Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / GameOfThrones

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I'm not sure if the Fridge Horrors are meant to be in order, so I'm just going to tuck this in.

Added DiffLines:

* In Season 4's "Mockingbird", we're introduced to the latest incarnation of Ser Gregor Clegane executing prisoners. Since the prisoners are provided weapons, it seems like what's actually going on is a Trial By Combat. Only since these are clearly poor nobodies and not Lords and Ladies of Westeros they on't get the dignity of an audience or even a genuine fighting chance. The horror comes in when you realize that even ''if'' a prisoner managed to kill [[WorldsStrongestMan The Mountain]] there is no fucking way the guards would let that person live. Clegane is Tywin Lannister's best soldier and Cersei's ace in the hole for any problem that requires brute force. The fights already [[FailureIsTheOnlyOption meant to be unfair]], managing to kill him would probably land you in even hotter water.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Jamie also admits all the way back in season 1 that he hates being known as "Kingslayer" to his father. The White Book doesn't even mention his involvement in the siege of Pyke, nor any tourney achievements. When that conversation took place, he had just been appointed Lord Commander of the Kingsguard, giving him the opportunity to add to the book himself. By the time he returns to King's Landing, the loss of his hand prevents this, which is hammered home not only by his own son mocking him, but later in Dorne, where his miserable attempts to write with his non-dominant hand are shown.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's been pointed out that the political condition of Westeros at the end of the series is... less than optimal. A bunch of noble houses are completely extinct, and many of those that have inherited or been raised to fill those titles are inexperienced at ruling and have little to no name recognition in a society where (as much as they are trying to reform) historically one's name means almost everything. In fact, the fates of some of the survivors almost come off as an attempt by the writers to give them better endings than 'disappeared into anonymity' and would be risky at best from a practical standpoint. Overall, Westeros is a country that could and probably will descend into civil war - if not a continent-wide problem like the War of the Five Kings, then certainly smaller feudal conflicts as those who remain alive scramble to fill the swiss cheese-like lattice of power gaps in the country. '''All in all, it seems that the Game of Thrones is destined to continue; but perhaps that is the point.''' Westerosi politics has consisted of power-grabbing, backstabbing, and the occasional murder for centuries (as is shown by the [[Series/HouseOfTheDragon follow-up prequel]]). But those are all very human problems, survivable by those who can navigate them or are smart or lucky enough to stay out of the way. And, in the big picture, they are survivable by the human race. [[OutsideContextProblem Mad queens with dragons and supernatural ice zombie invasions that affect the very climate]]... not so much.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Keep in mind, the ''average'' soldier in a land heavily inspired by medieval Eurasia would be levied from among the common folk when (and only when) war was necessary. Keeping a full-time army was more than most lords could afford. Meaning most of them would be farmers or perhaps merchants for most of their lives and wouldn't be trained much if at all until the moment someone stuck a spear in their hand and basically gave them Jon's "stick them with the pointy end" speech. So aside from your freaks of nature like the Cleganes (who, let's keep in mind, were minor nobility with all the attendant advantages), the gap between each individual soldier in an Unsullied army and each individual levy wouldn't actually be all that big. Not to mention the spear was a weapon with an extremely low barrier to entry. Even massively long spears like the ''sarissa'' (which can exceed 15 feet[=/=]5 meters in length) didn't get above 14 pounds (6.5kg). With a good weapon, it takes far less strength than you'd think to penetrate the very basic armor a levy would wear and kill them if you know what you're doing. And since the Unsullied have been brutally and slavishly drilled from preadolescence to manhood and do little else ''except'' fight, each will know what he is doing - and then some.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The change of Robb's wife's character from Jeyne Westerling (a lesser lordly house under the Lannisters) to Talisa Maegyr (a Volantene noble daughter turned itinerant field nurse) adds another layer to why the Northern lords would have been upset at Robb marrying her. Not only is Robb's wife not from the North, she's not even from ''Westeros.'' The Northmen are known to be proud of their heritage -- often to a fault -- so for most of the Northmen it probably had as much or more to do with [[FantasticRacism Talisa being Essosi]] than it did about the tactical implications of upsetting Lord Walder. Especially given that ''no one'' could have forseen his revenge plot coming -- or Roose Bolton betraying them in a power grab, for that matter. Guys like the Blackfish or the Greatjon certainly wouldn't have stood for it.

to:

* The change of Robb's wife's character from Jeyne Westerling (a lesser lordly house under the Lannisters) to Talisa Maegyr (a Volantene noble daughter turned itinerant field nurse) adds another layer to why the Northern lords would have been upset at Robb marrying her. Not only is Robb's wife not from the North, she's not even from ''Westeros.'' The Northmen are known to be proud of their heritage -- often to a fault -- so for most of the Northmen it probably had as much or more to do with [[FantasticRacism Talisa being Essosi]] than it did about the tactical implications of upsetting Lord Walder. Walder - who [[TheFriendNobodyLikes nobody was overly thrilled about having to ally with in the first place.]] Especially given that ''no one'' could have forseen his revenge plot coming -- or Roose Bolton betraying them in a power grab, for that matter. Guys like the Blackfish or the Greatjon certainly wouldn't have stood for it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* It's been pointed out that the political condition of Westeros at the end of the series is... less than optimal. A bunch of noble houses are completely extinct, and many of those that have inherited or been raised to fill those titles are inexperienced at ruling and have little to no name recognition in a society where (as much as they are trying to reform) historically one's name means almost everything. In fact, the fates of some of the survivors almost come off as an attempt by the writers to give them better endings than 'disappeared into anonymity' and would be risky at best from a practical standpoint. Overall, Westeros is a country that could and probably will descend into civil war - if not a continent-wide problem like the War of the Five Kings, then certainly smaller feudal conflicts as those who remain alive scramble to fill the swiss cheese-like lattice of power gaps in the country. '''All in all, it seems that the Game of Thrones is destined to continue; but perhaps that is the point.''' Westerosi politics has consisted of power-grabbing, backstabbing, and the occasional murder for centuries (as is shown by the [[Series/HouseOfTheDragon follow-up prequel]]). But those are all very human problems, survivable by those who can navigate them or are smart or lucky enough to stay out of the way. And, in the big picture, they are survivable by the human race. [[OutsideContextProblem Mad queens with dragons and supernatural ice zombie invasions that affect the very climate]]... not so much.

Added: 335

Changed: 414

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even long before the final season, it was very clear that she operates under a different moral code than you'd expect to see from such a noble woman. Her time with the Dothraki and in Slaver's Bay hardened her heart considerably and made extreme actions like using the Dragons and killing potential allies seem less like a big deal.




to:

** I got the feeling that Melisandre originally misinterpreted the prophecy and assumed everything was literal when she worked with Stannis. That's why she took so much stock into Lightbringer being a real flaming sword used to fight Darkness. Only later, perhaps when she met Arya, did she realize the struggle against the dead was (mostly) not the primary concern, as much as it was making sure Jon Snow lives.

Added: 207

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ellaria Sand and her (dead) daughter are still in the dungeons of the Red Keep. Best case: they, like Jaime and Cersei, were crushed under rubble in Daenerys' attack. Worse case: the route to their cell was blocked by that rubble, so Ellaria will soon die of suffocation or deydration. Worst case: the cell and the halls leading to it are completely intact, ''but no one knows they're down there, so no one will come to free her, or even fed her''.

to:

* Ellaria Sand and her (dead) daughter are still in the dungeons of the Red Keep. Best case: they, like Jaime and Cersei, were crushed under rubble in Daenerys' attack. Worse case: the route to their cell was blocked by that rubble, so Ellaria will soon die of suffocation or deydration. dehydration. Worst case: the cell and the halls leading to it are completely intact, ''but no one knows they're down there, so no one will come to free her, or even fed her''.her''.
** Even if Ellaria is eventually found, rescued and freed, it is debatable whether she still has the will to keep on living after what Cersei did to her or if she'll slit her own throat at first opportunity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Imagine the series had ended with Daenerys ''not'' undergoing a FaceHeelTurn and ruling as a benevolent Queen of the Seven Kingdoms. It's heavily implied (and outright stated in the books) that after her traumatic stillbirth, Daenerys is sterile. Best case scenario, peace would have only lasted a lifetime until her death [[HereWeGoAgain left no clear heir to the Iron Throne.]]

to:

* Imagine the series had ended with Daenerys ''not'' undergoing a FaceHeelTurn and ruling as a benevolent Queen of the Seven Kingdoms. It's heavily implied (and outright stated in the books) that after her traumatic stillbirth, Daenerys is sterile. Best case scenario, peace would have only lasted a lifetime until her death [[HereWeGoAgain left no clear heir to the Iron Throne.]]Throne, especially if Jon predeceased her]].

Added: 125

Changed: 657

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As he has the unanimous approval of the Great Council, there is less likely to be conflict and opposition during his rule.



** Bronn as Master of Coin: At first, it seems ironic, since he didn't even know how loans worked a few seasons ago. But what drives Bronn? What does he care about the most? [[OnlyInItForTheMoney Money]]. He'd want to be sure that he's always paid in full, so finding out about loans and how little he actually knows about money would have given him plenty of reason to become more financially-savvy over the next few years.
** Also, Bronn may be lowborn but he's also a former ''sellsword''. If he didn't have basic knowledge on how to budget and manage money he wouldn't have survived this long.

to:

** Bronn as Master of Coin: At first, it seems ironic, since he didn't even know how loans worked a few seasons ago. But what drives Bronn? What does he care about the most? [[OnlyInItForTheMoney Money]]. He'd want to be sure that he's always paid in full, so finding out about loans and how little he actually knows about money would have given him plenty of reason to become more financially-savvy over the next few years.
**
years. Also, Bronn may be lowborn lowborn, but he's also a former ''sellsword''. If he didn't have basic knowledge on how to budget and manage money money, he wouldn't have survived this long.long.
** Davos as Master of Ships: Though a bit less of a stretch than the other two because his life at sea, Davos has no real experience in military naval command. But he does have something more important: Bran's trust. The Small Council is made up of the king's top advisors, so it makes sense that Bran would choose people he trusts on a personal level. Out of those, Davos has the most experience of seamanship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jon's parentage remaining a secret to the general public at the end of the series ensures that unless one of the characters privy to that knowledge chooses to reveal the truth, Rhaegar is doomed to be remembered as Lyanna's rapist and kidnapper.
** And truth be told, the other option isn't much better; almost everyone who finds out the truth regarding Rhaegar and Lyanna's relationship in the show has the same reaction, which basically amount to: "That's great Rhaegar's not a rapist, but his choice in abandoning his duty to run after another girl he fell in love with still got innumerable people needlessly killed." So at worst Rhaegar's a villain and at best he'll be remembered as a fool that screwed up the realm by sheer political incompetence.

to:

* Jon's parentage remaining a secret to the general public at the end of the series ensures that unless one of the characters privy to that knowledge chooses to reveal the truth, Rhaegar is doomed to be remembered as Lyanna's rapist and kidnapper.
kidnapper. This also means Arthur Dayne and Gerold Hightower will continue to be remembered as having died holding Lyanna hostage instead of defending their newborn king.
** And truth be told, the other option isn't much better; almost everyone who finds out the truth regarding Rhaegar and Lyanna's relationship in the show has the same reaction, which basically amount to: "That's great Rhaegar's not a rapist, but his choice in abandoning his duty to run after another girl he fell in love with still got innumerable people needlessly killed." So at worst Rhaegar's a villain and at best he'll be remembered as a fool that screwed up the realm by sheer political incompetence.incompetence, the exact opposite of the wise prince he was known as.

Top