neglect on Arkham Island, it's likely that the graveyard was disrupted by something — a previous escape attempt, an earthquake or some similar phenomenon, etc. — that has caused the graves to be pushed up and exposed, and no one's really been bothered to do anything to fix it up.

     Batman resisting the physical effects of Titan 
  • The cutscene leading into the Final Boss sees Batman taking a dart full of Titan for Gordan, but manages to avoid transforming into a massive monster thanks to his famous Heroic Willpower. But... That doesn't really make sense... It would make sense for Batman to resist the Psycho Serum part of the Titan chemical, just as he's able to resist Scarecrow's Fear Toxin. But no amount of willpower can resist, let alone prevent, your physical body from transforming. That's just not how things work; unless a given transformation is directly influenced by the mind, which can't be the case for Titan since it's a chemical formula created specifically to make people physically stronger, your body will be altered no matter what the mind says. The only thing that should stop Batman's body from growing huge to the point of the muscles and spine ripping through the skin and exposing themselves would be a chemical compound that counteracts Titan: something that Batman actually does create late in the story, but doesn't see fit to use it on himself when infected with Titan I know Ivy slapped the antidote out of his hand when he attempted to use it on her, but it wasn't made clear that it fell down a Bottomless Pit and Batman ended up not needing to use it on her anyway, so he still should've had the antidote on his person. So, what? Does Batman have an impossible level of control over his entire physical self?
    • Basically, yeah. He's the poster boy for being a Determinator. He routinely ignores or resists extremely painful injuries or mental attacks by virtue of his Iron Will.
    • ...What? Didn't Bats use the antidote on himself once Joker brought him up to the roof? Joker tells him, "Change, go crazy! It's the only way to beat me!" Batman refuses, injects the antidote into his chest, and Joker replies, "You used the antidote on yourself? Now that's funny!" and then tosses him away, thus beginning the final battle.

     Batman not hearing about Gordon's capture 
  • At the game's midway point, Gordon gets on a boat to the mainland. At the end of the game, we (and Batman) find out that Joker has recaptured him, with the implication being that the cops on the boat were disguised Joker goons. The fact that Joker has recaptured Gordon comes as a surprise to us (and Batman), but why? Shouldn't Oracle, who's on the mainland and keeping up with goings-on in Gotham, have been able to inform him that Gordon, her father, never arrived back on the mainland?
    • She kinda had other things to deal with. Once she knew he was on the boat back, she probably assumed that he'd be back safely and didn't bother to keep that close of an eye on things, given everything else that was going on.

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: